Hit or miss. Sadly it's not consistent enough for us to make it our go to spot. I've had great pies here and other days we didn't like it..Same goes for their apps read more

This place is a hidden gem. Delicious pasta, nice and hot and fancy. It took a while, but was steaming hot. It was a bad location for the quality. The service was fast. The bread is SOOO good. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Mushroom pasta - Pizza Near Me - Rock Hill, South Carolina

I'm in love with this place, and I don't even like pizzas. I find myself dreaming about it when I'm craving. Located in a small strip mall. They're tucked away next to a bar. Their thin pizza is sooo good, slightly crispy and come out piping hot. Like boiling hot. The cheese just stringing along when you take a bite. Everything was balance just right. Amount of cheese to the sauce, toppings all just come together. Every time I visit my friends in Rock Hill, I demand that they order pizzas from here. I have drove from Charlotte to Rock Hill to get to this for pizza. The young lady who took our order was very pleasant and I get to meet the man who perfect the rolling of the thin pizza. I'm a happy chick. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Half eaten garlic Garlic Knots, pepperoni/ Sausage and Peppers , Onion's pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Rock Hill, South Carolina

I am truly confused how any business can continue to keep there doors open with Rude staff and poor quality food. The place is dirty and needs a good cleaning. I am sure the lazy staff won't do it as they cannot even great you as you enter and approach the counter to order. My pizza was way too oily, soggy and the outer crust was burned. I suppose this is another business which survives on new customers as I have difficulty believing people return here (maybe a few with very low standards). We will not be back and I will certainly inform my friends, family and pretty much anyone I come in contact with to avoid this place. Does anyone find it interesting the staff are rude and owners/Managers refuse correct to make their mistakes? No love goes into this pizza. You really should remove "Brooklyn" from the name because I know that Brooklyn people care about their pizza! read more

Adding to a previous review... This joint has potential. I like the cheese slice for a midday snack. Not sure how a whole pie would travel (for sure "not cut" and slide it in the oven to crisp up at home. I'd like them to switch to the smaller cupped pepperoni. Dough could use a little work to improve the flop. Heck, how about you just do it like Scarr's in NYC. Wouldn't that be great!?!? read more

I have always loved the food here. I'm not sure what a lot of these reviews are with negative feedback. It's not a fine sit down place. You call your pizza in and pick up a pie that is way better than anything in town. On the way home you down the jalapeño poppers you didn't tell your wife about and then enjoy the pizza at home with your family. They are great people in there. read more

Real pizza from real Brooklynites! Leo and his team are phenomenal. If you want to try real New York pizza, make sure to stop by and grab yourself a slice! read more

Best pizza I've had so far in rock hill. Always looking for other places with good pizza but this will be my go to when we order out. Pizza is New York style. Small shop and a little expensive but it seems all pizza prices are up now. Definitely recommend! read more

worst pizza I've ever had, must have been served the leftover pizza from the per slice pizza for lunch because it was cold and discolored. The people working there were nice but so disappointed in the product. attached are pictures of what I ordered and what I got. Definitely cut Corners read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rock Hill, South Carolina

See all

I was in the mood for pizza tonight. Something a bit different I am so glad with my choice; Hawaiian Pizza. I've never had anything from this place that I didn't like. read more

See all

Idk... I've been 4 times now. The slices aren't bad, but it takes around 20-30 minutes to get them even if you order in advance. The customer service is perfunctory at best. The meatball calzone I had was not good at all, soggy, and didn't even contain one full meatball, per my conversation with whomever I spoke to upon calling and asking about it. It would have been better if it had been properly filled, but it was already lacking in flavor. If I'm close and craving a slice, I''ll consider stopping, but otherwise I don't think I'll keep exploring the menu. read more

Several choices at the counter for pizza slices. Thin crust, like NY pizza. Grandma pizza is delicious!

My husband and I ordered a cheese pizza for a quick dinner on a Saturday night. When we got home and opened the box we noticed half of the pieces were burnt. It was dry and just awful. I am just thankful we did't have guests we were serving it to. It was bad enough that we bought it. Truly awful! read more

We ordered a regular cheese, wings (6 mild, 6 hot), garlic knots, and a Stromboli. The pizza and Stromboli were very good, but we are sure it would be better eating in house as food is always best that way. We hope this pizza joint does well, since they've been open for a roughly a year. We'll be back. read more

These guys make some good pizza. North jersey native thumbs up, they do a delicious grandmas pie too if you're familiar. Dough and crust good flavor/crisp. read more

See all

Chicken pizza was on point. The sauce had an even taste across the entire pizza. Crust was excellent. Grammas pizza was very good. I travel an hour each way for the pizza. Try the cannoli and the tiramisu for dessert. This is New York pizza. read more

My family is in love with this pizza! My husband and I, retirees, are working outdoors all the time. Every time we finish outdoor work, my husband looks at me and knows what I want after hard outdoor work. We are a pizza family, try all the closest pizzerias around the York area. Born and raised in Brooklyn, been waiting to find a good pizza in the South. This is it! This is the real thing!!!! Now my sons from California and FT. Bliss TX., come home to visit, and this is the first place they want to visit. Family from Connecticut, Michigan, Charleston, Georgia., this is now the first place they want to get eats from! If you come to town and need a good place to eat and a really good pizza. You need to go and try this place is a must !!!!!!!!! The people are from Brooklyn, and the ambiance is friendly and real !! I hope they never go anywhere ! Except to open a new location closer to us in the York area zip code 29745 read more

Very bland crust, no flavor. Canned mushrooms, the whole pizza just tasted very bland, wings were ok. Was hoping for a good experience, continuing moving forward on looking for a new pizza spot in Rock Hill. I've heard Off The Tracks has amazing pizza so trying that next read more

My hubby and I wanted to love this their pizza. It is not greasy like the kind of central NY state pizza we are used to. Not enough sauce and needed more cheese. The crust on our pizza was tough. I will give them 5 stars for speed of service. read more

I drive for DoorDash and had an order to pick up from there and the gps didn't have the correct location for the address so I called the location and a man answered the phone and was REAL rude and said "put the address in Google maps and find it!" And hung up. So I called back and the same man answered and I asked to speak to the manager and he claimed to be the manager. So I told him he was a Piss poor excuse for a manager. He says what are you gonna do about it?" And hung up again. I finally found the location and sent my father inside as I was beyond pissed, so he goes in for the order and the manager asked did he call twice and he said "my daughter did" and the manager says "I'm not giving you the order out to you. Get another driver to pick this order up" WTF??? This "manager" is now Messing with MY money. The food might be good but I won't know that because the manager is the first impression of the restaurant and I'm not impressed. If I could give Zero stars I would because that's what it deserves read more

Brooklyn Pizza - The flooring - Pizza Near Me - Rock Hill, South Carolina

The pizza is alright. It is a bit thinner and not so much cheese than what I am used to. I read the reviews and people rave about it but it's not anything to write home about. Extra large was a good size pizza. read more

These guys are great..Simple, no frills, real NY Pizza. .Fresh pies! Awesome slice deals, this is the real deal....hope Rock Hill supports these guy, really a great addition to the area. read more

Best pie in town. Foldable with a crispy crust. Sooo good I get two slices and a whole pie to go weekly. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - 1 slice pepperoni 1 slice all meat. - Pizza Near Me - Rock Hill, South Carolina

Burnt, soggy and bad. Taste was bland and bottom crust burnt. Do not get this pizza !! I would not recommend this at all.

First time ordering here and will be back for sure. Love it when you want to support local and it turns out they have some of the best food in town! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Grandma's pie Large Grandma Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rock Hill, South Carolina

See all

Haven't even gotten our food, ordered an hour ago. Sitting here waiting for our food. Given a 25 minute timeframe when ordered. I don't even care how the food tastes at this point, this is the worst service ever. Don't recommend at all!!! read more

Some of the best pizza in the area! I will be back. Grand ma style was really good! I like the thin crust also!

When you want pizza for 23.00 you expect a really good pizza. Well for 23.00 got a pizza that was burnt on the bottom. Called them to tell them i have received a burnt pizza and all they could so was "SORRY". Well to say the least this will be the last time. read more

The grandmas pizza is trash! This place is so over rated it's sad,if you like ya pizza burnt at the bottom this is the place for you. Customer service is awful at best. I've only been here 4times and each time it gets worst. The last 2 times I've called in my order and when i get there it's a completely different price. Only reason I'm giving it a 2 star is bc the toppings were good since that's the only part i could actually ingest. read more

Last visit the pie was not too good, it might have been a different cook, the mushrooms were canned mushrooms, completely different taste from fresh mushrooms. read more

Worth every slice! Really enjoy a quick slice from these business. Always a welcoming smile, hello, and a quick thanks for the business!