I"ve been going here since 2010 when Dr. Bogden did my first knee replacement, he did the other in 2017. When I got a compound fracture of my wrist, I only saw the PA but she was awesome. Dr. Sargent did a great job treating me for tears in the rotator cuff. He did not recommend surgery even though the awful pain may have convinced me I needed it. read more

Hello I will stay anonymous here. I was seen in the Brick office on Thursday September 10, 2026. I saw Dr Phillips. While he was examining the reason why I was there, I could see he was sick from his eyes. He coughed while he was very close to my face and was not wearing a mask. I became very nervous because I have a weak immune system and prayed that I did not catch what I thought simply was "his cold". By Sunday morning, I felt like I was hit with a Mack truck. My fever was 102. I had flu like symptoms, head cold symptoms and had a hard time breathing due to my asthma. No matter what I did, I could not get warm. I missed 5 days of work last week. Finally on Thursday September 17, 2026, I went to my GP. She swabbed me for COVID, SARS and RSV. This morning Sunday September 20, my GP called me at 12:26 and told me that I tested a hard positive for COVID!!!! I still have a fever and symptoms but am getting better. I am not allowed back to work this week per my GP. How many patients became sick from seeing Dr Phillips on 9/10/26? PLEASE get tested for COVID if you are not feeling better. When this is all said and done, I will have lost 10 days of pay at the very least. I am not mad because it is human nature to be sick. I am scared financially because I live paycheck to paycheck. Maybe Dr Phillips will pay me for the 10 days of lost wages?!?! Maybe Dr Phillips should have stayed in bed or at the very least, worn a mask to protect his patients. As a senior, this was not very nice and he should know better. read more

Dr. Steven Mennona is literally the most pompous doctor I have ever met. I was supposed to have knee replacement surgery. I was literally on the table when he noticed an infection in my groin area. When I questioned him, he threw up his hands and said "surgery is off!" and left the room. I went to see my dermatologist 2 days later. She rolled her eyes & said he should know better! I went to see him 3 times following that non-surgery. Not once did he tell me he wouldn't do the surgery ever! He also never looked at the infection until I called him on that! He also accused me of bullying him into doing the surgery. I laughed! I'm only 5'2 with a tiny size 6 shoe. His surgical report at the hospital stated he would do the surgery once the infection cleared. After 3 appointments of his bull s***, I left his office. He has that air about him and a quirky smirk that says " he thinks he's the greatest doctor EVER" He's not. He's just an asshole. Within 5 days, I had a new doctor with an excellent reputation, and a new surgery date! read more

I only went to this practice one time. Brielle Ortho had a great reputation so I was recommended and made an appointment. I won't be going back. I'm not even going to complain about the wait time (over an hour)! I never got to see the dr. that I had the appointment with... the PA gave me the knee injection... but when I received the bill it was payable to the doctor's name. I never even saw the doctor. read more

Don't use. Terrible practice. Sent me away due to being 10 min late. Referred me internally for cowboy surgeon who wanted to fuse when a simple microdiscectomy would do. Found a great surgeon in C Gillis. Surgery done and I'm walking on day one! Stay away from W Lopez!!!! read more

Horrible service from Dr Nuitini. when he was reading looking at my scan i had questions that he refused to answer and acted super short and nasty... then proceeded to give me a gel shot and left the room. no one asked me if i needed assistance getting down off the table and my leg gave out...almost fell and then had to walk out of the office with no assistance holding onto the chair rail. i'm a 74 year old disabled woman. the doctor was obviously annoyed and super short... read more

My husband called to make an appointment tonight and when he was explaining what he needed the woman on the phone hung up not once but twice. She didn't take the time to listen to his needs. She assumed she couldn't help him. Meanwhile our family has been patience of the office for over 15 years. Very upsetting since the doctors are excellent. Front desk needs to do better! read more

Absolutely horrible service. My father has been a patient for 15 years and they are on the phone yelling at him and hanging up on him. I have been in healthcare for YEARS and never seen this level of service. Michelle is the name of the woman very very rude woman. I can't believe my poor father had to deal with this. read more

If you are a senior estate away from this place! I was misdiagnosed in March of 2024.I saw Dr Mennons twice my hip. He said twice I didn't need a hip replacement. Was in agony for 7 months until I found a brilliant orthopedic surgeon. Had my hip replacement all is well! DONT GO THERE! read more

First it was Brielle ortho and most mds were excellent, started to go downhill as Rothman. Now combined with Ortho NJ the visit with Dr, Natchez was 3 mins, if that and remain with same issue. Received a bill for 368.00, was told this was for an established patient, couldn't imagine if you're unestablished. Should have learned after horrible experience with Dr. Rodricks. While still having pain after bilateral. Knee replacements was told I has buyers remorse. Have been going to Brielle ortho over 20 years, never again. Ps, Dr. Marciano is great, there prices are insane though​​​​ read more

went to the ER February 2022 diagnosed with rotator cuff tear Hospital recommended MRI. I came here and was refused an MRI he said it was not rotator cuff tear. I just had surgery 9 cc tear in right arms bone spurs cysts, bicep tear. Physical therapy was not the answer. Now I have a long way ahead. In both arms !! Very upset to say the least read more

Very satisfied with the care I got and the way the office was run. I was seen on time(front desk was efficient and pleasant), Dr. Sadik was easy to talk to, gave me options for care, his opinion, and I was treated immediately. His PA was kind , knowledgeable and gave me a painless shot. My knee feels better already. Will definitely recommend this dr and this practice. Shari D read more

Beware the 'complimentary' braces they give you. You'll get a steep bill a few weeks later for that 'free' ankle brace and they'll refuse to take it back once you realize they misled you. Another group of doctors that have gone corporate. read more

We were lucky to find dr Phillips after an accident on Xmas eve 2023- he has seen us quite often and completed two successful surgeries - very caring and understanding . read more

Do not waste your time here. I'm an existing patient with knee pain and have needed 2 steroid injections for pain over the past year. The first appointment was made with a spine doctor. They apologized, Second appointment went as it should. I was told by doctor Sargent i will need gel injections next time, when the pain returns. I called for an appointment, I'm in pain again, can't climb stairs and was told I could be seen A MONTH FROM NOW...... As an existing patient I find this CRUEL AND DISPICABLE! read more

The best Ortho practice around! I'm a chef and they help keep me going! I have had such great treatment from. Dr Nitche, Dr Katt, Dr Stamos and the whole gang. My mom had her knee replaced by Dr Bogdan and had a perfect experience. My friend had her knee replaced by Dr Rodricks after a terrible fall and now has her life back! I can't think of a better group of Doctors and staff!!! Limp your way over to Brielle Ortho and they will fix you! read more

Since June of 2022 I have had both shoulders operated on and now looking to get my knee fixed due to a previous injury. I can't thank the staff enough for my care and attention to detail. Dr. Stamos is an outstanding doctor. He is extremely knowledgeable and cares for his patients. It is a friendly atmosphere with lollipops if you are a good patient. If you are looking for an amazing medical experience this group will see to it that you are satisfied and healthy. Thank you for fixing me up! read more

One of the PA sent me for MRI. Got he results tuesday. No One has called me about it. Upon calling the office I am told you need to come in and discuss this. I have had numerous MRI done and each and everyone of them the Dr called me to discuss results and what to do next. Never have I heard That i need to go in for this. Its crazy that they want me to go in just to collect more money. Needless to say i'm finding another Dr. read more

Nearly impossible to get through in a phone call with this medical practice. The automated voice response unit is incredibly detailed yet something as simple as ordering a prescription refill is not one of the options. To add insult to injury the automated response says for all other calls hit zero, when you hit zero it says that's an invalid option. Really? I did leave a message on someone's voicemail and the correct department called me back saying they arranged my refill with my pharmacy. read more

Run don't walk out of that place right now. I was treated like a dog. I had surgery and it failed and the doctor refuses to see me it's crazy house please don't stay read more

They suck in the billing department. Nine mos after appt I get a $400 bill in the mail. They changed over systems. Gotcha.

awful staff, spoke like she didn't want to talk. after taking down my info she tells me at the last minute, to stick to my old doctor. according to her you are not supposed to switch pain management doctors even though I already done that. what's funny is I called another doctor and made an appoinment. this happened in the toms river nj office. read more

I'm a patient and it's IMPOSSIBLE to get anyone on the phone to schedule an appointment. The doctors and physical therapists have all been great, but the phone system is awful, I've had it. read more

Dr. William Law and Brielle Orthopedics could be the worst medical experience that I've ever had. If you're interested in terrible patient care, horrible bedside manner, inability to send prescriptions for MRIs, a dirty and unorganized office then this is the practice for you. It was an awful experience. I wouldn't send my worst enemy there for care because no human being deserves to be treated like they treat their patients. read more

$230 charged just because i was a new patient!!! Which of course insurance didn't cover. Need I say more read more

A waste of time, too many options exist to expose oneself to the subpar practice. Good surgeons do not treat patients literally as radiology reports. There are plenty of superior spine surgeons locally with better credentials & expertise to risk being treated by the spine surgeon. read more

My husband is no longer in pain after having his knee replaced. Dr.Rodericks was wonderful. My husband was able to walk without having that terrible knee pain. We're so happy he had it done. read more

The doctors here have a good reputation. However the service is terrible. You cannot reach them by phone to make an appointment or change an appointment or anything else. I've resorted to communicating with them by going to their office. Never experienced anything like this. read more

My very first visit, I walked in and almost walked out, staff has no idea how to treat anyone, nevermind me. Co Pays are more important than seeing a patient, you could be in dire need of medical help and if you can not pay, they smack you with an additional 20 dollar service fee. I just changed doctors and will move on, but...will always remember how awful they are and always suggest a different place to anyone in need of help. Dr. ESQUIERES staff and billing, you people really know how to destroy a doctors practice, keep up the good work! read more

Elizabeth Conway is my physical therapist, although I am more inclined to refer to her as a miracle worker. I have never had a great experience with physical therapy until meeting her. The entire team on the first floor physical therapy department (the therapists and the support staff) is extremely supportive and tactful, which expertly mitigates the shame, embarrassment, and unease that comes with needing a prescription for physical therapy to begin with. Elizabeth Conway is exceptionally consistent in her methods, and is always amicable to detailed explanations when questions arise. It is nice to finally meet a medical professional who clearly enjoys their craft. I am humbled by my experience here. I walked in skeptical, hoping that I would receive some effective physical rehabilitation. I look forward to walking out with a miracle of physical recovery, and a mental sense of relief that I could not have expected. Thank you, Elizabeth Conway. read more

I was referred to Brielle Orthopedics from Ocean Medical Center, for a metacarpal fracture. Dr. Brian Katt, is the surgeon who specializes in hands. The staff at Brielle Orthopedics are pleasant and helpful. The initial office visit, surgery, and follow-ups were in a timely manner. Dr. Brian Katt is an an amazing surgeon. I felt VERY confident with his knowledge, and his compassion for my situation was heartfelt. I would recommend Brielle Orthopedics, specifically Dr. Katt, to anyone that needs to see a hand specialist. read more

"THUMBS DOWN" DR MACASIUM Had carpal tunnel surgery in both hands from a bicycle accident as well as cell phone computer use etc. I am actually using voice recognition right now because I like to limit the use of my right hand so forgive my grammar doctor mcassium is a great guy the place is very nice but the results were horrible I went from having numb fingers on my right hand specifically my middle finger and ended up with a problem with my index finger and now my THUMB I had no issues with my index finger prior to this situation I cannot grab onto anything and pull it which is a big problem because I am a gym rat further more and more importantly I limit the use of my right hand at work it if I ever have to actually hand write something it is a chore the bottom line is this I had my left hand done at seaview orthopedic doctor mcbaide and had no issues my hand is completely recovered and I regret the fact that I did you see him in the 1st place I highly recommend seaview orthopedic over brielle orthopedic because this is just so wrong I can't go back and have another surgery now I will have to pay for it because it is a new year with my insurance company and obviously it is my dominant hand and it is a major issue I literally have to grab things with my pinky and ring finger Can you imagine picking up a suitcase with you pinky and ring finger with little to no assistance from your other fingers 732-522-0425 Bill DeMato Sr read more

Love Dr. Stamos!! I had an awful pain in my left calf and Dr Stamos was able to have me get a X-ray and then schedule an MRI on site. Once we found out the issue which was a small mass in the center of my calf muscle we were able to discuss and find the appropriate doctor and measures to take. Love Brielle orthopedics for the care I received and the ease of appointments! Recommend to everyone! read more

Very great experience and staff coming here!! I saw Dr. Kanarek and her passion and concern for patients definitely shows. Her secretary, Margie Mauceri also made my visit enjoyable, easy, and quick. They both understood my needs and having this convenient location, I am sure to return and recommended this business to friends and family. So thankful to know such a trusting staff!! read more

We were happy with Brielle Orthopedics before they merged with Rothman. Since they've merged, we can never get a call back. We've literally been leaving messages for 2 weeks now with the medical assistant and can't get a call back from the doctor. Feel we have no option but to move on. We used to feel cared about, now we just feel expendable. Terrible service. read more

Great doctors, excellent and friendly staff - overall great experience at Brielle Orthopedics! :)

Horrific. They do not return calls or do any sort of follow up. They are a lawsuit waiting to happen. Absolutely terrible service. Go elsewhere and save yourself the stress. read more

My whole family goes there , we are very happy with the Doctors and staffersthe Fairweather clan

I have been a patient of Brielle Orthopedics for years. Last year, on Memorial day weekend, I injured my knee: damaged the cartilage in the weight bearing portion of my knee. I was being treated by Dr. Law. We tried treating with medicine and physical therapy, but I was not getting any better. Ultimately, Dr. Law said a knee scope was the only option. I had surgery on July 11, 2018; a Pick Microfracture Chondroplasty. I was non weight-bearing and on crutches for 6 weeks. I weaned off crutches and then to a cane, and finally came off the cane in November. I never stopped feeling pain. Every post-op visit, I told Dr. Law I didnt feel as if I was getting better and wasn't sure the surgery worked. He was very dismissive of my claims and kept saying it was a picture perfect surgery and he couldn't have asked for it to go better. His bedside manner is in serious need of improvement. The only times he appeared to be kind were when my husband was present for the visits. But, I was willing to see past that so long as he could fix my knee. Although he initially told me he would discharge me at 6 months, he actually discharged me at 4 and a half months. Confused with the discharge since I was still in pain, I questioned this and he told me if I wanted my knee to feel better, I should lose weight to take pressure off the knee. While I could stand to lose a few pounds, maybe 10 or so, my weight certainly is not the issue. I should also mention I did 6 months of physical therapy post-surgery, 3 times a week. The pain has worsened over time and now, I cannot take one step without feeling significant pain. I asked to see a different Dr. at Brielle Orthopedics, but the office told me in order to do so, I would have to explain to Dr. Law why I dont want to see him and then get his permission to see another Dr. in the practice (no thanks). They would rather lose a patient than let me see someone else. When I requested my medical records and told them I was going elsewhere, they didnt care or even ask why. After seeing another orthopedic and getting an updated MRI, we have learned that what I suspected all along was correct: the surgery was a complete and total failure, and my knee is in much worse shape than before surgery. I have wasted a year following Dr. Law's advice, enduring pain and spending quite a bit of money....for nothing. Now, I am looking at the possibility of joint replacement surgery, if gel injections do not resolve the pain. I will never return to Brielle Orthopedics...and neither will my family. read more

I've been going to Brielle Orthopedics for several years now. I have seen three different doctors and all were very knowledgable and helpful. I've never had a problem making an appointment or getting in touch with office staff. Everyone always seems really friendly. I'm not sure what spurred the bad reviews, but I've never experience anything negative from this office. read more