It was a pretty nice Saturday night. My friend and I were looking for a new place to eat. I used my Yelp "special abilities" and found a Hot and New place to eat. That place happened to be Chicky's.
Parking is pretty limited since only street parking is available. There is a lot right next to the restaurant that belongs to the diner next door though. There are signs posted that the lot is for diner patrons only and if you are not, you will be towed. Park there at your own risk like I did.
Upon entering the restaurant there was a group of people dining. We walked up to the counter. The menus are well lit on three TV's above the cashier. We were greeted very friendly by the cashier and asked if we needed menus to order. We explained that we reviewed the menu online and had an idea what we wanted. We still took the menus just in case they differed from the ones online. (They were the same.)
We then placed our order. While we were waiting for our orders we were browsing their Instagram and decided to add additional items to our order based on the tantalizing photos that we saw on Instagram. We ordered the quarter chicken (breast & wing), 18 grilled wings with various different sauces, the chicken and waffles (shown as Weekend only on the menu), grilled chicken sandwich, the spicy chicken sandwich, two orders of the chicken skewers, mashed potatoes, Peri Peri French fries, 2 small orders of mac and cheese, and finally the butter corn. The total wait was roughly 30 minutes.
On to the food: The quarter chicken was flavorful down to the bone. The wings were cooked to perfection and sauced well, also flavorful down to the bone. The grilled chicken sandwich was delicious and tender. The Spicy Chicken sandwich was a mixed bag. The chicken was cooked perfectly on the inside, yet the breading was soggy and had a burnt or overdone flavor to it. The sauce on the Spicy chicken sandwich was delicious. I really was looking forward to this. The chicken and waffles were a joke. The chicken was really dry and came with Eggo waffles (Please see pictures). The chicken part of the chicken and waffles was basically inedible (see pics). The chicken skewers were lacking, we found them chewy and it lacked any love. The onions were charred beyond belief, nothing like the stock photos indicated.
The sides were a complete joke. I don't know if it was because we ordered takeout. The fries came out flaccid and the container came out half full (see pics). The only redeeming factor on the fries were the Peri Peri seasoning, but even that couldn't bring it back to life. The mashed potatoes were like plaster with a sludge of some sauce dabbed on top; not drizzled or piped on like in their photos (see pics). The mashed potatoes were dry and needed to be revived- get the paddles- (CLEAR). The Mac and cheese was forgettable, how about using that Peri Peri seasoning on the Mac and Cheese? Last, but not least, was what was called Butter corn, which was more like rubber bullets. It was so overcooked and chewy. It could not be eaten and had to be thrown out.
I would come back for the wings if I happen to be in Queens. If I'm not in the area, I definitely wouldn't go out of my way to come back though. Stick to the chicken, that happened to be the most enjoyable part of the meal. Revise your sides or just drop them off the menu altogether. If you are not going to do chicken and waffles well you might as well just drop it off the menu. It is not a weekend treat. Please be flexible when it comes to kind of meat that you can get with you chicken sandwich, I like white meat chicken but many people prefer dark instead. I came in with high expectations and was left disappointed. Nando's it is not. Please do better. read more