Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Brenda's Creative Cakery

    5.0 (1 review)

    Brenda's Creative Cakery Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Brenda's Creative Cakery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Brenda's Creative Cakery

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Custom Cakes 369 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Smallcakes Idaho: Cupcakery & Creamery - Caramel Crunch Cupcake

    Smallcakes Idaho: Cupcakery & Creamery

    (72 reviews)

    $$

    The shop itself is adorable and very inviting. Walking in and seeing all the cupcakes and desserts…read moredisplayed is genuinely pleasing -- it's the kind of place that makes you excited to try something sweet. Unfortunately, the flavors didn't live up to the presentation for me. I tried the carrot cake cupcake and was expecting a classic cream cheese frosting, but what I got tasted more like a very sweet white frosting. If there was cream cheese in it, I couldn't really tell. The cake itself also had a slightly soapy/perfumey flavor, almost like the batter picked up fragrance from a recently cleaned counter. I'm very sensitive to that taste and it really threw me off. I also tried the Boston Cream Pie cupcake. There was barely any Bavarian cream filling inside, which was disappointing since that's the main reason to order that flavor. The cupcake was also very crumbly, making it difficult to hold and eat. Overall, the shop is cute and the display is beautiful, but the flavors I tried didn't quite deliver. I might give it another try someday in case I just picked the wrong flavors.

    So many beautiful cupcakes here, in all sorts of styles and flavors!!!…read more It's a very small shop, but loaded to the brim with sweets. They have ice cream too! We bought some of their cupcakes for a birthday party that everyone enjoyed, plus a few treats for our dogs, which we didn't know they offered. We have two dogs, who thoroughly enjoyed the goods!!

    Boise Pie Co - Salted caramel latte with vanilla cold foam and a Cutthroat Cookies rice crispy treat

    Boise Pie Co

    (111 reviews)

    $$

    Review based on non-baked goods and service. Pies may be a different story…read more Cashier/clerk was cold and had no people skills. Greeted her and she didn't respond. Just looked at me coldly. Odd. After paying, didn't tell me to wait, sit, or if they'd bring it to me. Severely lacking basic service skills. Ordered the funky chicken sandwich and a bottle of soda. $12.99 for two pieces of bread with a little filling, and a slice of cheese (see pic). Sandwich assembler eventually brought my sandwich out to me. Will not be returning to this place. Wayyyy better off going to any of the many sandwich chains.

    Boise Pie Company was recently sold to new owners yet again, this is the second owner (or maybe the…read morethird?) since the original owner opened this business in 2018. I haven't been in in a while because the location is an awkward one for me and the interior is not particularly a cozy place to sit and enjoy a piece of pe. But Boise Pie Company pies in limited options are now available to order through Farm Deliver (the aggregator for local food hub that takes orders for local farmer and producers and delivers their good things to homes on Wednesday afternoons) so I had a Peach Huckleberry pie in the delivery yesterday afternoon. The crust on this pie was so delicious, in fact much better than my memory of Boise Pie Co. pies being ever. I wonder if the new owner changed the crust recipe? I often leave the crust on a piece of pie, but on this one I ate every crumb. Every holiday I try to find a local producer food item to gift to neighbors. Something that doesn't need to be eaten right away but can be saved and used at any time during holidays or after. I know Boise Pie Co is now providing frozen take and bake Huckleberry pies. If they're still doing that at holiday time, they may be my choice for the neighbors' gifts. (I plan ahead. :-) ) In years past it has been treats like the frozen Lasagna or Chicken pot pie from Certified Kitchen & Bakery's freezer case or Dan Ansotegui's award winning Basque chorizo sausages from Ansot's cold case or stollen from Acme Bakery or assorted artisan chocolates from Chocolat Bar so Boise Pie Co would join great company in the gifting. ;-)

    Brenda's Creative Cakery - customcakes - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...