Whenever we come to Mexico we go eat at Casa Sofia! The food and service is always perfect! Make sure to get the Barrette and stuffed gnocchi (mozzarella, and tomato) with Alfredo sauce and a side, Bolognese! pizza is always a great choice as well. read more

Pizza was overly wet and the prosciutto was not evenly cut on the pizza which made it impossible to eat. The cook was overly rude about it and basically just told us off. Avoid this place if you can read more

Casa Sofia - Burrata prosciutto - Italian Near Me - Playa del Carmen, ROO

Apps were good. They forgot my lasagna and served everyone else in my table. They argued with us asking if someone else took my order but I ordered a lasagna. I finally reordered and took three bites -- it was dead cold in the middle. I sent it back. They charged us and the chef came out with a serious attitude. They gave us a free dessert which was a flourless chocolate cake but it was tasteless. read more

See all

Among the most expensive dinners we have eaten in town and our least favorite. We ordered the steak and mashed potatoes, and a simple spaghetti with meatballs along with drinks. The spaghetti was not even close to being adequately cooked so it very chewy. We hate making an issue of it but it was not eatable. Staff agreed to cook it longer. The meatballs just tasted very cheap, processed and lousy. The bread did not taste fresh. The steak was descent but it all tasted way overpriced for the lack of quality. read more

It was my first time at Casa Sofia and I'd say it was a great experience. It was a beautiful night for a date night, it was breezy outside where we were sitting but perfect. The service was very quick and we were helped by multiple people. The food didn't take long to come out either. There was complimentary bread with oils at the table. I got the Mediterranean salmon, could have been cooked a little longer but still delicious. I got the sauce on the side because I don't like black olives. They were smaller portions, but the perfect size for me.The rose wine was good, a little more dryer than i would have liked. Over a great experience, but next time I would have tried a pasta dish. read more

Casa Sofia - Mediterranean salmon - Italian Near Me - Playa del Carmen, ROO

See all

Went for breakfast. Food was fantastic. Service great and very nice ambiance. Nice job on the Aperol spritz! Will return. read more

It's easy to enjoy a restaurant meal. But to receive amazing, and consistent food, that is priced well is another story. I return to Casa Sophia on a regular basis , whether in-person or by delivery and they never disappoint. In person their COVID protocol is diligent and their delivery is always beautifully wrapped and delivered piping hot. So many choices: soups, appetizers, pastas, pizza , enters and deserts. Tonight's delivery was flawless- minestrone soup, penne with fresh tomato and basil with shrimp, spaghetti carbonara, chocolate volcano and apple tart. Yes 1/2 is still in the fridge because the portions are so hearty. Big thanks to Sophia and Sarah read more

See all

Best lasagna in Playa. Great service and the price is incredible! Love this restaurant.

We had the most wonderful experience at Casa Sofia. Decided to eat here on a whim, and so glad that we did. As an Italian who is vegan, I couldn't have been more pleased! So difficult to find wonderful vegan options on an Italian menu, and Casa Sofia absolutely broke the stereotype with this. I actually had trouble deciding what to order there were so many choices! I went with the pizza and it was fabulous. My husband and son (not vegan) were so happy as well. We all thought the food was absolutely delicious and priced correctly. The atmosphere is so sweet & romantic. We will absolutely be returning next time we visit the area. read more

This restaurant seems like a local Favorite. How did we find it? We asked our concierge where he would go for a romantic dinner (not touristy) if he could pick anywhere. He said Casa Sofia so off we went and we loved it! We will go back. We started with an Antipasto plate which was perfection! The Mahi Mahi was authentic and delicious. I had lobster stuffed ravioli and every bite was amazing! Don't miss this place it's delicious, relaxing and lovely with great service. Great for families because they have the cutest 'kids club' where children can play and make adorable crafts while parents can see them easily and in full view in a small side area. The kids were having so much fun. Don't miss the antipasto- the selection was perfect and high quality. We will be back! read more

See all

Hands down the best Italian food you'll have in Playa! We are in a happy food coma after experiencing their lasagna, the tastiest shrimp w a sauce that's to die for and yummy bruschetta. We also had pizza but the teenager gobbled it up before I could take a photo! Lol read more

Casa Sofia - Meat lasagna - Italian Near Me - Playa del Carmen, ROO

Our second time at Casa Sofia Playa del Carmen 5a Avenida and the food is incredibly good. We tried the Risotto Porcini and the Pizza Margherita with fresh basil, prosciutto and fresh sliced Parmesan cheese, both plates were amazing. Highly recommend!!! read more

Casa Sofia - Italian Near Me - Playa del Carmen, ROO

The food was excellent the service was excellent and the ambiance was excellent. The only fault was the google map which did not show the correct route which was a little frustrating but the wine brought us back to smiles and laughter Star rating is 5. And worth it read more

Mi esposo y yo somos fanáticos de ir a Casa Sofía en la 5ta avenida desde que nos mudamos de California para vivir aquí . Siempre nos han dado un servicio increíble . Pero hoy quisimos probar en Playacar. De no ser por el chef que lo conocemos muy bien y por los chicos que atienden , les habría dado cero estrellas si pudiera . El "capitán " creo que se llama Héctor , nos hizo pasar un muy mal rato. Su explicación me pareció de muy poco profesional , de hecho hasta altanero, le pedía ajustar la cuenta de dos copas de clericot y no de un litro de clericot porque me trajeron la jarra con muy poco contenido, la sirvieron con mucho hielo y no rinde. Pedí que fueran justos y me contaran el precio de 2 copas porque apenas si salían 2 copas . Su explicación fue altanera y ridícula . Si no fuera porque el chef es excelente y buen trato yo no volvía aquí . Tranquila olé capitán pudo dar otra opción para agradar al cliente y no una negativa y burlón además . read more

I must admit that, despite my friend's enthusiastic recommendation, I entered rather skeptical as to how good an Italian restaurant in a touristy area of Mexico could be. I guess the 15 min wait for a table should have helped assuage my fears, but Casa Sofia was well worth that reasonable wait (and more), providing very good food at incredibly reasonable prices. The menu literally looks more like a book than a menu, with countless pasta options that you can get in various sauces. We shared a nice Caprese salad and a bruschetta appetizer to start, and then I had gnocchi in pesto sauce for dinner. I was quite impressed with how fresh and flavorful the tomato and mozzarella were in the apps, and how light and fluffy the pasta was, with a solid pesto. My friends had chicken and salmon dishes and were similarly impressed. The wine list is extensive and varied and... let's just say we made ample use of it, and were quite happy with our selections. It is a charming venue, offering indoor and outdoor seating and, while adjacent to major shopping districts, is just off of a side street enough to feel like a nice respite from the boisterous main drag of town. I expected at best to be grading on a curve, but I would have thought this was a solid Italian option even back in New York. In Playa, it felt like a star--a quality, adult option for a nice meal, at non tourist-gouging prices. read more

Very cozy ambience inside this restaurant. Our server was very attentive and friendly. The menu is huge! So many dishes to choose from. We ordered the melon and prosciutto appetizer. A very large portion; definitely good for sharing. It was delicious. Juicy and perfectly ripened melon. For dinner, we ordered the spaghetti and meatballs and lobster ravioli. Both very generous portions. The meatballs were so good, homemade from what we could tell. Same with the spaghetti, al dente & just right. The lobster ravioli was just okay. I didn't taste much lobster or much hint of seafood in the filling. We also ordered some cocktails that were very good. We took home some desserts (cheesecake and chocolate cake) that didn't disappoint. We really enjoyed our time at Casa Sofia and hope to visit one more time before leaving Playacar. Great job, Casa Sofia! read more

See all

Wow! What a perfect hidden gem in Playacar! We got a recommendation from a local we met at the condo we're staying at in playacar and wow, this place did not disappoint!! Just happened to be all you can eat pizza today, and man, was it delicious!!! Our gracious waiter, Eduardo aka Lalo was so kind and recommended the most delicious pizzas for us! We just got back from Italy last month, and Casa Sofia's Pizza was on par with Italy's Pizza! Make sure you come by and try this place! Between the excellent staff and amazing food, you won't regret it! Your bikinis might tho ;D enjoy!!! read more

Not a great experience. First off, the waiter was missing in action. After he took our order, we did not see him until the presented us with the bill. They were out of a ravioli dish my son wanted and also out of a special drink he wanted as well. As for an appetizer, we got a mixed fry plate. It tasted like everything was cooked in old oil. Then, my drink was taken from me with some left and I wasn't offered another drink. Then the food arrived, we had two pizzas, they tasted ok. We had two pasta items, both tasted good. I had the bass with the potatoes and vegetables. The plate looked great, but they forgot how to season and cook the dish properly. There was no seasoning in the entire dish. The skin on the fish was soggy. The vegetables were under cooked. They had a raw vegetable taste. Not a great plate. Then it took so long for the waiter to come over with the bill, two of my kids fell asleep. I think the service might have been better If the manager was not busy taking care of what I can assume is his child. The air conditioning inside the restaurant was nice. read more

The entire experience was very positive. Food (pizzas) were tasty, prepared well and large enough for leftovers! Our waitress was very attentive, kind and patient. Sat on the covered patio which made the evening even better. Prices were fair. Will definitely go back. read more

First off, the entrance is on 5th street (Calle 5). Using the map app on my phone based on Yelp put us one block away with no way to get there other than walking through somebody's yard. Family of 6 went here twice. Prices are incredible. Pasta with seafood was excellent. Kids love the pizzas. 2 people can share a single pizza. Pizzas come out super quick. Brownie dessert was really good. The cheesecake was a let down. The Arrechera was not cooked enough. Rather disgusting. It may have been a translation issue when ordering. Only 2 real issues with this place: It takes forever to get the check. The waiter just disappears after the dinner is served. They bring the pizzas out first. 5-10 minutes later the pasta dishes come out. Half our party is eating and the other half is watching. Really? read more

Would do zero stars if possible. Our meal took 3 hours. Not because we wanted a slow paced dinner but because the kitchen "lost" our order. Apps took an hour. Food was subpar and we were promised a discount for the inconvenience. Check comes and there is no discount. They proceed to tell me they need my American ID to discount. I refused to give it and had to get a manager. Manager asked for ID also and finally, after 3 hours of terrible experience, we were given a measly $10 (usd) discount. Food was Inadequate. Prices would be good if dinner didn't take so long and service was better. Such a shame because we heard such good things. HUGE DISAPPOINTMENT! read more

This place was soooo so good!!! If you are sick of tacos this is the place to go :) They make all the pasta fresh which is AMAZING! i reccommend the truffle pasta it was insane, just like italy! the margarita pizza was also very good! the only reason i do not give it 5 stars was one pizza was a little charred, which i do not particularly love. i also did not loveeee the bolognese sauce, the flavor was just a little off for me but i am used to american style so may just be a personal issue. also would not recommend the lemonade it's just water with lemon, very very sour. read more

Casa Sofia - truffle pasta and bolognese pasta and lemonade - Italian Near Me - Playa del Carmen, ROO

I've lived here for a few months and I wish I found this place earlier. Super good food, local prices.

We wanted something nearby as we'd been walking all day. This was a short walk and it seemed to have pretty good reviews. The ambiance is really pretty and classy. And well when I took a look at the menu I was a bit overwhelmed with how many choices. I went with the meat lasagna, not bad but it was not hot it was like warm, also barely had pasta in it was a very thin layer. Didn't finish it. Table bread was stale. Lobster ravioli was just ok as well. I will say the pizza was delicious definitely go with that. And tiramisu was good as well. Service was very attentive and nice. And price is fairly cheap. read more

This is a cute place , the atmosphere is nice the problem is the food , it is not fresh . I ordered a shrimp pasta and the shrimp was so fishy and i tasted that throughout my entire plate. My mom ordered the bolognese sauce over linguini and it was so watery and absolutely terrible... the drinks are also not good very filled with ice and nearly Any Alcohol in it... the only good thing we ordered was pizza , everything else was not good. I was having high hopes for this place based on other reviews but the food again is just not well made.. if you visit this place please only order pizza nothing more. The Brushetta was not good the bread was as hard as a rock and the tomato wasn't very fresh at all. We basically paid for the bill and didn't eat more more then a spoonful of food... The service was good I just wish they can improve on the quality of the food.. read more

Love this place and we have had so many amazing meals and fun night here. We love the menu and the value is amazing. We have eaten at tons of different restaurants throughout Playa but always seem to come back here. It amazes me to see some neg reviews. I mean I understand things can happen time to time. We have had never had any problems and if it was something minor it was always corrected immediately. Just remember when you read a negative comment, sometimes people were having a bad day long before they get to the restaurant. One of my favourite sayings is, "Nobody has ever constructed a statue of a critic." Hope you like my blog as well. You can see it on dino's blog about playa del carmen, Mexico on facebook. https://steemit.com/food/@deancarter/casa-sophia-playa-del-carmen-my-favorite-italian-restaurant read more

Nothing like coming to Mexico for some Italian food! Traveling with an adventurous foodie husband and an overly-cautious father (along with 2 kids), I was hesitant to try something off the beaten path. Ok, not too far off...a block or two off the main touristy strip. 2 minute walk. We were seated immediately (it was early) and promptly greeted with our server. The menu is in Italian, Spanish and English. Our drinks came immediately "sin hielo", without ice, to appease mi papá. Complimentary bread with olive oil, balsamic vinegar, spicy oil, salt/pepper, and grated parmesan to dip in. The bread was delicious. Dad ordered a calzone, cheese and ham. He said it was delicious. High marks for the guarded man. This calzone was HUGE! Literally the size of this dinner plate. $8 Kids ordered pepperoni pizza. Daughter pouted that it said "salami" on the menu and wasn't convinced that it was the same until it came out. Again, huge pizza. I was worried that my teen son would eat the whole thing. There were leftovers after both ate. $7 I ordered pasta alfredo. It came with mushrooms, maybe I accidentally ordered. They were big and few enough to pick out. $5 Hubby ordered lobster ravioli with seafood sauce. Calamari, octopus, mussels, crab, shrimp. $10. He was in heaven. Split cheesecake at the end. Creamy, baked in the oven, topped with fruit sauce. All of it, plus 3 sodas and 4 beers = $40 USD. That's right. Forty American dollars! Service was phenomenal, the staff setting the tables paid special attention to detail and clean! read more

See all

i commend the management of Casa Sofia for the rebound .. i'm back and Casa Sofia is back .. i just Love this place .. great pizza and ambiance .. service is also great .. outdoor seating just awesome .. very reasonable prices i highly recommend read more

See all

Fantastic find!! An incredible place only 3 minutes dr from 5th Av.The fresh pasta and the choices of sauces were incredible. It was so good that we decided to come back on a second night of our vacation for had a great pizza and Tuna steak cooked to perfection. The service was top notch. It is very rare I leave a restaurant feeling I should have been charged more for such a quality meal. The owner warmly welcomed us both night. One of the best memory of our trip to PDC. read more

This is the most disgusting place I have ever dined at. The Owner and staff are rude and I was appalled at the way I was treated. The food was under cooked and I got food poisoning that same night. I do not recommend this place ever. I seen Cockroaches in the bathroom this is not acceptable in any manor. This place should be shut down and the health department needs to be contacted read more

Good location away from the Playa Del Carmen mobs. Nice layout with lots of outdoor seating and inside A/C if you want it. Prices are very reasonable. Pizza is excellent, but we had the mushroom lasagna one night and it was amazing. We came back again and it was just OK. We are not sure what happened? The weird thing is they charge for butter to use on your bread. Got to say that is the 1st time that has ever happened. Overall good food and drinks, just not consistent. read more

Worst food poisoning I have ever had. Besides paying for the deadly overpriced food, I also had to pay for an overpriced hospital bill. I'll definitely return next time I'm contemplating suicide. read more

"Vegan ravioli" not vegan! Made with cheese!!!! Ruined our entire night. Ended up with crying daughter and hungry husband. So bummed. Owners need to change menu and learn what vegan really means. read more