Such a lifesaver! We have four cats (2 adults and we've recently adopted 2 kittens). I much prefer…read morecoming to Pet Supplies Plus over Petco or Petsmart. We would pretty much never go to the latter 2 if Pet Supplies Plus sold our favorite litter (soPhresh scented paper pellet). Otherwise, they offer many of the same features as the bigger box stores: -rewards points -a great variety of products for all kinds of animals -competitive prices and sales and relevant right now: -curbside pick-up Not as ubiquitous as Petsmart/Petco, I feel like this store has more of a locally-owned feel (looks like at least half of their 400 shops nationwide are individually owned/operated). I'd be a lot happier to shop here if they didn't sell live animals. Just putting that out there. Finally, their staff is exceptionally kind and helpful, much more so than I have historically encountered in the big box stores.

I'm sorry but y'all need to get new staff because the ones you have are completely rude except the…read moreshort white girl with red hair she is very nice and respectful I was told by another employee who was really rude that I had to move from one side of the store because I had my 2.9 pound teacup Yorkie with me, mind you she was in a purse I was carrying and apparently dogs weren't allowed on the side with the fish??? I'm speechless I've been shopping here for like 7 years and I NEVER once had an issue like this before!! Idk why my little dog couldn't be over there she didn't explain anything to me but I had to move away! My 2 pound Yorkie wasn't barking growling or nothing she's super quiet and only had her little head peaking out the bag we didn't do anything wrong?!?? I felt as if I was targeted especially since I seen another dog over in that section and no one said anything to her! Is it because she was black like the employee ( who I assume was also black) she gets the pass?!? Her dog was on the floor walking my dog was in my purse doing nothing!!! Idk the employees name but I think she might of been wearing headphones? Also the white guy at the cash register look like he hates his life and has a certain tone when speaking like I'm sorry but everyone has to work to earn money that's just life! I never write Google reviews but I just had too! I'm thinking about calling my lawyer because I feel discriminated! I also might post a video on tiktok, Facebook, and write a Google review about my experience. DO BETTER PET SUPPLIES PLUS I might just go back in today to get their names not that I want to step foot back in there!! Definitely never shopping here again

This store is much smaller than their Mahopac location but a lot is stored in the back room. Great…read moreprices and reasonable selection despite cramped space. The 2-owners (sisters) are usually on the premises. One is very nice, sweet actually! The other, NOT SO MUCH! I always cringe having to deal with her at check-out, or God forbid ask a question! This store would get 5-stars if it weren't for the one sister/owner, which really is quite sad. Since I live in-between the Mahopac & Brewster stores, I shop at both.

Superior service ... super staff and they have anything you need for animals…read more I go once a week for my seed

We use this local store for the wide variety of specialty foods for our cat. They are not…read moreparticularly expensive if this is the sort of food you normally purchase. The employees are very helpful and they've provided sample of some foods which my cat, who was not eating due to a medical condition she is being treated for, decided she would eat despite her condition. I would also note that traveling far away or paying for shipping to save a dollar or two on some cat food is not that great a deal either. It's nice to have a friendly local store and I'm personally a convert. FYI it seems there are 2 entries for this store so I cross posted this review on the both.

Helpful staff but their prices are OUTRAGEOUS. I paid $31+ for a 60L bag of paper bedding by…read moreCarefresh. Amazon is $21.99 and Pet Kraze (near Home Depot) is $16.99. Yes, Choice Pets will match, but they don't really advertise it. I think it's ridiculous that you're paying almost DOUBLE from your competitor. For this, and this alone I will not ever go to Choice again. I feel robbed and cheated. I even called the very next day to ask if they would do a price match since I came in less than 24 hours ago and I have the current dated receipt from them AND Pet Kraze. They said no, but if I came in to buy something else they would price match that and keep it in the system. No thanks, I'll be frequenting Pet Kraze from now on.

Great local pet store that offers your hard to find foods and pet supplies, supplements and all…read more Staff is very sweet and kind to to all creatures including humans. Prices are not the best but then again not the worst considering they carry many brands other places do not and a good feeling to help support small local businesses. Wish they had better hours but still high on my list for my fur buddies.

Excellent service! Was very helpful in finding a harness and providing good input! 5/5read more

I love these ladies. There is a genuine care and concern for animals amd their owners here. I…read morealways feel well treated and cared for. They carry very high quality products for great healthy animals. My choice for food is Raw Dynamic which is the best food I've ever used for my dogs. Highly recommend that one.

This is place is absolutely fantastic. I had never met a more caring and helpful owner. She took…read morethe time to walk me through the food choices for my dog's sensitive stomach and ended up giving us free samples of several. She introduced Honest Kitchen to us and it has been a total blessing. It is a superb dog food. The store also has fun and truly indestructable toys. Prior to that only the Kong could claim that label.

I love this store! Staff is always friendly and as an owner of small animals I really enjoyed…read moretheir knowledge and advice on piggies and bunnies which is truly rare at all other stores. Michelle is GREAT and always is the go to person for me. She made me rethink my bedding and food choices and my pets are def the better now. I love that many of the pets are rescues too!

First off it's not called Pet Kraze. It's Pets Blvd. I tried to correct the Yrlp listing but my…read moreedits seem to have been ignored I used to like the place but on my recent visit was pleasantly surprised they got rid of the composting (no flush) urinal - so the bathroom no longer stank of piss.....however I spotted some kind of bugs on the floor 3x this visit and that was enough to make me abandon thee shopping trip. Hopefully they take care of whatever the issue is and I can go back without being grossed out.

Our go to place for our hunting and farming needs. Tractor supply always has their stock available…read moreand my favorite part is that's the aisle location doesn't change. you know where to go right when you walk in. I love when the my have their little chickens and ducks for sale! Super adorable.

So glad to have this TS near and not far as I'm often in need of something there, including ongoing…read moresupplies. Staff are very friendly and helpful. I have been going since they first opened and have had many good experiences. TYTS

This is a great store! My wife and I are totally impressed. The owner and staff are not only…read morefriendly and extremely responsive, they also go out of their way to make sure you get what your pet needs. We used to have to drive to Albany to get the food we needed for our dogs. Not any more. How good is that!? I heartily recommend them and wouldn't shop anywhere else. Wil E.

Update: if I could give this place less than 1 star I would. Gave my dog the sweet potato treat…read morelast night (same day it was purchased) in small pieces in portions. Made sure she didn't eat it all at once. She woke us up at 6am yacking up the sweet potato and left orange vomit everywhere. No idea if it was old or bad but stay away. Honestly what a disappointment. You can get everything there at any other pet store. There's nothing local or unique. Some Grateful Dead toys but they're from a brand. Some slightly more elevated brands that maybe you can't find at PetSmart but that's it. The girl working the counter was incredibly rude. She was on the phone talking loudly for at least 5 minutes. Said she was talking to her boss to a customer she was ringing up at the register but then talked about personal stuff on the phone. The store is very small and cramped. Even though it's a pet store it's not dog friendly. The girl never acknowledged my dog. I asked if they had any local baked dog treats like most small individual dog stores do, she pointed me to a shelf of big brand dog treats. I clarified and she was clueless and then said no. Waited at the register to buy something and she was looking at paperwork on a clipboard even though we were directly in front of her with our wallet out. Asked for a sweet potato treat. She shoves the container from her side of the counter at us. I asked for a bag for it. She expected me to go in there with my hands and take it. Immediately started ignoring us after we paid. It's a cute name but that's about it.

Animalia was a true down-to-earth pet shop, Pete the original owner was an awesome guy, very…read moreknowledgeable in his field, and all the great guys that worked for him, I miss that pete shop so much, I almost lived there, I was in that pet shop nearly every day. that sad day when I found out they were closing there doors was painful. then many years later , one of the workers named Mike decided to buy the name and reopen this great pet shop again, in Fishskill, NY, mike now the new owner had brought back what a real pet shop is really about, a true down-to-earth pet shop that actually sells pet animals like they did years ago, he has brought back what a pet shop use to be years ago, not like these so called pet shops that just carry supply and very minimal pets. I highly recommend visiting Mike's Animabilia pet shop,

Great place, pets are cared for properly with proper substrate, heating and lighting unlike most…read moreplaces like petsmart or petco. Insects are healthy a​nd good to feed to your reptiles. Plants live after purchase and don't look under watered or dying. Their selection of cork bark is always great and their exotics are always changing and seem to be well priced.