Great pizza. Spaghetti and meatballs is like once a week for me. Haven't had anything thing off menu I didn't like. The staff is great.

Best pizza ever! I love this place and I have been going since I was a baby. The food is always freshly cooked and it is never cold. The only thing that is cold are the drinks. (that is a good thing of course) read more

Ordered for a group work lunch - so excellent I couldn't stop talking about it. The perfect NY slice and the staff is very friendly and accommodating. read more

I order catering from them all the time, they have some of the best italian food in Bergen County. There service is always the best, Roland & Chris always take good care to make sure experience is excellent. Highly recommend read more

PROS: staff is friendly, they make the food fast, clean place, nice parking lot, menu variety is plentiful CONS: prices are high compared to other pizza places OVERALL: I would definitely come back here if I'm in the area. read more

See all

The Freakin' BEST Pizza around and brothers top notch as well as staff LOVE These folks...cant say it eough th best crispy, not soggy, sauce fantastic and the Grande' cheese smooth and perfect compliment Garlic knots with sauce out of this world...instead of turkey for thanksgiving we went with Chicken Parm & Eggplant Parm with sphagetti 1 out of 10 we give ***************** B&D read more

Stopped here for lunch after going to the Closter golf dining range and what a great place this is. Tried the pain, white, and grandma chicken slice. Then the owner came over and gave us garlic knots on the house. The food and service were exceptional. Definitely check this place out. read more

Best pizza place!! Everyone who works here is so kind & gives excellent service. 10/10 every time.

Order from them frequently, the pizza is first rate, there may be different, but none better.

Pizza is amazing as are the sandwiches. Delivery is hot, fresh, and on time. They are accommodating for special requests whenever possible. Highly recommend. read more

I know this is a place to leave a review for the restaurant, but for me, it's so much more than just a spot to grab a meal. It's a place where you're not only treated to some of the most delicious food around, but also welcomed with genuine care and a sense of belonging. The owner always greets me by name, takes the time to check in on me, ask about my older father and engage in heartfelt, authentic conversations. It's these small, yet meaningful moments that make every visit feel special. In addition, the staff is always attentive and friendly, which makes each time even more enjoyable. In a world where so many interactions feel rushed or transactional, this place is a rare gem. It's a true example of what it means to create something beyond just a business--it's a community, a family and a place where you can always feel appreciated! - Marjorie G read more

I'm a pizza person and coming from NY you only expect the best. But never found one till I found Carmine & Rays Pizza. It's hands down the best in Closter. Not only with the pizza, but also the mozzarella sticks, the lasagna, the meatballs, the garlic rolls, I can go on but the list will be too long. But if you're looking for some good a$$ pizza then this is the spot you must go. read more

So I've been going to this place since I was 3. I'm now 34. It's changed ownership. My mom doesn't go bc she found hair in her slice. I walked in on a Tuesday to get a slice to go, and there was a group of 3 teenagers on the basketball team sitting and eating knots and pizza while conversing with the lead pizza man. Bald. Nice guy. I paid $6.55 for water and a slice. As I placed my order and was waiting, the 3 kids proceeded to order more food in an "indian" accent and taunt me. The owners and staff did nothing to correct their behavior. Wildy childish and unethical place of business. I mean - who does that? it's 2022. I won't be going back. read more

Good chicken parm sandwich. I don't have more to write but it has to be 85 characters read more

One of the better pizzas in New Jersey almost like NYC. The dishes are decent enough. read more

I have gone here for decades. Owner was rude at times and decent others, depending on the day. Pizza was huge and good. $3 got you a mega slice. I mean huge. Two plates for a slice. Well he now only serves regular sized slices (bordering on small) but the price has gone up. $4.75 for a speciality slice that is relatively small. Pizza is pre-made and sits in the display window. By 3:00pm you're getting a tiny selection of slices that are stale. Business is dead from what I see. Place is old and dirty with mop buckets and cleaning products in clear view behind the register. He has not updated the place at all in all this time. Service is by the owner who is mean and doesn't care. Employees looked like they hate being there. Seems right since you can see many of his former staple employees working at other local pizza spots. $9.50 for two slices of mediocre pizza. Lol. No. I was going to take photos but it wasn't worth the effort. Oh, he takes credit cards finally but gets a real attitude about it. He is pretty heavy about demanding cash. I used to drop in here for nostalgia via a slice of ziti pizza. Not anymore. Thanks for the memories, Rudy's. Time to say goodbye for good. Good night, sweet prince. read more

Shout out to Chris! Always friendly and makes you feel home. PizzasGood, Sausage parmigiana even better. Don't know what to cook for your kids, order their meat ball parmigiana and your kids can have breakfast lunch and dinner. That's how big their portions are. read more

$9.51 lol... We live in a world where 2 slices is almost 10$lol lol lol all i can do is laugh.. It does taste good just jeezeeeeeee

The pizza is really bad in Closter for some reason, and Carmine and Ray's is no exception to that rule. There is no customer service at this place, and I have seen some unsanitary actions from the guys behind the counter. From using their bare hands to handle dirty cash payments directly on to prepping the food without washing them or putting gloves on. They put cold pepperoni on a pizza that has already been cooked because they forgot to add it on before they put it in the oven. They pick up cheese that slid off a too-hot pie with these dirty hands and put them back on the pie for it to re-settle before feeding it to customers. If you didn't see them do this, you would never know! People like this will most likely not wash their hands after using the bathroom. read more

The pizza and food has improved significantly. Still kinda of old time setting. Old tables etc. but good food.

best slice of pizza I've ever had and I love the owner and workers. I am very satisfied!

Ordered on Grubhub. They decided to close early when I went to pick up. No pizza and then the hassle of getting refunded on grubhub. Guy was rude when I went in and he said I'm closed! Said they close at 9:30. Placed order at 8:45. Times are tough with Covid I'd assume a restaurant would want business. At the very least call me and I'd skip this crappy review and move on. It looked very dirty inside as well. read more

We ordered matgarita pizza today and this is what was delivered. Margarita pizza is supposed to have fresh basil on top! Thats what makes this pizza special! Instead what we got was poured on dried basil or thyme??? read more

Carmine & Ray's Pizza - Margarita pizza- where's the fresh basil that's supposed to be there??? - Pizza Near Me - Closter, New Jersey

Overall the pizza here is ok and it had been the local place that I was taking my young son to for a slice about once a week. Unfortunately the 2 older gentlemen are extremely rude and do not care at all about customer service. Last time I was there they almost dropped my slice and the toppings all slid off. The older man said "don't let it go to waste" and pushed the toppings back on and made a mess of our lunch... That was the last straw for me. Between the dirty inside, bad attitude every time one of the owners are there and recent experience (which made me think if they will do that in front of me what do they do in the back with their food) I am done with this place as there are lots of other options on the area. They need a reality show to come clean this place up! I saw the one review saying that this is NJ and people are over-sensitive. I was born and raised here and the rude attitudes here are way over the line. read more

$6.75 for a Snapple and a slice of margherita pizza.... YESTERDAYS pizza! It's one thing to be expensive but to offer left over slices, that aren't worth eating, at top dollar is a sad state of affairs. I've been here several times out of convenience and it's never been good but at least it was fresh. This time it was neither and I won't be back. Should have used my head when I saw the "Conditionally Satisfactory" in the front window. read more

Great staff and decent prices for what you get. I got the baked ziti slice and my friend got the BBQ chicken. Slices are $4 and change. It's definitely a great place to go when you don't want to spend a lot of money and get a big slice of pizza to hold you over. I definitely enjoyed it, but I've had a lot better pizza in Bergen county. read more

Carmine & Ray's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Closter, New Jersey

See all

I've been going to this place for awhile now, in general I would say it's been pretty positive! Quality: the sides they make there taste quite good. Pizza is also pretty good if u get fresh slices. Service: completely depends on who you get helping you. Most of the time u get a rlly cool guy who once even gave me an extra slice just because. He's super chill and def lightens the place. If u get the owner most of the time it feels a little grumpy and kinda eh. Price: while the price for the pizzas are fairly expensive, it's worth it when you get it fresh. The pizza isn't the absolute best but the rest of items on the menu make up for it. Vibe: I've never eaten there in person, always got takeout and people seemed to know each other and it was quite wholesome. A little old fashioned but the workers work real hard! I would definitely recommend this place, if u get the right guy the service is top tier read more

I say the following as a fan of this pizza: The slices in the restaurant are delicious. Crispy crust and lots of flavor. Reminds me of the pizza I had as a child. IMO, the best slices in the area. That's the good part of this review. The not so good: 1.The in-store slices are much smaller than they used to be, and the price has gone up. I wish the slice sizes had remained the same size, and would've been happy to pay more for them. 2. The take out "large" pies are so SMALL. Barely enough to feed 2 people. Please consider making the take out pies larger, even if you have to charge a bit more for them. 3. The appearance of the restaurant: often looks like it hasn't been cleaned in a while. Same dust balls on the floor each time. Stacks of beverage cases....stacks of delivery cases...disgusting garbage can. This doesn't inspire confidence in the overall cleanliness. I've never had a problem with the food, but a little effort to make the place at least look clean and neat would go a long way. I hope the owner will take these comments in the spirit they were given....as a way to improve his business and make this fan of the pizza want to continue to be a customer. read more

We ordered a plain cheese pie and a 2 liter Pepsi.. the delivery boy just had the pizza and apologized that he didn't have the Pepsi. My mom kept saying it's okay don't worry about it! 20 minutes later we get a knock on the door and it's the delivery guy with a 2 liter Pepsi saying my manager wanted us to bring it to you! Good customer service! read more

HORRIBLE DO NOT GO HERE... gave me the wrong pizza would not take it back even though I did not even touch it yet. called them up they told me "IF I HAVE A PROBLEM COME DOWN TO THE STORE AND DEAL WITH IT FACE TO FACE" This Guy Was trying to pick a fight with me. He said he made the delivery and knows where I live and said if I keep complaining he will come to my house and deal with me dace to face Do NOT go here.. the most rude people ever read more

Their pizza is good and the size of the slices are huge!!! I can never finish a whole slice. Tbh i wish they were smaller. It gets a bit overwhelming. They are on the pricey side because of the size. Their pastas are good too. read more

Pizza quality: good, but nothing outstanding. Staff: nice, but all charge you different prices. Why I am giving it 1 star? Because their prices are so outrageous I really think it's possible there is some insanity happening here. Is there gold in this pizza? Oil? Diamonds? I am not tasting any... Do they think they are in NYC? No wait, NYC has cheaper AND better pizza. One slice. FOUR DOLLARS. Yea, I get that the slice is big, but ONE slice of pizza and a bottle of water shouldn't cost me over 6 bucks. Utterly ridiculous! And it is incredibly frustrating that they charge you differently depending on who is ringing you up. There is a pizza place across the street, Closter Brick Oven. Nothing great either, also overpriced, but not as bad as this place. There are so many pizza places in the area, AVOID this one. read more

This place is horrible. A "Supreme" pie is a pizza with tomatoes and broccoli. This place is a joke, the staff are rude and they don't seem to understand the difference between pizzas! I mean they work at a pizza place? Would you pay $25 for this pizza, that they say is "supreme" pizza? Don't come here... please. There are plenty of better places in Closter like Rudy's and Alessandros. This place is a joke, pack up and get out of town. read more

Carmine & Ray's Pizza - "Supreme" pizza........... - Pizza Near Me - Closter, New Jersey

Magarita pizza is the best.. . and the rest of pizza.... I don't know. Shrimp scampi is good.... Compare to other pizza places in closter, their margarita pizza is the best. read more

Overall, a pretty decent slice. Certainly not the best in North Jersey. Keeping in mind the individual slices are fairly larger then your average slice. Therefore, you pay around $3.25 for one slice give or take. Not my "go-to" pizzeria, however I prefer this location over Rudy's. (Across the street). read more

Average pizza and they charge you a service fee for using your credit card. I ordered here a few times out of convenience but probably won't be ordering from them again. read more

Outstanding Pizza!! Nice size, perfect sauce/cheese/topping ratio! Will DEFINATELY be coming back here!! read more

Carmine & Ray's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Closter, New Jersey

Great pizza and convenient location! It's a little pricey but so worth it if you enjoy a good slice. I would def recommend

Terrible experience. Workers were rude. Cups were filthy. Very bad attitude from man at cash register. Charged extra 4% for using credit card on $25 order. No sorry, for dirty cups. No thank you! Just rude! Never again. Go to Rudy's or anywhere else!!! Pizza cheese was like bubble gum. Worst! read more

Best vegetable slice of pizza i have ever had. Crunchy crust which is difficult to find on a vegetable pizza. I would give 1,000 stars if i could. Owner is so sweet and hard working. Love supporting a family business. Super clean. MUST TRY. read more