We visit in this area at least annually and always seek out the Mount Joy Gift and Thrift. On our…read morelast visit we were pleasantly surprised to find this shop in a new location and facility which is also more directly accessible. The store lives up to its name in that offerings are more on display vs resembling a garage or yard sale manner--more organized with space surrounding the houseware items. Clothes are neatly hung appear clean. I especially like viewing the donated China sets , gardening supplies and seasonal figurines. The prices range from reasonable to real bargains. Music adds to the relaxing browsing experience. Overall one of my favorite thrift stores!

The new store is great, we go here often and everytime we leave with great items. The prices are…read morereasonable not high at all, not sure why there are negative reviews on pricing people obviously hasn't been to a goodwill store lately. And to the lovely ladies that work there you all are kind and helpful and super nice to deal with. They also have a great selection. Great location and prices. A++++ will be returning for more great finds.

This is a must visit when in Marietta! Saw so many cool things, wish I could take half the store…read morehome!!Looking forward to seeing what else they get in stock in the future, will definitely be back.

A vintage collection of stores in an old time theater? Yes please! We saw a listing for one of the…read morevendors on yelp and decided one Saturday to stop in. What we found wasn't just one vendor, but a collection of various vendors all specializing in any and everything you could ever want! Vintage toys, anime and Japanese collectables and candy, video games, VHS and laserdisc, vintage décor ranging from Halloween to Christmas and beyond, clothing, Japanese Gundam and model kits. If something was missing a price or you weren't sure it was for sale, the guys up front will be more than happy to contact the owner of the stall and get you a price. We had the pleasure of meeting some of the owners/employees, all really cool guys passionate about local business and vintage goods. Its a little confusing as how it all works for a newbie, but basically you walk in, pick up a basket, and just peruse the site, which is a historic theater! What better setting for this place! Pick up what you want and head back to the front and they will ring you out there and answer any questions you have. The guys were knowledgeable about everything they had and went above and beyond to answer our questions. Prices were pretty reasonable based on the market now. Best advice I can give is don't come looking for anything in particular. Just peruse and enjoy the treasures you might find! Also BRING QUARTERS FOR THE PARKING METERS! I cant stress that enough. We talked to several shop owners and saw meter readers ticketing cars who were minutes within their spot expiring.

I went to their old location and it was ok but wow this new location blew we away. Every thing was…read morewell organized and thought-out. I'm a sucker for Halloween items and found so many things Ive never seen before. Items were clean, able to see, and in great condition. Staff was friendly and location perfect for an antique shop. There were so many cool things to see, great selection! It can be pricey but nothing surprising. Can't wait to visit again.

For those of you that thrift often, you're probably like me and wondering when, if ever, the Etown…read moreGoodwill location will open back up. It's supposed to be closed for "repairs" but it's been at least a year. Recently while calling to inquire about their reopening I was told that a new, temporary location has opened in Mt Joy to make up for and accept the donations that would otherwise go to Etown. Since opening 3 weeks ago I've been here twice. I hope this store ends up becoming permanent as it's closer to my house and has a better layout and parking. While it is a smaller Goodwill store as far as square footage it does have all the normal departments just on a smaller scale. Housewares are still arranged by color, with clear glass being dominant. Clothes are sorted by size and item (size organization is much better here than other locations too!). Prices are in line with other Lancaster Co Goodwill locations. Shoes are piled on top of clothing racks due to space limitations and there isn't a place to sit and try them on. I did find a small end table for sale under the linens that I pulled out as a seat, so hopefully it'll stay there for a while. There is no dressing rooms. Aside from that small end table they don't carry furniture. Pictures and frames are tucked under the racks and housed in large plastic bins, as are children's shoes. Over all the store has much less selection than other locations but the sorting is pretty solid. I didn't spend a lot of time looking at clothes knowing I couldn't try them on but didn't see any with flaws. They have yarn in baskets at the one end cap, as well as cards. They do tend to throw things in baskets that either sit on a shelf, floor, or end cap so do look thru those. They still have Christmas decorations for sale, in fact an entire isle of them. I didn't see any signs saying they were discounted, and currently the only loyalty promotion is the military discount. The children's department is very small, as is linens. The majority of the store consists of men's and ladies fashion. They do cute décor displays on the end caps facing the window, but the ones by the wall are pretty much a mess. No hand sanitizer is offered, nor is cart wipes, but overall the store is cleaner than most, employees are masked and a Plexiglas shield is present. Every employee I've encountered has always been friendly and helpful. A win for me because it's so close, I do hope this location stays. SIDENOTE: Isaac's is next door, located in a safe and active strip mall right on the main street rt 230

I was shopping in the Elizabethtown location. I found a beautiful blouse that I tried on and…read morereally liked. I had some other items in my cart as well. I get to the register and the blouse did not have a tag. The cashier said they couldn't sell it to me because it was untagged. I asked for her manager and she rolled her eyes and said...she's just going to tell you the same thing I told you. I don't know the woman's name but she came up and did in fact say the same thing...grabbed the blouse and went to the back....I offered her $10 for the blouse because I really wanted it. I got a resounding NO. Fast forward to the next day. I went back to the store, saw the blouse on the rack for $5.99. It had a tag on it this time and I snatched it up. They only got $5.99 when they could have received $10. Why did I have to endure that grief??

Excellent source of an array of items!! Houseware, clothing, shoes, bags - they have it covered…read more Friendly staff and throughout their social media they usually offer discounts or coupons- nice ways to get a little more bang for your dollar. It is a bit cramped but they offer a lot, thus space to move around is limited.

If I was a shopper I would rate this a 3-4 star experience. The store itself was well organized…read morewith nice displays. Inventory was plentiful. While I felt some prices were a tad high ($12.95 for mall store jeans), others were low ($12.95 for never worn CK flats). While I only meandered around the front of the store I would say alot of the styles were more catered towards a sophisticated, mature professional woman. However I didn't venture beyond the first few racks. Overall I think they are very picky with what they accept and it shows. I would consider this consignment shop more upscale and selective than others and wouldn't mind coming back to shop for myself. They obviously take great pride in their business. Aside from clothing I saw accessories and jewelry and believe they offer additional departments as well. As a seller I would consider the process cumbersome with little reward. My transaction was for a straight buy out and pennies on the dollar was paid out with what I considered too much paperwork for the merger amount I received. Honestly for a buyout you would do better having a yard sale. Some of my items were purchased for .60 cents. I don't know anything about their consignment terms which is more common and what they prefer but it would be worth looking into if your stuff is immaculate. So while I won't return for a buyout, and probably won't return to shop for everyday wear, I would come shop for any special occasion or high fashion needs.