I loved this library before the upgrades and massive changes. It was my favorite of the Garland locations and I was so sad when it shut down for renovations.
I've been anticipating the Central Library's reopening ever since it closed for construction. It had a wonderful collection to choose from and a great design. I was so excited to hear that it had finally opened back up.
I took a friend with me and have been telling her about this library for a long time. She also was excited since she hadn't been prior to the changes at all and this would be her first time.
However, my review is low for a reason.....
Everyone that I took with me to see the changes was shocked. It's a great outdoor design (looks very nice) and once you step inside, it goes from interesting to loud. You can hear kids screaming. It's because the bottom area, which is now completely devoted to the kids section, is basically a major play area, almost reminiscent more of an outside park-like setting with swinging benches and games that leave kids screaming, running around. School is about to begin, so maybe this will die down and it won't be so loud in the future, but it was very chaotic and crazy down there. We were trying to look on one of the children's books aisles, and there were some kids throwing things across the aisle that was part of a game in that area and we basically had to squeeze against the shelves to keep from being in their way.
I'm assuming that they based their changes off of community input, but I've never seen anything like this. It's so loud. Some of it was super cool. I really appreciated the cubbyholes in the walls for kids. Those are great fun reading areas that encourage reading.
I've always thought of libraries as peaceful indoor places to read and relax. This is no longer that place. It's as loud as an outdoor park now. Don't get me wrong. I really thought some of the things included were very cool. But the noise level on the day we visited was extreme and it was nonstop.
If you had never visited this particular library prior to the massive changes, you may not know that the entire bottom level used to be devoted to non-fiction. It is now devoted completely to the children's area. I don't know what happened to their massive collection of non-fiction books but they're gone.... I think a large amount of weeding out took place with the renovation. I used to love the massive selection that this Library offered, and it's possibly in storage or gone? I loved the fact that they had so many shelves of books that offered more privacy when you were looking for something to read, and that's gone. Now, you're being watched by people who are renting computer time when before you could be sheltered by so many shelves. There was a man on one of the rented computers watching one of our kids, and I was very uncomfortable with that.
It was a more intimate comfortable setting before, now it's open, bare, intrusive, loud, sparse with books, did I say loud, and modern. When we left I asked opinions and it was unanimous: we didn't want to go back any time soon. The main reason: the noise. Maybe it will calm down once school starts?
Even from upstairs, the screaming from the first level could still be heard.
The reason that I go to a library is to decompress, to quietly peruse the shelves, to maybe sit and read for a bit, for a relaxing, quiet setting to visit in my free time. I've been at libraries where children played, people talked without whispering, noise was happening and all of that is fine but this was constant screaming. I have never been to such a loud library or to one with playground equipment inside. How can you expect kids to be anywhere near quiet with that? Why would they be?
I'm sure parents with kids will love this. But the kids with us didn't. I'm sure the children we had with us may have liked this if it hadn't been so loud. It was crazy down there and really jarring. The kids said they didn't want to visit again.
I've heard that libraries are beginning to do things like this, I've just never seen it before and I've never even seen it in a big city. Garland is technically not a really big city (comparing to Dallas), but this was very surprising. Loved some of the changes but the noise level was off the charts. Kids didn't like it. read more