So I stopped by with my family tonight for a quick bite out. I've had Taco Island once before but…read moreto take home, I don't recall what I got the first time around but I do remember being impressed. Growing up in New Mexico and Texas, I find it hard to find a spot on LI that helps satisfy the craving for good Mexican/TexMex. Tonight, we got a pretty good platter of food. My wife and I got a total of 8 tacos, 4 Birria tacos (2 of each), and 4 street tacos. (2 carne asada, 2 carnitas). My kids each got a quesadilla, regular and chicken bacon ranch. I tried the chicken bacon ranch and that thing was pretty serious lol. My kids could have definitely just shared one. With all of that being said, the carne asada street tacos were definitely my favorite of everything, followed by the carnitas then finally the birria tacos. The salsa verde they served in the cup was as authentic as they come, and I put that sh** on every single bite. Something about the salsa verde in the bottle just wasn't hitting the same. As my family was wrapping everything up, this nice young lady approached us and offered complimentary churros for the kids! Super nice of them. This experience was definitely a 9/10 for me. I would probably just skip the birria tacos next time, personally.

I rarely give a five star review but the service today was outstanding. First time trying this…read moreplace so I tried the shrimp and carne asada Mexican street tacos and both were delicious overflowing with shrimp and steak. The steak was tender too. Hubby had the avocado and fish taco and he thoroughly enjoyed it. We also shared a taco de birria barbecoa and the pulled beef was so tender melt in your mouth. The tamarind drink was very refreshing and would order it again. The churros came toasty and warm. There are only a few tables inside but there are also cute colorful tables outside as well. Will definitely be back.

Went to the Setauket location and everything was better than the next! Our server was incredible…read moreand so sweet. The birria tacos are incredible, my daughter loved her beef taco bowl and my husband loved the chicken tacos (didn't get a pic of those they were eaten so fast ). I ordered a Paloma it was delish! We will deff be going back!!

Chicoa is amazing. If I could eat here every day I would. Great food, good prices and kind people…read more Not too loud either. Great place!

Stopped in for lunch. Restaurant and counter area with food were very clean. I had a bowl with the…read morehoney chicken, yellow rice, pinto beans, corn salsa, shredded cheese, and guacamole. The honey chicken was very tender and flavorful, so good!! My husband had a bowl in the fried tortilla, which was fresh and crunchy. He ordered the honey and shredded chicken. Both were excellent. He loaded his bowl with more than I can list. It was an enjoyable lunch. For 2 bowls and 2 bottles of water $35. Out of all these chains, this was the best for us by far.

This is our favorite take out Mexican food. It is very delicious and always fresh and the portions…read moreare quite generous the guys working there are great

Some of the best tacos around! Vegetarian burrito and black bean soup are great. Love the fish…read moretacos as well.

Whenever we crave fish tacos, this is the place we think of, plenty of fish stuffed in a taco,…read moredelish! Chicken quesadilla is also my favorite along with their salsa.

Came here with a coworker for lunch. We had seen this place while in the area. It was ok. The…read moreservice was good, the ambiance was fine, and the food was fine. It seems like one of the only places like this in the area. It is not personally someplace I will return, but if you're in the area give it a try for yourself.

SITTING DOWN EATING AND SAW A RAT running through the restaurant !!!!…read moreI'm grossed out and never eating blue tortilla ever again. absolutely disgusting l It was 5pm broad day light! and there's rats running around!

Great food, diner/dive feeling interior. Friendly staff. Primarily a Spanish-speaking inside with a…read morebig menu that they do well. Tortas are perfect

This is a authentic Mexican food place , the chef and staff are very friendly, all the food was…read moredelicious, the tamarind juice needed a little bit more sugar but everything else is on point . Will definitely come back again.

The ambiance is amazing and the lone mariachi that played here was very talented. I recommend this…read morerestaurant to anyone looking for a different dining experience and good food.

We ate here for Mother's Day and had a wonderful time! We did have to wait a bit for our seat…read moredespite having a reservation, but the staff were super kind and friendly that we didn't mind waiting in the gorgeous garden lounge outside. The staff here make this place as amazing as it is. Many of them have worked here for many years, a few remember my family coming since I was a toddler! The food was fantastic, especially my delicious Carne Asada. Cooked perfectly and super flavorful. I also loved my Bahama Mama drink, which was special for Mother's Day. It was so good, I had to get a second round! This is a great spot I will definitely be visiting for many years to come.

I love this place. You always get very good food. Great…read morealternative to crappy fast food when you don't want to cook. I usually get it take out and bring it home and it has always been fresh and delicious.

My wife ordered dinner delivery she got quac and chip and pulled pork bowl…read moreShe liked both For me she ordered 12 piece chicken wings plain And they came burnt and and uneatable.

We wanted some birria tacos and Mexican food and found this place on Google. We ordered at the…read morefront and sat in their seating area. We ordered the Green Cactus Combo, Birria Tacos, Burrito Fajita, and a Passionfruit Jarritos. The Birria Tacos and Burrito Fajitas both came with a side of chips. The Green Cactus Combo was good, and the portion was big. It also came with a tortilla. The steak was juicy and well-seasoned. The Burrito Fajita was flavorful and big. Our favorite item was the Birria Tacos. They were juicy and flavorful, and the cheese was a great addition. However, we do wish they served a bigger portion of the consomé. The price for our meal was pretty good. Overall, we would come back here for their Birria Tacos and to try their Horchata.

They give a whole brown paper bag of chips when you get a chicken quesadilla to go, but when you…read moreeat it in the restaurant, they literally give you 8 chips on top of the quesadilla on the plate. When I politely asked the lady there for a few more, she says "that's extra". I asked why you get more when it's takeout and a whole bag as opposed to just a few on the plate when you eat in the restaurant and she says, "that's not true." It surely is true. Every single to go quesadilla I've gotten there for the last 20 years has come with a full bag of chips that I can't even finish by myself.. but when you eat in the restaurant and order the same exact thing you're given 8 chips... I have a question for management - what is more expensive- a few extra corn chips or losing a customer for life? You can thank your grumpy, frumpy, bean burrito shaped lady who's been there for 20 years and never once smiled or acted anyway other than forcing a monotone response to the customers. I mean, I get that she's 50 years old and angry that she's been working at Green Cactus for over half her life but come on.