A pretty decent slice for people who prefer a cheesier pizza. However, the abundance of cheese does make Broadway Slice a greasy one, so you'll probably want to dab it with a napkin to remove the excess oil. The cheese was fairly salty and very gooey; there's no need to order extra cheese from these guys. The crust was very tasty and had a nice crunch to it. The sauce was on the tangier side which is how I personally like it. I ordered delivery and it arrived pretty quickly and still hot. I've put Broadway Slice on my list of go-tos for pizza when I'm having a lazy day at home. I'm glad that WaHi has some decent choices now. read more

Broadway Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

The app says price $28 for family meal number two than when you call they say $35 when they come to deliver they said they told me it's $ 41 crazy how they charge people service sucks read more

I've been wanting to try this place for a while so decided to take the chance after craving Alfredo Pasta all day. Unfortunately, I was disappointed with my dish. When I opened it, it had an off smell to it. I took 2 bites and decided the throw the whole dish away - it was that bad. Unsure if the pizza or other dishes are any better but I'm weary to try this place again. I will say that the staff is nice though! No complaints there. read more

Broadway Slice - Pasta Alfredo - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Pizza is ok, there slices are dense (doughy and heavy). Definitely not light or flaky at all. Customers service is good and the restaurant it self is clean and nice. It was an ok slice , should work on that pizza dough read more

Broadway Slice - Regular cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I'm impressed. I've lived all over Jersey and NYC and this pizza is a combination of great NY pizza and great Jersey Shore pizza. Crispy crust and fresh sauce and cheese like the city, with the just-slightly-thicker, chewier crust and rich cheese like the shore. Plus the toppings are not from a can, but sauteed in the joint. Next to Columbia Presbyterian hospital, too. read more

Pizza is good if you eat it right out the oven. Doesn't travel well. It's an ok slice. I'd rate it a 6.2.

tl;dr in a neighborhood without any clear standout pizzerias, this slice shop is solid and convenient When surveying the NYC pizza game, Washington Heights is not a neighborhood likely to come up. However, Broadway Slice enters as a popular local slice shop. The small, square space sports a bright red and baby blue color palette, with slightly worn, dark wood finishes. The customer area has a single 4-seat bar-height table and a narrow counter along the window and left wall. Pizza-related memorabilia and pay-per-view posters starkly contrast the soda machines along the perimeter. A medium pizza counter displays the daily offerings, with the industrial pizza oven just behind. I've been to Broadway Slice a handful of times, and my experiences have ranged from great to forgettable. My advice to maximize your slice is to stick with the regular pizza varieties (some of the more adventurous pies I've sampled have been disappointing) and ask the staff to heat your slice extra hot. My favorites are the Buffalo Chicken and Pepperoni. The former is loaded with slightly crisp chunks of meat, sports a nice buffalo flavor without being overwhelming, and pairs well with red pepper flakes. On the latter, the greasy and aromatic pepperoni creates a perfectly melty slice, especially with a bit of extra time in the oven. The crust is not uber-thin, and unfortunately occasionally runs slightly doughy. Service has always been quick, even with a line. However, by the time dinner rolls around, there often is only a limited selection of 'zza remaining, sometimes without even cheese or pepperoni. Further, the slices, while reasonably large, are on the expensive side, at $4 for plain and a bit more for toppings. Of course, you can find a cheaper or tastier slice if given access to all of NYC. But when around the neighborhood or hospital, Broadway Slices has proven to be a convenient option that, when at its best, hits the spot. read more

Broadway Slice - Buffalo Chicken (back) and Pepperoni (front) Slices - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Good pizza. Large slice to go with the large price $6. Pleasant staff. Room to dine informally.

I ordered a large chicken pizza and the chicken was rotten and the pizza smells horrible

If you get a cheese slice when it's freshly made it's really good. If they have to heat up an old slice from a pie it's basically just cardboard with string cheese on it. Buffalo wings are actually pretty good and the fried chicken is great as well. read more

the pizza isn't terrible but i wish the guy who's always there making the dough wore gloves lol, he handles the dough then goes and wipes his face or touch other stuff around the kitchen then go back to handling dough. read more

the best pizza in the area and beyond. I am particularly connected with their square slices - Grandma-esque. Flavorful crust is excellent. Sauce is excellent as well. read more

By far the best pizza in this area of Washington Heights. Good sauce, and the sizes of these slices are awesome. Not as big as koronet but close and taste better. read more

Broadway Slice - Sausage square. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

A good slice of old style pizza not too much added to it just a good Slice ingredients are fresh pizza was nice and hot.

I decided to order pizza from this establishment on a Friday night. My pizza arrived ruined, and the mac and cheese bites container was broken. The pizza wasnt edible, and it was super SOGGY. The slices were on top of eachother and mushy. I had to go to a nearby pizza shop to get food. I didn't even bother calling them because I will never order from here again. Anyone who delivers this quality of pizza doesnt care about their customers! read more

Broadway Slice - Broken container - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

These guys are great! I just moved into the neighborhood, and I was nervous to try a new pizza place so soon. Thankfully I did. I love more of a thin crust pizza, and that's just how they make em'; the sauce to cheese ratio is also good. My Italian friend approved as well; she's super picky about her pizza. Haha. One more thing! For Halloween, I asked them to make a Jack O'Lantern pie; first, they seemed apprehensive, but after the counter person showed the chef the picture of what I wanted, they laughed and agreed. It came out fantastic! read more

Broadway Slice - Jack O'Lantern pie - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

It is decent pizza. I've had it a couple times . It is pretty consistent I had too much sauce once. The people here love the grandma slice. I had plain cheese and pepperoni with peppers read more

This place was desperately needed. It's not that I don't love chain fast food joints or the one diner that is close to NYP, it's just that...welllllll...how do I put this.....they all kind of suck/are super generic. Like no offense Sabaro or Famiglia, but your pizza is pretty lame. Broadway slice is very much the polar opposite. Small business, real pizza, and fair prices. Oh, and the slices are enormous, especially when you consider a plain cheese is 3$, or 3.50$ for a topping. I honestly wouldn't recommend more than two slices unless your ravenous (we split three when we come now). The space is small but cozy, and they play pretty great music while you eat in. I also like how the delivery guys have their own door so they don't slow the line of foot traffic from getting to the counter. Stoke this place opened, wishing this new business nothing but the best (And PS, ignore that guy from Chicago, they don't know jack about pizza out there, let's be real). read more

See all

This place has one of the best slices of pizza I have ever had! I got 2 slices with sausage and was literally in heaven! Forget about parking though, but definitely worth the walk! read more

Broadway Slice - Sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I ordered a pizza from Broadway slice and they screwed up the order and refused to fix it. As far as I'm concerned they are the least friendly and cooperative people in Washington Heights and I would stay as far away as I could. read more

I just had what might have been the worst Chicken Parm hero I've ever had, and I've had a lotta them. I've never been to Broadway Slice before, but was in the neighborhood and looking for a place to grab a quick bite for lunch. I should have stuck to pizza as their slices looked good, but I was hungry and in the mood for a chicken parm. Any good pizza should make a good parm, so I wasn't afraid, but what I got was nearly inedible.. Number one, the sauce was horrid. Literally no taste at all to it. Secondly, the hero itself was wet and soggy. Yes, when you put sauce on the hero you'll expect a small amount of sogginess, but this was ridiculous. Finally the chicken was tasteless. Literally just a slab of microwaved chicken thrown in a sub with canned sauce on top and some melted cheese. I ate it because I was starving, and because I paid $13 for it. I'll never be coming back to this place, at least not for a chicken parm. read more

This review is for the absurdly horrendous delivery order that was delivered to me this evening. I've ordered Margherita Pizzas from Broadway Slice numerous times in the past; they've always been made the proper way with fresh mozzarella and basil. Tonight I received a disgusting mess of crap that I threw away. I don't know if there's new management but if there is, that person is doing a terrible job. Skip the new version of this place. read more

Broadway Slice - Crappy "Margherita Pizza" - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I ordered via Grubhub. I ordered the family pack 2. It's a good amount of food for the money. I was seriously hoping to find a good pizza place in my neighborhood. I ordered the regular cheese pizza to be cooked "well done, I like my crust crispy" I get a call from a young girl at the restaurant who says they are out of the 2 liter soda included in the package that I ordered, ginger ale. I begin explaining that it the only soda that I drink and she hangs up on me! The food came and once again, I was pleased with the volume. The pizza was not cooked well and the crust was not crispy. Also, they provided the ginger ale! No explanation! All in all, a good value, although the wings and pizza were quite salty. However, the customer service could be better. I am not sure if I will order again after the strange phone call and the lack of listening to my cooking request of well done. read more

We have grabbed a slice at least once a week since broadway slice has opened. I really like that it is not a chain of crappy, toaster oven type slices. The space is pretty small but there are a handful of stools if you are able to snag a space. The guys are friendly. The slices are HUGE. I always ask for my slice to be left in for a longer time to crisp it up more (I request this at almost all places). My go-to order is the rectangular grandma slice with chunky sauce and cheese. Slices start at 3$ so it definitely is a cheap, quick option if you don't have much time for a bite. read more

Great Pizza for Washington Heights. I walked in after seeing all of the new "open" signs and ordered a cheese slice. Different slice combinations and calzones were ready for me to select from. There is a small amount of bar-top seating or they will pack it up for you to take out. Pizza had a nice crisp to the bottom of it and softness to the dough once you take a bite. The sauce was tangy, not too salty. I'll be going back! read more

Broadway Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

By far the best pizza in Washington Heights. Slices are huge, have a crispy crust and a perfectly complementary sauce. The grandma pie was done RIGHT with crispy-cheeses edges and just the right amount of basil. Garlic knots are great, Caesar salad is super basic and not worth it (unless you really needed a vegetable like I did). I'm SO happy this is in the neighborhood and I will be back over and over. read more

My go 2 pizza spot. I love their garlic knots! Fluffy garlic knots with the right amount of garlic - not too oily nor bland. read more

Broadway Slice - Cheese Pizza 5 Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

They claim brick oven, I think not. Delivery is consistently late. Good food but at what cost? read more

Really great spot to grab a slice. Great garlic knots too. Happy addition to the neighborhood.

Are y'all serious with this...? My first time ordering here, and this is how my food arrived. I was luckily able to get a refund through Seamless. I won't be ordering again. read more

Broadway Slice - Sicilian (18in), or at least was supposed to be - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

great pizza for a great price! Also good seating options! The service was great, and I love the vibe of the restaurant

Buyer beware. If you order through Grubhub you will be overcharged. Prices on Yelp ordering system did not reflect the prices on the restaurant menu and the receipt that was sent with my order. I was over charged a total of $10.00. After calling grubhub I was told the restaurant sets the prices on the site. Well there is zero transparency here. If you are charging me a service fee why add that cost on the food price and be sneaky? Very shady business practice. My boys said the Pizza was good. The other food was nothing to rave about but its a pizza shop not a 5star restaurant. read more

Broadway Slice - Shady Business.... - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

have been here twice now. Each time I ordered the family deal. Large pizza, wings and 2 liter. I also enjoy the garlic knots, they come with marinara. As far as toppings, pepperoni has nice salty taste and jalapenos hot. They also don't have garlic sauce. One time my order was messed up... but they corrected it by making another pizza. Just be careful communicating your order so there are no errors, otherwise I would recommend read more

See all

Worst pizza experience I've had in NYC. Let me set the scene: mid-afternoon on a Saturday. I walk in and am the only customer. I order a Sicilian slice and a regular slice from an employee manning the oven. I wait about 10 minutes, all the while wondering why it's taking so long to heat two slices for the one and only customer this place has. The cashier suddenly asks "something I can get you?" as though he just now noticed my existence, even though I've been the only customer in the place this whole time. I explain that I've been waiting on an order. Cashier then proceeds to charge me for 3 slices. I explain that I only ordered two. Cashier then consults with oven-man, as though this is a major stock transaction. Oven-man retrieves a box with my slices, which I now realize has just been sitting out for what has easily been half the time I've been waiting, however, oven-man clearly did not alert me or cashier as to its presence. At this point I've been here for over 15 mins. Oven-man puts my two slices back into the oven because they are now cold. Finally, after close to 20 mins of waiting for two slices at a place where I'm the only customer (still!) I get my food and leave. Now to the actual pizza: they were arguably two of the coldest and greasiest slices of pizza I've ever had. VERDICT: Fuck this place. read more

Good spaghetti meatballs!! The ingredients are good quality and fresh!! Salad was good and fresh!! First time ordering from here! I'm looking forward to try their pizza! read more

Just stopped by to grab a sausage hero and a rum punch. The rum punch is great. The hero not so much. I wasn't expecting to get ground sausage on a soggy roll. I won't be ordering that again but the pizza isn't bad. read more

Grandma pizza is on point. Delivery has always been awesome. Tonight I didn't realize I ordered pickup instead of delivery and they were really cool about it. Ran it up to us really quick. Also really appreciate being able to order from their website directly so we can support them and not seamless. read more

I work nearby and noticed it was finally open. Stopped in for lunch and was very happy. Slices are huge (and delicious!) and the price was super reasonable. There was a pretty large variety of slices ready to go. I'll definitely be back. read more

It's essentially a step above basic $1 pizza at $3 a slice. Pizza was edible, nothing special. Ill agree its better than 90% of the pizza places in the Heights, but that's not saying much considering most are either super cheap greasy ingredients at inflated prices or just ridiculously expensive. Fine if you're on broadway in that part of the hood but if you want a better price for a better slice, walk a couple blocks north and pay an extra 75¢ for a HUGE slice on 172. Verdict: ..........Meh............. read more

The Pizza and Calamari was absolutely amazing and the delivery time was way less than expected. This will be my pizza place from now on. read more