Totally AMAZING ! We had a birthday party for our grandson, and we had 22 invited guests 19 Adults and 3 children. First time trying Casa Mia, and was little nervous. We ordered Full Tray of Penne in Vodka sauce, Full tray of baked ziti, full tray of sausage & peppers, Full tray of broccoli Garlic & oil, half trays of bacon wrapped shrimp (YUM), buffalo wings, cold antipasto and mozzarella sticks. Everything was ready on time, food was amazing. They totally filled up each tray so you were getting exceptional quantity in all trays! They threw in 10 loafs of Italian bread and utensils. Literally everyone asked where the delicious food came from and all were asking if there was any leftovers to get a take home container. If you are looking to cater an event, I highly recommend Casa Mia and if looking for a fine, excellent restaurant, with excellent food and great service, go to Casa Mia for dinner with your family! read more

So grateful that this amazing restaurant is close to home :)! Their pastas, appetizers, and pizzas (the broccoli pizza ) are so delicious. I recommend this restaurant to anyone who is looking for something to eat. Excellent service and staff!! read more

I placed an order during Covid on Uber eats and the delivery was perfect, but when you I got my order I was appalled. The paper bag was wide open and the chicken roll I ordered wasn't even wrapped properly in the foil paper. It was open and exposed. It was such careless packaging! Especially during Covid. You guys need to do better! read more

My first time at Casa Mia, I was pleasantly surprised by the food, atmosphere and service. Jamie was very accommodating and provided fantastic service. Rich and Victoria were very pleasant and helpful as well. Definitely looking forward to our next visit. read more

Got a delivery today and great pizza and zucchini sticks more then enough Please order from them you will not be disappointed read more

Let's start off by saying I ordered take out over the phone I was put on hold for 15 mins , the customer service for take out food was horrible! The veal Parmesan was like rubber it was over done and it wasn't a good quality piece of veal the personal pan pizzas are pretty good and the stracciatella soup is pretty good also. read more

Had the meat Lasagne and my DH had the Sirloin Steak with a side of Alfredo Pasta. Steak was decent but hubby regretted not having Lasagne.They make fresh sour dough bread and serve it with the entree! The Tiramisu was good but was a bit icy from the fridge. Overall service was great. Was waited on by Selena who was very helpful and provided us with tips on the menu. read more

See all

Horrible service lots of mistakes...one girl doing telephones clean tables serve .... never again...two tables walked and ordet after us and they got served before us... they ate and the food came.... my food came without linguine and had to go back..... read more

I ordered the Chicken Parmigiana with Penne Pasta. The food and service was amazing. Their new manager Jaime is extremely efficient and time conscious. I ordered takeout and while I was waiting I ordered a glass of homemade Sangria, this Sangria was amazing. I felt completely welcomed and comfortable. I will be back next week for one of their specials. Great atmosphere, even for takeout! read more

Meh pizza. Pretty expensive given the quality. Delivery was an hour and a half and food was cold.

This place is a hole in the wall in Yonkers. Very easy to miss wedged between the Dunkin and CVS. It was a pleasant surprise. The small pizza was huge, 8 slices. We had a white pizza and it was delicious. They had a decent wine and beer selection. It was also very quiet for a Saturday night, but that was also a pleasant surprise. A rare find in this area, I would definitely return for a nice dinner! read more

Add shrimp to penne vodka $7, there were 3 shrimp!! The pasta fagiole had no broth, it wasn't soup. Just a container packed with beans and pasta. The bruschetta wasn't toasted so it arrived a soggy disgusting mess. Never will order from here again read more

Great pizza! I usually order from Carlo's but they suddenly don't deliver to me, this pizza might be better... thin crust, great sausage and fast delievery. I'm in love read more

They have the best broccoli rabe . My Go To Spot For a Quick Light Lunch . Great Customer Service & They have a really nice set up when it comes to the restaurant . Definitely recommend this place for a nice dinner / quick lunch ! read more

Great Place, picas are just perfect, few times I have eaten with family was nice! Baked clams are to be remember! Pasta Fagioli just perfect, we need this in our neighborhood ! read more

Yep, big fans here. Personal pies are great. Might take a while to get a delivery, but the delivery guy is pleasant and the food is worth the wait. read more

Amazing pizza! I loved it!! Best pizza in the neighborhood! Nothing more to say, found my go to place for delivery!

Finally decided to dine in a restaurant after so many covid19 restrictions. We chose Casa Mia after only ordering take out for so long. The food ordered, gluten free veggie pizza, garden salad, garlic knots, lattes, Expresso and tiramisu was delicious. The waiter Rafael was very pleasant and quick with our order. We were a party of three and appreciated Casa Mia's pleasant atmosphere and cleanliness. We will definitely be returning again! read more

This place is a gem !!! So disregard all the negative petty reviews ! Linguine with shrimp is amazing, lasagna pie is the best ever and the delivery is super fast !! Keep up the good work Casa Mia read more

3 strikes You're Out. Ok dining in was very good and the staff was very polite and professional. I order online and somehow they always get it wrong. They messed it up twice and I let it go but last time I watched them pick off the sausage because they messed up our Sicilian and then they didn't put the little plastic tables in right and all the cheese was stuck on the box. A Sicilian and two smalls was $55. Not going back sorry. read more

Have eaten in and ordered out and food is always good. Would just like to mention the guy making the pies at the front needs to wear gloves when handling/preparing food, especially if he is being the cashier as well. He should not be handling food and handling cash and/or credit cards at the same time. If someone hasn't already gotten sick this is a good way to start. Most places employees handling food always wear gloves as it should be. Just food for thought. read more

Do not order from this place. Especially when it comes to Richie. He is rude and disrespect. Extremely unprofessional. Chris the manager claims to be available if there are any concerns but yet is nowhere to be found when there is an issue. Highly recommend you do not order from here WHAT SO EVER If there was an option to give 0 stars I would. read more

Love food people are friendly a bit pricey but on week day in lunch time they have a wonderful specials that let any people buy it I truly recommend. The Italian sauce this cooker make is to die for read more

Ordered 3 different personal pies and a chicken parm hero. GOOD JOB!! Nice service, clean place, fair prices, tastey food and good size portions. read more

Worst Italian food we've ever experienced. Awful tomato sauce. How can you ruin pizza? Chicken Marsala without a trace of wine and slathered in Franco American Brown gravy. read more

Wish I could give this place 0 stars. Went in to get pizza with my daughter. Sat down, ordered...waited, waited, waited....20 min for 2 small personal pizzas. Waitress put butter on the table...thought we'd get some bread while we waited....waited some more. Asked about the pizzas. She said sorry, 10 more minutes the guy in the front got slammed...there were 3 tables in the restaurant, 2 of which already had food. So this means that they were more concerned about filling grub hub orders than taking care of actual in person customers. So we left.. after 25 min all we had on our table was butter....worst place I've been to in a very long time! Wish I could comment on food, but I'm still starving. read more

This is a nice local spot. Quality is much better than a typical pizza joint. I think they are going for quality food at a mid point price range. I've tried many of their personal pies, mostly the meatless ones, and they are all delicious. I've also dined in and ate the Fra Diavlo and the Lobster Special. Everything was tasty and well priced. The service was outstanding and the manager also came over to greet us to make sure everything was fine. The place is cozy, and clean. The prices are higher than a typical pizza place, but so is the food quality. This is good spot for a quick order of pizza, or a quality sit down meal at an affordable price (good for large families like mine). read more

******FOOD POISONING ALERT!!!***** I wish there was a "0 stars" option. From the moment that Casa Mia opened, I was ecstatic. They are the only pizzeria in the area that offer the personal pies. The taste is ok. They open late and after I get out of work it's a good option. Recently (02.03.17) my husband and I look a ride over to get a bite after work.. I ordered the personal size plain cheese pizza and garlic knots. But husband ate the garlic knots NO pizza.. I ate 2 garlic knots and some of the pizza. The next morning I woke up feeling sick, which isn't like me. I decided to go to work a little late and went back to bed. I took a 30 min snooze and that was it!!!...I THREW UP AND UP AND UP!!! Oh my FRIGGING GOODNESS!! That was all I ate Friday! I have never been this sick IN ALL OF MY 24 YEARS OF LIFE! 5 days later I'm still suffering! I got food poisoning! I will NEVERRRRRR EVER EVER return to this restaurant. They need to be inspected by the health department to ensure they are following the correct guidelines. Cross contamination is a serious problem. People can die from food related illnesses. They need to be closed down. ASAP. I don't wish this feeling on anyone. Please don't eat from this place guys! read more

We found this little gem as we were driving on the Bronx River pkway heading home. We stopped in for a quick meal and discovered this cozy little spot with really good food. Since then we have returned several times just because the food is good and the price is very reasonable. We love the pizza there especially the white pizza and the chicken parm. We definitely recommend this place. read more

If I can give this place zero stars, I would! So the first two staff in front of the established is unaware of the food items from the back. When I ask for the food by name, the staff members have to read out the description of the item. After ordering food with white wine (in which my actual Italian request was denied), I asked for a marinara sauce. I was then told that that my order was made with enough white wine sauce and I did not need it!! When I asked for the sauce to eat with bread, I was then told I have a lot of scampi sauce. The owner then heard me asking for the sauce and asked what was wrong. The owner then said that the sauce is very expensive and they cannot give marinara sauce to everyone. He then said, this is not ketchup and water. Let's skip to the food, it's equivalent to the service!!!! read more

Food is ok. Something good to pick up when you are running to work or coming home. There pepperoni rolls are pretty good tho. But Nothing else I've had really grabbed me. Ordered a plain pizza, the dough was under cooked. Ordered a chicken roll, chicken wasn't seasoned well. Ordered salad that was good. The older guy is very nice, he is the reason why I keep giving this place a shot. read more

I've been here quite a few times and always get something different. Everything on the menu has been incredible so far. The place is very comfortable and the owner is very friendly. Has that authentic Italian restaurant feel. You can tell they use quality ingredients in the food. Definitely my go to spot. read more

This is a cozy little spot in Yonkers to get a bite to eat. The personal pizzas are tasty and reasonably priced. The chicken-bacon-ranch selection was robust in flavor, and did not leave me feeling sluggish afterwards. Not a bad snack for $8.75. I will have to check out the other varieties on my next trip. read more

Tonight was actually our third time eating at Casa Mia and each time was fabulous. Wednesday is lobster night, which is what brought us there this evening and we were not disappointed! As a first course, we had traditional Italian straciatella Florentine soup, that was perfectly cooked to order, so fresh! Then we shared the stuffed artichoke, which was also cooked perfectly. Usually I'm not a fan of this dish, because I always find it too dry, but not here! The artichoke was perfectly tender and moist. Now to our main course: In addition to the traditional steamed or broiled whole Maine lobster offered, our Server, a sweet gentleman offered a half lobster in a Zuppa de Pesce with calamari, clams, shrimp and mussels, which is what I ordered with two optional twists: fra diavolo-style, and with homemade squid ink fettuccine! Omg, it was to die for! Seriously, the best tasting ZdP I've ever had, and a very generous portion, I might add. It's very rare for me to eat carbs like pasta, but this time was definitely worth it! My husband had the lamb chops and they were cooked perfectly, delicious! On a recent visit, I had the chilled seafood salad (shrimp, squid, scallops) and it was the most refreshing I've ever had with obviously the freshest lemon juice and high quality olive oil and fresh parsley. The hubby ordered a couple of different personal pizzas since he was going to get one to-go afterwards anyway (figure ya might as well get a little variety while we're here). It was obvious that only the freshest ingredients are used here. I work in the business and have become quite the food snob, so it's refreshing to see a place in the neighborhood serving this quality at such a reasonable price. We were customers at the former tenant in that space, Valentino's, but everything had gotten a little stale there (literally). Casa Mia gave the space quite a facelift, the interior is beautiful, with a nice bar and what seemed to be a thriving pizza business up front. Thank you, Casa Mia, we'll be back soon! read more

Casa Mia - Zuppa de Pesce with homemade squid ink fettuccini and a half lobster. Fra Diavolo, not too spicy with fresh basil and tomato. Buon Appetito! - Italian Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Definitely a bit overpriced, but the food is good. Sometimes it's a hit or miss because I've gotten amazing chicken Cesar salads and I've gotten terrible ones. I would also recommend the chicken parm on a hero. read more

I've purchased personal pizza twice and both times were delicious! The front staff is extremely courteous. Definitely going back for dinner.

Pizza is great. I go to many pizza and restaurants and find casa mia to be one of the best The best in yonkers and mount vernon. Love the steak. This place is a hidden gem. The owner is very nice. I highly recommend the steak or pizza. read more

Worst place I've ever been to the pizza maker stands there and drinks beer where they make your pizza un the staff is friendly is but they are unprofessional I ordered food once took about45 min to get to my house the driver didn't have change and they wouldn't leave the food so they took the food and Had the nerve to bring me back cold food with a free 2 Liter Their food is good but everything else is horrible read more

It was my first time to Casa Mia and the experience was excellent. I was greeted right away with friendly smiles by Troy and the pizza man. For my lunch I got a pan sized pizza and I must say it was delicious. The menu has an extreme variety of food and everything looks fresh and tastes fresh too. I'm looking forward to lobster night which is a steal for $29.95. I'm definitely going back! read more

Great place! The pizza is delicious and the service is very friendly. Felt free to relax since I wasn't being rushed and I always appreciate that. Would nightly recommend it. read more