This is one of my favorite restaurants. We eat here at least once a month. I've been coming here for over 15 years now. I usually get the pizzarolli and a salad, but I've tried the roast beef sandwich, the manicotti, and several more items over the years and have never been disappointed. It takes about 20-30 minutes for the food because it's made to order. The staff is always friendly and helpful. This placed does get busy and fill up fast, but we've never had to wait more than 5 minutes to get a table. read more

The front desk manager gave me their menu. I ordered pizza and salad. Very good and fresh ingredients. Good pricing too. Thank you.

It left us with food poisoning and ultimately resulted in my husband being diagnosed with H. pylori.

So, after seeing the reviews I decided to give Chicago pizza try. Looks like an old traditional pizza place. Service was fast and I got a salad and pizza. Rolls drink and salad came quickly. However, the pizza rolls took over 30 minutes. Food taste excellent but don't expect to get it quickly. I think because of where they're located there just low on staff. read more

Chicago Pizza & Pasta - PizzaRoli - Pizza Near Me - Tifton, Georgia

See all

great pizza! great tea! clean restrooms! amazing vibes! quick & polite customer service! 10 out of 10 place! will be back again! read more

For this being a very small and cute little local place in Tifton Georgia, I have to say hands-down one of the best pizzas I've actually ever had. The pizzaRoli it is an absolute must try if you go to this restaurant. It's not like anything other is not like a calzone everything is made in the house made to order fresh ingredients and absolutely delicious. I will say that you will not be able to finish one oh my yourself definitely shareable. I will definitely be going back to Chicago pizza and pasta next time I go to Tifton they definitely have my five star review. read more

See all

Ordered one Philly cheese with only double cheese one regular got the only cheese one without double cheese. Both were way over salted almost inedible. The whole place needs cleaning and freshing up. Someone's used salad bowl was sitting on serving counter next to salad bar. Not impressed today read more

Quick stop traveling through Tifton. Pizza was great! Worth traveling a little off the highway for!

We ordered a large pizza and salad tonight, and it was delicious! I love that this establishment gives you a nice amount of toppings on a pizza!! Yummy read more

Hands down, BEST pizza I've had since I moved here. ALSO, the wait staff is super friendly and attentive. 5 stars!! This will be my new pizza spot. read more

The pizzas we're delivered cold.The delivery guy made up some lame excuse about getting lost.He was the same delivery guy on the last pizza we ordered.Never ever going to buy from there again. I'm from Chicago and that shitty pizza is not even close to being Chicago style pizza.Your crispy crust was soggy and horrible.Their pizza is like Chucky cheese.Terrible. read more

Great food, great service! Best pizza in Tifton. I would highly recommend. Prices aren't to bad either.

Food is great, service is terrible. Staff is rude and doesn't have time for guests. 5 of us went in and 2 got food about 10 minutes before the remainder did. read more

Food was good. Service was good very friendly staff I got there guite often for pizza

Best pizza ever. And I mean it. The pies are pretty large, and the sauce is great--not too acidic, and not too sweet either. Order 2 pies if you want a better price. Garlic IS a FOOD GROUP. read more

We ate here a year or so and the service was bad. We decided to give them another try. Not a good idea. Seat yourself-easy. Tables clean but grillwork between booths covered in cobwebs! Ugh! Took ten minutes for someone to take our beverage order! Another ten after they brought out drinks to take food order. The only thing that came out fast was our appetizer... it wasn't what we ordered but by this time we just ate it anyway. My styrofoam cup leaked. The replacement cup also leaked. Then we waited 52 minutes for our food . Pretty standard Italian fare, good but no... we won't give them another try! Our valiant waitress deserves a prize! Only one on on Saturday night and she was trouper! She needs to make a move to a restaurant worthy of her skills! read more

Chicago Pizza & Pasta - Dining area - Pizza Near Me - Tifton, Georgia

See all

Amazing food. I'm from Los Angeles and I love pizza. I travel all over this place is definitely in my top ten! The pizzaroliii was perfectly cooked thin crust pizza perfectly cooked. Very satisfied and I think Tifton will be a city I start staying at more just because this pizza was that good! read more

They have the best pizza around! They res gravy is superb! Pizza Rolli's are a tradition in my family. We have been eating here for over 20 years! read more

This is what good local food yelp dreams are made of! This place is not far off the interstate and in a building that you wouldn't place as a pizza restaurant. Don't let that fool you! The pizzarollis we ordered were made with fresh ingredients and came with a delicious marinara sauce (if you like ranch, order a side of ranch as it was also delicious! - this comment is for all of the ranch snobs out there - you know who you are). Give this local place a try! Best tip for travelers with kids - order ahead and utilize the drive-thru! read more

Over charge for nothing waste of money and time need better staff , and food sucks smh

My family ordered a half cheese and half Hawaiian thin crust from the hotel we're staying at. Being from Chicagoland, the local tavern style pizza cut in squares has always been my favorite. Love deep dish, but rather avoid it and live another day. I didn't think this was an accurate representation of Chicago thin crust but more of a cross between Chicago and New York thin crust style. It was also not cut in squares. The crust wasn't as crispy and chewy as Chicago style and not as foldable as New York style. The edges were puffier and a little breadier closer to New York style but not quite there. Whatever you want to call it, it was F@$#ing Amazing!!! When traveling South to visit family, will definitely stay the night in Tifton again. I'll let you all you be the judge of the deep dish. I'm not messing with that. read more

I visited this place a week ago while in town training for my job and the service was good; and the staff was friendly. However, the chicken manicotti was horrible. It was overpriced, dry and overall sub par. The week prior, on my first visit, I was pleased with the portion and tastiness of baked the spaghetti. It was good enough for me to try it a second time. It's a hit and miss. read more

It feels like a mom & and pop place instead of a big chain. The location seems a little dingy. OTH - the health score is very good. I have only had the pizza and it is excellent. The servers are very personable, cheerful, and knowledgeable. BTW - the have a pizza available that is absolutely humongous or doubly so. I also prefer their thick crust. Update - this has become our family's go to pizza place. read more

I love Chicago. Vince (the owner) bought this from his Dad when he retired. It is a long-standing example of having a niche in a small town. The pizzarolli is one thing I brag about to visitors to Tifton. I love to get mine stuffed with chicken and broccoli. There is no sauce, so you can choose to dip it in their house marinara or something else (I pick ranch. ..cause I'm southern!). Vince is constantly updating the place while keeping the old vibe. Most of the staff have been around for years. This is a great place to take kids. Be patient though! ! You can watch as each piece of dough is slung in the air to make your pizza. Nothing out of a freezer!! read more

Great product, terrible service. My visits here have ranged from waiting 40 minutes to an hour waiting for pizza. Once, we brought friends here and walked out after 20 minutes because no one came to help us. Pickup/delivery isn't any quicker, either. They're pretty pricey and don't offer specials. That said, it's the best pizza in town. With better leadership/ business plan, they could be a huge success. Their website says it all- a business stuck in the past. I would give a 4/5 on product and a 1/5 on service. read more

Stopped here on the way back to Florida. Don't be fooled by the size of the parking lot or the outside. The food was fantastic and the staff was very friendly. Will stop back again when in the area. read more

My replacement philly was delicious mucho props for customer service for replacing the unsatisfactory Chicago (burger) with the delicious philly! read more

Chicago Pizza & Pasta - This is beef! - Pizza Near Me - Tifton, Georgia

Anytime is a good time for pizza... Mine was fresh,hot and delicious . Ordered the Neapolitan style or thin crust. Pretty good. Local friendly vibe with great cus serv .. Simple menu, small salad bar with cozy family style seating. read more

See all

Great small town stop. Pizza was excellent and atmosphere was laid back. Service was fast and I had my pizza within about 15 minutes after ordering, not bad for a made to order pizza! Make sure to take someone's with you because there's a jukebox plays any music you like. read more

Chicago Pizza & Pasta - 12" 6 slice pizza. Banana peppers, Italian sausage and black olives. - Pizza Near Me - Tifton, Georgia

Very small mom and pop place. Food was good-I had the fettuccine Alfredo-I've had better, but this wasn't bad. Meatballs were good-breadsticks with cheese was awesome. The salad bar was small but tasty. I'm from Ohio or I'd definitely visit again. Staff was very nice as well. read more

Chicago Pizza & Pasta - Fettuccine Alfredo. - Pizza Near Me - Tifton, Georgia

See all

Very good food and quick service. We got a medium pizza and a piece of cheesecake. The pizza was cooked perfectly and the cheesecake was huge. read more

We were on the way back to Florida and decided to give this little mom and pop pizza joint a try. So glad we did. Pizza was amazing and so was the price. We will return on our next road trip. The only reason I did not rate a full 5 was the restaurant was a mess, however it was at the end of the night. read more

This is not Chicago Style Pizza. First I asked the lady taking my order if they served Stuffed pizza. Her response was "we don't service stuffed crust pizza". I should have taken that as a sign and departed but I decided order anyway. I was born and raised in Chicago on Chicago style pizza at best this was a Louisville Kentucky style pizza. Very disappointed nothing close to a Chicago style pizza. Pizza yes ...Chicago style pizza No!!! read more

We were staying at the KOA park. Staff advised us that we could get Chicago pizza and pasta delivered to our site. We ordered the Greek salad and a large pizza and we're pleasantly surprised at the quality of the food. We would do it again Yum read more

We had been driving for hours on I-75 when we decided to look for something OTHER than Chick-Fil-A (which we love but had had four times in three days). We were so blessed to find this place!! Just off of the interstate in Tifton, it's a small place with great food and even better service! We called the order in so we wouldn't be off the road too long, and they had our pizza just about ready when we got there. The small salad bar was fresh and clean, and was just what we needed after eating less-than-nutritious meals while we traveled. We ordered pepperoni and pineapple pizza, and it was delicious- just a tad on the greasy side, but not enough to make me sop it up with a napkin or anything like that. :) They did charge us a quarter each for our waters, which was odd, but wouldn't keep me from returning. In fact, we're going to make this place a planned stop from now on when we make the trek from SC to south FL. -Süz and Kirk read more

We picked up one large pepperoni and cheese pizza, one large meat all the way pizza, one medium cheese pizza, and one medium veggie and meat pizza. The pepperoni pizza was the best pizza I've ever had. The crust was just right. It wasn't too thick or too thin. They cooked the pizza to perfection. It was kind of fluffy, yet not too thick. I loved the sauce it was not a sweet sauce. I would have to describe the pizza sauce as being spicy. They told us that they use a blend of provolone cheese on their pizzas. It just had this unique pizza sauce flavor. One of the more unique toppings they offer for your pizza is meatballs. They offer sweet tea, and a variety of coke products. They also offer pastas and salads. We ordered a salad but I didn't sample any of it. I didn't try it out but they advertise free wireless internet service. They have a kids menu that offers a Pee Wee Pizza. Even though it's small I'm sure it's packed with flavor. This is just another great reason to visit Tifton. read more

Management sucks. Food is pretty good. But I got to subs for 18$ and it wasn't worth it. Wish I got give it 2.5 stars

I have visited Chicago's Pizza before and many years ago I would have bragged on the place, but not now. My wife and I had lunch there today and it was by far the worst experience I've ever had there. Unless there's a tremendous change, we will not go back. There was plenty of employees, but the restaurant was filthy and the food was mediocre at best. Just about all of the tables were dirty from other guests that had clearly already left before our arrival. The employees were talking bad about one another too. After one trip to the buffet, we left without eating everything we got. Some of the food on the buffet looked like it had been there a while. So disappointed. read more

We were going to eat here. Walked in and 5-tables had dirty dishes on them with only two customers eating and at least three people working. Needless to say we left disappointed. read more

Can't review the food as we never got any. In fact, the server walked by our table at least 4 times before we finally gave up and went elsewhere. We understand being busy but a modicum of courtesy would have gone a long way. They did not even acknowledge our presence. read more