It was such a great atmosphere - waitress was adorable and so friendly. Really above and beyond and…read morepersonable. She had the BEST earrings on! We had a few beverages and ended up heading out after that because our friend was a lame no show!

Service was great. Ordered the buffalo wings. Perfect except they were on the cool side of warm…read more(temperature wise). Pizza was average. Beer and atmosphere was really good. Update: fairly certain I got food poisoning. Don't recommend.

I'm visiting again since January and we decided to come back for dinner. New owners I've read and…read moremenu too. There are still some food items that are still being served, like the Shepherd's pie, which I had last time. Service was good, I can't complain. If you like the local bar vibe and comfort food you are coming to the right place. I order the steak fingers, my first time ever with the fry sauce and garlic fries, I was pleasantly surprised that they were quite tasty and a big portion. Yes, I'll be back next time I'm visiting Idaho.

We've given this place two tries now, wanting to be fair before leaving a review, but…read moreunfortunately, both visits left us disappointed. On our most recent visit, I ordered the meatloaf, and my husband had the bangers and mash. The meatloaf tasted more like Salisbury steak, lacking the classic texture and flavor we expected. My husband's dish was equally underwhelming--the sausage had a freezer-burnt taste, and the peas looked the same. Service was a mixed bag. Our waiter was friendly, but the overall experience was confusing. When you walk in, no one acknowledges you. The staff makes eye contact but doesn't greet or guide you, leaving you to guess whether you should seat yourself--without any signage to clarify. We really wanted to love this place, and it has potential. Hopefully, management takes feedback seriously because with some improvements in food quality and customer service, this could be a great spot.

Food is excellent! Chicken tenders are our favorite. The meals are so large we split an order and…read morehave plenty of food! We like to go prior to College of Idaho ball games. Get there early! Fills up fast!

The owner/manager is abusive verbally and mentally to his help. We have witnessed this many times!…read moreHe walks through the place and yells at his help and doesn't care what his patrons see or hear. We WON'T be back for awhile, tired of his ride, pompous ass. There's other restaurants that have more class and manners that this ass!

Fantastic food and service from Amy. My wife and I loved it. Live music beers pizza sportsread more

Fairly average mid-west American food. Beers and Ciders but no hard alcohol as the name may…read moresuggest. They serve hot dogs, burgers, chicken sandwhiches, and more in addition to pizza. The enviorment is loud and very much a bar. Close to the Boise Towne Square Mall which is convenient. Friendly staff and fairly priced.

This place is great! We went here yesterday, for dinner-- it's always busy, because everybody loves…read morethis place-- they have 44 beers on tap, plus a full bar. Love the food- try the ITACATE TACOS!! The shells are made from melted cheese, then stuffed with shredded pork carnitas, avocado, and other delicious things... these are the best damn tacos I've ever had!! Amazing French fries too-- crispy on the outside, tender on the inside. Our server was Kailey. She was kind, friendly, helpful, and attentive.

Very poor performance on the management, I've been going there for the past 2.5 yrs and it concerns…read moreme that having a group of over 10-12 friends after a few hours they cut us off on beers, I understand the safety part of things for a restaurant however we had several group of friends that left and others that took their place in which it made it seem as if we had the same people there, however there were maybe 3 of us in which I came towards the tail end of the first shift. the restaurant decided to cut us completely off from any type of alcohol, as they have every right to do, per the restaurant regulations. with that being said if I ever want to have any kind of of business or celebration type of entertainment I will look elsewhere, the management was very disappointing and very disrespectful in every kind of way on how they just dismissed us in which led us to just walk out with just paying out tab and never want to return, considering we have a lot of friends and family that will no longer use their services..if you have a big group coming in and out and replacing others, THEY WILL CUT YOU OFF!!! Do not support restaurants that don't allow you to contribute to their own business, we would have gladly paid tab and extra... First tab- 170.00 waitress received 90.00 on tip Second tab- 130.00 got cut off.. walked from restaurant paid tab..

Came with a few friends for a late lunch on a Thursday. Wasn't busy at all. With that said, the…read moreservice was very slow. Drink menu is only available via QR code. Not a fan. The beer I wanted they were out of. So I ordered a vodka tonic. Got a vodka soda. Our waiter didn't know any of the drinks on the menu so I wasn't going to take the chance of trying to get it corrected. I got the Shrimp Louie Louie. It was just ok. Had to ask for extra dressing. The salad definitely needed some nuts or croutons for some crunch. I wouldn't order again. I did steal some fries off my friends plates, which were good. Typical sports bar, but underwhelmed with the entire experience. Don't feel the need to return.

I can see why it has a roughly 3.5 star rating. I ate there today and have a mixed review. The…read moreservice was great. The Server took our order promptly and was friendly. Upon receiving the food that's where it went a bit downhill. I ordered the Hawaiian Chicken Sandwich. The flavor was definitely there, but the chicken was drier than the California Mojave Desert. My tater tots were pretty good. I had a bite of wifey's mushroom soup and it tasted like, well, gravy .... Literally. I was like where's the mashed potatoes? Anyhow, it definitely was a mixed experience.

Update: Came here for the second time. It's been about a year. What took so long? Our daughter was…read morewith us this time. Leah was our server and she did an excellent job taking care of us. We were here this evening (Wednesday). The place was busy but not so much that we had to wait for a table, and in fact were seated at a nice booth. It's a little loud, though you can still carry on a conversation. My wife had the salmon dinner. My daughter had the BLT with fries. Both liked their choices. My sampled my daughter's fries and they were pretty crispy and well seasoned. I had to go with what I had last time: the Bee Sting pizza. Love the feta with spicy sausage and honey drizzle. Delicious. My daughter and I had a Hazy IPA, very good. Maybe next time I'll try something different, because most certainly we'll be back.

This didn't quite meet my expectations based on what I had heard about Proof. We went for our…read moreanniversary, and I would say the food was good but not stand out. I felt the $23 Mac & Cheese could have used a pasta that caught more sauce (ie more grooves) and the sauce was a little thick and not saucy and creamy. Perhaps that's personal preference. The appetizers were good but I think the server automatically gave us the larger wing order instead of asking which size we wanted. It was more than 2 people needed at 2lb of wings for an app. The potato skin spring rolls were almost there. They needed deeper color on the fry, and it seemed to only have what felt like mashed potato inside. I appreciated the crisp on the wings - a little heavy on the seasoning on some parts. The server was attentive! No complaints there. I do appreciate however if the timing of the entrees is spaced well to give time to eat the appetizers. This did not happen. Why are the floors so sticky? I may or may not go again. I don't think I'd go to Star from Caldwell just to go. For the price, I expected a higher level of attention to detail.

Service was great. The interior was like an old style 1980s bar vibe. Just stick to the basics when…read moreyou order food here they do not make anything from scratch. It's basically instant potatoes gravy from a packet and free frozen chicken fried steak but their wings and hamburgers are not bad. I can't give it more than two stars only because my meal was pretty terrible.

Today, Quinn's didn't demonstrate a satisfactory outcome. First, despite clearly telling the server…read moremy food/omelette request, it didn't come out as requested. Then, my toast did not come out with my order and the server didn't realize until I brought it to her attention. I'm not a difficult customer, didn't send the omelette back or raise a fuss when I did get the toast. Only thing I can do is write a review. Hope you have a better experience