Very efficient dinner order and solid flavor. Stomach definitely might've felt it the next day, but…read morewas a great meal for the night and the leftover came in clutch late night (it was a little bit too much to have in one sitting, but that's perfect) Not really a sit down spot, but perfect to order and pick up. Got the job done and nice to have this as a local dinner quick option in Oakdale, where there aren't a lot of options.

I used to really like this brand and product having been happy with them taking over the LI map…read morewith locations - however, I just paid 23 and change for what? This quality of meat doesn't warrant that price point even in today's market. I'm not a food snob I just know food and this is not it. The bread is mid and I would even go to say the beef is below mid. The fries were a good quality fry but it's a cheesesteak place and they gave you enough and it included a drink but overall 5.5/10 from me dawg. Service and space was clean and diligent but Respectfully i thought I would be happy here and I just wasn't,

The pasta and roast beef sandwich was good and ice tea. yummy food. Not the best cookie.read more

Weak service, nothing unique on the menu. Special complete dinner menu has been the same for…read moremore than three years.

Pretty decent and consistent food, though nothing mind-blowing. The chicken is crispy, the smash…read moreburger is flavorful, and I usually get the mix plate since it's a good value -- two burgers and fries. Their milkshakes are really good too, and the fries stay crisp. The mac and cheese was a disappointment though, and I wish they had a spicier or at least more garlicky sauce. Their sauce leans more on the sweet side, which isn't really my preference, and is why I personally prefer Sheikh's more. But overall, not bad.

Unfortunately, not the best visit back. Now it is important to note this is my second visit back,…read moreas my first visit was of the upmost pleasant experience. So I'm not excited about leaving this review. Service: (+) What I will say is the cashier was very nice and welcoming and he seemed passionate about his job throughout conversation! He asked us what we tried the first time and provided explanations and different options on the menu for us to explore. Ambiance: (+) still clean inside (-) it's still SO COLD in the restaurant. We had originally ordered to stay, however after sitting there for a couple minutes while waiting for the order we changed it to go- prefer to eat at home where there is sufficient heat. (-) Another thing was we weren't able to hear each other over the very loud music playing. Not only while we were ordering (we had to ask for the cashier to repeat himself and had to repeat ourselves), but also when we were trying to talk to each other as we were waiting for food. Food: {we ordered the Yoyo Mix Plate, double burger, lotus biscuit milkshake, and Mac and cheese} (+) the chicken sandwich mild is still really delicious, although I'd like to see more coleslaw in it, in order to even out the flavors. (-) the smash burgers were dry. Not like the first time we were here where it was toasted but still moist. (-) lotus biscuit milkshake was good, but didn't seem to be as rich as the one we had the first time. It was watery- seemed to have ice cream to milk ratios off (-) Mac and cheese was my ultimate disappointment. I'm huge on Mac and cheese and the first time we came it was white cheddar and literally top tier flavors. This time around the Mac and cheese was yellow (?)... and it tasted like the Kraft Mac and cheese powder. Really not pleasant at all To me, CONSISTENCY IS KEY. I truly believe a restaurant has hit its peak performance when it achieves consistency. Here, unfortunately, it is missing. To me, the very evident change in the color of the Mac and cheese speaks volumes. It doesn't allow you to speculate whether maybe you might be tasting something different- it's just outright in your face different, and the taste is inconsistent. And not only with this, but also the other parts of the meal I had mentioned above. I can now see some of what had been mentioned by other yelp reviewers to be true. I don't believe I will be back- but do wish this restaurant the greatest success and hope they see this and take the feedback constructively.

We appreciate great service. We enjoy a nice ambience. But ultimately it's the food, right?…read more Well the food at Olympic Diner is excellent. Breakfast - Fantastic pancakes! Possibly the best in the area. Lunch - Juicy burgers! Crispy fries! Like McD*** only better! Dinner - Hot open turkey! White meat. Fresh bread. Rich gravy. Corn. And the mashed potatoes... honestly some of the best I've ever had. Try them! You won't be disappointed.

First off the menu is very very long,, a lot to decide from…read more Totally impressed by the taste of diner food. Usually it's mediocre but not here. The waiter was very helpful and knowledgeable about the food. The wrap was unbelievably delicious. Definitely worth a try if you're in town.

Peter Pan recently reopened after a fire took out the old location in 2024. Walking into a…read morebrand-new version of a place that's been around for generations is a little strange, but the rebuilt space holds onto the diner's identity well enough. Food 4/5 We ordered an omelette and basic eggs. Both came out well, not overcooked, not swimming in grease. Nothing on the plate is going to end up in a food magazine, but solid comfort food. No digestion issues. Service 4/5 I ordered the wrong thing by mistake and they fixed it quickly without any fuss. The waitress came by once for follow up. Ambiance 4/5 Modern lighting, nostalgic photos on the walls. You can still tell this place has some history behind it, even if the walls are new. Cleanliness 5/5 Brand new construction, so a 5 here is the starting point, not an achievement. Still, it was clean. Bathroom didn't look like it was remodeled (at least not the floor.) No issues though. Passed the inconspicuous location dirt test. Parking 2/5 There's a lot, but it's on the small side. At busy times it can be difficult to park there and the parking lot becomes a maze of cars squeezed in all over. Value 4/5 Supposedly any meal before 3 PM comes with pancakes. Ours didn't. I wasn't planning to eat them anyway so I let it go, but worth knowing if you were counting on that. Portions are fair for what you pay. Overall 4/5 Peter Pan is back. The food is what it should be, the service works, and the space is comfortable without overdoing it. I'll be back.

A family institution that has been ruined. We have been going here for four generations and sadly…read morehave no desire to return anymore. We visited twice since it's reopening after the fire. The last visit confirmed that we'll never go back. There are other LI diners with better pricing, food and service. Our last visit started with hot coffee being spilled on my husband's hand by the employee. Then there was no spoon to stir the sugar when a new cup was provided. We had to flag another employee to get a spoon since she disappeared. Never was offered refill on coffee or water. The waitress was nice but lacked training, she didn't even know the menu that the eggs Benedict order was missing the spinach. We received 2 orders with iced cold over cooked poached eggs, the waitress response was that she saw the cook take them out of the water. Also one of them was missing the spinach. Back they went to be made correctly. The new orders came back and one was missing the cooked tomatoes. We didn't mention this because we just wanted to eat. Our eating was stopped early due to the black hair found under the poacher egg. By then we gave up, flagged down another employee because we couldn't find our waitress. She reluctantly took the hairy eggs and we asked for the manager. The manager didn't come to the table but the waitress came back and said the manager said we wouldn't be charged. We left a tip on the table and left heartbroken that the Peter Pan Diner we knew and loved was gone forever. Maybe the new social media guy they hired can help this mess since it appears that they are trying to go the trendy route.

Given this place many different chances. The last sandwich I got here was inedible, disgusting!…read moreTook bite and right in the garbage! It was some mystery meat hero with bacon, cheese etc. Foul. The owner is super nice, service is usually good, counter food looks good. Maybe it was just a bad day. So I tried again, got and egg sandwich, it was very good, but it was $12 bucks, coffee and a snack, almost $20, felt ripped off. Think I'm done here...They were good in the past, but when owner is not there, leave and go elsewhere. You'll thank me later!

I was in town for business and stopped by Gold Coast Deli for a quick lunch. It was very busy when…read moreI got there, and not clear who was in line to order and who was waiting for their food. There isn't a lot of standing room by the counter, so we were all cramped and unsure where to stand. They have a very large selection of sub sandwiches, paninis, salads, and other items. I ordered the Mexican panini, which was pretty large, I couldn't even finish it. It was decent but came with WAY too much chipotle mayo. Not sure I'd order that again, but the other sandwiches looked solid!

I still come to OOTP whenever I'm nearby. Sadly I don't work as close and can't enjoy it almost…read moreeveryday as I used to. I realized I should clarify from my previous review that for Long Island and the rest of the state that is not Buffalo, where quality chicken wings can be hard to come by...wings at OOTP are well above average. You're talking more a 9/10 for what you can expect outside of the chicken wing capital of the world. They're really good, and the sauce flavors are excellent. Still, it's hard to get me to sway from the BBQ bacon burger and Cajun fries, my all time favorite. This is the "All American Burger" of Suffolk County! Always delicious.

Not a bad spot. Very small inside and has a lot of options on their menu to customize your burger…read more I was in the area for court and walked over here for lunch before going home.. decided to order the combos. Ordered two cheeseburger combos, one without cheese. Came out to around $27 for two small burgers with 0 toppings. One had cheese, and they just had ketchup..also came with fries and small drinks. Super expensive if I am honest, a lot of the toppings were also extra $ and the fries were super salty and very fried. The taste wasn't bad but it just didn't justify the price for me. I pay this type of money for a large combo meal in NYC. There was also a huge spider that ran on the floor towards a table lol. I am not used to seeing spiders this big but I am usually not in LI very often. (I didn't take the star off because of the spider, just the overall value of the meal and what we got for it)

Was pleasantly surprised having dinner in a diner that felt more like a five star restaurant from…read morethe wait staff to the service and the food!!! Impressed!

Food was good. I forgot what I had something I couldn't think it's called a hungry man special…read morelooks like two pieces of ham two pieces bacon two pieces of sausage and three eggs something like that anyway it was pretty good but my wife wasn't happy with her french fries she ordered an omelette with french fries they don't have the skinny fries they have these thick fries they're not very good. The waitress was nice I think her name is Amanda she provided very good service the only reason I gave it four stars is because of the fries.