I have visited other jewelry stores and left because the service was snooty or cold. Not here! I walked in seeking a jewelry repair. I was greeted warmly without delay. The woman who helped me consulted with someone else before attempting the repair. She did the work in front of me and insisted on cleaning and polishing the piece before I left with it. I also had a great experience bringing my daughter for ear piercing several years ago. The staff at Callahan is kind and patient. I will definitely return again. read more

Callahan Jewelers offers excellent customer service with a truly knowledgeable staff that stands behind everything they sell. Gene helped put a new watchband on my watch and was an absolute pleasure to work with. The entire staff is very friendly and makes you feel like a valued customer from the moment you walk in. I will definitely be back for all of my jewelry needs and highly recommend this store. read more

Callahan's staff are the absolute best! They are soft spoken and very knowledgeable. Importantly, none are pressing you to purchase like I've found in other jewelry store. The store is large with a wonderful assortment of gorgeous jewelry--something for everyone. They also have a section of very reasonably priced previously owned jewelry. They also do an incredible job of fixing all types of jewelry including rosary beads! I highly recommend this terrific local store. read more

I always go get my watches bracelets and all my jewelry fixed. They have such an amazing staff they are always so helpful!

Solid job here for giving piercings (quick and simple for a single or second earring piercing), and clean and painless for the kids. $50 fee for piercings. Deal on jewelry of 30% off of the 14k earrings (little stud versions) that the kids found cute little ones for their first sets (after the piercing ones come out) and good advice on how to clean and you can go back in to get the piercing studs removed (they get jammed in pretty good). read more

See all

I had such a great experience at Callahan Jewelers! I was greeted warmly, and Kamila and Helin were incredibly helpful. They adjusted my bracelet, which needed a little fixing, and did it free of charge. Their service is truly excellent. Highly recommend! read more

This is a go-to place to get any type of jewelry! Staff is friendly, parking lot in the back along with street parking in the front, good prices, they buy precious stones and metal. Showroom is organized and lots of named brands read more

This store is tops in every way . They have wonderful jewelry and gifts , and perform expert repairs . They are professionals in every way . They are extremely knowledgeable , and have the most courteous , friendly , and helpful group of people working there . Gene , the owner , Kamila and the whole staff are top notch . I have done business at Callahan's for 35 years , and it is always a pleasure . read more

When the magnetic clasp wasn't holding, I took a bracelet I received as a gift to the store right before closing on Saturday afternoon. Although the bracelet wasn't purchased at Callahan's, Camilla worked patiently right then and there to reseat the tiny magnet which now works perfectly! This kind of service and attention is so rare these days. Callahan's has a new customer! read more

Rick DeKovessey here, I have been in this very friendly jewelry store a number of times. I have a Timex Indiglow digital watch which is over 20 years old. i wear this time piece everyday and when the day light savings time of year rolls around, I can't change the hour because the setting buttons are clogged and do not allow for the adjustment. Gene (owner) very kindly uses watch maker tools to make the modification, which I could never manage, I have asked him many times over the past few years for help and he always provides this service. I highly recommend The Callahan Jewelry Store for any and all jewelry services. Here come the holidays, I know where I'll be shopping. read more

Popped in this evening at 5:40 with 20 minutes to spare towards closing. Fortunately we were greeted upon entering the business. They assisted us immediately and with their help, we Ended up purchasing two gold chains with gold crosses. We were in need of small giftS for our godson's TOMORROW and we walked into the right place at the right time!! Thanks Callahans for providing such great service, including recommendations, cleaning and wrapping the gifts!! read more

Callahan Jewelers - Jewelry Near Me - Closter, New Jersey

I hold Callahan Jewelers in the highest regard. I have been doing business with Callahan for over 25 years. Gene, the owner/gemologist, is highly skilled in all phases of the jewelry business. His staff is always professional, transparent and willing to help make choices. Excellent customer service! From jewelry purchases, watches, repairs and resetting my old diamonds into new settings, I would highly recommend Callahan Jewelers. read more

I had a great experience at Callahan Jewelers. The staff were very nice and professional. They even cleaned my chain for free which they didn't have to do. read more

The woman who greeted me upon walking in was very kind and helpful. She fixed the two clasps on my new bracelet free of charge on the spot. This was very generous considering the bracelet was a gift and purchased elsewhere. This is not my first visit to this store where I always meet with the utmost of satisfaction . I will definitely be returning due to this exceptional service and their beautiful products. read more

Very good customer service Would recommend if you are looking for some goodvalue jewelry read more

If you value you're fine jewelry, do not have your repairs done here! They took my beautiful engagement ring and ruined it. Instead of using 14k gold as I asked for, they repaired portions of the ring setting with some other metal and then gold plated it. It was 6 months later and I noticed the entire inside of my ring was black and tarnished! Real gold does not turn black! They repaired the ring with fake gold and charged me $350 dollars! Callahan's was deceptive and told me they used 14k gold. Don't trust them! Don't use them! Going forward I will have to have my ring re plated with gold again and again to cover the the cheap metal they filled it with. Very angry and disappointed! I thought Callahan's was a reputable jewelry store - NOT! read more

Callahan Jewelers is sadly not the same. The store is under new ownership and the new owner, Gene is rude and impatient towards his customers and employees. I had a repair done there and they ruined my necklace and said I "brought it in that way" which is completely false! I would not recommended this store to anyone. It's too bad, it used to be a great store. read more

I had an issue with a watch and the staff at Callaghan's were very helpful! I would definitely recommend using them to make any jewelry/watch purchase and/or service. read more

I have used the Callahan's jewelers for many years I have always found the staff to be helpful and knowledgeable.They are pleasant and easy to work with. Kevin W. read more

i popped in yesterday to have my sons link watch band fixed. its an old Seiko from my father that he loves to wear. the woman looked at it for a minute thinking, then went off to work on it for half an hour. she would not take money for her work. I was surprised and delighted. i perused the store and would definitely go back again! Thank you! read more

Top quality jewelry and people! Impressive selection of in stock items. Very sincere and caring staff. My daughter had a costume jewelry necklace and the clasp broke. She loved the necklace so I brought it in and they were so kind. I told them I was embarrassed to waste their time with such a small matter. They were happy to help and said tell your daily it's our treat! read more

Callahan's is the mist professional jewelry store u have ever been in !!!! U came to them with an emergency swollen finger they cut off my ring no charge. Then expertly repaired the ring upping the size . Can't thank them more . This is the only jewelry store our family will use . read more

With eagerness and rave reviews about this neighborhood Jeweler. I went with my my Fiance to discuss the specifications about a ring I recently purchased and was surprisinly met with an unusually high amount of attitude and disrespect from a so called professional Jeweler. The sheer amount of disrespect to my Fiance is disgusting. I have not left a detailed review ever before and it saddens me that this is what unfolded. read more

I am not a steady customer of this jewelry store because I am mostly an online shopper. I bought a necklace over the internet that needed shortening so I stopped by this store on the way from work. I was helped immediately, the necklace was shortened right on the spot and at no charge; all with a smile! Considering that I am not a known face in this establishment I was really surprised. Callahan has a good reputation in our town and they deserve it! read more

Callahan Jewelers has been like a tradition, passed down from my mom to me. It has been my jewelry store of choice for years. The people are pleasant, honest and helpful with above par customer service. I always get my watches resized and batteries replaced here because the price is extremely reasonable. I recently dropped off my MK watch to have the battery replaced. They were having an issue with the screws and asked if they could hold onto it till the person who has more experience would be in. 2 days later I received a call saying that while they were able to replace the battery, but the watch still doesn't seem to be working. They offered to see what the problem was and give a free estimate on fixing it. Next thing I knew I was receiving a call saying my watch was ready. I don't know what was wrong with it, but it was working when I picked it up and all I paid for was the replacement battery. They also have great sales every now and then. I bought a few white gold petite chains from them while on sale because the price was just right. I have also gone to them to sell some of my gold jewelry because I needed some cash before a vacation. What you have to keep in mind when selling gold is that there are different karats (anything lower than 24 k means other metal is mixed in). The higher the karat, the more valuable the gold and the more money you will get for it. I happily walked away with enough cash for my trip! read more

Today I went to Callahan's Jewelers to get my ears pierced. I will definitely be coming back! The employees are super nice and helpful. You should definitely visit Callahan's Jewelers for a piercing or to purchase any jewelry. read more

I've lived in Bergen County all my life, but recently moved to Las Vegas and can't find a jewelers like Callahan Jewelers!! Brian Callahan is one in a million and his staff is superb! Not only do Gene,Maura,Kamila,Maryann, Gino and the other employees welcome you with a big smile, but are quick to ask "How can we help you?". And help they do- whether it be either a pair of sterling silver earrings and necklace or a 14kt white gold diamond necklace and a pair of diamond studs, Callahan Jewelers will find the perfect gift for your friend or even yourself! So, thank you Brian and the crew for treating customers like family. Callahan Jewelers- what more can I say?! read more

BRIDES AND GROOMS DON'T GO HERE. I recently got engaged and I went in with my fiancé to look for men's wedding bands. We're young and we were a little nervous my engagement ring might have been a fake diamond since we purchased it in the NY diamond district so we asked if they could check the certification number inscribed on the diamond to see if it matched the paperwork. The man in charge there started loudly lecturing us on what a diamond is for no reason. ALSO HE WAS SO CARELESS WITH IT. he had the audacity to just carelessly touch the top of the diamond (WHICH YOU'RE NOT SUPPOSED TO DO WITH DIAMONDS) and drop it on the table. I literally got proposed to two days ago and just got this ring. It is so precious to me but the way he embarrassed us for no reason and treated the ring when i still get sad accidentally touching the diamond just almost made me leave in tears. THESE PEOPLE DO NOT CARE ABOUT YOU OR WHAT YOU THINK IS PRECIOUS. I WILL NEVER RECOMMEND THIS PLACE OR COME BACK HERE. My fiancé read the reviews and so many people were saying they don't care about the price and what you're getting because they will treat you with care but what a load of bull. These people are the worst. Also it's hilarious they call themselves professionals when they called my band white gold when it's platinum. If they can't even tell the difference between that and considering how they treat diamonds seriously What a hack. And considering he touched the top of my diamond WHICH YOU ARENT SUPPOSED TO DO. it's scary to think how he treats the jewels he's selling there. Seriously. I used to work in the wedding industry and have worked personally with many many brides and I would never ever recommend my couples to go here where they so obviously do not care about what a purchase like this entails. It is one of the most major purchases and a serious show of love and wanting to do your partner right and these people trample on that sentiment. read more

This is a local business that has been a town tradition in Closter for years. The service and customer attention is something you dont see anymore these days! read more

Callahan Jewelers is the definition of a family-run and family-centered business. They have always been courteous, always have great sales, and always look to help you out and not charge for little repairs or things that other jewelers would take advantage of the customer for. I go in there anytime I need a gift, and always find a great deal on quality items, with kind, respectful, never pushy customer service. They were so kind to me when I went to find something for my grandmother's funeral. I think 4 different people helped me and found sales for me. I would recommend this business to anyone looking for great jewelry at low prices, with quality service. read more

I have been coming to Callahan's since I was young for various things - from having my children's ears pierced to finding the perfect chain for the charm that I wear as a necklace every day. Today I walked in because one prong of my engagement ring was sticking out. They were able to fix it on the spot and did not charge me at all. They even cleaned my ring! I insisted that they take something, and they refused, telling me that it might come loose again and would then need to be replaced and to come see them at that point. I don't visit a jewelry store very often, but when I do, it's Callahan's! I can't recommend Callahan's highly enough! read more

I walked into Callahan Jewelers today and was ignored for a few minutes while two employees finished their conversation. I obviously annoyed one of them with my presence but she got up walked over to the counter and stood there, no smile, no greeting, no "can I help you?" just a sour puss on her face. I then decided to take my business elsewhere and told her a greeting would have been nice to which she replied "well I'm standing right here, tell me what you want". I will NEVER step foot in that place again. read more

Very friendly and proffesional staff, helped me with everything I needed and wanted to look at!