5 stars the best wings in Chicago by far! Took a bunch of first timers here and they were like what are we doing in the middle of Evanston? Yes the place is run down and dated but you are not here for the ambiance or decor you are here for the delicious wings which they have the best! Everyone in my group was blown away by how delicious the wings were and we all will be back anytime we are visiting Chicago! read more

This spot is such a classic! I have been coming here for many years and always love coming back. Just an FYI that it is cash only. They also have an ATM machine if you don't have cash. Generally this location is usually pretty busy almost every time I have been here. Not too loud, definitely a place where you chill and hang with your friends over some wonderful wings! The food comes out pretty fast though & it's a spot where you can order, eat, and leave in a reasonable time. The wings have gotten a little smaller over the years, but I still come back because it's just so good. My usual order are the spicy wings and waffle fries. Something about the waffle fries that make it so good. I always have to have it. The wings.....you can't stop after a few. It's also addicting and you have to eat another one. Writing this makes me want to go on another road trip to get wings and waffle fries now! read more

(Kari's Rating 8/10) CASH ONLY! Was in the mood for wings and a friend suggested this tiny one hit wonder wing shop and wow did it live to its name. We came all the way from River north and it absolutely exceeded all expectations. It is a cash only so make sure you bring cash! The place let us place our order and then we ran across the street to grab cash. There's not much seating in the front, but they have a larger seating area in the back. They don't necessarily have servers coming around, but if you don't clean up your garbage, someone will pick it up, but please also pick up your own garbage like a normal person. This has to wing ratio was on par. The wings refresh and since they were made to order, they were perfectly coated. Price was relatively fair. Unfortunately, the seats were not very comfortable, but the place was pretty packed when we went. Since it's right on Northwestern's campus, there were a ton of students. We got an order of the mild and the spicy wings, but I think we preferred the spicy. Overall, I probably would come back if I was in the area, but I don't know if I'd make a special trip up there. read more

These are the real deal. The original buffalo wings and the best around! They come with celery and ranch and try the spicy..:or suicide if you dare! We've been coming here for as long as I can remember and I'm so glad they've stood the test of time. Just awesome. They have burgers and other menu items too and be aware that they're cash only. Shout out to Gary, my childhood classmate, who has worked there for 33 years!! read more

I must be crazy, why have I not reviewed this spot because I've been here a million times...whelp better late than never...or I'm just going to go with its right on time for me LOL. My go to order is a double order of spicy with at least 3 orders of buffalo chips so I can eat one bag on the way home. I'm not greedy I'm just being realistic. The seasoning on the waffle cut fries makes the greasy bag irresistible and making sure I have some for the fam by having my own car snack home is a win for everyone. I've ordered single pans and whole pans for parties and their wings are always sooooo good. They are cash only so plan accordingly, otherwise you'll be messing around with their in-house ATM...which may or may not give off mild sketchy vibes. Street parking is available as well as seating. Generally staff is chill and in the years I've been going, haven't had any issues. read more

See all

We thought it was really solid! Called ahead on NYE around 4:15 and was quoted for 5pm pickup. It worked out perfectly with a stop on the way from home. We shared the double order of Spicy Well Done Traditional Wings. That sauce was TASTY let me tell ya. I haven't had wings like this before where they're completely drenched. I personally loved it but my husband wants to do dry next time with sauce on the side. We also want to try suicide in hopes it's still buttery/creamy with more heat. Bring it on because we love the heat. I have to be honest and say I was influenced by Jinabaobina and it was a great rec! Never heard of it prior, don't cancel me. Service was quick and accurate with quote. Welcoming upon walking in and cash only!! read more

Buffalo Joe's - Closeup well done wings - Chicken Wings Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

See all

The wings are awesome. Probably the best I have ever had. Nothing more to say. Not sure about everything thing else. The burger was meh.

Definitely some of my favorite wings of all time. The buffalo sauce and ranch is unmatched. The waffle fries at this location are always cooked well and soooo good! It's a very casual restaurant, so don't expect anything fancy. The staff are not always the most welcoming at the front and when ordering. There is plentiful seating in the back of the restaurant, making it a great spot to enjoy food with friends. We like this location better than the one on Howard for a variety of reasons. Note: They are cash only and there is an ATM. read more

Buffalo Joe's - Chicken Wings Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

Cash only Refried chicken wings Not worthy it Run as fast as you can! STOP REFRYING your chicken wing --food is too high. read more

Pretty good for a local wings place. They take cash only. Has plenty of seating and gives a small diner vibe. We ordered the bbq wings and fries with extra ranch. The ranch is homemade and the waffle fries are well seasoned. The bbq wings taste good too but are small. Also the workers were sweating behind the counter and touching their face/arms and then handling the food without gloves. Overall, I liked the food and would still go again. read more

Buffalo Joe's - smol bbq wings - Chicken Wings Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

See all

Best wings in Chicago Wide variety of other excellent fast food Wonderful staff Great burgers read more

Hands down the best buffalo wings - anywhere. Best sauce, perfect size wings and their waffle fries are outstanding. The mild sauce is perfect - not to spicy and just right amount on the wings. Been coming here for over 30yrs and hasn't changed per the quality. Same smiling faces when entering! read more

First time trying this place it's not bad, but it cannot beat the one on Howard , chicken not enough sauce or the flavor is downside with water.... The ranch seems like they add extra water to dilute to make up to accommodate for more I'm guessing. I wouldn't say the food isn't bad , but it isn't as tasty. The one in Howard taste better maybe because longer cook time where the sauce can sink in more into the meat and also the ranch has more texture and thickness to it. read more

I didn't enjoy it the first time and I didn't enjoy it the second time. I understand why it might be a staple for local college kids, but everyone else should probably stay away. I ordered spicy wings with waffle fries and an RC. The place is very dirty inside and smells like a bathroom. The fries are flavorless. The wings are small but the flavor is okay. RC products generally aren't that great. I really wanted to live this famous dive. The servers were friendly but it's cash only which is inconvenient in this day and age. read more

Buffalo Joe's - Wings and fries - Chicken Wings Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

Prices going up but wings about have stayed the same over 30 years.. quality is good but I'd like a few more wingers read more

Buffalo Joe's - Chicken Wings Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

See all

Easily one of the best places for wings in the Chicago area. I would recommend getting an order of spicy wings. The sauce is flavorful and buttery. It is a popular spot, so I would recommend ordering ahead so you don't have to wait as long. It is unfortunately cash only. read more

Best wings in Chicago hands down. I always order the double suicide wings and it conquers from Wisconsin to Florida (currently in Tallahassee) and I desperately miss the tender snap of their wings. Buffalo Joe's is a standard for the nation. I only wish they offered blue cheese and habaneros for the bold. read more

I always buy boneless chicken buffalo style. Excellent, I just don't go there often because they don't take cash they kind of force you to use their ATM. Sooooo inconvenient The staff at my hospital chose not to go there because of that read more

Buffalo Joe's is considered a Evanson institution by many of my friends that went to Northwestern. though it sits a bit off campus in the business district .it does seem to get a big crowd from both staff members and locals as well as students.. most people tend to order a single order of wings, which get you about 12 wings and their sauces, unusually sweet and buttery. I went during lunchtime but I can see this being a popular late night institution: #buffalowings #evanston #cashonly read more

Buffalo Joe's - Chicken Wings Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

I think this place is just alright. I did like the waffle fries and that you get a nice healthy serving of celery with your wings, but I found the sauce on the wings too sweet for my liking. I did get mild so maybe they'd be less sweet if I got a spicier sauce? read more

Used to love this place. Completely down the tubes, I think, based on two recent visits. Burgers were sad. Fries were sadder still. Tables were dirty. Counter guys were surly. read more

If you know you know...Buffalo Joe's is ALWAYS a stop when we visit. We have taken our friends here when they visited and they have nonstop talked about this place. Their sauce just hits different. They are cash only and don't expect amazing service. I don't care for their attitudes, but I usually do take out anyways so it's a quick in and out. You get what you get here lol. read more

Buffalo Joe's - Single Order - Chicken Wings Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

My go to wing place when I'm always in town. Other wing restaurants don't do justice like buff Joe's wings especially their suicide sauce.

A friend of mind introduced me Buffalo Joes! I have to say I am highly happy that he did. Let me get into it! Food: Hands down the best chicken wings! The flavor and the freshness was great! Each time I have come I always feel satisfied. Service: The speed of how quickly the food comes out and how the cashier is very chatty and how they walk you thought the menu is great. Atmosphere: Or ambiance like I call it, the decor really matched the shop vibe! I really like walking in as it makes me feel I am going back in time. Overall, I would visit Buffalo Joes any time I am in the area. I love the food and how friendly everyone is. read more

Buffalo Joe's - Chicken Wings Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

Took a nostalgia trip back to Buff Joes, and I it was like nothing changed. Went for the spicy wings, just like I remembered. Waffle fries were perfectly crispy with just a little too much salt like always. Same weird pictures on the walls. Plus the only place that is keeping RC cola still in business (Gut Buster is a drink size). Glad to see this treasure from my Northwestern days made it through. Plus the prices haven't gone up that much either, the only affordable place still in Evanston for college students. They got my boyfriend's burger a bit wrong, but that might because he doesn't speak Chicago or Buff Joes. He still enjoyed it. Never change Buff Joes, you're the future-nostalgia a college student needs. read more

Buffalo Joe's - Spicy wings and Buffalo Chips with a Gutbuster RC - Chicken Wings Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

Buffalo Joes in Evanston! We heard nothing but amazing reviews about this place so we went to go check it out! Be warned you will have to wait 30 minutes to an hour if they're busy like we did! The wings were good, they had great flavor and were yummy, they were just tiny! Definitely can't be too hungry when coming here unless you want to spend money that's our recommendation! read more

Buffalo Joe's - Chicken Wings Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

See all

Went there because I heard good things. The wings were average at best, the cheese fries were not good at all and the beer was warm. Cash only and not worth the price. read more

Buffalo Joe's - Chicken Wings Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

Best wings of all of Illinois I've ever tried and I still say they are the best wings I've ever tried hands down in America. Wish they had more places. Evanston Illinois is a far ride for me. But awesome wings best ever!!!! read more

Been going here since the Mid 80's. Best wings ever and a huge fan, Only complaint ever would be that a larger wing size would be appreciated. read more

I thought it was pretty good. It's been awhile since I've been to any Buffalo Joe's and I don't think I've been to this one. This is a low down greasy wing place which isn't a criticism. It's true homemade wings and sauce. While o think it's a little on the expensive side, you do get a pretty generous order of wings. I thought their spicy was going to be hotter. I guess I need to try the suicide flavor. The biggest surprise were the waffle fries. Nice and crunchy with some seasoning (pepper?). Complemented the wings and was awesome dipped in said sauce. While people have complained about the service, they treated me quite well, especially since I didn't know what I was doing. The woman who took my order was so helpful! Sometimes you just want wings. This is the place for some down and dirty wings made with love. I'll probably be back, but you gotta bring cash! read more

My favorite wings around. I found this place in college and I've been going here ever since. Whenever I'm in the chicagoland area I make sure to hit this place up. There is nothing magical about the restaurant except for the wings. The restaurant itself is just a walk in storefront. Food is walk up to order. A few places to sit in the back. Service is simple.. not much. Wings are awesome. Several different spice levels. Full of vinegar goodness. I love these wings. Give this place a try if you love wings! read more

I used to love Buffjoes in my teens and 20's, I think it was maybe 10 years or more since I last had it. And I gotta say, it has not changed at all. The suicide sauce is still FUEGO. The suicide sauce has my heart. It's not that spicy, but has all the flava. And cheddar chips are a necessity. The inside has not changed in the last 20 years. You order at one end of the counter, then wait for your food. Once your food's ready, pay at the register. Grab an oatmeal chocochip cookie if you can! Parking in the area is usually not too difficult. Oh and bring cash! They're cash only, but they do have an atm inside. read more

Buffalo Joe's - Suicide only - Chicken Wings Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

This is a home town staple. Hubby and I go to Chicago twice a year from California. When we were looking for some thing to eat, my husband said how about Buffalo Joe's. As I looked at him, he says I am drooling right now. Just thinking about it. So we went. It wasn't as busy as we anticipated but the surprising thing is one of the workers was still there, a bit older, he's been around since I was working in a salon in downtown Evanston many moons ago. We ordered a double order, medium spice with a side of cheddar chips. It was really really good and just brought back memories from high school. However, since I am 25 years older, I definitely felt the heartburn the next day. Though the memories are still fresh in my mind my stomach lining is definitely a lot older. Great place to be. read more

See all

Cheese sauce was gritty and ruined the fries. Wings were average. Ranch was good. .

I just came back to buff joes after a several year hiatus. Wings: top notch. Excellent. Worth the long wait time. Freshly fried, tender, juicy and super flavorful. Fries: waffle fries. Can get with or without cheese. Cheese sauce is super thick - maybe not in a good way lol. Service: quick, not especially friendly, though the food more than makes up for it! Cash only. Long wait times. Ambience: worn out interior. Tables with benches. Avoid sitting too close to the restrooms as the cleaning solution scent is off putting. read more

Buffalo Joe's - Wings and fries - Chicken Wings Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

See all

I used to be a Buffalo Joe's aficionado but sorry to say, they have gone down in quality. First, they dry their wings ahead of time and when you place an order, they refry them to which makes them very hard to eat. I ordered a single order BBQ and the wings were very chewy and puny may I add. Nothing like I used eat; the wings were plump and plentiful. Second, the price does not match the quantity. I paid almost $15 for 12 nasty pieces. I guess those college kids will eat anything. I know Buffalo Joe's is a staple but I don't know how they stay in business. I will stick with Buffalo Wild Wings as their wings aren't fried twice and you can sink your teeth in. read more

With my boyfriend claiming his last meal on Earth would be Buffalo Joe's, I had high expectations for this joint. And Buff Joe's delivered! Definitely my favorite buffalo flavored meal, since their sauce isn't crazy strong and has more of a cheesy flavor. The chicken patty is fried with a thin coating and not a crunchy (or soggy but thick) shell of batter, doused in the sauce, and perched on a bed of lettuce and tomatoes. The hamburger bun is nothing special, so all the magic was the chicken and the sauce! I think taking the tomatoes out helps you taste more of the flavor but that's just me (and everyone else in my group)! The the meat was tender and so, so good. The fries were ahhhh-mazing. Even though the waffle fries really crispy at all, the salt and pepper seasoning combo was addicting! Definitely not the healthiest choice, but a combo of their sandwich and seasoned fries is definitely a new favorite of mine :D they also have a bunch of other items like award-winning chili-- check them out for some Om nom noms! read more

Buffalo Joe's - Buffalo chicken sandwich + waffle fries-- you can buy tubs of sauce on the side! Fries are seasoned deliciously! - Chicken Wings Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

Very good wings a little on the small side but really good. I also love the seasoned fries my only complaint is the wings are on the small side and sometimes they put broken pieces in there with no meat. The service is really good though quick and efficient And I think it would be a good sit down restaurant to have dinner in read more

I've been coming here since I was a little kid and honestly it's the place to go for wings! They have other menu items, but really most people get the wings. I most recently ordered both mild and spicy and loved both. The sauce doesn't have a super vinegary flavor like some places and it is well balanced. Even the spicy wasn't too spicy for me. The chips aka fries pair nicely with the wings. The wings themselves are on the smaller side and fried to perfection. Nice and crispy. The celery came with them and it was a nice palate cleanser. Don't expect much from the interior here, but come for some of the best wings. It is cash only. read more

Buffalo Joe's - Chicken Wings Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

Haven't been here in over a year. Street parking only. Went around 7pm Wednesday they had a few spots right in front. It's cash only they have a atm inside. The place could use a remodel. The men's bathroom was out of order with a strong sewer smell coming out of it. Good and quick service. We ordered buffalo chips and double order spicy (wings). Sauce taste great as usual but the wings were on the small side compared to last time. The Buffalo sauce just taste so good. I'll be back! read more

Buffalo Joe's - Chicken Wings Near Me - Evanston, Illinois