Welcome to Bootcamp Smack Down. Two bootcamps enter the ring, one leaves. We'll see who has the…read morebest cuisine. Wait.. that's Top Chef. Oops, sorry.
I've attended two of the oldest and best established bootcamps in San Francisco (probably the country): Bootcamp SF, and Sgt. Ken's START Fitness. This is a review of Bootcamp SF, but it's also a compare/contrast with START Fitness http://www.yelp.com/biz/start-fitness-sgt-kens-boot-camp-san-francisco
Bottom Line: Both START and Bootcamp SF are excellent programs, but for most people START is the better, and cheaper, option. For details, read on -
Facility
BCSF is entirely outdoors. That's a welcome change for many a gym rat, but you are at the mercy of the weather, equipment is limited, you'll frequently be running around public parks in the dark, and no showers or changing facilities are available. They suggest you buy a headlamp and gloves. I think the gloves are optional, but the light is a good idea.
START meets inside everyday and offers nice mats, clean showers, changing rooms, and decent if basic equipment including brand new TRX suspension mounts. It heads outside, weather permitting, for a distance run on Tuesdays, sprint work on Thursdays and for half of class on Friday.
Intensity and Effectiveness
BCSF makes students work hard. START is all about pushing students out of their comfort zone. I also think START's five-days-a-week class availability (even if you don't go five times a week) and lack of a session structure make it easier to be consistent at START then at BCSF .
One BCSF veteran said she saw major changes in herself after about three sessions (18 weeks) and I believe this. Based on my own experience and gossip from both classes, I'm guessing the same amount of change would probably have come in one to two months at START.
The Vibe
For a program to work you gotta go. The right vibe really helps.
Bootcamp SF has taken a few knocks on Yelp from people who felt left out. I had a fine experience, but I can see how BCSF could feel like junior high school PE: a bit cliquey, and there is little sense of being together as a team.
Sgt. Ken's is, in my experience, aggressively inclusive and more diverse than BCSF in every way, including ability level. It is, however, a little more structured than BCSF (example - at BCSF everyone may go out and run around a course as individuals, at START you are more likely to be put in a group of 5 people doing relays). If you hate structure but are still attracted to a group exercise program BCSF might be a better fit.
Schedule/Location/Cost - BCSF
Bootcamp SF meets four days a week (though there is a Saturday make-up session you are welcome to attend whether or not you actually missed a class). The program is organized in six week sessions with a week's break between sessions. You have to join at the start of a session, so if you're timing is bad you could end up cooling your heels for five weeks.
Classes are available in the Marina (where I participated), Golden Gate Park, South Beach, Dolores Park and at one location in the South Bay. Times vary by location, but classes are usually at 6:00am, 7:00am, 8:30am and 9:30am Monday through Friday but with Wednesday off. There is also an evening class in Golden Gate Park. Schedule here https://docs.google.com/Doc?docid=0AfptCVdE9mT9ZGczNmZqeGdfODdjd3YycmpnMg&hl=en
BCSF is $295 per session if you go 4 days a week, $260 for 3 days a week. This works out to $12 and $14 a class.
Schedule/Location/Cost - START
Sgt. Ken's boot camp meets five days a week at 6:00am and at 7:00am, in a studio at Franklin and Bush. The program runs continuously, so you can join anytime. Cost varies depending on length of commitment, but if you don't mind stepping up for eight or twelve weeks, it's half to a quarter as expensive as BCSF. They have a three day free trial.
1 week commitment = $17/class
4 week commitment = $14.50/class
8 week commitment = $5.90/class
12 week commitment = $2.92/class
If neither BCSF or START sound like your cup of tea, and just in case I haven't given you enough information, here's a list of some other bay area bootcamps. I haven't been to any of these, but I figured I'd share my Googling...
Raw Fitness: http://myrawfitness.com/services/boot-camp/boot-camp-415/ (note - only meets twice a week)
Schnell Schnell Boot Camp http://schnellschnellsf.com/ (Cole Valley, outdoors, looks like it meets 3 times a week in the morning and twice in the evenings)
BasicTraining SF http://www.basictrainingsf.com/ (program organization looks a lot like BCSF)
Koi Fitness http://www.koifitness.com/ (program organization looks a lot like BCSF)
Crossfit http://www.sanfranciscocrossfit.com/whatis.php According to the New York Times http://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/22/fashion/thursdaystyles/22Fitness.html an intense, sometimes dangerous workout
SF Adventure Boot Camp www.sfadventurebootcamp.com (Women only and coed camps, sessions are 2 and 4 week