We arrive ten minutes before the closing at 9:50pm and the restaurant welcomed us and rushed two pizzas for us. That was truly amazing as the owner does not enjoy the most gracious sense of hospitality. Read other reviews. But their Server C was the opposite. He accommodated my son and I for a quick in and out late Italian dinner. We had the Classic Pane Rustico and one Margherita Pizza and one All Meat Pizza. Everything we ready in a heartbeat and truly delicious. This was a great experience. I left a 30 percent tip as it was well deserved! The ambiance is always casual low key with a super efficient service. You can indulge yourself with delicious Italian pizzas cooked in two wood-fired brick oven· Their outside patio's offers a warm ambiance perfect for romantic date nights or family-gatherings. read more

See all

I had been running errands and I had not been feeling well for the past couple of days so I thought something simple like pasta with meat in it would hit the spot and be nice and soothing on my tummy. I decided to come here and the service was great, exceptional More on the waiter in a bit. The food came out quick. It was hot and tasty so of course I don't eat much all in one sitting the waiter had brought me a to go box and he brought me some cutlery to go with it. He said just in case I wanted to snack on the way home girls if you're single this guy is a keeper. He is nice looking and mature and those how to take care of a lady you need to come on over here and come have some dinner. The place was clean. The ambience was great. read more

Cafe Italia Cimarron - Sometimes spaghetti is what the Dr ordered! - Italian Near Me - El Paso, Texas

Food was amazing but was pricey for the atmosphere. service was just ok. Definitely one of the best ribeyes in town but $60 is to much in my opinion for a not so fancy restaurant read more

We really enjoyed our meal last night. We had previously ate at Cafe Parisian and our waitress recommended Cafe Italia. I'm so glad she did. We opted to sit outside since it was the perfect night to do so. The pizza was so good and the service was impeccable. We were never rushed, our waiter checked on us regularly and had everything we needed. This is definitely a place we will go back and bring out of town guests to. read more

See all

The service and ambiance were excellent. The pizza was delicious, but I was a bit confused about the appetizer. The menu described toast with goat cheese, prosciutto or salami, pear, honey, and walnuts, but everything was spread all over the plate instead of being on the toast. read more

Cafe Italia Cimarron - Italian Near Me - El Paso, Texas

We ordered two ribeyes and a calzone for pickup. We asked for medium steaks and they came out medium well when we got home. $130.00 plus for two over cooked steaks. Steaks and vegetables were VERY salty. read more

Cafe Italia Cimarron - Container for two ribeyes with an M for medium. - Italian Near Me - El Paso, Texas

See all

Delicious food! I also love the ambiance! The service was decent but I would definitely come back.

1st Jose was able to accomadate our party of 12. It was perfect! Then Fernando, Juan, & Erin gave us excellent service!!!. The food was phenomenal! This was our 1st visit & we had out of town guests. We will definately be returning here. Special shout out to Erin " Luigi" for the special coffee. read more

Cafe Italia Cimarron - Expresso - Italian Near Me - El Paso, Texas

See all

Cafe Italia at Cimarron still makes a fantastic pizza, and the Nutella pastry dessert almost redeemed the evening. Almost. The staff were hustling heroically against an obvious short-staffing, and the atmosphere was cozy, but the real sour note was struck by the owner, who impatiently hurried us through our meal with the charm of a bus conductor. It wasn't a one-off slip, either--this repeat offense confirms the owner's consistent lack of manners. I'd only returned because a visiting friend loves the place, but it's clear the owner remains arrogant, rude, and tragically immature. read more

Changing review to 1 star if I could give it a zero, I would. The owner Daniel is an asshole, we spent over $240.00 and asked us to leave because people were waiting. When I confronted him, he didn't care and showed us the door and all he could say is he understands?????? Even his staff stated that they wish he would stay home and let them do their jobs! So, haven't been here in a while and came to their new location at Cimarron - party of 4 - brought our own bottle because website didn't reflect they offered wine...customer service is excellent!!!! Appetizer was below average for the quantity and the price. Pizzas were out of this world -absolutely delicious! Had the marguerite and the all meat. Next, we tried their spaghetti and meatballs -let's just say chef boyardeish...then, we ordered the shrimp linguini was very good, not spectacular but good! The antipasto salad with pears was absolutely delicious and was a good size, enough for 2 people. Dessert time, we ordered Tiramisu, Nutella calzone and the lemon tarte...the Nutella Calzone is like wow!!! Definitely worth trying! The Tiramisu was good and the lemon tarte cheesecake was very good too! We ended the meal with regular coffee and coffee Americanos, very good!!! All in all, it's worth the experience, stay away from the spaghetti and meatballs! We just spent $200 and was asked to leave because they have people waiting???, read more

Cafe Italia Cimarron - Nutella calzon - Italian Near Me - El Paso, Texas

Pasta, wine and Nutella calzone were always our favorite here, but the oven cooked ribeye just took this place to another level. Perfectly cooked with a crispy outside that preserved the natural juices inside the steak. read more

Cafe Italia Cimarron - The perfect does exist. Ribeye with charred vegetables - Italian Near Me - El Paso, Texas

Friendly staff. Was busy but got seated fairly quickly. Food was great and the service was great. Was hesitant at 1st to go sue to the negative reviews from others but didn't have any bad experience. Will definitely visit again. read more

I was hesitant to go because of the reviews. I didn't want to be rushed through dinner. But it was a lovely experience. We brought our own wine which made it that much nicer. The corkage fee is only $10! I have to say their pizza is hands down the best in El Paso! Lovely thin crust, sauce that tastes homemade and nice ingredients. My only complaint is the antipasti which is a type of charcuterie board. The amount of ingredients aren't portioned well. Too much prosciutto (which was just ok) the pears were Terribly over ripe, yuck! 4 small olives and 7 pieces (and I do mean pieces) of walnuts and goat cheese. It's a bit hard to divide up the items evenly. But the bread is so incredibly delicious and satisfying that you kinda forget about that. I want to go back and try their desserts. It is pricey but I think it's worth it! read more

Recommend ordering to-go or opting for the Mesa location for dining-in. While the food is pretty decent, the restaurant's policy requiring customers to pay/leave within 10-15 minutes after eating just makes this place a 'pass' as a neighborhood favorite. I've dined-in at this location twice, and was disappointed with the customer service both times. The first experience resulted in multiple servers coming to the table every 2-5 minutes to ask if we needed anything else. Normally this would indicate exceptional service and attention to the customer, but we got the feeling they were pushing us to leave. Second visit I was shocked to see an actual sign notifying all customers about their customer policy on leaving after eating. I took a picture of the sign just to show friends, family, and colleagues as this is a bold move in any industry-more so in the competitive El Paso restaurant market. Unfortunately, the pic was lost after damage to my phone. Restaurant owners beware: market analysis from 2023 show inflation outpaced groceries so consumers are going out less and leery about trying new places. However they are willing to spend more $ at the restaurants they do frequent. This mostly impacts mid level restaurants. So unless El Paso is an anomaly, restaurants would do well to assess similar customer service policies. Needless to say, this is NOT a good go-to for me in this neighborhood. But if in a pinch-I may decide to order to-go, or better yet travel to the Mesa location instead for a more positive dining experience. read more

Despite reviews, the owner was extremely kind and attentive to us. The service is also great. The staff is very attentive and is always checking in on you. Some may take this as being rushed but they asked if we were ready to order we said no and they said take your time. I think this place deserves better reviews. Please come and see for yourself. Fresh ingredients and the best pizza you'll find in west Texas read more

See all

Honestly, I don't see why this place has this much negativity. Went with some family, and we loved it! We walk in, and get the roasted vegetables, which came out instantly and were delicious. Then we ordered fettuccine Alfredo, pepperoni, pizza, and a margarita pizza. All three were very good. The service was incredible, very nice people. It was really nice and clean in there. I will definitely be coming back! read more

If you're looking for good pizza then this is the spot! Pizza is freshly made and thin so you don't get as bloated. The appetizer was as fresh and delicious. We even took some to go because even though it's thin it fills you up. We got seated in about 6 minutes on a very busy day. The waitress helped us out a lot by giving us detailed descriptions of the plates. We found out you can also bring in your bottle of wine. An option I saw used commonly that night. The parking is not bad if you don't mind having to put in some steps on busy days. The ambiance inside is very relaxing as well and you could go for a walk on the plaza after you're done. Provecho! read more

Cafe Italia Cimarron - Margherita Pizza and veggie - Italian Near Me - El Paso, Texas

The food, service and ambiance is great. Everything is well seasoned and as close to authentic as you can get here in El Paso. It is also great that it is a bring your own wine place so you aren't being charged huge markups. Go and enjoy. read more

Best margharita pizza I've had in Texas, kind of pricey for what you get but very delicious pizza

My wife and I went to Cafe Italia and it exceeded all expectations. We had two salads and the smoked pizza as well as the bread. The bread was hot out of the oven and delicious. It also came with seasoned butter. The salads were fresh and you could tell the mozzarella on the caprese salad was homemade. The pizza was straight out of the oven. We added mushrooms, which were fresh-not out of a can. The crust was amazing. Service was excellent and food was timed perfectly. Not a huge variety on the menu, but they focus on doing each item well. We will definitely be coming back. read more

See all

Café Italia Cimarron - had Delicious food, and excellent service to say the least. Customers while waiting could order beverages. The draft beer was nice and cold and staff were very friendly. All the plates that we saw go by looked delicious. Our Calzone was fabulous. We'll be back. read more

Cafe Italia Cimarron - Stone oven. - Italian Near Me - El Paso, Texas

I needed a place to eat after visiting my mom in the hospital. I was intrigued by this place after reading the reviews. My "radar" goes off when reviews are split between 1 star and 5 stars. In my experience, when I see this, the low ratings are mainly bogus competitor accounts. So I tried it, and my gosh the best spaghetti and meatballs I've had in a very long time! Everything made fresh. I talked about them to my wife (who wasn't with me) for a couple of days after leaving El Paso. Disregard the very low reviews for this place. Give it a chance. read more

The owner will ask you to leave as soon as possible. You would think that for the prices that this place commands that you should be allowed to stay and rack up a tab. This place is a prime example of how bad leadership can taint an entire organization. read more

This place deserves ZERO stars. The owner Daniel is the MOST arrogant, rude, discourteous, impolite, ignorant and insulting restaurant owner I have ever met in my life. I feel for the staff as they have no other option but to work for this person. I will save you the long story and will give you the very condensed version of how prevalent these 1 star reviews are at the Cimarron location and they all pertain about the same issue. The owner being extremely rude at diners to the point of kicking diners out of his establishment. Daniel...wake up! You are in the service industry and having a servant mentality will completely change you as a person and will turn your business around and bring you so much business and 5 star reviews that you will not know what to do with them. I doubt this will help you. If you want to be treated with a great deal of disrespect and contempt, come by and have some really good brick oven pizzas and roasted vegetables. read more

We went on a Saturday night and as expected, it was busy. Not a problem though. We waited for about 30 minutes to be seated. The table we got was at the very front corner of the restaurant and there was a pole right in the corner on the bench side of the table so we were a little cramped with two people on that side. The tables are very close to each other so we couldn't even move ours much to give us more space. The menu is not very big which isn't always a bad thing. However, I would have liked a little more variety. We ordered pizza, salad and pasta, all which were very good. The only disappointment I had was they only serve beer and wine with a very limited selection, only three wines ($35 a bottle) and 4 beers (one being cider) to choose from. You are allowed to bring your own wine for a $10 corkage fee and we saw several others bringing in their own bottles. Overall, an ok experience but more than likely will not to return. read more

Food and Service was very good definitely would come back. The chicken alfredo was very well seasoned.

The food is great, but be ready to get kicked out 10 minutes after you finish your meal. My recommendation is to avoid this place during peak hours in order to avoid the embarrassment of being kicked out. I hope the owner realizes how he is hurting his business. read more

Had a simple but nice bridal shower there on a Saturday, it was beautiful! The owner and staff were very helpful and very accommodating, even though there is no partition that separates the area, they let us decorate so we had our own section. They even changed their music and played love songs and the bride-to-be was feeling very special. Food was excellent and elegant, French style brunch. Highly recommend this restaurant. read more

See all

Food is completely decent but nowhere near as good as owner thinks it is. They will rush you out within 10 minutes of finishing your meal. Terrible dining experience given the rush. Ardovinos will offer a better overall experience. read more

They are super rude. Restaurant closes at 9:55pm they play music so laud that there is no way you can stay longer to finish your meal, which is ridiculous because yesterday night they offered us coffee and dessert at 9:45, which meant that we only had 10 minutes to finish. We were never warned that they were about to close. Waitress, manager and the owner didn't apologized for it arguing they were closing. I shared this with my friends and they say that this is a regular practice in both restaurants (at Cimarron and at Mesa) So disappointed for this, we will never go back. read more

Amazing! Always a great meal! Been coming here for years. Great service and ambiance.

We are locals and dine here at least once a week. Food is amazing and always consistent. Love everything from the ribeye to the pasta, appetizers and pizza! read more

Food was good once we finally got served. Four tables in the whole place and owner sitting at one of those tables outside. Owners table only table any server is helping with as all the servers are at the bar eating their meals. Once we were able to get a servers attention to take our order, she walked over as she was still wiping her mouth from her meal. Other table of four women waving their arms to get a servers attention to take their order as the servers meals continued uninterrupted. Have heard good things about this place and reason I tried it while I was in town. read more

The pizza was good. Too bad they rush you to get out of the place. We had to finish our dessert and coffee right away because they were anxious for us to leave. They told us that if we were done, we had 5-10 minutes to leave. read more

Don't recommend this place the owner is arrogant and has no customer service skills. Apparently I'm no longer welcomed at any of the café italia restaurants simply because I told him we weren't ready to leave that we were enjoying our last glass of wine. Daniel I hope you read this, you did me a favor I don't ever want to spend a penny on any of your restaurants. To readers stay away from this place unless you like to be rushed out of the restaurant. read more

The food is really good but I don't get this idea they have with rushing you out the door and asking you to leave because there is a wait. It's like your being watched as you take your last bite then there they are trying to clear the table and get you to pay the check. That's the only reason I wouldn't come back here, the food is great, being rushed out is not. read more

For anyone wanting to dine at Café Italia Cimarron, don't. We came in for dinner and waited 40 minutes for our table with no questions or problems. They don't take reservations, it is first come, first served. We were seated, ate our dinner, and were each finishing a glass of wine (only about an hour after we were seated) when the manager came to our table to inform us that a large party was waiting for our table. He asked us how long we would be and we said not long. He pressed us for an actual amount of time so I said 20 minutes. He said absolutely not, you have 5 to 10 minutes. I reminded him that we were paying customers and would not be forced from our table. He left without saying anything. He returned about 10 minutes later to urge us once again away from our table. This time we were fed up and left. Will never eat here again which is so sad because we love eating here. read more

Worst experience being kicked out because we had the nerve to expect to enjoy our wine which we brought to the restaurant. Ridiculous that you can't have enough time to enjoy your meal and wine but are asked to leave to accommodate others. Hey -- we went to Your restaurant during the early days of Covid when no one was there. Shame on you on how you treat good customers. Learn the importance of loyalty and good customer service. read more

Awesome food and awesome service! The restaurant is a little tight on space but overall solid place!

Visited Cafe Italia yesterday for the first time with my family for my birthday and it exceeded our expectations. From the moment you enter and leave the place you are greeted by a nice host. Great ambiance and perfect music selection. Our waiter( Fernando? Not sure if that was his name sorry) was wonderful and went above and beyond to make us feel great and welcomed. We ordered pasta, pizza and the house pear salad which they were all delicious! the draft beer was great too. Not to mention the hot baked bread right out of the oven. I'm glad I didn't come to yelp to look at the reviews before our visit as I see a lot of people complaining about the owner rushing you to get out of the door. Hopefully they heard their customers feedback and hope this is not the case anymore and this is your sign to give this place a try! . Will be definitely coming back! Excellent staff and customer service! My entire family loved this place! read more

Cafe Italia Cimarron - House salad with pear - Italian Near Me - El Paso, Texas

See all