Peace Pie

105

221

1300

4 months ago

This place is so adorable! We have walked by it many times, but finally decided to get dessert here recently. Homemade ice cream cookies so delicious. read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Deb F.

0

7

1

22 days ago

Ordered lemon crème-no lemon flavor. It was so vanilla that I went back and asked if she made a mistake. She said the Lemon flavor came from lemon topping spread on the cookie. I don't know about other flavors but this one was disappointing! It should taste like lemon if flavor is lemon crème or else change the topping to impart more lemon flavor. read more

Peace Pie - Peace pie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Nina L.

439

133

620

7 months ago

This is my favorite dessert spots in Cape May! I love that their classic flavors are nostalgic pie fillings This spot is a takeout window at the heart of downtown Cape May. I just went up to the window to order and got my ice cream sandwiches. Banana Cream: my favorite! Vanilla shortbread cookie with real banana filling and creamy vanilla ice cream PB Brownie: another fave! Vanilla shortbread with rich chocolate brownie and peanut butter ice cream Raspberry chocolate: tangy and sweet raspberry ice cream with chocolate cream read more

Peace Pie - PB Brownie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Peace Pie - Chocolate Raspberry - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Stephanie L.

626

467

1229

8 months ago

Super cute little shop with a window for ordering. There's no seating but sometimes I'll catch people sitting on the flower ledge in front. Such a creative and unique take on an ice cream sandwich. I had a vanilla ice cream sandwich in between vanilla shortbread, with custard cream and toffee pieces. It looks small but is filling. Cost $8 read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Kate F.

1

163

21

10 months ago

Thankfully you don't know the ingredients when you are at the shop but we happened to grab some from the freezer at our hotel and I was SHOCKED. This is not ice cream. It is pure chemicals with a dash of dairy. But don't worry, they donate .05 cents from each sandwich to Doctors Without Borders. Unfortunately you'll need a doctor if you eat enough of these toxic 'ice cream' sandwiches. read more

Peace Pie - Horrible ingredients - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cindy M.

667

1609

9653

2 years ago

This Cape May gem is an ice cream shop that will visit for years to come. The small shop has a cool walk up window. The ice cream sandwich is tasty and tons of cool flavors to choose from. I'll be back read more

See all

Helpful 6

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kaitlin E.

0

11

19

10 months ago

Stopped by Peace Pie in Cape May and tried the Peanut Butter Brownie ice cream sandwich. The flavor was incredible--rich, indulgent, and packed with the perfect combo of peanut butter and chocolatey brownie goodness. It definitely satisfied my sweet tooth! The only drawback? The cookies holding the sandwich together were a bit firm, which made it slightly tricky to bite into and eat neatly. Still, totally worth it for the flavor and fun experience. The shop has a colorful, inviting vibe and a menu packed with creative options. Would definitely come back to try more flavors! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jason M.

982

1839

8122

2 years ago

Peace Pie fell on my radar when researching eateries to try while in Cape May. The name piqued my interest, being a fan of pie and dessert in general I thought this place was right up my alley. Also, the Yelp reviews and recommendations of this place sounded great - so I made it my intention to check them out during my trip. While Peace Pie is not technically in the Washington Street Mall, it sits parallel to it on Carpenters Ln near several other businesses; it's very easy to get there if you're at the mall. There is no interior to the shop, rather it is a walk-up window with all of the production being conducted in a small structure. The exterior is really capturing to the eye - it's bright with an inviting aura. I quickly learned - and it's worth noting - that Peace Pie does not sell pies as in the baked good. Rather, they sell ice cream sandwiches - their signature being that each sandwich has a layer of pie filling in it. In addition to this location in CM, they have two other spots in NJ plus others in SC and FL. As I approached the window I noticed a menu with all of the flavors listed. They have a lot - but it really only lists the flavor name/combo without giving detail to the actual components of the sandwich; you would need to ask or consult the website to get that information. Anyway, the triple vanilla looked good so I went with that - it was vanilla ice cream with a layer of vanilla mousse between two shortbread cookies. The sandwich itself was good - better than a typical ice cream sandwich. Even though it was premade, the quality itself was higher than what I have found elsewhere. Service was fast - there was nobody else there when I arrived so I was taken care of right away. Overall, I was impressed with Peace Pie - it definitely fits in well with the whole beach aesthetic of Cape May, and I wouldn't be against returning the next time I'm in the area. read more

See all

Helpful 8

Thanks 0

Love this 4

Oh no 0

Bina P.

190

319

179

11 months ago

I am not a fan of ice cream sandwiches but had to try this place after seeing the line. I split the salted Carmel brownie cookie and boy was it delicious. Highly recommend read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Gloria L.

165

428

1064

1 year ago

My husband and I love Peace Pie and always stop by here when we're in Cape May. My only complaint is that they have so many different flavors and variety that I have a hard time choosing one every time I go. They have two lines and are very efficient if there's a lot of people in line. All of the flavors I've tried so far have been great! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lee E.

4

282

53

9 months ago

It's delicious! My wife and I had the banana cream and an apple pie (?). My only gripe is there's no north jersey location read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michele C.

40

304

553

2 years ago

Had to try this spot. Got the cookie dough sandwich. I wish a little bit more cookie dough and wish the cookies that make the sandwich were a little softer, but overall it was good. Also the girl serving the ice cream didn't have too much of a personality. I felt like asking a question was a major inconvenience for her, but whatever. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Sarah D.

1

26

18

1 year ago

Unique flavors and good ice cream. The sandwiches are pre made so you can't mix and match. The ice cream definitely needs a minute to soften but good still. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sarah G.

55

110

381

2 years ago

My 1st time at Peace Pie. I surely was missing out. Such a cute place and so vibrant and colorful. Love the peace signs in the front. The large flavor sign made it easy to pick a flavor and I love how every pie is $8. You can't beat one set price ! I definitely recommend the salted caramel brownie ice cream sandwich ! It was so sweet and the brownie was so gooey and delicious! read more

Peace Pie - Salted caramel brownie ice cream sandwich - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

CW F.

46

81

13

7 months ago

All that and then some. I love this place and wish we had one in Westchester, NY. Wonderful flavors and creative concoctions. There is something here for everyone. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Vivian L.

104

91

125

2 years ago

A cute little ice cream sandwich spot right in the heart of the Washington Square Mall in downtown cape may. It's the perfect little treat to cool yourself in the jersey summer weather. I love the variety they have and each flavor combination sounds amazing and unique. I would have loved to try a few more flavors but one is decadent enough. Service was quick and friendly. Would recommend for any ice cream lover!! read more

Peace Pie - Jersey Devil - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Peace Pie - Outside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Emily C.

Elite 26 All-Star

142

693

2942

3 years ago

Fun spot for a cold and sweet treat! The exterior is colorful and fun. There are a ton of flavors to choose from, maybe too many -- it is hard to know what each flavor's name actually indicates. Separating out the menu by type of cookie, or otherwise indicating the type of cookie used on each peace pie (like color coding) could be an improvement. During our time in Cape May, we tried the blueberry lemon drop, peanut butter blondie, and caramel coffee toffee. The blueberry lemon drop was incredible and I was thoroughly impressed. I thought the other two were just OK and wouldn't order again; the chocolate cookie on the caramel coffee toffee tasted old and/or burnt. Definitely overpriced for what you get, but still a fun treat! read more

Peace Pie - Blueberry lemon drop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Peace Pie - Exterior - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Peace Pie - Caramel coffee toffee - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Peace Pie - Peanut butter blondie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Jennifer C.

0

19

13

1 year ago

Stopped by here after Coast Guard graduation & we loved it so much, we went back later at night for round two! The cookies alone are to die for. Bananas and Cream was a fave of the kids while mom died over Peanut Butter Chocolate brownie during our second visit. This is a must stop for any ice cream lover!!!!!!!! read more

Peace Pie - Round one- Bananas and Cream, Key Lime& Peaches &Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Leah T.

7

64

24

10 months ago

I wish I had taken a picture but we ate them so fast it was impossible! These take the term "ice cream sandwich" to a new level. The team onsite works so quickly so don't be deterred if there's a line; it's a hidden gem right off the Washington street mall and absolutely worth a stop. I loved the Key Lime Pie and my husband would absolutely drive over from the wildwoods for the peanut butter cup again. Don't miss Peace Pie, go level up and enjoy! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jennifer B.

5

32

16

8 months ago

A must stop when in Cape May. So many flavors to choose from. Big enough to cut in half and share.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michael T.

36

143

510

3 years ago

A long overdue review for one of my favorite ice cream spots in the area. Peace Pie serves ice cream sandwiches in Cape May. They're different than your typical ice cream sandwiches. The two cookies are very firm (maybe a little too firm) and are quite tasty. They change flavors pretty often and I've sampled quite a few of them. Not a single one has disappointed so far. These sandwiches are pretty big too, I suggest only trying to chew through one cookie at a time. But anyway, this is a great spot to quickly get some really tasty ice cream. Good value for what you get (as of now the going rate is $8). OMy only suggestion to them might be to make slightly softer cookies? PS: they are open year round to boot! read more

Peace Pie - Key Lime Pie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Ethan M.

0

11

2

9 months ago

Large ice cream sandwiches very good prices lots of variety in flavours shortbread cookie was great service was awesome napkins were available great ice cream I got the s'mores ice cream sandwich read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Paul M.

37

505

1234

2 years ago

Some really good ice cream sandwiches from a cute little stand right off the main shopping strip in Cape May. Friendly patrons and darned good ice cream sandwiches. Their chocolate cookies surrounding the ice cream are yum and the peace signs are a cute touch. Best $8 you'll spend on ice cream. Bring the kids elsewhere unless you want to drain your wallet. read more

Peace Pie - Triple chocolate - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Elena Y.

Elite 23

5

50

76

3 years ago

Get yourself the salted caramel apple! It's so good without being overly sweet. The salted caramel balances out the sweetness and the apple is so good in this. I've tried some of the other flavors but this one is my favorite. read more

Peace Pie - Salted caramel apple - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Caitlin S.

12

44

54

2 years ago

Peace Pie is one of the best ice cream places in Cape May! I've been an avid customer of Peace Pie ever since they opened. Since then they've opened up more locations across the East Coast and even offer shipping across the country. The service here is always top notch and the prices are reasonable. The ambiance is very different from what you normally see in Cape May but don't let that steer you away as Peace Pie is a gem! There are many flavors of ice cream sandwiches to choose from so there is something for everyone. The layer of pie filling gives it an excellent twist on the classic ice cream sandwich but it's small enough that most picky eaters (myself included) don't have a problem with it. All in all, I would highly recommend a stop at Peace Pie while you're down the shore in Cape May! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Heather J.

Elite 25

88

65

296

2 years ago

Yummy!!! A great dessert that I get every time I come to Cape May. Service was friendly. You will not regret a stop here! Such a fun vibe read more

Peace Pie - Peanut butter. If you ask they will cut it in half for Sharing - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Peace Pie - Peace out! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Peace Pie - Mint chocolate - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jenifer M.

8

147

61

2 years ago

Unique and tasty dessert. I love that they will cut the sandwich in half (if you ask) and you can be a little less indulgent. Service nice and it's close to Washington mall. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Urooj F.

147

252

503

3 years ago

Delicious ice cream sandwiches! They are not made fresh on the spot, they are pre frozen but honestly taste amazing! And bc they come pre made, the line goes quick if there is one. read more

Peace Pie - Brownie ice cream sandwich - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Emilia J.

0

10

23

2 years ago

I give this place 3.5 stars. I got the banana cream cookie sandwhich. The sandwiches comes premade so you can't try any sample which is understandable. The sandwich in itself was good. No freezer burn, nice cookie and the banana filling wasn't too overpowering. I will say I was a little shocked to hear it was $8. I wouldn't say it's extremely expensive but i probably wouldn't come here often. I still look forward to try the other flavors tho! read more

Peace Pie - Menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Micah C.

63

215

584

3 years ago

This place is a must if you're in Cape May! I don't really like ice cream sandwiches, but the pie crust is a game-changer. I love the texture of the crust with the soft and creamy ice cream. My favorite flavors are peaches and cream and the blueberry cobbler. They did bump up the price -- each ice cream sandwich is now $8 this summer 2023. read more

Peace Pie - Peaches and Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Business owner information

Maryrose L.

Thank you; so glad you enjoyed!

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michele M.

0

5

1

9 months ago

Amazing concept and you can find any flavor you like - there's something for everyone. Granted you need to know that they only have ice cream sandwiches - but this is likely going to be the best ice cream sandwich you've ever had - at least in my humble opinion. Service is quick and easy - we have gone 3xs and never a wait. Highly recommend the caramel bromine classic - the vanilla ice cream in it is literally some of the best vanilla ice cream I have ever had! We have also tried the Banana Cream Pie (not my thing because I don't like bananas and it had nutmeg in it) but my husband liked it. The chocolate strawberry shortcake with strawberry ice cream and chocolate cookies is my 2nd fav! Love this place. We will be back. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Alyssa D.

0

4

0

9 months ago

Delicious ice cream and courteous service!! All flavors were very good. 10/10 recommend

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Nick C.

451

382

916

5 years ago

Fun and delicious! Trust me, this place is definitely worth a visit. We were amazed by Peace Pie's large menu of ice cream sandwiches (their framed Allman Brothers tee caught our eye too) that we had to try them. Our family tried many different flavors throughout our visit, and my personal favorites were the Jersey Devil (with some delicious blueberry ice cream) and the Peanut Butter Brownie. Save some room in your stomach for some dessert at Peace Pie! read more

Peace Pie - Jersey Devil (yes that's blueberry ice cream), so good!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Mary R.

0

27

45

2 years ago

This place is soso good!!! highly recommend! lots of options! we got mind chocolate & pb blondie and they were both delicious!!! read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Thomas G.

7

284

345

4 years ago

Simple ice cream sandwiched by two cookies. Whenever we're in town this place is a must and I imagine has stolen some desert sales from the surrounding restaurants. A variety of gourmet ice creams and choice cookies make this a life changing experience according to my wife. They are big and awesome and at $7 a sandwich it's easy to share with your partner. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Anastasia R.

43

202

269

4 years ago

Tasty treat on a hot day! This is a fun take on an ice cream sandwich, but I found myself missing the softness of the typical flying saucer wafer. My husband liked the shortbread cookies of the peace pie so it's definitely dependent on personal taste/preference. The pie filling was creamy and complimented the ice cream well. I took my sandwich apart and mostly ate the ice cream/filling. They have so many flavors so if I were to return, I'd try one with the chocolate cookies instead. By the way, since they're pre-made, expect a very cold first bite if you dive right in. read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Martin M.

21

60

34

2 years ago

A wide variety of delicious ice cream sandwich flavors - frozen solid but eat it fast on a hot day! The staff is always polite and efficient- great service. 2 lines that move quickly. I recommend the Jersey Devil sandwich! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Marie S.

0

68

44

1 year ago

A place like this could only have good reviews at a beach. The ice cream is mediocre, the cookies on the sandwiches are thin and hard, and there is little flavor overall. Plus, they give it to out of a cooler (premade), in a paper cone with no napkins, and there is nowhere to sit, no inside at all, or even a garbage pail to throw out the mess. Not worth the effort. I wouldn't go here again. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Isaac M.

0

5

1

2 years ago

This was my favorite dessert I've EVER had! Such a fun and unique idea for an ice cream shop. I had the salted caramel brownie and my wife had the pb cookie dough; both were incredible. I want to try every single flavor!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ponnu V.

Elite 24

37

27

24

3 years ago

Peace pie is amazing! The ice cream sandwich is huge and so many flavors to choose from! We went 3x on our last Cape May visit because I am obsessed with he strawberry shortcake. Two windows open and service is quick! Totally worth the trip. I'm read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 7

See more reviews

More info about Peace Pie

326 Carpenters Ln
Cape May, NJ 08204
Directions
(609) 435-5321
Call Now
Visit Website
http://peacepieworld.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does Peace Pie open?

Peace Pie opens at 12:00 PM on Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Peace Pie close?

Peace Pie is closed on Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday.Peace Pie closes at 9:00 PM on Thursday.Peace Pie closes at 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.Peace Pie closes at 8:00 PM on Sunday.

Mon-Wed ClosedThu 12:00 PM - 9:00 PMFri-Sat 12:00 PM - 10:00 PMSun 12:00 PM - 8:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Peace Pie take Bitcoin?

No, Peace Pie does not take Bitcoin.

Does Peace Pie take credit cards?

Yes, Peace Pie takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Peace Pie have catering options?

Yes, Peace Pie does have catering options.

Does Peace Pie have a drive thru?

No, Peace Pie does not have a drive thru.

Indoor Amenities

Does Peace Pie allow dogs?

Yes, Peace Pie allows dogs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Peace Pie have bike parking?

Yes, Peace Pie has bike parking.

Does Peace Pie have parking?

Yes, Peace Pie has parking options. Street Parking

Other Amenities

Is Peace Pie wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Peace Pie is wheelchair accessible.

Does Peace Pie have free WiFi?

No, Peace Pie does not have free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

The Ice Cream Sandwich with a Layer of Pie Filling!

History

Established in 2015.

I still remember coming home from college for Thanksgiving in 2009. Walking into my father's house in Woodstock, he said, "Joe, you aren't going to believe what I just made." (I've learned to become concerned when he says those words) "I took your pecan pie recipe, put it on top of a shortbread cookie in a large baking tray, and covered it all with ice cream! I call it 'Pecan Pie a la Mode Lasagna!'" My less than enthusiastic response quickly changed after I tried a piece. And that's how it began. Now, the lasagna has become hand-sized portions, and is being produced and sold by the thousands (they also picked up a better name along the way). We know you'll enjoy them as much as we do! See you soon, Joe

Meet the Business Owner: Joe K.

Peace Pie is a family run business, officially established in 2015, but having roots back to 2009. For Thanksgiving dessert that year, my father created a "pecan pie, shortbread a la mode lasagna". Over the next four years, he went searching for how to make his "a la mode lasagna" into an ice cream sandwich. In the summer of 2013, my father enlisted my help in selling Peace Pies at a local farmers' market on Thursday mornings. They were a huge hit. Building on the success of that summer, in 2014 my father and I brought in the help of my mother and sister as we expanded into 9 farmers markets and many other local festivals. Realizing we had something special, we purchased a storefront in Cape May, NJ. The first Peace Pie store opened up on Memorial Day of 2015. Continuing to build, we have chosen Charleston, SC as the second location, and opened our Meeting Street location on February 5th, 2016. This story is just beginning.

Verify this business for free

People searched for Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt 800 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Dry Dock Ice Cream Bar & Grill

3.7(58 reviews)

1.3 mi

•$$

Nice little place away from the busy downtown area. Pretty good menu for food and ice cream…read more The food came out quick which was a plus. The New England clam chowder were very good. The fries of all varieties were good. I thought my boneless wings were weird, honestly. They were like chicken nuggets balls. The clam strips were good as well. The fresh flounder sandwich was a nice order. Big piece of fish and flavorful. Definitely a return trip needed

Since my last visit there have been only positive changes! They no longer have a minimum charge…read morefor credit cards and now they accept ApplePay too. Fellow Yelper Dee M and I decided that Ice Cream for Lunch is now a thing when you're on vacation, so we headed over there after a morning of shopping in downtown Cape May. She got a milkshake and I got the 'Smores Sundae. Both were delicious, generous portions, creamy and just the right bout of sweet. Staff were friendly and worked quickly. They were slightly amused at my sheer delight in being able to use Apple Pay. It's the little things, people. Love this old school ice cream parlor, and hope they have many more successful years.

See all

Hours 8-2023

Kohr Brothers Frozen Custard

4.1(96 reviews)

We stopped by for some frozen custard. It was a cute shop with soft serve custard. The girl behind…read morethe counter took our order. We got a small vanilla custard dipped in chocolate. The ice cream was good especially with the chocolate dip. The price however was a little steep for a small cone (over $7).

Classic life cream spot but not a fan of how much the prices have gone up…read more $17 for two regular size cones is a bit crazy imo. One with chocolate dipped and one with jimmies. Very fast service.

Ice cream time

Vanilla / orange sherbet!

See all

Fine Fellows Creamery

4.5(151 reviews)

Cute ice cream shop in Washington Street Mall in Cape May! I'll be honest I can't remember exactly…read morewhat the flavor was but I think it was salted caramel pretzel lol! Very good. You can try some samples while you're there too.

I had Fine Fellows Creamery bookmarked for a few years now, well before I ever made any plans to…read morevisit Cape May. However, I always knew I would be back, and when I did I wanted to check this place out. I love ice cream, and while they can be a dime-a-dozen on the Jersey Shore, FFC stood out with their great Yelp reviews and the high visibility of its owners across social media. I had finished dinner and was looking for dessert, so I thought this was the perfect opportunity to stop in for some ice cream. FFC is located on Beach Ave, right in the heart of one of the main drags in Cape May (also, conveniently around the corner from where I was staying). The decor is super fun - the entire space is decked out in Pride decor, with colorful ice cream aesthetics on the walls and an overall upbeat vibe. FFC serves Bassetts Ice Cream, I'm not familiar with the brand but apparently their cream content is higher than average so how bad can that be? They have several flavors to choose from, as well as a number of toppings, sundae combinations, and milkshakes. I decided to go with Moose Tracks in a cone - I was able to choose the number of scoops I wanted (I got two), as well as the type of cone I wanted. The ice cream was really good - super creamy with lots of peanut butter cups and fudge; the moose were stampeding. Service was also great - I was taken care of promptly and everyone I interacted with was very friendly. Overall, this was a yes - with the plethora of ice cream spots in the area, FFC stands out by serving high quality product in a fun and inviting atmosphere. I would definitely return the next time I find myself in Cape May.

Death by chocolate

See all

Raspberry truffle on a dipped waffle cone served with pride

Uncle Charley's Ice Cream

4.1(114 reviews)

0.0 mi

When there is a line out the door on a hot summer night for an ice cream spot you get on the line &…read morewait -- cause you know it's worth it! And we were right, a massive assortment of flavors & quite the substantial size cup -- all in all a perfect choice!

Small shop right on the mall being hit hard by people looking for ice cream. One guy behind the…read morecounter but he was super efficient. Small seating area out front. We were here on Saturday 9.20.25. I am not the hugest fan of ice cream. I get it out maybe 1-2 times a year if that. I had a big chocolate craving (as per the usual) so I ordered two scoops of Death By Chocolate in a waffle cone. My friend ordered Chocolate Marshmallow in a cup. Mine was to die for. I loved every second of it. It was scrumptious and fresh. I will definitely return.

Menu

See all

Scoops On Sunset

4.5(37 reviews)

0.5 mi

The ice cream is amazing here and the owner is so nice. Right around the corner from our favorite…read moreItalian restaurant in Cape May. So after dinner we stroll on by have our dessert. Oh and they have gluten free ice cream cones. Great flavors.

A lot of flavors to choose from. I had cappuccino caramel brownies. Very good with some chunks of…read morebrownies. Kid's size is one and a third scoops. Small size has 2 scoops. I didn't realize that they have moose track sugar free until I read the menu on the wall by the register area. I was told that they keep the sugar free at the back. It would be helpful if they have all the menu by the entrance

See all

King’s Ice Cream

4.2(39 reviews)

We both agree that this is a great place to get ice cream. We didn't think it tasted very "home…read moremade" which some other places are but their flavors are great! My husband had the Cookie Monster and it was delicious looking. I had one scoop of Ube and one of the Honey Lavender. The flavors were so real and didn't at all taste like any weird extracts were added. Aside from the flavors, this place is just darn cute! Beautiful decor and some cute little market items to buy.

My family and I came here after my friend has talked about this place numerous times. We decided…read moreto come here and check it out. Wow I would have to say that the ice cream is very delicious. We all loved out ice cream. We were also able to try some samples before getting the one that we wanted. The employees were very nice and accommodating. I would highly recommend coming here and checking them out , you won't be disappointed. It's delicious ice cream and homemade.

Taro soft serve

Ube Ice Cream

See all

Kohr Brothers Frozen Custard

4.4(13 reviews)

0.4 mi

So good! My favorites are the orange/vanilla swirl and coffee (when they have it) with vanilla…read more It's expensive but so creamy and worth it !

After a week long stay in July in Cape May we were basically on the hunt for a new ice cream spot…read morenightly, it's hot & all you do in CM is walk everywhere! Entire Kohr Bros & you bet it hit the spot. Yummy frozen custard & since I'm a sucker for history knowing they've been around for over 100 yrs made me enjoy it all the more/ Super fast service to boot!

$8 Cone

See all

Rita’s Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

[1121] 7/2020…read more This Rita's Italian ice is located in Cape May NJ. Plenty of street parking but most people walk right up to the window. The custard was the tasty Ritas. The staff was not friendly or mean .. just blah with no personality. We sat at one of the tables which seemed to be shared by a few eat places in the same strip mall. Looks like no one was responsible for keeping it clean :(

While I normally love bringing my kid to get Rita's closer to home, my experience at this franchise…read morewas the worst. The owner decided to decried my 5 yr old about the difference between gelato and gelati. He was scared to even finish his order!

See all

Ben & Jerry’s

4.1(51 reviews)

Average Ben & Jerry place. It was clean. The staff was super nice. I had the milk and cookies…read moreand my mom had vanilla. I just can't give it a higher rating because it's just average.

Clean store, pleasant staff and a ton of flavors make this place excellent. The portions are…read moregenerous and the ice cream is rich and delicious. I had the chocolate peanut butter which was an excellent choice. Smooth and just the right amount of rich chocolate and peanut butter.