Dining at The Commodore felt like stepping onto the set of The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel. It…read moreimmediately brought to mind the family's lakeside gatherings, where everyone was impeccably dressed and every dinner felt like an occasion. The restaurant captures that same timeless elegance of the late 1950s. From the moment we walked in, I knew we were in for a special evening. The candle burning in the reception area smelled amazing and set the tone before we were even seated. The service was impeccable, the lake views were gorgeous, and every detail was thoughtfully done. Even the restrooms were beautiful--spotlessly clean with elegant wallpaper, vintage-inspired furnishings, and even a mother's room, adding to the nostalgic 1950s flair. Now, let's talk about the food. Start your evening with a Boulevardier--it just sounds elegant, and it certainly tastes the part. Pair it with the fully loaded shrimp and crab bisque for a fantastic start. For your entrée, order the filet Oscar with asparagus and whipped potatoes accompanied with additional sides of hen-of-the-woods mushrooms and candied carrots. I also enjoyed an Infante with my filet, and it was the perfect complement to the meal. And whatever you do, don't skip dessert. The rhubarb dessert was the perfect ending--creamy, crunchy with a light meringue topping, and filled with tart rhubarb that balanced every bite. If you're looking for a place where Lake Country celebrates life's special moments, The Commodore is it. With impeccable service, stunning lake views, timeless 1950s-inspired elegance, and exceptional food, it's an experience as much as it is a meal. Make a reservation--you won't be disappointed.

We were genuinely excited to try The Commodore, as we are big fans of several other Bartolotta…read morerestaurants. The setting was beautiful, and the food itself was very good. Unfortunately, the service and follow-up were disappointing. We were not initially offered a wine list, and when we asked about ordering wine for the table, our server assumed we wanted individual glasses. The menu also referenced a soup of the day and dessert of the day, but we had to specifically ask what they were rather than having them explained to us. The biggest issue occurred when we ordered four desserts for the table but were charged for seven. I replied to one of the restaurant's follow-up emails explaining our experience and requesting contact from a manager. I received a quick response saying my message had been passed along, but more than a week went by without hearing from anyone. I then called the restaurant directly, provided my information again, and was told a manager would contact me and address the overcharge. Another week has now passed, and I still have not been contacted or refunded. I really dislike leaving negative reviews, and I gave the restaurant multiple opportunities to resolve the issue privately. While we will likely continue visiting other Bartolotta restaurants, we probably will not return to The Commodore. It is unfortunate because the food was good and the setting was truly 10/10, but the lack of follow-through has overshadowed the experience.

I used to bartend there. Place was awesome and the owner…read moreBob was always a fantastic boss!

Horrible service and worse attitudes. All in a drab atmosphere circa 1975. Keep waiting and don't…read morecomplain.

Listen to the locals. We had a wonderful meal and definitely not Chicago places. Photos of our…read moremeal and ticket attached. Really a wonderful meal and experience.

Korean chix with waffle was amazing for Sunday brunch . We Picked Timmer's not knowing what to…read moreexpect!! Never heard about it hiding there near West Bend...What a wonderful surprise! So classy and lovely in every way. Macy our young and sweet waitress was great! Hats off to chef and all the staff...is apparently under brand new management .... Bldg. and landscape are so beautiful. If it wasn't raining we would have eaten outside on patio!! With views of the beautiful big Cedar lake.

I only have one visit under my belt and I have been torn on a review, but I am familiar with a…read moreregular that tells me my experience is pretty typical of their own experiences. So, very interesting building and space. There appears to be a fun patio area for the summer months and there's a big screen tv that I'm guessing shows sporting events. My review for atmosphere would be 4-5 stars. Unfortunately too much time doing nothing but waiting and looking around killed the visit. I was there on a Saturday at the noon hour. It was not exceptionally busy, especially for the space they have. We were just there to get a coffee and go. Should be in/out in a few minutes right? Wrong, there was one girl managing the counter and two guys visible in the back area. We waited a full 10 minutes at the counter while the girl took one order ahead of ours. I was getting the this is going to take forever vibe and would have left, but we weren't in a hurry and my wife wanted to try the coffee. So once our order was placed and paid for we proceeded to wait another 20 minutes for two drinks and a scone. In that time the counter girl certainly kept moving, although not with any deliberate speed. The two guys in the kitchen did not come out to help her at all and when delivering only two plates to tables did so at a snail's pace. The place really wasn't busy, but the staff they had struggled mightily to keep pace. This is similar to what my friend reports experiencing time and again. To give credit the counter person did apologize for the wait time to place our order and apologized again for the wait to receive our order. So the drinks (coffee and a chai) were average and the blueberry scone was on the dry side of mid. All in all, really nice atmosphere and decorations. Maybe a place to bring your own drink in, because you may not get one from them for awhile. Definitely not a good place to stop if you are in a rush to get somewhere else.

Always great service! Comfortable. Really good food!…read more Reading a couple of the reviews on here from the elitist, whiny, entitled children are hilarious. Go grab your banky and nuk-nuk and take a nap. You need it!

It has been completely remodeled very nice inside. Great for a wedding or large parties. But they…read moreare pricey for the Area.

Our family really enjoyed the atmosphere and were there for a recent cornhole tournament. My kids…read morehad an absolute blast in the relaxed atmosphere and we had a great afternoon. There is a limited menu but the kids really like the flatbreads and the loaded fries are solid. Just don't tell your cardiologist you had them; The only complaint is that at the end of the night we got dipped for a 3% surcharge on our bill for our debit card on a $99 tab and I paid most of it in cash. The service for this size group was solid and Lexi does a great job at the bar. I love playing cornhole and it's a great venue but not sure I will be spending more $$$ there due to the added fees. Small businesses have it tough for sure, but adding fees for customary service is not the answer.

I always enjoy stopping into Stingers. Their outdoor range is fantastic. The indoor sims have…read moreimmersive screens that wrap 180 degrees around you. The simulator software seems very accurate to my ball flight and yardages when playing outdoors. Hands down the best range and simulator spot around.

The new owner is great! You can tell he is putting a lot of work into the place! Everything looks…read moreso much better and you can tell that they are only getting started. I love that they put a bar in now too it's a great place to hang out with the family or with friends!

Nice establishment with different entertainment value. Interior has a golf vibe, obviously, but not…read moreover done. Not much for seating other than the sims and bar. Staff is always polite. Drinks are priced about average for the area. If booking weekend or after work the prices can start getting expensive. There is a lot of competition around but this place is better than most. Only knock I have on it is the limited food menu. Appetizers only. A grill would take this place a step further as Wanaki sims have an edge there.

Love this place service is always great. Went there with my daughter for her birthday i think she…read moreloved it more than I did!

This is a Jamaican owned and operated establishment. They have league bowling. However like most…read morethat like to patronize for the food and bar area Mondays are a good night to check this spot out.