I'm pretty sure the only reason this place is still in business is that underage undergrads from…read moreWesleyan University stream in every Wednesday night to get trashed. On any other night of the week all you find are miserable, beaten down locals who do not want you to be there. The place has the strangest decorations, as if they're trying to be quirky but only know how to be insane. Note that on a Wednesday night you will probably not find a place to sit or indeed to stand without being in physical contact with at least three people under 20 years old. You'll probably have cheap beer from a pitcher spilled on you and you'll probably spend 5 minutes or more trying to push your way through the crowd to get out.

It's a nice dive. The bartender might b drunk, sure. There might b an inch of dust on the veteran…read moreand harley decorations adorning the bar. There might b an insulting bumper sticker or two. The regulars may not b quick to smile. But this place has had its day and every couple years, the students re-discover its magic (and cheap beer) and take it over again. Dont order food, but Go for the experience, don't b quick to judge, and u just might enjoy yourself.

Been going to The Ave for years. They always get it right. Friendly professional service and…read moreamazing food.

We enjoyed a quick dinner while traveling with the family. Services quick, food is very tasty, and…read moreservice with a smile made the kids really happy! We would definitely come back.

Krust never disappoints! I always love their aesthetic, and the vibe at the bar is always super…read morechill. The bartenders and servers have always been super cool and friendly so at a quiet time they are up for a chat. They mix great cocktails and have a fabulous collection of whiskey, as well as a thoughtful and well priced tap list. On this visit we checked out their happy hour which has some great value. It was my birthday so we were splurging a little so we tried the happy hour wings, buffalo Mac and cheese, and two pizzas - an elote special and a sweet and spicy roni. The wings are delicious! Nothing like a standard crispy buffalo wing, rather a delicious roasted wing that's super tender and flavorful. The Mac and cheese was better than I even expected. The cheese sauce was soooo good and their buffalo chicken component was loads of super tender sauced pulled chicken, all topped off with crispy fried onions. It was absolutely killer! The pizzas were good as always with a flavorful, charred crust, and a pleasant hint of a chew. Needless to say, we'll be back soon, as always!

Pizza; Buffalo chicken and the Meat, were great! Wish the pizza wasn't as soggy in the middle…read more Wings were good. Ranch sauce with dill was different. Mac and cheese is good. Wish it had more flavor Drinks were good

Something's going on here. It pains me to nick them two stars. They've changed staff and now the…read morebar is now very unfriendly to all but regulars. The staff used to be so welcoming. Now, the woman (who calls herself the manager) who holds court there must be summoned away from her cadre of regulars just to serve us a drink. She didn't notice us on a recent visit -- had her back to us -- and was told by another customer that we'd arrived. It was a cool place to visit at off-times -- and we could smoke there. The reality is that this place is down on it's luck, and they're doing nothing by way of friendliness at all to make up for the shabby, threadbare furniture or the (*gasp*) bathroom -- the floor now squishes when you walk on it. I was afraid the toilet and I were gonna fall through to the floor below. And forget about the smell. We're going to keep trying, in hopes that we may someday witness it's reincarnation -- or renovation. You may not be so patient.

Wandered in looking for a drink and discovered a great bartender and great patrons! Loved the juke…read morebox machine on the wall - tons of options! We enjoyed their beers including one juicy IPA on tab. Place seems open and friendly to everyone.

I love a moody vibe and Conspiracy is just the right amount of dark and laid back. The entrance is…read morea bit tricky if you're driving by and expecting a big sign but once you're in the door and up the stairs, you're set. I got the pixie eyes which almost reminded me of an aperol spritz just a bit sweeter. The drink came with a banana bread shot which I thought would be strange but it works so well. We sat in the back and things weren't too busy. The staff is cool! Can't wait to come back.

Loved this intimate, 'secret', experience that Conspiracy has to offer!…read more The decor, the lighting, music, is all exceptional. I love the speakeasy vibe that they have very much achieved! Bartenders were great, it was so busy but they handled the rush very well (we barely waited for our drinks to come out, I was impressed!) I ordered the Devil (2024) drink and was very impressed. I will need to revisit for their updated menu this year!

Decent beer selection, however the outdoor area ambiance is what sells this place. The firepits &…read moreseating in the sand is such a vibe. Great for the warmer months when joined by a couple of friends. I am giving this a 3 stars because the last time me & my partner visited we did not get the same welcoming attitudes which we experienced in our previous visits. Another weird vibe I got was when I was ordering another round of beers for both my boyfriend and I -- my order was taken last despite standing/waiting at the bar before other patron's. I was the only woman standing there so I am not sure if this had something to do with it.... Definitely a college bar-type atmosphere. I will say the crispy brussels & spinach and artichoke dip were tasty and cooked very well.

Stopped in for a quick bite and a beer on our way out of town. Beer menu is definitely what…read morebrought us there but the food was surprisingly good as well. The atmosphere is straight up bar but we still felt comfortable with our teens with us. It would have been fine with smaller children too as the restaurant seating is away from the bar area. The beer menu was fairly comprehensive. They have their own brews and have many local CT craft brews on draft. They also have some cans and bottles if that's your thing. I didn't notice any crazy rare lambics but that's not what we were looking for. We had a few hazies and few stouts and everything was delightful. Our server Anna was a seasoned pro. She knew the menu and exactly when to come by our table to check in. We had some pulled pork nachos and there was plenty to go around. The dry rub on the wings was delicious and the wings themselves were cooked right. Overall, if you find yourself in Middletown looking for a nice beer and some decent food, this is a great choice!

It's a friendly neighborhood bar with really good food. We stopped in for a quick lunch of burgers…read moreand they were as usual very good. Got a couple sandwiches to go for others that were also enjoyed.

This turned out to be the go to bar, super close to my house but don't come here asking for any…read moretype of fancy drink. Very basic drinks and food. It all is pretty great though. However every time we go, it is karaoke night.... I'm not sure maybe they have it every night? I thunk they should skip that once in awhile because I'm not a huge fan but I'll still keep coming back.

Super Friendly staff, good food&drinks , I always have a fun time when I go , I love Elmer'sread more

Magic Pizza... I cannot explain why the Pepperoni Pizza is so delicious at this place. I have eaten…read moreat excellent pizza places like Mondo's in Middletown or Square Peg and Pepe's... but the Pizza at Elmers wins, it shouldn't, this is a sports bar after all.... But it does. The staff is infectiously nice, and my glass is never left empty.