I have to say I've never been to Findlay and so glad this little spot was near ny hotel - and I read the reviews I was sceptical but this was VERY good and fresh authentic Mexican food ! The chile rellano is my go to and it blew many other experiences out of the water Very good value - the street taco amazing ! Corn tortillas yum Great margarita gold - the waiters super attentive Need I go on ? Anyhoo I'd say give them a try ! read more

Casa Fiesta - Chips margarita and inside - Mexican Near Me - Findlay, Ohio

See all

We were there a month ago and everything came out cold. The queso was even cold, so runny it wouldn't stay on the chip. We told manager and they took queso off bill. Wouldn't recommend. read more

We love Casa Fiesta not only for the food but also for the wonderful people that work there! We have so many favorite dishes, you really can't go wrong, but the carnitas in green chili sauce is a standout. We also love their puréed jalapeño dip. read more

I love this place even have a hat with the logo. Great food and service only have had one time when they brought me the wrong food but it was a new employee so I wasn't upset he was super kind and fixed it. Food comes out quick and hot. Great place strongly recommend read more

Good food served hot and quickly, waited on promptly, server was very nice, it was a relaxing atmosphere- one of the best Mexican restaurants in town. We'll be back! read more

I've gimave this place three chances in three days. First day sat at the bar for 5 min and a lady comes up and ask how I was. I said good and she left. I waited another three minutes and walked out because of no service. Second day I ordered to Al a cart item and absolutely awful!!!! Shrimp burrito and a chimichanga. The shrimp was like licking a salt block and the chimichanga was like I would have gotten out of the freezer section at the grocery store. Third day. Ordered 3 hard tacos and it had bland beef, shredded lettuce and some kind of cheese that looked like it was sprinkled on. The taco shells were nasty. I honestly would have had better food at Taco Bell. I have no clue how this place is even still open. I won't lie though. The second two days the service was good. read more

I 10/10 recommend this place. Always hits the spot, it's delicious, fresh, and as far as I can tell very authentic. I always order the pick two combo chicken chimichangas, with rice and beans. And am never disappointed. That being said, this is the first time I've been disappointed. As previously mentioned, I always order the pick two combo chicken chimichangas, and one of them is pork. And the one that is chicken has tomatoes and an over abundance of green chillies. I hope this new renovation is not changing the way they make their food. Because that would be heartbreaking. Overall, the food was still good, I'm just really picky, which is why I have always loved and continued to order from casa because they're always delicious. Even though my order was wrong, my food was still good. Since their renovation the place looks cleaner and more alive! Absolutely should eat here. read more

Best authentic food I've eaten since I moved from Texas. Service is awesome also. Prompt servings time for orders can't say anything but positive enjoyable experience. read more

Since moving to Texas 6 years ago, we have yet to find a Mexican restaurant that will even come CLOSE to Casa Fiesta ! When we come back to visit family and friends in Ohio, we have a roster of favorite places and Casa is at the TOP ! Eduardo is an awesome host/ manager and his wait staff are attentive and met all of our needs. The place is clean and vibrantly decorated. Like I said...THE FOOD IS THE BEST ! YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED ! read more

The food wasn't as good as I hoped. :( the salsa tasted like straight up garlic. The tortilla chips were so so. The main course was also so so. I probably wouldn't go back. Service was fine though. read more

We are pleased to announce that Casa Fiesta is back. The restaurant used to be a regular stop during our trips to Findlay, about a year ago, after a couple of disappointing stops, we dropped from our lists. Just last week, we tried it again, and were greatly pleased with our experience. First of all, the service has always been excellent, with a friendly and helpful staff. The entries have always been very plentiful, the food authentic, and freshly prepared. And the 'Ritas, always a winner. We also enjoy the atmosphere with colorful art and fixtures. Is it the best Mexican food ever, no, but certainly the best we have had in the midwest. read more

See all

Best Mexican food in Findlay. The guacamole is delicious. Huge portions. Authentic feel. Amazing service.

All seven of us enjoyed our meals. Fajitas, enchiladas, chicken, chimichangas. Prices were good too. Enough for 3 leftover cajas. We were in town for a funeral but the place was comfortably decorated and we were able to relax and have a few good laughs. Did not notice the music, so we don't know if it was still bad. read more

I will not go back. It took forever to be waited on. The rice was cold and the taquitos were dropping with grease.

This restaurant is hands down my favorite place to eat in findlay! The atmosphere, the amazing food, the excellent service, timely manner in which your food is prepared, the margaritas ***so many flavors to choose from! I recommend you try the banana margarita!**. I love mexican cuisine I have been to so many! This place is full of flavor! The different dishes have their own sauces. Nothing is bland, none of the flavors run together; you can distinguish each dish from another. So polite! My server was telling ME thank you! I cannot think of one negative thing to say about Casa Fiesta. Clean facility and staff Large menu amazing food Presentation of food was on point timely services- did not wait for anything! Promptly received our entrées Amazing staff, we felt like guests our service was excellent and we did not feel bonbarded. All in all I would rate Casa Fiesta a 6 star restaurant if I could. !!! read more

See all

My second favorite Mexican restaurant in town after La Charrita. Ask for the salsa verde, it is the best. Wide selection of foods, good margaritas, and generous portions. Service is good and friendly. I rate this 4.5 stars. read more

This was a 2-3 star place for me. Service was good, most food was passable. I had a taco, chile relleno, and chimichanga. The taco was a Taco Bell / El Paso (store) type. The pepper was breaded in an extremely soggy coating or maybe just an unusual egg? It was very unusual and stuffed only with cheese, no sausage or spices. Rice and beans were overcooked. Flavors overall were okay. The biggest offense for me was their guacamole is just...not guacamole. It seemed to be blended and made with high onion content? It had more in common with a vegetable smoothie than real guac; it was a bit sweet. Actually, now that I'm describing it, I wonder if it was prepared with green peppers added; that seems likely. I do want to highlight four menu selections that went over well with my family. The drinks were reportedly good (little light on the pours, but tasty). Items 57 and 75 were well-received. I tasted the milanesa and it was tasty; definitely the best thing on the table imo. #75 was a mountain of food and I'm told it was good. The tamale looked pretty good/authentic and I'm told it was. This is a decent "American Mexican" place, but if you're looking for something authentic and tasty, this isn't your top choice. read more

Casa Fiesta is a 5 star Mexican restaurant, and about as good as it gets. The service is excellent and they are very friendly, enjoyable, and accommodating for their customers. Right away we got chips and salsa and they will bring out queso as well if you like. They also have a couple other homemade salsas to try if you ask for them. The main meal came very promptly with a short wait from the time we ordered. Everything came out hot and exactly as it was shown/described on the menu. The steak inside the burritos is very tasty and grilled to perfection. The burrito grande is always my go to dish here but other entrees look excellent as well. Long story short, if you are a lover of good Mexican food then Casa Fiesta is your place to go. The friendly and prompt service also makes it a very enjoyable restaurant. read more

I left another longer review, but a nutshell version of my most recent visit is below: Great food, nice atmosphere with the colors and music, I had smiling and friendly hosts, lunch prices are especially a great deal, complimentary chips and salsa were tasty, when I left a guy shouted "Have a wonderful rest of your weekend guys!" with a smile and a wave. I am definitely coming back and will be recommending to friends and family. read more

Casa Fiesta - #40, Fajita Quesadilla (steak) - Mexican Near Me - Findlay, Ohio

See all

Better music seems a change has occurred !! Very good - best in town and the people great. Keep in mind it is a real Mexican restaurant and you get the same bad music from 50 years ago and sometimes the service is lacking. But for a Mexican restaurant it is very good - it is the best I have experienced in Ohio. But it is what it is and don't expect anything different - You cant complain about the food - it worth a try Outstanding - Better music now - contemporary- perfect - please continue- change !!!!!!!!! Thank you read more

This is one of our favorite places in town to eat. The atmosphere is great and the service is usually just where it should be. My favorite part of their menu is the gringo glossary! read more

Slow service. Sat at bar and waited 45 minutes for food. It was room temp when it finally arrived. Servers were covering bar as if individual seats were sections. Couple next to me left as I sat down. No one cleared their plates or glasses for the hour I was there. The next group asked to have it cleared but server only nodded and smiled. I would not recommend going here. No one cared when I offered my opinion about room temp food and slow service. Server just gave condescending smile; constantly. And poured beer with 3 inch head. Way more than good pours should have. Wish I could give 0.01 star. read more

The food might be good if you ever get it. Ordered food, sat at our table over an hour waiting. A group of eight and another couple came in after us and were served. Halfway through our wait the waiter came over to confirm our order. We surmised he forgot to submit it to the kitchen. After an hour we got up and left our drinks and chips. Will never go back. First impressions matter. read more

Worst meal we have ever had in Findlay. We sat at our table for 20 minutes (as waiters and waitresses passed right by us) before someone finally stopped to take our drink order. No chips. Nothing. Margaritas were fine when they finally arrived, but chips were so stale that they were chewy when they were finally given to us some 30 minutes after we were seated. Approximately 40 minutes after we were seated, someone finally took our meal order. We waited another 30 minutes before just paying for our drinks and leaving. No meals ever arrived. No one came back to our table to check on us. We had to just leave the money on the table. We will never go back again! read more

Traveling through town someone recommended this Mexican restaurant. We were not disappointed the meal was delicious and they also had steak and hamburgers for a fussy husband. Waitress was very courteous and helpful and helping us choose what we wanted. Would definitely go back to this place when traveling through this area again read more

My family just celebrated my mother's birthday at Casa Fiesta Restaurant in Findlay. Our party of 12 was seated promptly. Our server, Christy, is relatively new to the business but she worked like a seasoned professional. Our meals were served promptly and everything was excellent. The queso dip appetizer is really good and the guacamole was fabulous - definitely not the bland, portion-packed stuff. Our party was treated as if we were the only guests in the house. Casa Fiesta is a winner! Thank you for making our experience special. read more

Visiting in Findlay to consider relocating business. Stopped here to eat. Waited 5 minutes before anyone came to welcome station to seat us. Once seated our drink order was taken and brought in a timely manner. After that we waited 25 minutes for someone to come take our order. No one came, and they were not busy. Left $ to cover the drinks and walked out. I would be hard pressed to try them again. read more

The food is good here. Fresh and hot....the service, not so much. Waited more than 10 minutes for a drink refill. Lady took my order, brought out my food and then disappeared the rest of the time I was there. read more

I love this place. It is a "lunch date" spot for my friend and I often. Their portions are a decent size and taste great. The staff is always friendly and always takes the time to answer all my silly questions about the menu. Their have been times that we just flat out asked "what would you get?", got it, and was not disappointed. We will definitely keep coming back here. read more

We love this place. Friendly people, great food, large portions, and family friendly atmosphere. Maria is fantastic! For Christmas Eve she gave us dessert for free. Churros are now our youngest child's favorite dessert. read more

OMG!!! Really great food. A family of 7 visiting from Texas and the food is on point. Fed my husband and I, 2 teenage sons, a teenage daughter, and twin 6 year old sons ate for less than $65 including drinks and before discount. They atmosphere is super kid friendly and they really catered to the kids... also gave me 5% military discount. AWESOME clean and tasty place! read more

Findlay is fortunate to have this place. Homemade real Mexican favorites like orchata, mole, and great seafood (the chef is from Veracruz). Ask for the freshwater tilapia. Staff is wonderful. Owner loves his job. And they have real hot sauce and peppers for those who like it spicy. I hope this place catches on it would be a shame to lose them! read more

We were in town for business and looked this up as option on Yelp. The reviews didn't let us down. I had a mix and match combo dinner and everything was excellent. My one colleague had the chicken fajita and something finally kept him quiet, his eating. My other colleagues plate ended up pretty clean even the enchilada with the sauce. We had a very large beer and the bill was like very favorable. I would highly recommend this restaurant and next time in town be back for at least lunch if not dinner. read more

It seems lately I've been leaving more bad reviews than good but welcome to west central Ohio, the arm pit of America. This place is absolutely horrible in every way possible! Their margaritas taste like straight Daileys daiquiri mix, and their fried pork isn't fried at all. I hate to say it but if you have the slightest of a craving for Mexican food drive another two blocks and hit the chipotle. read more

This is our "go to" spot for Mexican in Findlay once you eat here you'll find it hard to go anywhere else, we love the vegetarian fajitas and their salsa is wonderful and made fresh here. We always buy salsa to take home its so good. They have a great vegetarian selection and if you want meat dishes they are also fantastic read more

Casa Fiesta was SO GOOD! Definitely a cut above your average Mexican restaurant. The food was very flavorful, and the guacamole is incredible!! 10/10 would recommend! read more

The only place I've found in findlay with horchata, and it's the perfect balance of creamy cinnamon sweetness. Plenty of options on the menu, with some authentic dishes that can be harder to find. My food has always been hot, delicious, with fast service. Would definitely chalk this up as my favorite place for Mexican in town. read more

This is clearly the best and most authentic Mexican food in Findlay. We absolutely love it. We've gone there probably six or seven times and have always enjoyed our meals. read more

Some of the best Mexican food in Findlay with ice cold beer and a great staff. Oscar and Edwardo are the best

Stopped here on a spur of the moment as driving through Findlay. Turned out to be a good choice. Was about 2:30 pm on a Saturday. It was not very crowded. We were seated and had our drinks and chips and salsa in less than five minutes. The atmosphere was very Mexican, although the music was a little to loud. Our food came in about 10 minutes, which was very nice. I had the Barbacoa which came in a large portion, plus beans and rice which were also large portions. My wife had a combo platter and her portions of the beans and rice were large. For the two of us, with drinks and tax was$20.21. That is great. Good food, large portions, great price. If we are ever in Findlay again, will stop here. read more