The literal best ice cream I have ever had. My husband and were jonesing for some ice cream. We did…read morea Yelp search and this was nearby. Best decision ever. We kept sampling and each one we tried was not only excellent, but better than the next, but also perfect in its own way. Thankfully there was the option for a flight, so we got to have four different scoops. We took a pint home, and this was us exercising self control. The staff is amazing, the locale is bright and airy. Absolutely incredible. Come check them out. You will find something you love.

Great Heights Creamery was a really great find, and the service ended up being just as memorable as…read morethe ice cream. We were helped by someone I believe was named Julie or Julia (I'm not great with names), and we ended up chatting a bit because she used to live in New York too. She was so warm with the kids and let us sample just about every flavor, which made the whole experience feel really personal. The ice cream itself is fantastic--creative flavors, but also genuinely delicious. You can taste the homemade quality in every bite. I had coconut and dark chocolate, the kids had vanilla, dark chocolate, and watermelon mint, and my husband also really enjoyed his choices (though I can't remember exactly what he picked). Overall, it was just a really pleasant stop with great ice cream and exceptional service. It's also right next to Origin Pizza, which is another spot we'd definitely recommend.

Tasty little treat on LWR Main Street! Stopped in for a single scoop of the vanilla moose tracks…read moreand it did not disappoint. Lots of options here, I think probably close to 20 if not over. They had some local ice cream and Hershey. Sample some of both and very fresh and creamy. Nothing to out of this world about the ice cream but good solid flavor about $7 for one scoop in a waffle cone. If in the area I'd come back but would go out of my way for it.

Yes! Loved this little ice cream shop with a wide variety of flavors. My Cookie Monster was great!…read morePerfect place to stop into after being out in the heat during Memorial Day weekend parade. Yum!

I recall the excitement when this ice cream shop first opened its doors, bringing a fresh wave of…read moreenthusiasm to our community. The staff here are remarkably friendly and efficient, making every visit enjoyable. The adorable decor and thoughtful touches, such as the children's area, create a welcoming atmosphere for all. With a diverse range of unique flavors alongside classic favorites, their ice cream is a true treat. Whether you choose a cone or a cup, you can't go wrong - every scoop is tasty proof to their dedication to quality and customer satisfaction.

Delicious ice cream !!! Great service and plenty of flavors…read moreeven no sugar added options

Been getting Blue Moon for as long as I can remember! Hands down my favorite ice cream. I visit…read moreevery time I come to Cortez from Ohio!

Delicious as always! We come every year and they never disappoint! Also, the hours are different in…read morethe summer...open until 10p!!!

Nothing special. The ice cream was good but the staff seemed inconvenience by us being there.read more

Was ok ice cream…read more Not much room to view ice cream's when you walk in. Perhaps make the dining area smaller to expand the enter/exits

Late night ice cream shop which was a good way the end the night…read more It's on a nice little strip to walk up and down with parking on the sidewalk but it' does get packed. The ice cream was good and fairly priced

Ice cream was great. Clean and fast. Lots of options and location is perfect in downtownread more

I visit Big Olaf's strictly for the nostalgia - it's where I lost a tooth as a kid eating ice…read morecream, after all! But after returning years later, it's unfortunately lacking. Though advertised as homemade ice cream, their product seems to come from a company called Yoders. Disappointing, but the ice cream was still tasty. The Kahlua ice cream had great flavor and I'm a sucker for unique flavors. The price point isn't all that bad either, which Ben & Jerry's walking distance away charging 3x more, it makes this treat a steal. The ice cream itself could be a bit fresher, as it tasted freezer burnt. The staff here could also be a bit friendlier. Overall, Big Olaf's isn't what I remember it being, but if you're looking for a cheap scoop when walking around St Armands it is worth a visit.

We were excited to try Big Olaf's, but we walked in to find a store that could definitely do with…read moresome updates. The man behind the counter was responsive but not terribly friendly. Of course the ice cream was still good--it's ice cream!!--but some of it seemed a little stale/crystallized, like it hadn't turned over in a while. The tables were small and chairs could have been cute, but their metal seemed rusty and the tables were obviously in need of replacing. As we ate our ice cream (mint chip, pistachio, my daughter had cheesecake and my husband had white chocolate raspberry, his favorite), I looked at the billboard behind them... There were old cartoons probably cut out 15+ years ago, and an ancient map of St. Armand's circle. The cartoons and map had drips of ice cream on them and were faded and torn. There was a fun fact about ice cream...from 1999. We might have caught them on an off day, but I was not impressed. They're also "cash only" and had a faded picture of George Bush and a Charlie Kirk hat on display... Overall, they need to do a deep clean, refresh their decor and perhaps implement some payment technology to join us in 2026.

Fantastic selection! Great people! The staff was very…read morefriendly and the portions were substantial! We had a Dole Whip and a traditional vanilla malted. So good!

After a beautiful day at the beach, we were looking for an ice cream store and came across holy…read morecow. The older man was just standing behind the counter, staring at everybody like you were going to steal something when I asked him to describe a flavor. He was very nasty and rude about it, not all of their flavors had descriptions. We both decided to get soft serve which should never be categorized as ice cream. It was frozen ice at best. It was definitely not ice cream. And they barely put any sprinkles on the cone. They used a spoon and just sprinkled it across the top so whatever stuck which wasn't much. We were going to walk out, but the young girl was very sweet. It was also very expensive and so not worth it.