The Old Steeple has a variety of seasonal gifts, home goods, a few food items, and decor. I agree…read morewith the other reviews that it's more of a gift store than antique shop. I would estimate that only about 10% of the inventory was antiques and many of these were bigger items like dressers. Several of the products I looked at were made by small businesses, such as the soaps and seasoning I bought. We came in December so the store had a lot of Christmas decor while we were there. I'd love to come back during another time of year to see what they have then as well!

I absolutely have to give this place credit for being such a cool shop, but it fell short of my…read moreexpectations. I paid a quick visit after going to Mayer Bros - this place is right down the street crossing Transit road, and is so easy to spot! They've got a small parking lot beside the building. The Olde Steeple itself is absolutely gorgeous - it's an old church built in 1880, and at one point the building had been burned down almost entirely. Extensive renovations eventually brought the Olde Steeple back to life, giving it new purpose by way of becoming a lovely shop, where you can now find some of the cutest home decor, craft items, even teas and coffee! The small barn in the back was donated to the Olde Steeple in 2010, and houses a ton of cool antique furniture pieces. I thought this place would lean more toward being an antique shop, but I didn't find very many antiques here besides what could be found in the barn. (They're listed in Sunday Driver, which is an antique shop directory for NY, so had guessed they would've had more antiques to offer.) I would classify it more as a country store if anything, though one that leans a little more toward the expensive side. I also thought this place would have had more locally made products. They had some awesome homemade jams, but the tea I bought came from SC, and one of the little decor items I bought came from China. The doily I bought also appeared to be mass-produced. I also noticed a lot of 1803 Candles products, which is a company based out of IL. There's nothing wrong with that, of course, but I would have looked more forward to spending what I did if they maybe had some Alpine Made stuff, or maybe some Amish linens and doilies? Maybe I got the wrong idea about what this place was supposed to be. But I will definitely visit again now that I know what sort of things they offer here. Just...don't plan on doing any serious antiquing at this place. Day 22

My NY friend and I visited this place and I was so delighted with all the vendors and art displays…read more The chapel is beautiful with high ceilings and stained glass tall windows. Items for sale were all reasonably priced and there were around 160 vendors. It took awhile to decide what I wanted/needed to buy. Finally bought 3 stained glass flowers ($5 ea) to put in my planters and a pretty necklace ($18). I wanted another necklace but it had no price and there was no answer from the artist after the cashier tried to get a hold of them which is a shame because they lost a sale). I was visiting from another state but I hope I get another chance to go back.

Beautiful church building which houses these wonderful items for sale. Always can find great gifts…read morehere. Highly recommend- you won't regret it

This place is super cute! Has an old time feel to it. Reminds me of when I was little with all the…read morecandy on the wall and the little Knick knacks to choose from. They have a deli and a lot of prepackaged dry goods selection. Some of the house decor is a little higher priced. I found some really cute stuffed veggie toys but they were nearly $60! Yikes. Overall, everything else was really nice. They had Amish made products too which we'll be back for. Staff was friendly :)

Store is lovely as always but I NEED to mention these subs. Saw a video on instagram so O went with…read moremy mom and WOW. I'm so impressed, like I only got a turkey, lettuce, tomato, and mayo...and i cannot stop saying how good it is and for only $7?? It's so fresh and sooo tasty you need to go.

This store is a great addition to Derby New York. Items are quality. The prices are fair. I love to…read moresupport small business in a small community whether you're looking for a gift or something for your own home or unique display and feel help you to find the right item. It is attached to, the ace hardware so you can accomplish multiple tasks while shopping. I truly enjoyable experience. I purchased candles here and enjoy them very much. Best of luck.

This store is absolutely amazing. They have incredibly friendly and helpful staff who helped me…read morepick out the perfect gift. They have unique gifts for anyone or anything which makes me love coming to shop there. The prices are reasonable the quality of the items makes me feel confident in all of my purchases. Being located next to Ace is a huge bonus for me as well because I can get all my shopping done in one trip. I would 10/10 recommend this place to everyone.

Beautiful store! The proprietor was welcome and we had a nice conversation. We found a little…read morebook box that we are going to give to our daughter for her 16th birthday.

After seeing a sponsored ad on social media, I knew I had to stop in here at some point. The time…read morecame on a Saturday in late October when I wandered into this magical store off Central in Lancaster. The shop owner was friendly and the store was welcoming. There were many items that caught my eye and I had to wrangle myself in. I purchased a pair of earrings and two pairs of socks. I got some Christmas shopping done. I will definitely return before the holiday shopping season is over. They have bath items, candles, serving items, barware, clothing, accessories, and so much more.

This place is in an amazing old house that they totally gutted and redid. Lots of new and ventures…read moreitems. A fun place to burn an hour. The owner Grace was exceptionally nice.

This was an unexpected pleasant stop! The outside is very deceiving -hiding the gems inside…read more Tons of stuff inside! The proprietor was very nice to chat with and welcoming. The store was well organized and clean!!

Awesome place for treasure-hunting if you enjoy DIY home projects or are renovating a house. If…read moreyou love watching home renovation shows, this is the place those people would shop for all the good stuff. They have SO MANY cool things of all ages, from antiques to newer stuff, everything including the kitchen sink. Prices vary widely but most items are clearly marked so you'll know which things are within budget and which are the splurges. Bricks and countertops are in the fenced-in outdoor area. The staircase to the second and third levels is just inside the main entry on the right, and there is a gender-neutral restroom there too. Staff is friendly, helpful, and easy to find. Parking is available on the street (free, no meters). I also met a very sweet and friendly shop cat wandering around. Bonus points for the shop cat. Note - as with any large building full of really cool very old building materials, there is a pervasive musty smell in the air, so if you're sensitive to those things (allergies, asthma, etc.) a mask might be a good idea.

Excellent place to visit for a variety of items...vintage doors, windows, knobs, sinks, lighting &…read moremore. Staff were knowledgeable and friendly. Will return again. I bought a small piece of stained glass & incense burner both very reasonably price.

Charming store in the village with a great staff! I love the selection of clothes and home decor…read more Emma is always sweet and helpful. Highly recommend going whether it's for yourself or a gift for someone else.

As a loyal customer who has followed you from 3 stores and have always enjoyed shopping at the…read moreNest, I had an unfortunate experience last week when after a 2 hour drive to the store from my house. I had shopped half of the store when I needed to use the restroom. I asked to use theirs but was told no. I asked again as it was an emergency, and was told I had to go up the street. I spent 1000s of dollars in your store and was told again to go up the street. (I'm almost 80 years old). My friend who also shops there frequently had a similar experience with rude staff and has decided to not shop there anymore. Emma was the staff member I consulted with. I'm disappointed and sad to report I won't be back.