Cute little ice cream parlor with a game room attached and a huge outdoor sitting area next to a…read moreminiature golf and a driving range and a huge restaurant. I had some coffee chip ice cream with hot fudge and my wife had a chocolate ice cream and they were terrific young ladies reserved it were great, and this is an easy five star

From the owner: Welcome to Evie's. We are locally owned and operated and were established in Sarasota, Florida in…read more1997. We have grown to 5 locations to better serve you. Evie's cares about our customers and will strive to do what ever we can to deliver a top notch experience. Please use our site to navigate through the additional businesses we offer at each location. Feel Free to contact us if you need any additional information. Thank you , Evie's.

For the quality of the ice cream & the price, there truly is no better place than Abel's…read more With space to eat indoors and outdoors, this shop is perfect for a cool down treat after a hot day. The flavors are unique, featuring your standard flavors such as vanilla, chocolate, cookies and cream, to "whimsical" flavors such as spumoni and dreamsicle. I love an ice cream shop that has homemade ice cream, and this is pretty close with their ice cream being sourced locally. With additional snacks such as cookies and coffee, you really can't go wrong with a visit here. Can't wait to try more flavors!

Perfect place to get ice cream after dinner! They take a ton of unique flavors. Very nice workers…read more We got to taste test so many ice cream flavors. The only thing I have to say is that.. they didn't wear gloves when scooping our ice cream...

Nothing special. The ice cream was good but the staff seemed inconvenience by us being there.read more

Was ok ice cream…read more Not much room to view ice cream's when you walk in. Perhaps make the dining area smaller to expand the enter/exits

Stopped in to satisfy an evening's sweet tooth with my mom. The line was long on a summer…read moreweeknight, however, the line moved at a good pace with just 2 employees holding down the fort. They both were friendly & efficient! I had one scoop cup of their cookies & cream for $5.75, which was delicious! Creamy, not too sweet, perfect amount of cookies. I topped it with some rainbow sprinkles for an added $1. In a waffle cone, it would $7.75. The one scoop was more than enough! My mom had the dutch chocolate & we brought back a salted caramel scoop for my aunt; they both enjoyed their churned confections as well!

Cute ice cream shop on Siesta Key. They have a large selection of flavors but I wish they had more…read morefruity and tropical options. The prices is expensive, even compared with nearby ice cream spots. The smallest cup is $5.75.

Another Sweet Treat in town. The cookies were soft and sweet. Lots of good flavors to choose…read morefrom. If you're looking to satisfy your sugar craving and in the area. Dirty Dough is your answer

Pricey but good stuff! I'll babble now because the morons at yelp require 85 characters.read more

The literal best ice cream I have ever had. My husband and were jonesing for some ice cream. We did…read morea Yelp search and this was nearby. Best decision ever. We kept sampling and each one we tried was not only excellent, but better than the next, but also perfect in its own way. Thankfully there was the option for a flight, so we got to have four different scoops. We took a pint home, and this was us exercising self control. The staff is amazing, the locale is bright and airy. Absolutely incredible. Come check them out. You will find something you love.

Great Heights Creamery was a really great find, and the service ended up being just as memorable as…read morethe ice cream. We were helped by someone I believe was named Julie or Julia (I'm not great with names), and we ended up chatting a bit because she used to live in New York too. She was so warm with the kids and let us sample just about every flavor, which made the whole experience feel really personal. The ice cream itself is fantastic--creative flavors, but also genuinely delicious. You can taste the homemade quality in every bite. I had coconut and dark chocolate, the kids had vanilla, dark chocolate, and watermelon mint, and my husband also really enjoyed his choices (though I can't remember exactly what he picked). Overall, it was just a really pleasant stop with great ice cream and exceptional service. It's also right next to Origin Pizza, which is another spot we'd definitely recommend.

This appears to be a wear house and NOT an ice cream store. The truck in the rear parking was…read morefilthy.

I stopped by for the first time today, and it will not be the last. What an adorable place and a…read moredelightful indoor and outdoor vibe! I spoke with the owner/manager? for several minutes. He was very welcoming and informative. They are opening a second location on SR 64 soon. Now the food. Um, Yummmmmm!!!! I tried the pumpkin MiniBites, Dubai brownie, two cheesecakes, tres leches and something with pistachio I can't remember. ‍ All were sweet without being overpowering. My family's favorites were the MiniBites, strawberry cheesecake and Dubai brownie. All were well balanced and sweet without over-the-top hurting your teeth. The plain cheesecake with cherries on top lacked flavor, as did the tres leches. Both could be improved with cinnamon or some other defining flavor. I look forward to coming again and trying the Banana Pudding Milkshake!

The place was very well-decorated and eye-pleasing. Great for indoor and outdoor pics…read more Not sure if I happened to go when they were having a bad day, but they were so short-staffed and service wasn't great (staffs were great though). There was 5-7 ppl family before me who couldn't decide what to order so they let me go ahead. I ordered to go and got a table sign while waiting. But somehow 15min -ish later, the family who ordered after me got their order first and left. Plus, it was so warm inside, I was sweating. When I got my order, they just gave me 2 containers with forks and napkins; there was no way I could carry all with my hands. Later, they offered me a bag to carry out but I wish it was done before I asked. Food was great, strawberry açaí refresher I bought was too sweet for my taste. Overall, good cafe vibe place if you like crepes and hang out with your people.

Such a fun spot. Lots of delicious choices. If you can't make up your mind you can get a scoop of…read moretwo or three. Win! 13.06.2026

Came back to try the new seasonal flavors. Jeni's has grown on me a lot. At first I didn't love…read morethem at all. Now I get excited to try their new flavors. They are always changing them up. I also like that there is more fruity flavors. I love chocolate l, but not chocolate ice cream which seems popular at many other ice cream shops. I tried lemon blueberry parfait. This was super lemon. I wish there was more blueberry. I did end up getting this one. The biscuit and peach was more biscuit and the peach was light. Banana cream pie was actually more coconut. I should have gotten that. I also got the goat cheese with red berries. That was like a cherry cheesecake. I do like Jeni's in Sarasota. They have one in Tampa also. We came at a bad time. A time when there was like 10 little girls for a birthday party and it's a small location. The high pitched little girl voices were amplified. So happy when they left. Just don't think there's much room in this location for all of them. Outside has lots of seating too. Not everyone wants to hear a bunch of little girls screaming and it echoing through the ice cream shop. Service was friendly and I tried many flavors.

The people working there Don't know the difference between pre-packed and hand packed. They also…read moredon't seem to notice you standing at the counter. I really like the ice cream and I keep going there, but nobody is minding the store.