Great lounge with lots of ample seating and a great humidor; selection of Nicaraguan, Dominican, etc. Guys here are helpful, remember you, and make you feel like cigar lounge family. read more

Casa de Montecristo - Tobacco Shops Near Me - New York, New York

Starting out with the lounge. Very nice a very large. Great humidor. I'm smoking a Liga Privida No. 9. An excellent smoke. Service is great. Very nice and helpful. Prices are very fair for midtown Fun group. read more

Casa de Montecristo - My stick - Tobacco Shops Near Me - New York, New York

Visited New York from Wisconsin on Valentine's Day and stumbled across Casa de Montecristo. It was the perfect ending to our day. Rob was friendly and helpful and the vibe was relaxed. Highly recommend checking this place out if you're ever in the area. read more

Casa de Montecristo - Tobacco Shops Near Me - New York, New York

This place is one of the most friendliest cigar lounges I have ever experienced. The other patrons were great and met many of pleasant folks. Great selection of cigars and pricing was reasonable. A very enjoyable time:) read more

This is a hidden gem in NYC. Crowd always welcoming. I live in CA and come here about twice a year and great place to watch sports, enjoy good conversation and have access to humidor with large variety of sticks. You can bring your bottle and for slight surcharge you can get ice, glasses, soda and water. read more

A few days ago we visited to relax and have a cigar, we ended up having 2 and staying well over 2 hours due to the ambiance. The staff here are incredible and treat everyone like family. By far one of the best cigar lounges I've ever been to in that regard. The alcohol is B.Y.O.B. But there's a liquor store nearby so that's not too big of a deal. Will definitely be coming back when I'm in town and highly recommend this place to anyone looking to sit down and enjoy some well rolled cigars. read more

Always a do-drop-in for me when I am in DC. It's close to everything and the crowd is always at a comfortable. Very , reasonably priced cigars with an outstanding scotch collection. I'm always surprised of how much value you get there for the money. Don't miss out on this one. read more

During a ladies day trip to New York we visited here the Friday before the new year, we enjoyed everything about the experience. The humidor has something for every cigar budget, preference, and 'taste'. The staff was friendly, knowledgeable and welcoming. The lounge has a relaxed old school lounge vibe to it, ample comfortable seating, clean, with several conversational spaces. The bathroom was very clean (yes that is important to me) and well attended to. This is a BYOB place, a fee for BYOB, there is a well appointed spirits store next door. I look forward to coming here again during my next visit to New York. read more

Classy and a upper scale social club ambiance. The cigars are fairly price for manhattan and there's a wide selection from affordable to more premium cigars. There are plenty of seats and the host is very attentive and passionate about his job. Also, love that I can walk here from my condo. Planning to come back here again shortly. read more

Love this friendly cigar shop in the Turtle Bay area. Rob was very welcoming during both of our visits. They have a well stocked humidor with an impressive selection of sticks and many smoking areas with comfy chairs. It appears to be a mix of friendly regular customers and visitors and we were greeted by several other customers. We had a nice time chatting with Rob and on the second visit Bernard and can't wait to return to this place the next time we're in NYC or if we're in any other cities with a store like this one. read more

Good selection, bit overpriced...asked for some help (suggestions to guide my selection), individual was clearly irritated than I interrupted his cheese curl snack. Ultimately figured it oui on my own, then watched him handle my cigars with the cheese curl fingers..,yep - great experience that way will only happen once. Go elsewhere! read more

I've been coming here since the Cigar Inn days. I've been here about a dozen time & I've never had a bad experience. My first thoughts of this establishment is the humidor. Plenty of cigars to choose from at a reasonable prices. There's plenty of room. Chairs, stools & couches to relax & watch some sports on the multiple TVs they have. They allow BYOB to pair with your cigars & menus to order food if you'd like. I've never really had much interactions with the staff aside from paying for my cigars. The gentleman who rang me up last time was pleasant. If you are a cigar smoker in NYC I highly recommend visiting here. read more

Casa de Montecristo - a hand holding a cigar - Tobacco Shops Near Me - New York, New York

Great selection and prices but the 2 cigar minimum is asinine. What if people don't have humidors at home and want to smoke here? They still have to buy a second cigar? Doesn't make sense. Also, their ventilation system needs an overhaul BADLY. In summer months it becomes very hot and uncomfortable. read more

A very good selection at average prices for NYC. (Taxes are about 33% above the list price.) Friendly staff. No alcohol. The ventilation is terrible. read more

Casa de Montecristo - people in a coffee shop - Tobacco Shops Near Me - New York, New York

If you are into cigars I want to be in a nice cozy place to hang out with friends I strongly recommend you to come here. The cigar Sommelier is a very knowledgeable and patient. I came here for an event and I really enjoyed my time here. They have a very large collection of cigars ranging from Davidoff to montecristo to cigars from Nicaragua in Guatemala and Dominican. The place was packed and there was good air circulation. We set an a little balcony with comfortable chairs. In regards to females I saw a few other ladies here. I came here with two other female friends and we were comfortable. People were respectful and we have pleasant conversations. read more

Casa de Montecristo - Cigar Lancero - Tobacco Shops Near Me - New York, New York

While putting my 96 year old aunt in assisted living in July I discovered the Casa three blocks from my aunt's new place. When the staff and regulars figured out why I was in town they couldn't do enough for me. Fast forward 2 1/2 months and a previously scheduled trip to check on my aunt turned into making funeral arrangements. Again-the staff and regulars were aware of what was going on and made sure that I was comfortable before and after she passed away last Sunday. Great place-unpretentious, great people, reasonable prices (for NYC). My new home away from home in NYC. They took good care of me-now by writing this I am taking care of them. read more

This was a nice mama man location. Wasn't a female in sight. Just the guys vibing with their cigars. There was a mixed crowd of black and white men. The music was more contemporary vibes. BYOB! The highlight of the spot I surprised my fiancé with a birthday date here since he loves cigars. The server was welcoming; however, after seating us she said nothing. This was our first time here so we needed a intro to what's next. We put our belongings down, and walked to the front to ask about the cigars. We walked into the room where you view the hundreds of cigar options. There was a man who was pretty knowledgeable about the selections and he was super nice. He lit the cigar for my fiancé and made small talk. He liked the spot, and said he would return with friends. read more

Casa de Montecristo - The Register where you purchase your cigars selection, get it lit, and can buy merchandise. Dope vibes - Tobacco Shops Near Me - New York, New York

Another layover in NYC Another visit to this beautiful joint not only you find what you need . You also learn a lot more if you think you know, Cigars talk to Nicolas. The dude is walking cigar encyclopedia thanks for the hospitality be back soon read more

Casa de Montecristo - a person's feet on a coffee table - Tobacco Shops Near Me - New York, New York

Luis was tremendously help in selecting a great cigar. The store was neat and clean. Exhaust system could be improved.

this time it was so smoky I could not take it. also the guy behind the counter was a rude idiot. not usually how it is here. I now prefer Carnegie or Club Mac. read more

This was my 3rd cigar bar I've tried in N.Y. and even though they don't serve food or drinks it's so much better than the others I've tried. The staff is friendly clientele is nice the cigar prices are reasonable you can bring your own food and and drinks. The place is just a nice comfortable place to chill and have a cigar to relax. This is definitely my new hang out spot when I'm in town love it here! read more

A great way to enjoy a cold New York City evening ...fine cigars and good friends ! Love the laid back atmosphere in this place . Great service from the all the cordial staff from The General Manager to the clean up staff ! read more

Casa de Montecristo - Tobacco Shops Near Me - New York, New York

I have been coming to this place for some time now and it's one of the coolest places in the city if you want to smoke a cigar. The general manager is one of the nicest people you'll meet including the rest of the employees! It's not as the other cigar lounges you'll find in the city. It's low key with amazing vibe and atmosphere. Guarantee you'll love it! read more

See all

I wanted to buy my brother a sampler of outstanding cigars for a big birthday that wouldn't require a mortgage. Mission accomplished! I will be back soon! read more

I love to stop in Casa de Montecristo. Oscar Wilde quipped the only means to get rid of temptation is to yield to it. I bet I am not the only one who is nostalgic about tobacco smoke. I mean from cigars and pipes, not cigarettes. So many of us associate it with a relative. It triggers memories, including of pleasurable occasions when I have relaxed while puffing away. I acknowledge the risks. I indulge rarely. I figure given the stress reduction, it is a worthwhile trade off. If you object, don't come into this place. The selection here is sizable. The prices are reasonable. The other feature to highlight is they are hospitable. But they are not snooty. You can sit in a comfortable chair and just think. I'm not big on clubs. The feel here is different. It is guys, and gals, who share an interest. You could strike up conversation about the sports on television. But it is generally to each their own. I sometimes am accompanied by a colleague. Even then, however, we are enjoying our own private reverie. I value such moments. If any of what I have described appeals, perhaps you'll step away from the busy life you have outside and whatever is happening on the street. read more

Service: 3 star Tobacconist Knowledge: 3 star Ambiance: 5 Star Price: 2 star Location: 4 star Lounge: 4 star Selection: 4 stars Humidor: 4 Overall: 3.75 Stars. Service was mixed, overall. The Tobaccanist behind the counter was exceptional in many ways. He immediately took care of me and helped pickup a cigar. However, I did not realize the cigar I wanted was generally a much rated vitola in comparison to it's cigar of the year brother. This is something he should have picked up on when I stated, I love one vitola and was curious if the other was just as good. The experience was the cigar that evening was fine, but not stellar. I was never asked once, by the gal, running around the shop if I wanted a drink. She only came around once while cleaning out an ashtray - which was really for someone else. When I asked about an ashtray for myself, where I was sitting, she pointed to the one she gave the other gentlemen which wasnt really next to me and arguably where someone else could sit. In the middle of the sofa. Instead of placing one to my right. This is the opposite to attention to derail you get at the other location deeper in to the Upper East Side. Their cigar selection is excellent, it is hard to lack a cigar you want in this store. My needs are not the norm so as long as they have any of the number of cigars I'm after I'm happy. The boutique cigars I usually want are harder to find. Like MBombay, Tatuaje, RomaCraft, etc.. which I get elsewhere. This is a luxury. None of this is necessary. But price is still important. Especially, when I can get the same items from their competition. Their prices are all over the place. The vitola I smoked was 2x more expensive here than in other locations around the city. Which is only fair to compare within the city as taxes on tobacco vary by state. Online, of course, is always going to be significantly better in price. So coming here should be about service, selection. The immediate satisfaction of smoking what you want now. And of course the ability to mingle with people in the lounge. This lounge is nice and comfortable. Technically, a bit too sunken in. I'm not the cross your legs type of guy and the sofas and chair sunk in to point that was awkward to sit in bit I went with it. My real critique is the ventilation and air filtration. I think it has not been cleaned. Contrary to popular belief people who enjoy cigars, do not enjoy the smoke. Once you've puffed your cigar and blown the smoke out - you want that smoke gone. I couldn't find where the ventilation and filtration current was. If there was one. So my smoke, and the smoke of my neighbors, lingered in our faces. That stings your eyes, make you smell bad, and ruins the experience. So this place needs to check their filters and air flow. It's a good place to come and smoke, my review sounds harsher than it was but with a few tweaks this location will be 5 stars across the board, consistently. read more

Casa de Montecristo - Tobacco Shops Near Me - New York, New York

See all

On this visit it's unfortunate I can only provide one star upon walking to the humidor I found a lit cigar just laying there confusing the humidor with its smoke. One of the sales people came in and I subsequently point it out that it was there he looked at me and said yes I know it's mine. Has anyone who smokes cigars knows there should be no lit cigars in the humidor itself as it can impart flavor on the inventory. Then when I got to the counter the gentleman standing there was quite rude rung me up didn't ask for anything cut didn't even ask if I wanted a receipt simply rung me up and throughout my receipt. This place has definitely taken a turn for the worst read more

Great service and atmosphere. Called before arriving to ensure dress code and requirements. read more

Decided to do something my little sister have been dying for us to try....cigar smoking.... A friend of mine dj here after work on Fridays but we came on a Saturday afternoon. It felt like an old school bar vibe. VERY COMFORTABLE sofas, I felt like I could have fallen asleep there. I tried 2 types of cigars, (sorry I can't recall the names) this is my first time trying cigars. Big screen TVs, older crowd & very friendly staff. Since it was my little sister's birthday we got a 1 cigar and water for free. Yay!! We are planning on coming back again real soon. read more

See all

If Club Macanudo is the Rat Pack Chillin' with Cigars and the Stars vibe, Cigar inn is where all my cigar buds choose as the go to, neighborhood smoke shop. The cigar prices are reasonable as well as the smoking paraphernalia: lighters, cigar cutters as well as a barber and shoe shine?? Very cool. It's just a chill vibe here, the smoking folks that come here are all cool and unpretentious. Another great plus, it's BYOB. We're all smoking, talking, laughing and just having a good time. There isn't that much seating so we're all standing around the table just enjoying Cigar Inn. It gets really smokey inside so if you don't like it smokey, stand outside. Check this place out, its a nice neighborhood cigar smoking spot read more

On par for NY prices. Staff was friendly. This is a BYOB establishment and a very diverse crowd.

A sanctuary for the cigar smoker. Very chill , hassle free environment. Brothers of the Leaf, look no further, this is the place to have a smoke. Well ventilated. Comfy chairs. TVs. and plenty of good conversation, if you want it. I stopped by on a Monday evening and I find plenty of seating room. Unlke the other cigar lounges, this one is not cram packed with too many people. A nice change of pace, a place to exit the crazy madhouse of NYC. Cool, calm oasis. The humidor is well stocked. I would recommend their house blend, their very own Cigar Inn cigar. A hefty smoke, perhaps 52 x 6, $8. A Nicaraguan with DR filler. Super dark and shiny wrapper. It smokes very mellow, creamy and nutty. No pepper, no burn, no young tabac. For $8, this cigar stands up to the Padron and Fuentes. If you like full body, and flavor over power, this is the perfect one. Chewy and satisfying smoke. Good draw, but a little too wet. Mine had a split about 1/3 into it. Nothing a little time in the humi would not solve. Protip --- Its BYOB. So go next door and pick up your Scotch and come on over. They have glasses ready for you. read more

Casa de Montecristo - House blend. A good smoke indeed. - Tobacco Shops Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Really like this place. It just changed owners so this is a review for mostly the old owners and one visit since the new owners took over. I live right down the street and visit cigar inn about once a month. They have a great selection of cigars and the employees are always very willing and helpful when it comes to recommendations. You can bring your own drinks, including booze which is a HUGE plus. Just bring a six pack or a bottle of wine or whiskey from ambassador spirits which is right next door. They have glasses and ice that they will bring you for the small cost of a tip at the end. It has a great decor and about 5 TVs. Great place to watch a game or a fight. But they need some upgrades on the furniture. Their couches and stools are getting pretty worn and funky. They used to always have DJs and whatnot on weekends but apparently since the new owners took over they have gotten rid of that clubby atmosphere at night. Which i can't say I'm mad about. Overall good prices. Cigars avg about $7-18 a piece. Which isn't bad. Check the place out. Its worth a visit if you like smokin the occasional stogie. read more

See all

A phenomenal experience of cigars, ambience and an incredible eclectic combination of people. This is my "go to" lounge while in New York. The Dallas location is a great experience also. read more

I love smoking cigar's at Casa Montecristo on 2nd Avenue in New York City Manhattan.great place very friendly extremely knowledgeable. Awesome with all the customers. Great crowd everybody is cool. I have been their Several times. Definitely worth it. read more

It's amazing to me that nobody cares about the temperature in the store. It's very hot and humid outside and even more so inside the store. It's been like this for the past couple of weeks as I've mentioned in a past review. Nothing changed since then and the few people I see inside are sweating and complaining but nothing changes. I for one am out and not coming back to a business who doesn't value its customers! Hello Macanudo! read more

Relaxing vibe, top notch cigar selection, comfortable seating and naturally wonderful folks behind the brand specializing in making you have a great time. Have a great cigar, pass the night chatting with friends, watch your favorite sports team play and sip on the drink (BYOB) of your choice. Anel, Bernie, Diana, Rebecca, Luis and Demetrius are always welcoming. read more

I am boxing and fitness trainer and my client (female) wanted to show me this place and said how amazing this place would be to chill and smoke. I bought my favorite Arturo Fuente Don Carlos, My Father The Judge and a Plasencia Reserva Original. April 4th, 2023. At first I was very very interested because of the crowd and tv's showing sports until a black man in the back area started having a conversation with a white man about "Pussy" very loudly and it was like I was at a lounge in some grimy area where people show no respect. I seen about three different staff members walk by and they didn't acknowledge anything. Great cigar collection but bad language spoken. I'll never step foot in there again. read more

Stayed in NY for my bday week. Hubby wanted to check this place out as he's a cigar lounge connoisseur. Cool points: hubby said it was BYOB not sure if there was a fee though because we didn't find out until we got there. Don't have to be a member to go there and hang out/smoke a cigar. NOT so cool points: $10 fee to bring your own cigar & smoke it there so hubby just purchased a $15 cigar there to smoke. He chose the usual fave cigar he likes. He cut it and the cigar started to unwrap. I told him to return it for another & he decided not to make a fuss. He smokes it and says it's stale. Before this, the girl working took his drink order at the register while I was sitting at our chosen area...she came over with his pelligrino and completely ignored me. Didn't ask if I wanted anything. Hubby also says they only have water and pelligrino. I didn't feel like it was female friendly seeing as I was the only female there and wasn't asked if I wanted anything yet every male that walked in, including my hubby was tended to. Oh well. read more

Great little oasis in a town that's not known for being cigar-friendly. Am told you can bring in food and sips from the nearby package store - well-appointed humidor and lounge. read more