I ended up staying in this town overnight by pure chance after traveling over the holidays and stopping in Logan for the night. Pizza Crossing was one of the few places opened and serving after 9 pm. This was a Friday night but they didn't seem too terribly busy and were able to make a medium pizza with cheesy breadsticks reasonably fast. As an aside one thing I like is their pizza sizing is actually accurate. A medium pizza is easily enough for 2-3 people and large pizzas are actually large. We got an "all the way" pizza which includes garlic, pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, banana peppers and mushrooms. It was a super stacked pizza for sure, and everything about it was awesome. The crust, toppings, sauce etc. were all very well done and clearly showed why this place won awards in the past. My favorite thing about the pizza was you could tell the vegetables were super fresh, and cut specifically for that pizza and not just pulled out of a Tupperware that's been sitting a few days or whatever most other pizza places do. Easily one of the best pizzas I've had in my life and surprising to find in a quiet small town like this. I'm genuinely sad I probably won't be passing through to try them again anytime soon. The breadsticks were ok, but nothing that really wowed me. Which is fine, the pizza quality easily makes up for that. They also have a good selection of sodas and beer, and have some "fancier" beers like Voodoo Ranger. I only got takeout but it looked like there was a pretty decently sized area for tables to eat in, and seemed like a pretty laid back casual atmosphere. Would 100% recommend if you're in the local area and want high quality pizza. read more

Pizza Crossing - Pizza Near Me - Logan, Ohio

We order our pizza to go, and placing the order was so easy and the person that took the order was so helpful and was able to pick the right pizza style and size. The pizza was delicious all the recognition they have is true. I haven't had a pizza this good in a long time, it was perfect, flavorful, fresh, thin crust load of deliciousness we got the all the way pizza. read more

See all

We stayed in Hocking Hills and I saw a bunch of reviews about the pizza here. The pizza was great! They use cup and char pepperoni which is a favorite for us. Bonus points for me since they cut the pizza in squares. The only complaint I had was we tried at least 5-7 times to call head and order and we never got through. The line was always busy or no one answered. We had to go and wait for our pizza while we made it. Hopefully they get online ordering or more people to answer the phones. read more

Definitely the best pizza I've had in Ohio since I've moved here 4 to 5 years ago. We are in town for spring break trip to see Hocking Hills and the reviews were good for this place so we gave it a try and I am so glad I did! Got the pepperoni and the what I called the meat lovers. The guy had no clue what the hell I was saying and probably I thought I was doing a joke by asking for a meat lovers pizza, but it's called the supreme meat. You would think with all that meat on a pizza and all the pepperonis on a pizza that it would be soggy nah, it was perfect. Not typically a fan of the smaller square cut slices, but I got over that pretty quick when I tasted the first bite, it was perfect and really great pizza! read more

We stopped in at Pizza Crossing and ordered a medium Supreme Meat pizza. It was excellent -- the sauce had just the right amount of spice without being too sweet, and the sausage stood out as especially good. The toppings were generous, with plenty of sausage, bacon, ham, and pepperoni on every slice. The crust was fantastic and made on site by the staff. Our server, Brianna, was attentive and friendly without being intrusive, which made the meal even more enjoyable. The atmosphere is simple -- a basic storefront with lots of seating -- but it's clean, comfortable, and welcoming. There's also a bar, though we didn't imbibe on this visit. All in all, Pizza Crossing delivers solid, flavorful food and great service. It's exactly the kind of place locals love and travelers are glad to find when they want a dependable, satisfying meal. read more

Pizza Crossing - Medium Supreme Meat Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Logan, Ohio

We have eaten at the Lancaster location which is really good but the Logan location is much better. The server was very attentive and food was brought out piping hot. Inside the restaurant was clean and well lit with some local school relics. As for the food, we started with a large house salad which was more than enough for my wife and I to share. The salad was good but nothing special. Now let's talk about the pizzas. My wife got a pepperoni and cheese and an All The Way with extra cheese for me. Both pizzas were fantastic. The crust is not really thin but had a nice crispy underside. The sauce is applied well but overdone and has a great flavor without overpowering the rest of the pizza. The pepperoni is really good and gets slightly crispy during cooking. The veggies on the All the Way are very good as they are cooked well and still had some firmness left in them and the sausage is a great flavored complement to the pepperoni. We will definitely be making the drive to Logan for the delightful pizza. read more

Pizza Crossing - Pepperoni and cheese - Pizza Near Me - Logan, Ohio

See all

High quality pizza that if ordered well done really opens up the flavors. It wasn't extremely busy this Saturday night so the service was at the ready. The setting is pretty dated and the tables are kind of small. I don't think there has been much updates to the interior in 20-25 years. read more

Pizza was touted as the best pizza in Ohio. Which was probably true 7 years ago when it won the award. Ultimately nothing special, but was made reasonably quick. The restaurant's decor consisted mostly of images and statues of native people. Which in the year of 2025 feels worth a mention. read more

Always will be my favorite. Loved the people and the food is always a cut above. Absolutely love the Italian sausage sandwiches. Just amazing! Great pizza as well. Wow just fantastic. read more

Wow! Coming from Chicago this pizza was pretty damn good! Ordered a pizza with pepperoni, bacon and jalapeños and they nailed it! Went to the bar to wait for my order. Bar was pretty good. They brought my carry out to me. Everything was perfect! Highly recommend this place! read more

We may have been disappointed by all the rain this weekend, but we are not disappointed with this pizza! The staff was incredibly friendly, we had no idea what we wanted when we came in but they were patient and kind. read more

Pizza Crossing - Big foot pizza - Pizza Near Me - Logan, Ohio

See all

I'm just visiting the area for the first time, and tried this local pizza place just down the street from our air bnb. Truly one of the best pizza's I've had in my life! I got the "All the Way" and it is completely smothered in toppings. read more

The is a honost real review. Food was mediocre but service was terrible and turned ugly on great people . We were harassed by the server and threatened and blocked in and kept from being able to leave after paying our bill and was on purpose and sarcastically attacked and embarrassed. Absolutely hope people pass on this place as save o lot pizza would have been a better option . Hope you go out of business read more

So my husband heard about the Pizza Crossing on TikTok. There was a food influencer who traveled around tasting pizza places in Ohio. He stated that their pizza was in his top 5 in the entire state! So of course we had to try it! He was correct AMAZING!! Crust was thin and crispy! Their pepperoni pizza was his favorite bc he stated that the pepperoni tasted more like crispy bacon and I agreed! I myself ordered The All The Way!! Soooo good! Also their cheesy breadsticks are a must! Service was excellent! We even told them they were TikTok famous! They serve ice cold beer mugs all around 5 review read more

Manager very rude. As with most of Hocking Hills they are resting on the fact that there's very few options available. Either get with it and realize where your money is coming from, or get out of it and stop resenting the tourists. Your pizza is decent, but the attitude sucks. read more

I love visiting local places when traveling. However would love to tell you how it was, but after 11/2 hours and still no pizza and two discussions and reminders we left, HANGRY! read more

I love pizza crossing ! The taste is great. However they always seem to let their phones go to voicemail and don't pick up. They also don't have online ordering like the Lancaster one. it's sad . I would order from their more if customer service was better . - get with it Pizza Crossing Logan. read more