Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    2.8 (6 reviews)
    InexpensivePizza
    Open Open 24 hours

    Casey's Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    9 months ago

    Grey pizza experiences in the past! Just placed a new order! Other options are also good!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    I really hate this place, their pumps ever work. It's so annoying, would give 0 stars if I could

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 8,131 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Rosati's Pizza

    Rosati's Pizza

    3.5(33 reviews)
    5.1 mi

    We ordered carry out for a quick lunch. The order was ready at the promised time with attention to…read morethe special requests. Staff were friendly, knowledgeable, efficient. The waiting area was comfortable and cool on a 95° day. The salad was crisp and the toppings were fresh making a salad that was visually appealing and delicious. Something that hit the spot were the toasted ravioli, a Midwest delight, and this one was a perfect dish.

    About a year ago, on my way back from Shilo, IL I stopped by Rosati's. They offer a large slice of…read morepizza and a Drink for $5.00. It was after 1 pm and there were only 2 slices of cheese pizza in the case. The person at the counter said there were more pizzas in the oven and they would be up soon. It was worth the wait. The pepperoni pizza was hot and delicious even after traveling the 25 min. home. I told me wife about the deal and the experience..both being positive. Then, on two separate occasions, we went out of our way, while traveling, only to be disappointed because the deal is from 11 to 3:00. Today's experience...we arrived at 1:50 pm. We were excited because we were finally going to get the $5 deal. We went in the door and there was 1 slice of cheese pizza. I asked if more pizza was coming out. The gal behind the counter said no because it was a slow day and the pizza would go to waste. ( The lunch special was supposed to be valid for another 70 min. Any other restaurant will try to accomodate their patrons for lunch special up to and including 2:59.) There's counter person was not concerned about disappointing customers or even trying to show some empathy. We asked about ordering a pizza..."for here or to go"...."here"..."you have to order that in dining room". We discussed it while sitting and both felt that the person at the front counter need some customer relation training. Another person was working the dining area. She was very friendly. We placed our order for a 14" Classic Combo. It was ready in a reasonable amount of time. Our opinion, as we discussed it at length, is Rosati's has the best thin crust of all the pizza places we've eaten. Their sauce is a little tomato forward. They seem to care about the amount of toppings on the pizza. We did feel that the pie was light on the sausage. There was an ample amount of the other toppings including pepperoni. We noted the pepperoni tasted closer to bacon than the classic savory pepperoni flavor. And there was plenty of melty stringing cheese!!. I am really getting discouraged at the amount of money restaurants are charging for soft drinks. A 20oz soft drink costs the restaurant 5 to 15 cents for syrup and CO² and they charge the customer $3.75 to, in Rosati's cases $4.00. Ambiance...it's large and uses cold materials. Looks like a semi sports bar. Prices...on the higher end for pizza Wait staff...hit or miss... one good-one not so much. Food quality...(pizza) very good Lunch special...if you can get it, it's a great deal. The all important!! The left-over pizza is very good, cold straight from the refrigerator

    Photos
    Rosati's Pizza
    Rosati's Pizza
    Rosati's Pizza

    See all

    Rosati's Pontoon Beach - Hot Wings

    Rosati's Pontoon Beach

    3.5(31 reviews)
    5.1 mi

    Great atmosphere for lunch on Mondays. We were searching for a great place to get Pizza for our…read morefriends who were in town from Brazil. We realized most pizza places were either closed on Mondays or were not open till dinner. We called and spoke to the manager who let us know they were open on Monday's and would have a place for our group to sit and talk for a few hours. The Rosati Monster was an amazing pie. The jalapeño poppers were great fun for our guests that did not have access to jalapeños back in Brazil. The sweet Italian dressing was the favorite of the people eating salads. All in all, it was a great place for lunch and I did notice a $5 lunch special that looked worth a solo return to get a single slice of pizza and a drink.

    upon arrival, the establishment was not very busy but had a few customers…read more me and my girlfriend drove 25 miles each way because we heard it was a good place to go. When we arrived, my girlfriend wanted to sit somewhere inside specific and we were denied that seating for some reason. Immediately after we were assigned their table the waitress walking by drops a tray of 7 drinks of beer and soda 2' away beside us splashing liquid on our clothes and chairs. accidents happen so we forgot quickly and our waitress (the manager female Latina) came over to take our drink order and we proceeded to put in for a small deep dish to get started. The manager said she would put that In and return to see if we wanted anything else. She was very nice and she took the rest of her order which was two House salads and the Rosatis bread bites. me and my girlfriend decided to play games that were sitting behind us while we waited for our salads. shortly after our salads have come, but our pizza never did. A different waitress had asked us if we were wanting anything else and we were puzzled at her question and advised her that we were waiting on a pizza when she told us that no pizza order was ever put in. Come to find out. The manager has left on an emergency and totally forgot about putting the pizza order in. The waitress wound up calling the manager on the phone and she wanted to speak with my girlfriend directly and admitted to totally forgetting about putting the order. after the phone call, The waitress asked us if we still wanted to put in for the pizza and we asked how long it would take. They advised us about 20 to 30 minutes..I then advised them that I didn't think it was fair to pay full price as we have been waiting now for 45 minutes and they failed to put our order in. She stated that she would take 5% off. needless to say, we were extremely disappointed in the service and it just didn't seem like anybody cared whether we left or not. we tried to contact corporate and left our information and we've also called the restaurant and left our information to see if anybody would call us back, so far nothing. we have had a lot of mishaps going to restaurants, we understand these kind of things happen, but it does seem to happen to us more often. like I stated it just seems like customer service has gone right out the window anymore and people just don't care.

    Photos
    Rosati's Pontoon Beach - Man.  We are seated for 15 minutes. No drink no Order and it's not busy.  I like there food but services is tanking.

    Man. We are seated for 15 minutes. No drink no Order and it's not busy. I like there food but services is tanking.

    Rosati's Pontoon Beach - These pillows of glory!

    These pillows of glory!

    Rosati's Pontoon Beach - Exterior

    See all

    Exterior

    Venecia's Pizza - Side Salad

    Venecia's Pizza

    3.2(23 reviews)
    2.7 mi

    We went on the Friday before Valentine's Day at 8 pm. They had clearly had a busy evening! They…read morewere taking care of customers and trying to clean tables in between taking and delivering orders. In other words, it was not clean, but I believe it was not clean because it was so busy. The dining room was mostly full at 8 pm. It is a former Pizza Hut building and the tables and chairs reflect that. The service was great - very friendly and efficient. The food was great. We split a large supreme pizza and had two cokes. The cheese is mozzarella, the crust is a nice in-between type crust. The sauce is not too sweet or salty. The vegetables are FRESH and crunchy. The soda was fizzy, but did not skimp on the syrup. Dinner was just under $30 plus tip, which is unheard of these days. This place is a gem and we will be back. They have pasta which I look forward to trying.

    When a restaurant impresses both adults and picky kids, you know you've found something special…read more This pizza and pasta were absolutely delicious! The crust was incredible, perfectly cooked with amazing flavor. The sauce really stood out too. The cheese and toppings were balanced just right. We ordered spaghetti for our kids as well, and even they loved it! Coming from two very picky eaters, that says a lot! The pasta sauce has a unique taste with the perfect blend of spices, meat, and richness that you just don't find everywhere. The garlic sticks were puffy, soft, and coated in buttery garlic goodness. Everything about the food was on point. And can we talk about prices...It's so refreshing to find a place not charging $4 for a soda (theirs are $1.85 and Coke products). The overall pricing is very reasonable compared to other local spots. A family of four can eat well and leave satisfied for under $40, which is such a win. The only downside was the wait. They were packed at 5:30 on a Friday night, and we didn't leave until almost 7:30. That said, our waitress was very sweet and helpful the entire time. We'll definitely be back! Might be my new craving! Hats off to the chef and staff! I forgot the pictures because it was just THAT good!

    Photos
    Venecia's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza

    Pepperoni pizza

    Venecia's Pizza - Half of a supreme pizza

    Half of a supreme pizza

    Venecia's Pizza - Gyro salad ... sooooo good

    See all

    Gyro salad ... sooooo good

    Casey's - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...