Center Cuts

Delicious wood fired pizzas-- We ordered the Lombardi's Love Lane & a Farmer's Market ($16 pies)…read more The pies are sizable and definitely shareable for two. They are generous with the toppings. Dough is very close to Italian pizzas--soft pillowy. Cranberry Walnut Salad by the weight was very expensive although it did taste good. 32 oz container came out to $9! It was a nice side dish to the pizza.

This is a very , very nice Italian Market with an extensive variety of foods and products…read more Pastas , salads , sides, deli products , specialty cheeses , butcher , pizza , panini station and much more . There are tables to sit inside and a few outdoor tables as well . The service was wondering , everyone was so friendly and helpful . I went in for lunch and purchased a delicious hero , The Italy , packed with chicken , eggplant , mozzarella and roasted peppers . It was one of the best hero's I've ever had , so well made , fresh and tasty ! It was big and plenty to share or enjoy for a second meal . I will definitely be back when in the area !

Bread shelf

See all

Village Prime Meat Shoppe

4.9(32 reviews)

10.3 mi

•$$$

Beat meat in the Hamptons . Great staff with Michael leading them. Great selections and variety of…read morecheeses and sauces

Village Prime Meat is THE BEST. I always buy my brisket there for the holidays and the quality is…read moresecond to none. Mike trims it for me and will vacuum pack it for me. The other meats are beautiful. Prepared foods look yummy.

Outside of the shop

Sandwich Specials

See all

Salad offerings by the pound

Peconic Prime Meats

4.7(26 reviews)

9.7 mi

Steve is a maestro butcher whose recommendations are spot on. His bark is worse than his bite- he…read morereally a teddy bear. Cuts of meat especially the heritage pork chops cannot be beat! Selection is outstanding.

Chicken thighs were awesome with the coffee rub! Owner was great and service fast. Will do the beef…read morenext time.

See all

Cooking sausage.

Westerly Packing

4.5(61 reviews)

46.3 mi

Great assortment that tastes wonderful! I go there for the best Italian food. Excellent catering…read moretoo!

Clean , well stocked and friendly staff. It's possible to go there for just one thing and find lots…read moreof other stuff you didn't know you needed!

Soupy soupy soupy!

See all

Signage outside of entry

Cow Palace

4.0(79 reviews)

21.0 mi

Went early Sunday morning and shocked the store so busy. That said, service was fast and efficient…read more Enjoyed all my purchases but especially the shaved ribeye that made for an amazing cheesesteak..

These guys have all the meat you could possibly want and then some they'll cut it anyway you want…read moreand all you got to do is pay and take it out super yummy I must go to

Exterior

See all

Exterior

Justin's Chop Shop

4.7(57 reviews)

13.4 mi

Had seen this place on socials and I loved their vibe so we stopped in today. I knew they had…read moresandwiched but it was a little difficult to find a sandwich board or menu (I eventually did) the place is very clean. It's an old bank so it's a fun look too! I was helped right away. My sandwich came out fast and hot and it was delicious. I'll definitely be back.

What a nice store! Stopped in for a freshly made smashburger after hearing about them and we ended…read moreup getting the "signature burger" and "Justin's burger". Was very surprised when they came out so small literally like sliders. At $12 a piece, even though they came with some fries, I thought the price was high. I do understand we're paying a premium for a burger from a quality butcher but probably wouldn't order again. Although very tasty! Loved the chopped pickles. They have a nice selection of gluten free pasta products from Italy which I hadn't seen before. Got a few of those and some pickles, chips and sauces too. Nicely organized produce section, friendly staff and overall a very nice business to frequent!

Ahi Tuna

See all

Provisions on State

4.6(17 reviews)

29.9 mi

Fresh meat, for the non-vegans among us. Best Chicken! Many cuts of meat available…read more But also some great cheese options and usually a fresh fish available. Added plus: The Nicest People on Earth. We try to go there every week...

We stopped in here on a whim and were so glad we did. The staff was knowledgeable and helpful. It's…read moregreat to know I can come to this butcher shop or order specific cuts of meat ahead of time. I so despise grocery stores and avoid them at all costs. We walked away with 2 cheeses which were fantastic. On street parking. Worth a stop in and planning my orders now!

Meat available to order

See all

Southold Fish Market

4.4(251 reviews)

9.8 mi

This place is busy and for a very good reason, the food is fresh and delicious!…read moreThe service provided by Emily was five star. She told me that the wait for food would be about 45 minutes. I explained I had to get back to Brooklyn, she let me know that I could get salads and soup. I ordered about a small container of shrimp salad my friend ordered seafood salad. Both were delicious l. They had the right amount of red onions, celery, dill, mayo and whatever secret ingredients they put in there. I also had the lobster Chipotle soup, once again great seasoning, warm and comforting. I would definitely drive about two hours back to this place. Hopefully during the week it's not as crowded.

Can't rate the food. We called ahead in early afternoon for a takeout order. We were told 45…read moreminute wait. We showed up a few minutes early and were told by the counter person that (a) that our order hadn't been started yet and (b) that we were told it would be an hour when we called and we were early. And there was an edge in her voice. So we went to run an errand and came back 25 minutes later and the order still hadn't been started yet. So it's now more than an hour from the time we ordered and now we are in freefall. So we cancelled the order - with more attitude from a different counter person. It wasn't so much the delay in the order - things happen. But it was the attitude that accompanied it that was most off putting. It felt like a learned behavior.

Corn fritters and warm lobster rolls one with salad as the side, one with fries

See all

My burnt friend eating some fish n chips

My Butcher

4.3(26 reviews)

16.1 mi

•$$$$

The Cole slaw was worse than dog food. Mac and cheese was nothing special. It does have a great…read moreselection and lots of options.

Top quality meats , very good grandfather baked clams . Good…read moreservice, nice hard working employees. Old style meat store . Quaint

Prime Rib

See all

Butcher's Best Market

4.3(54 reviews)

47.9 mi

•$$$

My husband is usually the one to pick up our meat from this wonderful establishment but my errands…read morebrought me closer today. So I finally met the famous Steven. And what a welcome. He remembered my husband's request for thickness and preferred amount of fat around the chop - perfect for searing. My husband has been preparing chops Steven's way for years now and it is flawless. It certainly doesn't hurt that the meat he starts with is fabulous. Since I had many errands to run, I asked Steven if he had any ice I could use in my insulated bag. He graciously supplied me with several sealed bags of ice which would be sure to keep the pork safe until I reached home. We enjoyed them tonight. One chop was enough for the two of us ( picture below), but we will have one tomorrow in our salad. They always preserve their juiciness and flavor well into the following day.

I stopped by during my travels looking for a sandwich and just loved the whole set up of the place…read more There is a butcher area for all kinds of meats, all looked fresh and of great quality. Customers were coming in to pick up their meat orders. The deli area offers a variety of cold and hot sandwiches, salads, sides. Great selection. I ordered a roast beef and Swiss on a hard roll, with coleslaw and horseradish sauce. It was fantastic! The meat was flavorful and plentiful and that homemade slaw added a great little kick. They also have baked breads and goodies. I left with a sourdough bread and a choc chip cookie. There are some tables outside to eat. They also sell unwashed, unrefrigerated chicken eggs from a local farm. So great! I did buy these, but somehow they didn't make it into my bag which I did not discover until I got home, but other than that, service was super friendly and helpful. So refreshing to have quality customer service. The store is well organized, nicely decorated, and extremely clean. I recommend a stop in and I will make a point to return as soon as possible.

Butcher

Chicken chip cookie

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Jenna R.

656

5 years ago

Seriously the best. Their filet mignon lobster roll is incredible and so are their other sandwiches. Not only do they have great sandwiches but the prepared food section and prime meats are some of the best I've seen. They have dry aged too. The staff is extremely friendly, accommodating and they all provide exceptional service. They also do catering which is awesome. Can't wait to use them for a backyard party this summer. Highly recommend! read more

Center Cuts - butcher - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Center Cuts also viewed

Eastport Plaza Delicatessen & Catering

3.8

(14 reviews)

Just updating to say I used this deli for a catered brunch at home... They were so accommodating…read moreand reasonably priced. Provided everything we needed (cups, plates, napkins, coffee, juice, etc.), and so much food! I highly recommend this business!

$23?!?!? For a sandwich of old roast beef with no flavor, a side of veggies, and a large…read morecoffee?!?!? I used to love this place. What happened?

Meetinghouse Deli

4.4

(8 reviews)

Fantastic deli , old school. Pickle with your sandwich. Delicious egg salad. I go out of my way to…read morecome here .

Got an egg cheese sandwich on a Kaiser roll and it was AMAZING. It was ready quick and and was…read morestill hot by the time I brought it home. The eggs were cooked perfectly, as I hate when fried eggs are runny/jammy. Old school vibe inside and friendly staff.

Hurricane Deli

4.3

(46 reviews)

didn't have to ask the guy for extra balsamic, he just did it. kind of place where you know theyve…read moregot poop schmears in the back but they can't put it on the menu. Couple hotties behind the counter too, two drinks and I'd hit.

Hurricane Deli is a Local east ender favorite - Not a touristy Yelp haven. In fact they wear any 1…read moreor 2 star Yelp reviews as a badge of of honor - literally posting the best of the worst reviews proudly on their wall of fame. Haha. What that means is they are out east and people are lucky to have a good year round place with always fresh food, plenty of staff to keep the line moving. Five years ago my son a slave to Yelp reviews and always getting top reviews came out here for the first time. Couldn't believe the proud post ups of 1 star reviews. The Hamptons sometimes draws grouchy travelers that don't reflect the different pace or gratitude people have for a reliable deli. They do a good BEC SEC and coffee and lunch sandwiches. So enjoy this as your mon Yelpy non touristy local flavor stop. I kind of don't fit in all chatty etc.. but hey I am a Yelper. Haha.

Peconic Prime Meats

4.7

(26 reviews)

Chicken thighs were awesome with the coffee rub! Owner was great and service fast. Will do the beef…read morenext time.

Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer

3.5

(53 reviews)

Food is ok. Very expensive. Staff was nice. Place is not clean…read more Also, they are MAGA. If that makes you want to go there than go there. If it makes you not want to go there than don't go there

Very clean, lots and lots of choices of sandwiches... large breakfast menu. I have a roast beef…read morepanini with melted mozzarella, onions and portobello mushrooms.... It could use a little more sauce bc it was a tiny bit dry but it was big... comes with a small salad ( macaroni/ potato) . The owner is nice!! I would definitely back and try other things .

Wine Country Deli

4.1

(116 reviews)

Wine Country Deli is a gem!…read more I was just visiting town for a wedding and stopped in for the Nick Rocco sandwich -- and wow, it did not disappoint! The place was busy with tons of locals coming in, which is always a great sign. The staff were super friendly, too. If I lived here, I'd definitely be a regular.

We were in town for a wedding and wanted to find a great local deli instead of another chain--and…read morewe're so glad we found Wine Country Deli. The team worked together like a well-oiled machine. Even though they were busy, everyone was friendly, efficient, and still took the time to make a genuine connection with each customer. The food absolutely lived up to the hype. We had the Italian sandwich with their mac on the side, and both were incredible. We were told, "You won't find food like this in Orlando," and they were absolutely right. Everything was fresh, flavorful, and worth every bite. We're looking forward to coming back and trying a few more things before we head home. Highly recommend!

Polka Deli

4.5

(35 reviews)

Purchased food for Pick Up. We go a sampler plate with most and saeurkraut…read more 2 types of stews. One was Cowboy Stew. It was all delicious! The cheesy bread was good. The beet slaw was good. Loved the stuffed cabbage. There were 2 sides that I didn't like. Forgot the names, but they were too overly Mustardy for my taste.

Kielbasa has been a staple in my diet since I met my wife and not long ago, our favorite Kielbasa…read moreplace shut down and with it went my much beloved Kielbasa until now! They were a little busy, but the line went quickly and the service was friendly. The establishment is clean and the food delicious so I definitely recommend!

4C's Deli

3.1

(10 reviews)

My favorite deli in Riverhead! A special request for a rhubarb pie was pure perfection. An over…read moreeasy egg sandwich with crispy bacon and cheese, and yummy chili, Mac and cheese, and soups! Always love when meatloaf is the special of the day!!

Should have trusted our instinct to drive by but it was on our route so we stopped. Service was…read moreinsanely slow; food was completely tasteless. Chicken cutlet sandwich with roasted red pepper, mozzarella, and Italian dressing would good, no? Well, the peppers were raw and in chunks like they were ready for a crudite platter, the dressing was just oil, and the cutlet had zero taste. Like none. Tried a half pound each of the cole slaw and potato salad and they were equally as awful - bland. Like not even some salt. Do yourself a favor and avoid.

Catena's Inc Food Market

4.9

(12 reviews)

•$$$

Best place in town Hands down Try it You will not be…read moredisappointed Friendliest staff in Southampton

Family owned. Pulled Pork is to die for. Beef tenderloin…read more Same. Best secret in S Hampton. You can keep Citarella.

Ammirati's

4.4

(83 reviews)