Both the food and service are excellent, and the quality of the food friendly staff and the cost was reasonable and Service in a timely manner read more

I found this place by accident, but I'm so glad that I went in. I got a half cheese pizza and half steak, it was one of the best pizzas I've had in Florida. I would definitely recommend. The guy in there was so friendly. I definitely recommend. read more

Caprese Pizza House NEW YORK PIZZERIA - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

See all

Mom lives close so when we visited last weekend we decided to stay close and ordered for takeout. Owner was there, pizza was done on time and as requested. Great pizza. Lots of flavor and plenty of toppings. We will definitely be back. Thanks. read more

We have been ordering from Caprese for over 3 years. Really enjoy their pizza, the owner Matt always remembers us. My newest favorites are actually the Philly cheesesteak sub and lamb gyro, highly recommend. The kitchen is so immaculate! It's hard to resist the delicious desserts, our regular favorites are the tiramisu, cannoli & cheesecake. read more

Caprese Pizza House NEW YORK PIZZERIA - Meat lover's pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

Good afternoon, wanted to share a shocking experience with Caprese Pizza House on County Line Road. I have been going there for few years and would even pick up cheesecake from there when I got Chinese next door. I ordered this Saturday night through the Slice app at 6:30pm, got the pizza around 7:45pm, pizza was good but later on when we went to eat the cheesecake it was horrible. I had to spit it out and it was so hard like it was old. They close at 8:30pm, closed on Sunday so I took the cheesecake back today. The owner was so rude about it me returning the cheesecake and how no one in 5 years has complained. I told him that I had been coming for years and he even worse saying it wasn't old and that I should have returned that night. i got the $10 back for the two slices, and left to never return. Everyone can have a bad shipment but to be so rude to a long time loyal customer is not something to forgive. read more

Walk up to the counter to order. My lunch was $25, which shocked me. I'm from out of state, and this is the first place I ate at. Maybe this is normal? The reason I'm writing a review is because I love the garlic knots. I may go back just to get more of those. read more

Caprese Pizza House NEW YORK PIZZERIA - Greek salad, Fettuccine Alfredo, and wonderful garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

Caprese Pizza House is an excellent family-owned restaurant! The location is in the heart of Meadow Point, which allows families to get pizza, salads, and wings quickly. The service is speedy, friendly, and spot-on timing when the food is ready. Their pizza crust is slightly thicker than the average, but I like its extra crunch. It was my first time ordering their wings, sauced perfectly and paired with a homemade ranch. read more

See all

Improve the customer service and replace the manager. After placing a delivery and upon arrival, I realized they did not deliver a 2 liter soda. I paid the 4.99 for thr soda, which was on the receipt. The delivery driver told me to call the restaurant. A very rude young woman, on the managers advice, told me to pick up the soda myself. Even after explaining if I wanted to pick up anything myself, I wouldn't have paid for delivery. Under the manager's advice they offered me nothing else. Not a refund. Not a redelivery. Not a store credit. I informed them of this type of review. There are other great pizza places in the neighborhood. Their food is not worth the poor experience. read more

I'm from ny so I know a good pizza. I Can't stop coming here, the pizza is loaded not cheap w the toppings and the cheese bread is amazing. I found this gem back in march and I can't stop coming here This is the best spot in Wesley chapel/ new Tampa read more

Caprese Pizza House NEW YORK PIZZERIA - 18" Extra Large Meat Lovers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

The calzone is to die for. It's super authentic and we get take out from here often. It's a hidden gem because there usually is not a lot of people there. read more

Great supreme pie well done. Thanks for cutting it into squares for me Matt. See you soon. read more

Caprese Pizza House NEW YORK PIZZERIA - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

Poor service, and not compliant to cleanliness and health requirements. I gather that Pasco county health inspection issued them violations and will shut it down. read more

Good pizza place in Wesley Chapel. We ordered for pick up, but there are a few tables inside to dine in. Tried the cheese pizza and pepperoni/sausage pizza. New York style with good crust pretty authentic. Good sauce as well, fresh ingredients. We also had a salad that was nice and fresh. We ordered online and picked up, it was very easy and the order was completely accurate. read more

Caprese Pizza House NEW YORK PIZZERIA - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

See all

Eggplant parmigiana is dry, they thoroughly spared the spaghetti sauce and the garlic knots are bland. Fries bland. 2 stars for the decent pizza. I haven't had anything there beyond the pizza that was worth the time or money. Stick with the pizza it's only menu item that's what you would expect it to be. read more

I do not know what the negative reviews are about. I really enjoyed my pizza. It was a New York style pizza just like I ordered, and I will get it again. The person who took my order was polite, and the restaurant was clean. The only thing I would say negative about my experience was there wasn't 500 posters from target with construction workers sitting on a steel beam eating lunch on a skyscraper. How am I supposed to know it's authentic? read more

After reading some good reviews of this pizza place, we decided to do a take away pizza order. We ordered on line and went to pick up the pizza. The first hint about quality/popularity should have been that on a Friday evening around 6:00 p.m. it only took 20 minutes for our order to be ready, and upon arrival, the place was empty. (Unlike the Chinese restaurant next door.) We did not feel comfortable in the parking lot either. It was dark out, but the restaurant sign was not lit, and the parking lot lighting was dim. Nor is the parking lot easy to enter. You have to make a right turn onto County Line Rd, then do a U turn to go back to the shopping center where the restaurant is located. Finally - the food. A great pizza may have made up for these negatives, but the pizza was simply not enjoyable. The pizza toppings were average, and the crust had an odd flavor. This was our first and last time to eat here. read more

Regardless of a hurricane, you don't get to talk to people (customers) any type of way. Or treat them any type of way. "Manager" said to request refund from customer service, customer service then said manager won't authorize the refund she told me to call customer service to get. That's just the skinny of the interaction and rudeness from the "manager". I've escalated to Slice customer service management (who services their online orders) and reported/disputed the charge to my Big Bank because I didn't receive it order. Shame the food looked good, wanted to try it. Although i saw them use their hands a lot handling cooked and raw food... I hope your first experience is better than mine. I'll wait for the lies the store will tell in response to my review. read more

I love pizza so I'm always interested to try different places. Our friends recommended this place. We had the 16 inch sausage, bacon and mushroom build your own pizza. I was initially disappointed when the pizza arrived and we saw they had about 1 piece of sliced sausage on each slice of pizza. One?! The crust wasn't crisp, very soft. However, the flavor of the pizza itself was very good with mixture of sauce/cheese. Our friends got a Hawaiian pizza and said that was very good. read more

3.5 stars. This pizza house has been open just a few weeks, the only staffer here to take my order & answer questions (which he couldn't) has been on staff just three days, the WINGS WERE VERY GOOD, & I'm choosing to be optimistic that everything will improve in time. (With all the small businesses lost to Covid restrictions, I'd like this one to have a chance; it takes some time before the wrinkles to be ironed out.) Currently, new customers save 10%, but you'll need to request the savings. (I learned late.) If you want to Pick Up, you can get a Large Cheese Pizza for $9.99. Local delivery is offered w/ a $15 minimum order. The delivery charge is $1.99; delivery ends 30 minutes prior to closing. Visa, Mastercard, Discover, & American Express are accepted. What's on the menu @ this business that's open Tuesday thru Sunday? Nine weekly specials, as well as nine flavors of WINGS; my Garlic Butter variety (SEE PIC) was definitely DELICIOUS. (Wings range in price from $6.99 to 100 for $94.99.) However, mine were received w/ blue cheese, but not w/ the celery sticks listed on the menu. (The young man who took my order said there were no celery sticks available.) Also on the menu are 11 APPETIZERS @ $2.99 to $8.99; 6 SALADS ($3.49 to $9.99); 7 types of STROMBOLI @ $14.25 to $15.45; it serves 2-3 people; 5 CALZONES @ $9.99 to $14.99; 10 PASTAS w/ Garlic Knots ($8.50 to $10.50), & 1 Kids's Spaghetti @ $5.99. There are also 4 COLD SUBS ($8.49); 5 HOT SUBS ($8.49); 4 GYROS offerings @ $6.99 to $7.99; 3 BURGERS @ $6.99 to $8.99; & 7 DESSERTS ($3.99 to $5.99). Lots of pizzas are available here! The menu states the following: "Our dough is hand-tossed and fresh. Pies cooked directly on brick stove oven." There are 6 WHITE PIZZAS (12", 16" & 18" @ $12.99 to $21.99); NY STYLE PIZZA @ $8.99 to $13.99; & 11 GOURMET PIZZAS ($12.99 to $21.99). I was not overly impressed w/ my 12" Cheese pizza w/ extra sauce & extra cheese (although I was charged extra for neither). Not only was there very little sauce on my pie, but the sauce really lacked flavor. There was definitely extra cheese on my pie, & it was good-- just not great. Overall, my pie lacked the flavor I would expect from traditional NY Style pizza. After some researching, I now know that a "brick stove oven" uses coal. Artisan pizzas are often cooked in a brick oven, which uses wood. However, the crust was not an issue for me. Due to the sauce, I'm unsure if I'll try another pizza on my next visit. But I'll definitely return to reorder WINGS, which are offered in these flavors: traditional Mild, Medium, & Hot; Teriyaki; Lemon Pepper; Hot Garlic; Butter Garlic; Fresh Garlic Parm; & Volcano. The dining room offered just 4 metal tables (due to social distancing). It was sparse, but clean. Napkins were available on each table. At this time, all beverages are in cans & bottles in a floor refrigerator-- see pic. There are NO alcoholic beverages sold here. I wish the owners of this new business well, & I will return to reorder wings, try a burger, & eventually order a pasta, gyros, & a dessert. Still debating if I'll order another pizza. read more

See all

Tried the Pizza House for the 1st time. Ordered an 18' pizza half Hawaiian half pepperoni. We all really enjoyed this pizza! Not too much sauce, not stingy on the toppings! So good we forgot to take a picture. I managed to get at least this one picture of the last two slices left. Check it out! read more

Caprese Pizza House NEW YORK PIZZERIA - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

This has become my family's favorite pizza place!! White pizza is awesome and so is the Hawaiian pizza! Definitely recommend.

Disclaimer: I'm a pizza snob/former New Yorker and am very torn between 3 or 4 stars. My family was in town visiting for Easter and wanted to indulge in some local pizza. This place is new so we decided to support small business and try it out this past week. We ordered two pizzas (a buffalo chicken and a plain pie), garlic knots and I had the large chef salad. The chef salad was ON POINT. Well worth the $8.99 cost for the size they offer and I'd order that again in a heartbeat. The garlic knots were also really good and tasted very close to what I know from back home. The pizza was alright though - seemed somewhat of a pan pizza that you'd find at a chain place like Marco's. Their online ordering is through an app called Slice and the standard time to wait is 30-40 min. Wasn't very busy when I went for pickup so I hope business increases over time. Again, they are new so please give them a chance. Not everyone has the same taste in pizza so this might be the place for you! I'll be back for the salad again. read more

See all

I ordered a supreme pizza and eggplant parmesan sub with no cheese for my wife. The pizza came as ordered and it was very well put together and tasted good. The eggplant parmesan did not come as ordered. The put cheese on it even though I requested that they not. I called back to the store to let them know. After checking to see how the order was placed and that in fact I was correct the guy on the phone kept talking about giving me a discount and never asked if I wanted it remade and to get another one. After advising him that I needed it made correctly he agreed to make another one I could come get it. When I got to the store he gave me the correct sub. No apologies for making it incorrect. I then asked about the discount that he kept insisting that I take vs making me the sub the correct way. He stated that I would not get a discount on a future order even though my wife did not eat with the rest of the family because they messed up her sub the first attempt. The reason that was given was because they remade the sub. I was amused. I advised him that he remade the sub that they didn't make right the first time, he didn't do me any favors in fact it took more time for me to get the sub the second time and my wife didn't eat with the family. It was more of a hassle that was created for us than anything. This was the first time that I have ordered from here. I thought I would give the local store a chance since they are close to the house and I can get there in less than 3 minutes and the menu looked like it had a lot to offer. I only give two stars because the pizza was actually good. I am not sure I will be back. They could have given me as little as a 10% discount for my inconvenience and I would have been happy. But to tell me that there would be none after they insisted that was the route they wanted to go before I told them I needed a new sub and they never apologized for making it incorrectly in the first place. read more

Ordered a cheese pizza, chicken tenders, and garlic knots all were super tasty. Definitely our new local pizza place!

Ordered 2 pizzas, garlic knots and cannolis. The order was delivered in about 40 minutes, everything was hot and very good. Will definitely order again. read more

See all

My favorite pizza in the area. I have tried multiple pies and have never been disappointed. The Greek pizza is a huge hit! They make a great pie! read more

This is my first time here as they opened 5 days ago. I gave them 3 stars in hoping for improvement. I bought a small extra pepperoni pizza and a meatball and cheese sub to take homeI'll start with the pizza. It looked good enough and I even check the underside of the crust to make sure that it was done enough. What it looks like they do is buy premade crust or it is done on racks and never touched the bottom of the oven. In the whole pizza there was not a crisp part anywhere. It's also really bread like. I did not get a pic of the meatball sub as it would not have done it justice. Immediately upon opening the foil I noticed 2 things. One that there was hardly any cheese on the sub but it was not melted all the way. There's plenty of meatballs on the sub but I am also wondering if these are also premade. They had no flavor except the cheese salt, pepper and garlic that I put on it. I ended up throwing half of the sub away. I really hope that they improve as we need a pizza place in that area. read more

See all

Excellent pizzas, very friendly staff, affordable price, definitely recommend! Try their regular pizza with extra cheese

Listen...I ordered a meat lovers pizza with no meatballs and this place DID NOT DISAPPOINT! It was hot and flavorful...the pull from the cheese made my soul smile. 5 stars! read more

Dough feels and tastes frozen... or at least not fresh. For the price I'd expect fresh, risen crust and flavor in the pizza. Won't be back. read more

Ordered the chicken parm pizza with garlic knots and couldn't have been happier. It was delicious! I will definitely be going there again and again. Ordered with the Slice app which was very simple to use. read more

They serve fresh pizzas. I like their pepperoni pizza, spaghetti with meatballs are delicious. I think we should support local business like this and I will return. read more

This is my go to spot for a Friday night pizza in Wesley Chapel. Big fan of their white pizza!

Best kept secret in North Tampa/Wesley Chapel. We have some really solid pizza joints here in Wesley Chapel. The owner is good people and this is the only pizza I crave. Perfect pie so good. read more

Another amazing night of pizza from Caprese! Our favorite pizza place did another amazing job with eight pies. The pizza with bacon is a must try! read more

Good pizza good prices. Went there while staying in Zephyrhills while my dad was away. Ordered a medium pizza the works. Crust was nice and thin the toppings were fresh the woman behind the counter was very sweet and polite. Definitely recommend. read more

The best pizza in the area. They don't skimp on the toppings. We usually get a supreme, Love the red onionsa, my # 1 pizza place now!

I normally don't write reviews, honestly the pizza is good, rest of food is made fresh and I'm taking the time to write a review, because I see people placing criticism that is not accurate. Family is very close to restaurant, literally right behind them. Go often and have never had a bad pie. read more

Have been long awaiting the opening of this place as I drive by it almost daily. We ordered a 16" meat lovers pizza and an order of garlic knots. The pizza: the toppings are pretty good. To me, the crust was a little thin and chewy, but not bad. Sauce is on the sweeter side, which I enjoy. The garlic knots: unfortunately these were not good. They were quite dry and zero garlic could be found. The top was coated in butter, but it didn't make up for the rest of the knot. I'm hoping that since they are just getting started, that they plan to tweak some of their recipes. Plan to try again at a later date and hope to be able to adjust the rating better! read more

Caprese Pizza House NEW YORK PIZZERIA - 16" Meat Lovers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

See all

For opening up during a pandemic, this place is on top of it! Very fair pricing. The dough is fluffy, crispy, and buttery! So good. The staff is very friendly as well. Thank you! read more