Cancel

Open app

Search

Brewster Pastry

3.8 (52 reviews)
ModerateBakeries
Closed • Closed

Brewster Pastry Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Brewster Pastry

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Thank you for this amazing cake for our 40th anniversary celebration! It was delicious and everyone loved it

Communion Cake

I ordered a cake for my son's Communion. The cake was 3 layers. Two vanilla one chocolate with buttercream filling. It was absolutely delicious! So fresh and decorated beautifully for his special day. We cant say enough how delicious they make their cakes. We had many items over the years from Brewster Pastry and they never disappoint!

Cake!
Daria S.

Ordered a cake for a family gathering at a nearby restaurant. Cake was delicious! Chocolate layers with (real) strawberry filling. Counter help was very courteous. Wish I lived in the area to try other items; smelled wonderful and looked delicious!

Sausage "empanada." Beautiful, buttery, flakey pastry.
Jane D.

Brewster Pastry was, happily, able to stay open during all the COVID-19 craziness, keeping the communities around it well provisioned with wonderful baked goods. We finally tried those rounds of bread, which are soft, maybe almost like a Portuguese loaf, with a pleasant rise. Very kid friendly, but I was, in truth, hoping more for a tooth-cracking, Poilâne-style mini miche, given Thierry Danvin's origins. A small loaf, about 8" in diameter, is $3, which is a real steal for a bakery-sourced, bakery-fresh loaf. An almond croissant we tried today was filled with something that resembled pastry cream instead of frangipane. It was delicious, but not the traditional filling I was hoping for (and seem to recall getting in times past). Still, that croissant and the chocolate croissant were beautifully laminated as usual. A generously filled sausage "empanada" was nothing like any empanada I've ever tried, but rather reminded me of "curry puffs" or savory pastries found at Hong-Kong stye Chinese bakeries in Chinatown. It was utterly fabulous, with a thick layer of creamy (maybe) ricotta cheese, lightly studded with crumbled sausage. I was quite smitten and ate almost the entire thing before I remembered to snap a photo. Only tip to the friendly, capable staff: please remember to change those gloves between handling food and handling a credit card. I'm not sure the nice young lady who served me, today, changed her gloves after putting through my payment, to help the gentleman who came in after me. My immediate family is relatively spry, and I have a fair amount of faith in my stomach acids... but more attention to hygiene may just keep someone alive in these times.... Love this place. Still the best bakery I've found in the area by far.

NY Cheesecake
Jen C.

The team at Brewster Pastry was wonderful and accommodating when I wanted to order a cheesecake for my friend who lives locally for their birthday. Their pricing was affordable and the cheesecake was delicious. They even offered to write Happy Birthday on it, which made this gift truly extra special. The pickup process for my friend was easy and the staff was friendly. I also love that they are doing deliveries for the local frontline workers. I would totally order from them again for future birthday treats or if I am in the area!

Almond Croissants
Stephanie Marie L.

Out of this world! Their pastries are fresh and flavorful. Their customer service is one of a kind because they truly appreciate their customers. Brewster Pastry pastries are at all of our holidays, events and celebrations. Their almond croissants are a family favorite.

#neveragain #FAIL #BrewsterPastry

What you see is what I got. Not their finest. My daughter ordered it and I was surprised at the quality and presentation.

Fixed the collapsed cake with new icing and wine bottles.
Starr J.

The owner of this shop saved the day for me quite literally!! I purchased a cake from a friend of mine in Danbury, CT. For a special birthday party all the way in Long Island. Well on my journey to Long Island the cake suddenly started to collapse. I called this bakery and the owner kindly allowed me to come in. He saw the tears in my eyes, and our of kindness of his heart, he fixed the cake. He somehow miraculously made it look as if the cake wasn't falling apart. I'm so impressed with this bakery and his knowledge in cakes. I should of just bought through him! At the end of it all he didn't even charge me to help me out and said just pass on the kindness Thankful to of met him and I'm thankful for all his help beyond words!! AMAZING OWNER AND AMAZING BUSINESS!!

They were fresh and hot when I got them. They didn't last too long! So delicious!

The cider donuts are so fresh and delicious! I came in at the perfect time. The bakery smelled so good as they were fresh and hot. I asked for 3 without sugar and 3 with sugar. I'm glad they were able to accommodate me. I'd go back for the donuts any time. I enjoy them without sugar just as much.

Sfogiatelle perfectly done
Lisa B.

From the moment you walk in and order till you leave you'll always find something new to try. Great fresh baked pies, cookies, pastries and soups to name a few... you won't be dissapointed!

Merri F.

We stopped back in for a quick snack and I was delighted to see all of the seasonal halloween cookies out. I had my eye on the canoli and had been waiting all trip for this pit stop. So glad we did! I also tried the coffee this time and it was good as well. Brewster pastry you are a winner!

Hard jelly

See all

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of D G.
0
96
0

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

15 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Lisa D.
2
88
19

14 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

16 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Mo O.
49
1
0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

I stop here all the time on my way to work great doughnuts and pastries and the owner is the friendliest man you've ever met.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

16 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Brewster Pastry

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Bakeries 930 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

The Baker’s Daughter - Snowflake cookie

The Baker’s Daughter

4.2(5 reviews)
5.3 mi

This is a lazy person and couldn't be bothered to respond after several calls, emails, for over 2…read moreweeks and when she did it was a slow and torturous process! The prices are absolutely ridiculous as I was quoted well over $100 for 15 cupcakes in a basic cupcake cake in the shape of a baseball. And was told she only offered 2 flavors - vanilla and chocolate. lazy lazy lazy and boring flavors I was offered...vanilla, chocolate...that's it. Vanilla and chocolate. A professional baker who can't be bothered to speak with a potential customer, who can't be bothered to do more than offer a lazy average box flavored cake at the most ridiculously horrendous prices. It's almost funny. Slow to respond once contact was made and so absolutely "who cares" and snotty. It was an exciting event for me...I realize my life isn't important to her and her life isn't important to me but her business is providing a service for an event important to the customer, duh. I was trying to keep my business local and I completely believe in supporting local small businesses. I will never use this baker and I'm still mad at how she lazily strung me along with her "email only" contact. Can you imagine? You can't be bothered to speak to your potential customers. I have 2 businesses and I would never behave like this or I'd be done. But then again, I expect to be treated as I treat others, and customers are important. I made the above review based 100% on my own personal experience. I have had no influence anyone, I don't know anyone who has used her. I don't know her and I still have no idea what she sounds like or looks like. This was a disgraceful way to conduct business and this is the review you get for that uncomfortable and rude process. Happy ending though ...I got 2 speciality 3 layer cakes for under $100 from a place in Patterson. It was wonderful in the end but the stress of having to find someone last minute was awful. Vanilla or chocolate, sheesh!

From cinnamon buns to pao de deus, cake pops to scones, this bakery has all your sweet tooth…read moredesires and more. Tucked in a little side street is this amazing and incredible Portuguese bakery right in the heart of Carmel. This husband and wife duo is extremely kind and ready to serve you your favorite baked goods. Though baked goods are ready to serve you, custom cakes, wedding cakes and special occasion desserts is their jam. You can place a custom order of just about anything, just speak with Stefanie and she's got you! This quaint little bakery is nice and cozy, you can order to go or hang out for a moment. They also have tea and coffee available, nothing crazy but just something to go with that sweet or savory treat.

Photos
The Baker’s Daughter - This pastel de Nata will not be here very long!!

This pastel de Nata will not be here very long!!

The Baker’s Daughter - Ciannamon buns!

See all

Ciannamon buns!

Alis's Bakery & Deli - The chicken stew dish (pollo guisado) was so fresh, and light and flavorful

Alis's Bakery & Deli

4.0(3 reviews)
3.3 mi

We took the train to Brewster and looked for a place to get quick lunch at. Walked around near the…read moretrain station and this place (now called Ali's Bakery & Deli) looked nice. The food turned out to be utterly delicious - we got the Guatemalan chicken stew kind of dish (pollo guisado), rice, 2 kinds of black beans, and plantains. The chicken dish was so fresh, and surprisingly light and very flavorful. The black bean paste was tasty too. The lady running the place asked if we wanted tortillas. So glad we said yes. They were thicker than Mexican tortillas, but light and slightly spongey and not dry. They were making them fresh inside, I watched them make these. I haven't had tortillas this tasty since we vacationed in Guatemala some years ago. The horchata was good too, not too sweet. Families were coming in, it was a very authentic kind of place and the food had a home-cooked taste. Theres's pre-made food, but you can also order from the menu. We were there on Saturday, around 11:30am, so the food was just being prepared for the day, but I think they cook throughout the day. Must say also a very friendly and gracious kind of place. A really fantastic surprise! Wish this place would open a location in Manhattan.

Having lunch on Main Street in Brewster, NY! Surprised to see virtually all restaurants serving…read moresome type of Spanish cuisine! Ali's has Guatemalan food prepared to order or from the steam table. Kitchen was busy, so I chose from the steam table. Chicken stew, rice, beans, and some veggies. First time I've had lunch served by the pound from a Spanish place! Food was fresh & tasty but it cost more than expected at $7.99/lb. Got two house made tortillas as well. Would stop in again.

Photos
Alis's Bakery & Deli - Lady running the place, so nice and friendly. She suggested the fantastic fresh tortillas which we could watch being hand made.

Lady running the place, so nice and friendly. She suggested the fantastic fresh tortillas which we could watch being hand made.

Alis's Bakery & Deli
Alis's Bakery & Deli - Delicious food at Ali's. The chicken dish, pollo guisado, was soooo good! The black bean paste was also yummy. The plantains not too sweet.

See all

Delicious food at Ali's. The chicken dish, pollo guisado, was soooo good! The black bean paste was also yummy. The plantains not too sweet.

La Deliziosa - Black and white cookie

La Deliziosa

4.6(100 reviews)
26.8 mi
•$

Already had my coffee and wandered past this gem! Fate…read more So so so many delicious baked goods to choose from. Grateful the staff patiently obliged my indecision. After quite a bit of deliberation, I ordered the cutest lil chocolate biscotti. A perfect pairing for my Joe! She was crisp, perfectly chocolate dipped and satisfied my carb to coffee ratio. This spot is bookmarked for my next baked good haul. Talk soon.. The Mocktail Madam

Thanks to a friend for the referral to La Deliziosa in the Little Italy section of Poughkeepsie…read more Back in the day, this area was busy and now it's not. We did sit outside after 5 and it got busy as folks drove in and walked up after work. So, for us..I told hubby he didn't need to buy anything because he already had sweets in the hotel room. However once he had a look at the cases, he just had to buy something! His favorite is the lobster tail and cannoli and I had to get the black and white cookie. We sat outside and since I had to be on a call, hubby went in for a strawberry ice. No chocolate until the weekend . A couple of bites of the black and white cookie for me right away. It's not overly make my teeth rattle sweet and the crumb is very much like a cake. I ate the rest after dinner and it quickly had hardened. Hubby LOVED the lobster tail. 5 out of 5. Hubby took a taste of the cannoli and gave it a thumbs up. He enjoyed the water ice more than Ralph's because it wasn't as icy. Local businesses are so important to the local community and it seems that La Deliziosa is holding its own. Regardless let's keep them going!

Photos
La Deliziosa - Interior

Interior

La Deliziosa
La Deliziosa - This Old World Charm

See all

This Old World Charm

Brewster Pastry - bakeries - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...