Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Borough Bagel

    5.0 (2 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Borough Bagel Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Borough Bagel

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    3 months ago

    Best bagel I've had in a loonnnggg time. Friendly service, Great music and more options than I was expecting. I'll be going back

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bagels 284 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Flour Shop - The cheech at the beach!

    The Flour Shop

    4.8(52 reviews)
    4.3 mi

    Super cute shop. Very tasty bagel sandwiches. Excellent coffee…read more Parking is on the south side of the building (north side lot is a private club). Enter through the door at the sidewalk. There is a sandwich board in the parking lot next to the employee entrance with the days sandwich options. The shop is small with seating for about ten people. Most of the traffic during our visit was take away. Order counter is on the left with the menu board overhead and available bagels in bins. Place your order and pay, then pick up at the next counter. No paper receipts, but you can have one emailed. For coffee orders, staff will add the milk of your choice, or you can add cream and sweetener at a table to the right of the pick up area. This table also has drink lids, napkins and stir sticks. Online orders are left on shelves by the door for quick and easy pick up. Staff here are very friendly. The bagel selection is creative. I had a jalapeno and havarti cheese bagel with cream cheese. The flavor of the bagel was just right. The cream cheese is very smooth and there was plenty on there. The bagels are a respectable size. Any bigger would be too big imho. The texture is dense with a pleasant chew. I couldn't tell the bagels were sour dough, maybe because of the jalapeno. My SO got themselves a Hot Boi on a prosciutto bagel. To say it was very much enjoyed is probably a bit of an understatement. It was pretty much inhaled and then expounded on in detail. So yes, it was a hit. We both had a Dave's drip coffee which is very smooth. They offer a variety of coffee drinks and seasonal specials are listed on the menu. They all sound amazing. Do recommend this spot.

    After visiting @flourshopbagels in the Pawcatuck / Stonington area, in the Bitter Cold, for an…read more@yelpconnecticut Elite Check In Event yesterday, I have to say Flour Shop Bagels is now among my favorite CT Bagels Shops. I'm going to do two reviews for Flour Shop. One is on the Event Page and is limited to what I tried at the Yelp Check In Event. This one focuses on the half dozen bagels and cream cheese I purchased. Flour Shop is a small independent bagel shop, with some limited seating. They also have a robust takeout business. I arrived at Opening at 8 am. The shop was instantly thriving. The Flour Shop Team was friendly, helpful and efficient. I ordered a half dozen bagels to bring home. I asked if they had Veggie Cream Cheese, which is my go to. They didn't have any made, but they offered to make Veggie CC on the Spot. And you know what? It was Top 10 Percentile for all Bagel Shops. Full of chunks of veggies. Great texture and great color. Flour Shop boils and bakes their Bagels. I tried the Prosciutto Special Bagel and a Spicy Egg Everything. They were good chewy. Fresh. The Prosciutto was crispy, which was the way to do it for a bagel. The seasoning for the Spicy Egg Everything was nuanced and tasty. The Bagels look a bit rustic in a good way. The Flour Shop executed the classics well. Great coverage on the Sesame and Everything Bagels. If you live in the greater Stonington area, visiting The Flour Shop is an easy decision. It's also worth driving from away to start an area day trip. 5 Stars

    Photos
    The Flour Shop - Menu July 2025

    Menu July 2025

    The Flour Shop
    The Flour Shop - Enter from sidewalk. Sandwich board w/specials in parking lot area by employee entrance.

    See all

    Enter from sidewalk. Sandwich board w/specials in parking lot area by employee entrance.

    Old Man Joe’s - This sugar spoon is so adorable

    Old Man Joe’s

    4.5(39 reviews)
    4.3 mi

    Old Man Joe's is the kind of neighborhood gem that makes you feel like you've stumbled into a…read morelocals‑only secret -- the kind of place where the coffee hits right, the bagels are legit, and the vibe is pure comfort. The bagels are the star: perfectly chewy with that slight crisp on the outside, the way a real bagel should be. None of that fluffy bread‑with-a-hole nonsense. Whether you're grabbing a classic bacon, egg & cheese or going all‑in on a specialty spread, everything tastes fresh and thoughtfully made. Service is exactly what you want from a beloved breakfast spot -- friendly, quick, and genuinely welcoming. You can tell the team cares about the regulars, the newcomers, and everyone in between. It's the kind of place where your order might be remembered before you even say it. The atmosphere has that old‑school charm that feels increasingly rare: cozy, unfussy, and full of personality. It's the perfect stop whether you're fueling up for the day or grabbing a weekend treat. Old Man Joe's doesn't try to be trendy -- it just nails the basics with heart, consistency, and flavor. And honestly, that's why it stands out. A must‑visit for anyone who appreciates a real bagel and a real neighborhood spot. Cheers

    The "Jersey Joe" Taylor Ham, egg & cheese on a toasted Everything bagel is the Best sandwich in the…read moreState!!! Hello Providence Journal, Westerly Sun and every other "Best Of" ratings out there!!! And that's the review! Thank you very much!

    Photos
    Old Man Joe’s
    Old Man Joe’s - Poppy seed bagel with (fresh) veggie cream cheese. Baked in house. Organic. Sourdough. Very generous with the poppy and sesame.

    Poppy seed bagel with (fresh) veggie cream cheese. Baked in house. Organic. Sourdough. Very generous with the poppy and sesame.

    Old Man Joe’s - The menu

    See all

    The menu

    Lighthouse Bakery

    Lighthouse Bakery

    4.2(121 reviews)
    3.7 mi
    $$

    I've heard of this place but finally made the visit! I have to recommend their Tiramisu Latte,…read moreprobably the best latte I've gotten out at a restaurant! Creamy and balanced, I was tempted to get another! We ordered the California Burrito and Big 55 sandwich. The jalapeño aioli paired with the carne asada on the burrito was unreal. Better than they make in Cali! Big 55 was everything you could want in a classic breakfast sandwich with sausage and bacon on a soft ciabatta with chipotle aioli. Last note - the guys behind the counter were so friendly, greeting everyone coming through the door! I swear they knew everyone, and introduced themselves if they didn't. Such a cool environment for a cafe in a place that doesn't always seem "local" based on tourism.

    Respectfully... what happened? This is psychological damage…read more I went out of my way to go to Lighthouse because I heard they had gluten-free options. They had gluten-free option, singular, so that's what I got. This plain gluten-free bagel with plain cream cheese ran me $7. I asked for it extra toasted. I got raw ass bread, slightly warmed up, with an insulting amount of cream cheese. So yeah you can get a gluten-free bagel here, but at what cost? (That's a rhetorical question - the answer is $7 & emotional distress). Anyways - I really hope they continue to stock gluten-free items, just with more intention & care. People will go way out of their way for a good gluten-free breakfast. It's gotta be good tho.

    Photos
    Lighthouse Bakery
    Lighthouse Bakery
    Lighthouse Bakery - Peppermint Mocha (seasonal) @coffeeinconnecticut

    See all

    Peppermint Mocha (seasonal) @coffeeinconnecticut

    Borough Bagel - bagels - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...