Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    5.0 (3 reviews)
    ModeratePizza
    Open • Open 24 hours

    Casey's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Firehouse 54 - Pizza and wings

    Firehouse 54

    4.9(27 reviews)
    50.7 mi
    •$

    If you find yourself passing through Eagleville, Firehouse 54 is a total hidden gem. It's exactly…read morewhat you want from a small-town spot--great food, friendly service, and a local vibe that makes you feel right at home. The Food They are known for their hand-stretched pizza, and the crust is definitely the highlight. It has that perfect chew and char. The Pizza Bowls: A great option if you're trying to stay low-carb but still want all the pizza flavors. Taco Tuesday: If you're lucky enough to be there on the 2nd or 4th Tuesday of the month, the tacos are a must-try. Just a heads up--they usually only do tacos on those nights, so no pizza then! The Vibe It's a cozy, "hole-in-the-wall" kind of place in the best way possible. It's where the locals hang out, and the staff is incredibly welcoming to travelers. Because they are only open for a few hours in the evening (5 PM - 8 PM), it can get busy quickly, so showing up early is a good move. Things to Know Hours: They have a short window, so plan your drive accordingly! Parking: Plenty of easy street parking right in front. Takeout: They do a brisk carry-out business if you're just passing through on the I-35 and want a better meal than typical fast food.

    Great spot! Pizza and cheese sticks were so good! Service was great! Love the history of this…read moreplace, it was fun reading the articles posted around the dining room. Oh! And they have a keto bowl option that I have never even heard of before at any pizza restaurant! W

    Photos
    Firehouse 54
    Firehouse 54
    Firehouse 54 - The ice cream menu

    See all

    The ice cream menu

    Gino's Italiano - quite and good.

    Gino's Italiano

    4.1(97 reviews)
    31.6 mi
    •$$

    We had heard that Gino's tenderloins were big but dang. I ordered two to go for three of us and we…read morecouldn't even get through one. I would recommend Gino's to everyone.

    So, when someone says to you let's eat Italian tonight, what goes through your mind? Are you going…read moreto order a pasta, like a spaghetti or maybe a penne, possibly fettuccine, and there is always angel hair? Or maybe you're going to go with a sandwich like a meatball sandwich or an Italian panini, what about baked? Is lasagna your thing how about chicken parmesan, will that work for you? For me it's simple I absolutely love Fettuccine Alfredo, and you toss in some shrimp and I'm in heaven. So today I was thinking about Italian, and I was wanting to go someplace I had never been before. So, I go out to my garage and get in my Horseless Carriage and send that buggy northward on I-35 to the Great Northern Tundra and a city called Kearney. And in this city call Kearney there's an Italian place called Gino's Italiano. So, I pull myself out of the buggy, I walk up and open the door and inside I go where was seated at table. I order up my fettuccine alfredo with shrimp. They served it with some bread, and I had a beer to help wash it all down. Just look at that gorgeous bowl of pasta! The Alfredo sauce was rich, creamy, and smooth and the noodles were cooked perfectly. The shrimp was to the tooth there was no rubberiness to it! And dig in I did, after I let it cool down a bit because you see they brought it to the table with steam rolling off of it! And with each bite of those pasta noodles and that sauce it got better, richer, and creamier. If you happen to find yourself in Kearney don't be afraid to give this place a try because they also have weekly hamburger specials and they have a breaded pork loin sandwich that I've heard other people say is quite good. Well done Gino's Italiano! Well done indeed! Stuffing my pie hole with delicious pasta and shrimp in a town called Kearny. P.S. I had a take box with what was left of the pasta and like the old fool I am, I walked off and left it on the table!

    Photos
    Gino's Italiano - Italian steak sandwich

    Italian steak sandwich

    Gino's Italiano - Chicken spedini

    Chicken spedini

    Gino's Italiano - Panini sandwich

    See all

    Panini sandwich

    Il Lazzarone

    Il Lazzarone

    4.4(370 reviews)
    44.7 mi
    •$$

    Potatoes on pizza? Delish! Excellent service and the food was amazing. We order the large Caesar…read moresalad and the chef sent out complimentary bacon and hot honey. Bacon was crisp to perfection and the spicy honey was the perfect complement to the salad. The crust is exactly what you would expect with a wood fire oven. It was crisp with small charred bubbles, fold was on point with the right about of chew. My husband got the carnivore which of course I sampled. The sauce was light with a delicious tomato flavor. The pizzas were both amazing. The service was attentive and very friendly. Downside we are only in town for one night! Highly recommend!

    My hubs and I had a great experience at Il Lazzarone! The Neapolitan pizza was new to us. It's…read moredifferent than anything we've had. The waitress did a great job explaining and her recommendations were spot on! We started off with the bruschetta. It was very fresh and layered with flavors! We then ordered the Salsiccia Italiana (Mozzarella, Sausage, basil, olive oil, sea salt) and the Crepa (Mozzarella, bacon, basil, garlic, balsamic glaze, olive oil, sea salt). We both agreed the the Crepa was our favorite but they were both very good! The Italian sausage was very flavorful. We ate half of each pizza and saved room for dessert. Our waitress recommended the S'mores with added cookie dough. It was so yummy and worth the calories! We love supporting these type of specialty restaurants in St Joe. We will definitely be back!

    Photos
    Il Lazzarone - Oven straight from Italy

    Oven straight from Italy

    Il Lazzarone - Burrata app

    Burrata app

    Il Lazzarone - Calabrian Pepperoni

    See all

    Calabrian Pepperoni

    Casey's - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...