This review is about three weeks late but absolutely remains as essential now as it did the night we ate here. Cantinetta Antinori looks like most any Italian restaurant from the outside, albeit with a pretty spacious covered patio. But dig a little deeper past the surface and you quickly realize this place is not your average Italian eatery. For one thing, there are only four of these in the world, and that kind of exclusivity commands major respect in my book. For another thing, the list of "regulars" at this place has to be in the stratosphere as the place is seemingly packed nightly with frequent customers who know a great meal and an even greater atmosphere when they see it. And finally, if it's your first time here, you can count yourself in with the "regulars" as the staff make each and every person who walks through the door feel as welcome as if it was their 500th time dining here.
By this point in our 10-day trip, we were over Viennese food. We asked the concierge at our hotel for a good, non-Viennese recommendation and this place won out. He made us a reservation, which "was a must," and we hiked over in the rain to the place, just a short jaunt away from the St. Stephen's Cathedral. The place was packed, but not too terribly busy, and the warm glow of the orange walls and bright lights made for a welcome sight after nearly drowning in the streets due to a torrential downpour.
We were promptly greeted and taken to our table right in the window. Tables stretch far along the wall opposite an opulent bar, and a dining room opens up near the back of the restaurant. Servers and food runners are courteously making sure no one is left wanting assistance up and down the restaurant, and the owner is a picture of friendliness, going to each table and making sure all customers are enjoying themselves. We picked up on all of this within about two minutes of sitting down, and it only got better from there.
With a bottle of wine ordered, our server kept us on track with food recommendations and answers to the dozens of questions we asked him. We ordered the ravioli as an appetizer and it was a great precursor to the rest of the meal: six big raviolis that melted in our mouths gave way to orders of Tuscan tomato soup that was beyond comforting on a rainy night such as this. We all ordered different entrees, from tortellini with prosciutto to taglioni with veal stew and an order of king prawns. And all of it was delicious. The pastas may take a little while longer than most are used to for preparation, but that's because you can tell the chefs here care about their craft. Trust me: the dishes are worth the wait.
Despite eating enough food to possibly result in a heart attack, there was no way we were going to pass up dessert. Our server recommended a dessert sampler tray that allowed us to try a few different items, and you had better believe these followed in the footsteps of the excellent tastes of the entrees that came before. In fact, the tiramisu would have gotten five stars on its own.
Even if you are not suffering from Viennese food fatigue, Cantinetta Antinori is worth a visit. There is a reason this place is packed with regulars, and you may find yourself wanting to make a repeat visit upon paying your tab. The owner personally thanked us for coming, shook our hands and continued his goal of making everyone feel as welcome as the next guest. Mission accomplished, I would say. read more