The store is in the hot of Andersonville and the staff are friendly and fun to talk with. Depending on the fashion of today, they will give you either money for your clothes in cash or store credit which will be a lot more. So bring your stuff in good and washed condition because that will help your situation And see what you can get for the things that you don't want anymore. read more

See all

The store is always well organized, with racks full of trendy, vintage, and unique pieces that cater to every style and budget. The quality of the clothing and accessories is impressive -- everything feels carefully selected and in great condition. Whether you're looking for something bold and expressive or just want to refresh your wardrobe sustainably, you're almost guaranteed to find a hidden gem here. The atmosphere is upbeat and creative, making every visit feel like a mini fashion treasure hunt. read more

I had a good experience here selling clothes. I got the app and joined the queue on the app so I didn't have to wait in store. I would figure recommend doing the same so that you don't have to wait too long. I felt like their prices were fair but seems like they don't take H&M items even if they are on trend. read more

Workers were totally racist towards me and rude. I won't ever sell my nice clothes here again.

Great staff! Huge selection! Super friendly people (shoppers and staff) Overall great experience ! read more

Buffalo Exchange - Buffalo exchange - Used, Vintage & Consignment Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

My wife and I came here, as we have shopped buffalo exchanges in other states. This location was very busy. A lot of people standing around and pushing their ways through the aisles. Have good items, but of course, they are pretty pricey. I found some name brand items like adidas and Nike, but they were overpriced. My wife found some clothing that she ended up buying some shirts. The fitting rooms were always busy, but to be expected. Overall, one of the better locations I've shopped. read more

Buffalo Exchange - Used, Vintage & Consignment Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Very friendly staff. Works quickly and efficiently. Honestly appreciated their openness about what items they bought vs didn't. Cash paid was fair enough for the effort to sell there. I would go back read more

Really great selection of clothes, shoes, and bags. If you find a shirt from target you'll find it a tad overpriced but I've found some great brands at a good price. I found a genuine commes de garçon shirt for like $15 and have found lots of Columbia and other great outdoor brands. read more

Buffalo Exchange - T-shirt bought at Buffalo Exchange - Used, Vintage & Consignment Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

If you're looking to sell here it is one of the better options I've found in the area, but they only took 3 things out of more than 20 pieces that I took. All the stuff I took was winter and 90% of it was new. In terms of selection there are some trendy items but not very high quality. read more

Quite possibly one of the hippest thrift stores in Andersonville. The youngins flock and shop because cool kids know where it's at. The inventory quality is on point and is put together in such a way to strike a certain vibe that resonates and keeps em coming back. I have to admit, I've been in the store maybe three times total and have tried on a pair of shoes that have caught my eye at least two of those times so you kind of dig where I am coming from on this. I have yet to buy anything, but then I am not their core demographic either. My college age daughter has and she was digging it. If you are in Andersonville, stop in and give them a look. read more

Maxim is amazing! Ask for help with styling or anything. Best selection of high quality merchandise and expert fashion sense in the Chicago area. Great atmosphere! Highly recommended. read more

Updating my review after a few more trips here, both buying and selling. While I still like this location for both, I've been noticing more and more how inconsistent they are with what they take. It truly just depends on who is working the selling counter when you're there. Almost all of my clothing is high quality, in good condition, and trendy/seasonally appropriate. Some employees there will buy almost everything I bring in, while others are incredibly picky and will buy 1 or 2 items in a bag full of nice things. I've had an item rejected by one employee, and then I bring it back a week later and another takes it. It's often luck of the draw on who handles your sell vs the quality of items you bring in, it seems. I do find some good pieces at reasonable prices when shopping here, but the layout of the store makes it SO cramped. They need to allow more space by the door and the checkout area. Half the time there are legitimately no exit paths between racks when I attempt to leave, and I have to push my way through. It's definitely hit or miss here, but it's still better than a lot of secondhand stores. read more

They are just overly picky about what they take! You are only paying me a freaking 1$ or two anyway for a shirt. Take the shirt that still has a TAG ! Crazy read more

This is one of my favorite thrift stores in Chicago. The organization, the helpful staff, the selection and style of items... What more could thrifters want?! Also, the music and aura when you walk in is a vibe. Happy finding. read more

Super friendly staff. Be sure to make an appointment to sell clothing. I believe the max is 30 items per appointment. Store is very clean and clutter free read more

Buffalo Exchange - Used, Vintage & Consignment Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

So Buffalo Exchange is always a fun spot and I feel like this location is really nice! It's a little roomier than the one in wicker park, and it hasn't been too crowded the times I've been in there. In the last few months I have purchased such treasures as: -a Garfield cutoff sweatshirt -a Selena Gomez concert T-shirt -a bridesmaid dress for my bff wedding -a modern, minimalist necklace -a 70s turtleneck sweater sans sleeves As far as selling: the key to successfully selling for me personally is to sell things you're a litttttle sad to part with. The old stuff that you're like "yes ew get this OUT of my life" never really sells well. But the things that you KNOW are truly special and nice are the ones they will maybe buy. Listen to your heart. You know what they are. Also, always check the men's T-shirt section!!!! Treasures. read more

Great selection, pricy 4 a thrift shop, I went in to buy a special outfit for a night and the staff went above&beyond to help me - Alo (?) and a gentleman with glasses who's name starts with G are incredible and I hope they're both going into fashion :) Will be back again, and again the staff are amazing read more

O my goooooshhhh!!!! So happy this place opened, it is amazing!!!! Great selection of clothes AND accessories. High quality and unique pieces-- I will be going back again and again! read more

Quite possibly my favorite hidden gem in Chicago. Everybody constantly is upbeat and looking to improve your experience shopping there. A cool place to find unique things and also unique people! They always make an effort to talk to you and seem to genuinely care about you as a customer. I recommend this store to anybody who needs to shop! read more

I will NEVER set foot in this place ever again. Even Crossroads bought more of my stuff. I brought in good brands in good condition. Approx. dozen and a half men's shirts and a few pants - the pants I didn't expect them to buy anyway - knowing I would just walk them up to the Brown Elephant. They bought 2 pairs of sneakers and a pair of pants. That's it. As the "Buyer" was looking over my my stuff - I looked over their stuff & except for a few pair of sneakers - the place had junk - at least in men's. Good Luck. I've seen a lot of shops come and go in Andersonville over the years - so we'll see what happens. read more

Let me preface by saying I have 4 years of retail experience. I know the ins and outs of what it's like to work retail, and normally I don't write bad reviews because people have bad days. I have had GREAT experiences here in the past. Typically, the employees are friendly and welcoming. However, I went in looking to sell some clothes and one of the workers there was AWFUL. First of all, they were whispering into their coworkers ear a couple minutes after I came in which made me very uncomfortable, it felt like they were talking about me. The store was very crowded so I decided to stay up front and out of everyone's way. I wish I hadn't. The person I am talking about (heavy eyeliner, don't know their name or pronouns) picked up a sweater I had in a bag and faked gagged. They then threw the sweater back into the bag and forced it all the way to the bottom. THEN they whispered to their other coworker, who was the main person looking through my clothing. I walked out of the store and started crying. I have not had someone make me feel that bad about myself since high school. Would NOT recommend coming here (to sell or buy). Brown Elephant is right down the street, it is cheaper, a better thrift store, and a way better environment. I have never walked out of there crying! read more

Buffalo Exchange in Andersonville is the newly opened second location of the buy-sell-trade clothing chain in Chicago! Although I like looking through the one on Milwakuee Ave., it can be hard to shop because of the tight space. This store is spacious and easy to navigate. I went in on a weekday afternoon to sell for the first time, and one person was ahead of me, and it ended up being about a 15 minute wait. I checked out a few racks while waiting, and the styles I saw were a mix of vintage revival and trendy fashion, which lends itself to fast fashion. All the associates were friendly, but I wasn't surprised when the buyer couldn't find anything to buy from me since I had minimalistic and preppy styles in my bag. They are buying pieces with for a certain look in this store, and it didn't offend me that I didn't have items that fit into that. To that end, it's a place where you can put together creative outfits with fun patterned tops, funky colored bottoms, etc. read more

i always find good stuff here and i rlly like the atmosphere. kinda pricy for a thrift store but at least the employees are rlly nice !!!

I went to Buffalo Exchange to trade in some old clothes and to shop for some new ones. The person who looked over my clothes was really nice and explained to me why some clothes she accepted and others she didn't. She didn't accept all of my clothes, but I still got quite a bit of credit for the clothes that they did accept. I liked how you could get store credit or cash from the traded in clothes. The clothes in the store were in good condition and I ended up finding a lot of items that I liked. The place was very well organized and everyone who worked there was so nice and helpful. I would recommend if people are looking for a more budget friendly and sustainable way to follow fashion trends. read more

Yay! So happy this location opened. I don't typically have the energy or time to go to a true thrift store so I rely on buffalo exchange. This place had exactly what I went in looking for - short overalls, urban outfitters, for $15. Perfect. The store has enough room - even on a Thursday evening it was not very busy and comfortable to browse. Still saw several Target items for sale which is a bummer, but I also saw some really nice upscale brands. read more

Recently visited this store to buy and sell some clothes. Had a wonderful experience. The store is clean and organized with a friendly staff. Selections and styles were varied but up to date and fun. Selling process was easy and was able to use trade-in value to get some great clothes. Great store in a great neighborhood, will return. read more

this place is trendy and has some good clothes. i found yeezys, several pairs of doc martins, a kenzo sweater, a moschino tee, a superdry jacket and a pleasures tee. lots of cool graphic tees in the men's section. there's a lot to choose from; each rack is packed with clothes. the person working there had a GREAT outfit btw. read more