I don't love pies or non-chocolate chip cookies but this ice cream sandwich was a winner for me. No…read moretraditional pies involved (I don't think!). I ordered one of their classics, the caramel + brownie. It was the perfect chocolate to vanilla ratio. The brownie chunks and caramel bits were perfectly placed. I really didn't think I was going to enjoy the vessel, but I did...very much. A chocolate chip cookie on both ends would have been too much here. Peace Pie's biscuit like cookie had a great snap and went very well with the filling. $8 well spent. P.s. peace pies are pre made and non-customizable but they have so many options, you surely will find one you like! Loved their cute mini store front on Carpenters!

A small ice cream shop located off the closed street mall in Cape May. Stopped here after dinner…read moreand tried three ice cream sandwiches. We tried the chocolate mint, peanut butter cookie dough, and coconut cream sandwiches. We then enjoyed them sitting in the mall and they were all very good. The shortbread cookie was great in the coconut cream. The service was quick, pretty sure they are pre made. If you're in the mall area these were great. Will be back to try other options.

Found when other ice cream shops were closed for season. Amazingly different ice cream! Great find…read moremuch better than traditional

Staff was very sweet and patient while the kids picked their ice cream flavors! They have a lot of…read moredifferent options. Definitely recommend checking out. We'll be back for smoothies!

We finally decided to check this spot out! Wow! I get it now. This is the best ice cream spot in…read morethe area (and there are quite a few ice cream spots in the area). Also, a reminder - cash only! Every time I've walked by here, there were always plenty of people waiting in line, even 10 at night. Sometimes out the door and near the parking area. Now, I understand why. The ice cream here is worth it. Plenty of great creations. Really nicely decorated ice cream store. It's perfect to bring your family or your friends. It's everything you would imagine from an ice cream store. We chose the Brownie Sundae. It was delicious! Really well made, with the brownies around the ice cream. It was big enough to be shared or eaten alone. I'm excited to try more when I'm here again. We will definitely be back!

The line is WORTH IT. Just about any ice cream dessert combination you can think of! The menu is…read morehonestly a bit overwhelming in the best way. I decided to do the apple dumpling sundae with soft serve for the 4th of July and my goooodness. One of the best I've ever had. Will be dreaming about this bite until my return.

Nice little place away from the busy downtown area. Pretty good menu for food and ice cream…read more The food came out quick which was a plus. The New England clam chowder were very good. The fries of all varieties were good. I thought my boneless wings were weird, honestly. They were like chicken nuggets balls. The clam strips were good as well. The fresh flounder sandwich was a nice order. Big piece of fish and flavorful. Definitely a return trip needed

Deceiving. Ordered a medium sundae. Says it includes 1 topping, cherry, whipped cream…read more Receipt shows 1.50 added for my topping of choice (hot fudge) Same thing with my boyfriend's sundae, charged 1.50 for rainbow jimmies That's an extra 3 dollars for our order alone, if this happens for every order, that ADDS UP

Always the Best ! Love the Coffee shop !…read moreWe are Local residents and during the summer months when all the tourists are here in Cape May ... if you don't want to wait the Coffee shop is the Best

While the restaurant is great and nostalgic and we enjoy it, we never knew about the "other"…read moreLobster House. A locals secret. The coffee shop has no signs outside and when you walk in you'll find a retro coffee shop/diner experience. Now for the secret....they have their own menu with lower prices than the main Lobster House restaurant but share the same kitchen. In fact you can see the kitchen from the swinging doors behind the counter. This is great in the off season but when it's nice grab it to go and head to to the docks behind the restaurant where you'll find plenty of tables and also some walk up raw bar and drink spots.

$20 cash for ice cream and 6 average tasting cookies that have been getting smaller each year. The…read morekids working here are well trained, attentive, and friendly. The ice cream is Bassets. It's close to our house and convenient which is why we come here occasionally but definitely not worth going out of your way for.

Excellent cookies! Also extremely thoughtful and friendly service…read more Highly recommend!

Quite simply the best donuts and cinnamon rolls you can possibly imagine eating are served at this…read morefriendly establishment run by a family. You won't find any of those design your own donuts like you might get a duck donuts. These are your classic donuts done with superiority. There's something that they do with that dough that makes it so much better, lighter, tastier; you really do just have to try one to know the experience of eating a Madison's doughnut . Devotion to their donuts starts at 3 AM every day to start making these wonderfully tasty delight. Every year my family comes to Cape May, and we look forward to getting Madison's every morning that we're here. We could not imagine coming to Cape May without Madison's. I hear there are crazy people out there that have negative things to say about Madison's. I have no idea why you would ever say something other than - this is the best donut ever in your review.

Delicious pastries. Lots of variety. Different selections daily. My favorite is the sticky bun but…read morethe cinnamon rolls are right up there with the best of them.

Very friendly staff, the ice cream was great. Been going here for years and hope other people can…read moreexperience the joy of coming here as much as me. The owner was fantastic and never takes a day off, has lots of jokes and very friendly with families.

The ice cream is amazing here and the owner is so nice. Right around the corner from our favorite…read moreItalian restaurant in Cape May. So after dinner we stroll on by have our dessert. Oh and they have gluten free ice cream cones. Great flavors.