I love goodfellas, after about 2 years here in athens they are one of the best slices on court. Not…read moreto mention how affordable they are (even more so when inebriated) lol. The atmosphere is top tier and never brings in too rowdy of a crowd, opposed to other places... other than that they are always kind and quick. Only get a four because i'm a thinner crust type of guy, overall great joint

Definitely a good late night snack after a night out at the bars. We did come in closer to when…read morethey were closing so they didn't have much to pick from. The service was quick and we brought it back to our airbnb. We only got pepperoni and cheese pizza, but it was still good pizza. We got our pizza pretty quickly.

Pizza by the slice! There is something about Gillespies pizza that can't be reproduced by any…read moreother pizza place I've ever tried. It is entirely their own. It's a cheap lunch, paired with a pop, and for a convenience store pizza it's surprisingly good. I like the mushroom pizza, but any flavor I've tried was delicious.

No longer in business. When it was open they were friendly and served exactly what pizza shops…read moreserve.

Busy place on Tuesday 5p and after getting a 12" meatlovers and 18" cheese pizzas did we find out…read morewhy - prompt - decent$ -quality - great taste

Continued great quality and taste. Always friendly service…read more Very convenient drive-thru.

Easy pull up window, tasty food, good prices. Note - no dining in. Easy and convenientread more

Easily the best pizza in southern Ohio. Very creative menu…read more We've had the super mushroom (my fave), the Philly, pepperoni, and the skeletonwitch (spicy). Their crust is phenomenal. Try the green chili jam!!! Service is fast. Only outdoor seating which with Ohio weather can be a pain. There's a speedway down a bit so order pizza then go grab drinks. By he time you get back - pizza done! They also have take & bake. We found it by accident first time then drive an hour back to have it again. It's that good. Full menu is not posted in the store so make sure you check the website.

As a college town, Athens has a plethora of pizza options. Avalanche stands out among this sea of…read moreslices. It leads for its creativity of combos, it leads for local sourcing of ingredients, it leads for its stall at the Saturday Farmer's Market with numerous bread options, and it leads for local ownership with deep commitment to investing in the community. The Super Mushrooms with diverse fresh mushroom types and ricotta and asiago cheese is always my go to even with lots of other tempting combos available in regular, gluten free, and cauliflower crust options in 10" and 14" size options. There is a table in the tiny parking lot for eating at the restaurant, but really this is for takeout or delivery. They do have NY Style and regular cheese and pepperoni slices available by the slice on walk in plus some to go salads and cannoli in the small pick up area.

Pizza Crossing -- what a hidden gem in Logan…read more Seat yourself atmosphere, and it did take our waitress a bit to come around, but multiple large parties walked in at the same time we did. Once she got to us, she was incredibly sweet and attentive despite being busy. Free refills, and she even offered drinks to go -- such a nice touch. We ordered a small pizza (around 10 inches), which was perfect for 2 adults sharing, and loved that you can do half-and-half toppings. We did half veggie and half "all the way" (their supreme). It's easy to see why this place has been voted one of the best pizzas in Ohio. The pizza is unique -- a thinner crust, but not quite NYC-style thin, topped with provolone cheese instead of the usual mozzarella. A lot of people rave about their pepperoni too: smaller, meatier, and clearly higher quality. Even the slices stand out -- cut into small rectangles instead of triangles. Absolutely delicious and we'll definitely be back next time we're in Logan.

The young lady serving us was very nice and a few other employees also treated us well. The staff…read moreis friendly and helpful. Now to the pizza. We sampled the pepperoni pizza hoping it would be excellent. Sorry to disappoint the locals and staff. It was mediocre. The crust was very thin, the sauce wasn't anything to write home about, and there was way too much cheese on the pizza. No crust and I am not a fan of how they slice it. Give me a nice NY slice instead of cutting away the excessive cheese and either use a fork to eat or grease up your fingers. For some, they may enjoy the pound of mozzarella cheese on it and the little square piece, but this is not for me. As for flavor, nowhere a good pizza but not at the bottom, either. I say middle of the row for this pizza. Our party never fought to eat the leftovers, and that says something. If you're in the area and just need pizza, this could do but do go expecting great pizza.

Wonderful costumer service!…read more I called ahead and order a few pizza before a family event, when I arrived they even carried the pizzas out to my car!

We obtained a carry out from Lucky's. Ordering two large pizzas, one deluxe and one pig pizza. We…read morewere advised it would be about 30 minutes and they were ready as promised. Both pizzas were warm when retrieved, toppings were ample and flavorful . The crust was very good, overall a great pizza experience. They are very large pizzas and not inexpensive. I would definitely recommend this pizzeria.

Great pie. Chef is very generous with the toppings. I would highly recommend…read more Neat place. They do more than pizza. Pasta and salads.

This small town pizza parlor is like walking into the past. We came in around lunchtime on a cold…read moreSaturday. The woman working was very friendly and made us feel welcome. The pizzas took about 20 minutes. They came out piping hot. They had a crisp crust and thick sauce. They were pretty good.