Large Blueberry Crumb Pie is to die for! Peach Pie not so…read moregood. People that work there are ok. Ambiance is great!

We have been ordering my Moms birthday cake from Tilda's since she was 86. Last week Mom turned 99!…read moreTilda's did not disappoint. I ordered a yellow three layer cake with cherry filling (Moms favorite) and chocolate buttercream frosting. The flavor was outstanding. The cake itself was moist without being gummy, the frosting was to die for, and the cherry filling wasn't too sweet. It was a perfect cake. Best one yet! My only critic, and it's a very slight one, is the edible butterflies they placed on the cake looked cheap. I removed them prior to serving. I'll be back for her 100th birthday celebration next year!

We couldn't leave the island without getting something sweet from Dortoni…read more I like the variety and colors. Not a fan of the amount of cinnamon added to it but my husband loves it. Small shop with comfortable seating to enjoy your coffee with a delicious cookie. The girls were very lovely and patient because we couldn't decide what to get. Until next time

I rarely leave negative reviews, but I feel compelled to share my experience because of the lack of…read morecommunication and professionalism. On August 3, I visited Dortoni Bakery with my wife and daughter to order a custom smash cake for my daughter's first birthday on August 6. I spoke with a blonde female associate, who told me the bakery would be able to have the cake ready in time. She also told me that someone would call me the following day to confirm the details. I never received that phone call. Instead, an email was sent at 8:58 a.m. requesting information that I had already provided in person the day before. I didn't see the email until later that evening, so I called the bakery to confirm the details. At that point, I was told they would not be able to make the cake after all because they require a minimum of four days' notice. Had I been told that on August 3, I would have simply made other arrangements. Instead, I was assured the order would be completed, only to learn a day later that it could not. As a result, I was left scrambling to find a smash cake with only one day before my daughter's first birthday. Mistakes happen, but clear and accurate communication is essential--especially when customers are planning important family milestones. This experience left me very disappointed, and unfortunately I cannot recommend this bakery based on how this situation was handled.

Really nice space , a lot to offer , very far from NYC…read more One of the more affordable wedding options from what I seen

Majestic Gardens was perfect for my wedding. If you saw my photos, you'd see why. The Christmas…read morelights were gorgeous and exactly what I wanted. My decor was set up perfectly, food and drinks were great, cake was out of this world beautiful and tasty. I also want to mention I was sent home with TONS of food and cake so that was a nice surprise. Would highly recommend. Don't overlook this place! Thanks everyone!

The owner, Val is incredibly talented & creative! Everything she makes stands out from traditional…read morebakeries. The attention to detail on every item she makes is truly remarkable. Not only do her creations look amazing, they are delicious! You won't be disappointed!!

Valerie, the owner and maker of these sweet creations, is great at her craft. She has the proper…read moreeducation and creative eye to make any type of baked good from scratch! And itll be festive and fun for any occasion. The lemon, raspberry naked cake she made for my birthday was a hit with me and my guests. Ive bought cookies, macaroons and more also. Shes great. And very reasonable.

It was on the expensive side for a sandwich but well worth it when servicng size and quality come…read moreinto play . Great bread . Great service . Lots of good products in the store . Definitely coming back to try this one or another in the near future.

Please look at the one star reviews. Everything I ordered was of poor quality. I bought two types…read moreof chicken salad and if I hadn't known I wouldn't even have known it was "chicken"salad. I also bought potato salad, macaroni salad, and a fresh Italian bread. Meanwhile, the bread wasn't fresh and the salads were below par. I was planning on returning the salads, but chose not to instead I won't be returning. Lesson learned.

June 28th 2026 I purchased 3 almond croissants which looked delicious however when I got home and…read moreopened the box all 3 were hard as a rock. They had to be several days old but were not marked as being "day old". I was extremely disappointed and will never make a bakery purchase from them again.

My husband and I came here yesterday afternoon to buy ice cream. The ice cream was good. But,…read morethe rocky road fudge was hard as a rock. You can kill someone with it. The fudge was not fresh, and how dare you sell old fudge to the public, and take there money. We always go to this place to get ice cream, but it will be our last since this is how you are going to treat your customers.

Excellent little ice cream shop with fast lines and great service. Parking is limited and line can…read morebe a bit long but overall had a great summer experience as we ordered our cones and listened to some live music outside. Ice cream was very good, and would recommend for your next ice cream fix.

Love me Some McNulty's ice cream! This place is a staple in…read morest James and a great place to take the kids to get ice cream in the summer. This place is always packed and they have a great selection of home made in house ice cream that a blow your socks off. Very good and no cutting corners making this amazing ice cream. If you're looking for a cool place to bring the kids for ice cream and want a do something different then carvel! McNulty's is the spot and you will not be disappointed! This place is a made house and always busy but the line goes fast. Great place with lots of history in the neighborhood.

The food was top shelf. The service was excellent and the ambiance was very pleasant. We will…read moredefinitely be back.

Was attending a concert in the area so met up with a friend for dinner beforehand. I'm not a…read moreseafood fan, and the name probably should've tipped me off, but I couldn't find anything I wanted on the dinner menu so went with an appetizer and salad. The seasonal sangria was good. Server was nice albeit a bit absentee. Bar seems to have a very strong following, every seat was taken on a Thursday early evening. Wouldn't return only because I don't have the affinity for seafood. Prices were a bit high too; $120 bill and my friend's entree was one of the specials.