After a long drive to spent the weekend in VT, we were happy to come across this restaurant and have some good food. After entering the restaurant, we were confused because it was two sections, one was a deli counter and another is the small dining area. Sat down and ordered. I got the steak and fries, I enjoyed it. Definitely can be a bit seasoned and buttery. The truffle fries is sooooo good! The calamari was good as well. Service at first was okay. We were confused that the waitress looked at us confused lol but later she opened up and was so kind about everything. I guess it's the weather that got everyone tired out here lol read more

See all

We came into Castelton on a snowy evening so we was very happy to see a restaurant still open. The best thing we had were the truffle fries. Everything else was okay. The steak was cooked perfectly but wished it was seasoned properly. The pasta Mediterranean should be taken off the menu all together. The sauce was watery and overcooked noodles. Nice restaurant but food can be improved. read more

See all

Took a large group here. With lots of kids. There was plenty of room for us. They put tables together for us. I called ahead and the lady answered all my question. The pizza was huge! The wings were good! I appreciated the attentive care they gave our large group. And how the pizza went a long way. While they did end up over charging on our bill and I didn't notice until we got home. I was still happy with the experience and will return. read more

Hosted a party for about 30 in the blue cat. Food was perfect, nice and hot, and our server was attentive. The ceiling will always be my favorite part of this intimate dining area. read more

Blue Cat Bistro - Small party for 30 in the blue cat - Bars Near Me - Castleton, Vermont

See all

When I walked into the restaurant it smelled like burgers and pizza. It was nice. I ordered a rocket burger that came with a really good sauce. The rocket burger had fresh lettuce with fresh tomatoes. The bun was buttery and crispy. The burger was juicy and the fries were crispy. There was also a lot chip selection. I recommend getting the rocket burger with extra rocket sauce . Next time I go to the gym I'll make sure to go back there. read more

Ordered a cubano wrap pulled pork was sliced dried 2 pickle cheese and 1/4 cup of mustard. Took four napkins to wipe off enough mustard to eat. Pretty bad even for a small town. Left half behind decided I had been punished enough for patronizing this .................... read more

We liked the Blue Cat, located in the same building as the pizza shop on Castleton's main street. Small, intimate and cozy atmosphere, they have great service and a decent, ever-changing menu. They serve meats and a variety of pastas and Italian dishes. A wine list has a good selection and lots of by-the-glass selections. Make reservations as they only have about eight tables, so space is limited. Desserts are very decadent and delicious. read more

We stopped by for lunch while looking at homes in the area. I had the special, burger and fries for $5! The bun was toasted, burger cooked perfect, fresh crisp lettuce, tomato, 2 slices, fries piping hot and a side of ketchup on the plate. What a great lunch! Had some blue berry soda which was quite tasty. Friends lunch was just as good. Where they make the sandwiches was impeccably clean, all the vegetable were fresh and crisp. The atmosphere was very casual, make your own way in getting a table, etc. without question I would stop again. Thanks for a great lunch. read more

A little little difficult to find but with the hunt. Very cutely decorated and has a nice feel to it. The herbed complimentary bread is delicious and starts the meal off right. We had the calamari to start and was one of the best that we've had. Each of us had respective pasta dishes, which were big in portion and flavor. read more

We go there a few days a week. Usually good-free wings Thursday & Friday then stay for dinner!! The menu on the webpage is over a year out of date. I asked for items on that menu no can get. I feel it is false advertisement & asked the update the menu but no luck. There is no excuse for this! Maybe this review will get some action. Fingers crossed. I would like the old menu on the web now to come back as it had more variety We went back 5-6-17 Tried the shrimp scampi. Not like any scampi I ever had. Served in a lemon sause!! Did not finish it. Not looking good for them read more

I have been there twice lately and I hit the bullseye with the food and drinks : delicious food (fish tacos one day and ribeye the next, were excellent) and there was an ample offering of wines and mixed drinks. Beers good also. It's sad they don't open for a full menu dinner every day though. Only Tuesdays, Thursdays, Fridays (and Saturdays ? ...) If it had a lake view it would be tops, but a slice of the view of almost quaint Castleton is good enough. read more

I had their famous Lemon Chicken, and I liked it quite a bit. I thought the sauce was especially flavorful, with a bit of sweet lemon, but overall very creamy and savory. The free bread they had were pretty tasty as well. It's a bit confusing to find, as it's somewhat behind the pizza place/deli, but part of the same building. I loved that they offer local beers, and the dining room is such a deep, lovely blue. read more

Blue Cat Bistro - a bar with bottles of alcohol - Bars Near Me - Castleton, Vermont

See all

My wife and I come here often. Our daughter was a server here for a short time, so we've become familiar with the staff. The recognize us every time and treat us with some extra attention - even the newly hired staff who never worked with our daughter. We always enjoy eating at the Blue Cat; it's one of our favorite restaurants in the area. Our favorite entrees are the Eggplant Parmesan and the Chicken Chèvre. I think we've tried just about everything on the regular menu, and some of the specials; I don't think we've ever been disappointed in a meal. No matter what you choose, it will be a win. read more

I feel like giving it 1 star is over rating it. We were going to order take out pizza,a large for $18.75. We were told over the phone the same pizza would be only $5.00 if we ate at the restaurant and enjoyed a drink. We had never been there before. We go in and sit at a booth , we wait and wait , several staff there, no one comes to help us. My husband walks over to the counter and gets our pizza we had ordered over the phone himself. We are told a waitress will bring plates and napkins. We wait and wait , no one comes , pizza now getting cold. We had to go find staff to get our own plates. No one came to take a drink order, had to go to bar and get our own drinks. We noticed other customers being waited on with no issue and it really was not busy. Very poor service, pizza mediocre at best. read more

The food is okay but what's not okay is falls advertising on there online menu. If you call in and order to pick up, expect to pay extra! I ordered a $15.95 slice of lasagna and they charged me $17.95. Two waitresses clame there prices have gone up since the online menu was made. Like it's my fault. One of them mentioned it had been like that for almost a year now. I wouldn't care so much if it was a week or so but a year is way too long sand considered falls advertising. Especially when they wouldn't do anything about it and charge me full price. read more

Great, consistent food. Excellent bread, appetizers, good specials every night. Entrees are generously portioned and delicious. Great small atmosphere, but make a reservation on a weekend! read more

We went there last winter and I was cranky and starving. What a treat to find a cozy little spot with a simple, fairly priced menu. Relax, have a glass of wine and look up at the ceiling. read more

It's cheap at least inconsistent to say the least it seems everytime I go in it's a totally new staff so its perpetually new people just figuring out how to make a pizza then they leave and the cycle begins again. Much better options in town read more

Have been here before and usually have excellent service and food so I'm hesitant to give only one star. However, earlier this evening we checked to make sure they would be open since we were arriving around 8:45. The hours were listed online as closing at 10pm. As soon as we pulled into the parking lot at 8:45 an employee ran to the door and locked it and shut the lights off. If their closing time is actually nine then they should change their hours online. Also, their employees could have a bit more tact in dealing with our situation. It was really awful to see an employee run to the door to lock us out. read more

Not a fan of this place. The food is typical American but lacks any unique flavor. The staff is a typical restaurant staff. I cant praise this place with much good but I can't say it is bad. read more

The friends who were with us on our prior visit, tried the Blue Cat Bistro again this year, and found that the service was still horrible, but the food was very good. I guess some things will never change. We might try it out again if we're in the area, and put up with the horrible service and enjoy the only thing which is good about this place - the food. read more

Not worth the money and staff suck! Waited in line for 29 minutes and that was only one person in front of me!

Pretty stylish and classy, but not dressy or over priced. Not just pizza, in fact I recommend you try an entrée. Attached to a take out deli that's decent. read more

This is my favorite local "go to" place for a well prepared meal, fair prices, atmosphere and decent service. Occasionally it's been a bit slow, but worth the wait. I have tried many of the entrees and there are no losers. Local in season produce is usually used. Desserts are awesome. There are really 2 dining experiences here: the pizza/deli in the front, or the sit down restaurant in the back. If I am too full for dessert or want an economic treat, the chocolate/ peanut butter bar cookies at the deli are a fabulous "to go" dessert to grab on the way out. I feel fortunate to live close to this place...advantages of a college town! read more

Cute little dining room. The food was very good. Started with a warm basket of bread. We had the Mediterranean pasta, the bourbon wings and the crispy goat cheese salad. All were delicious. Service was friendly and attentive. Will definitely eat here again. read more

Had their pizza last night, its was great. This was my first time trying their food, hope to return soon.

The service and welcome we received here was wonderful and that was the best part of the meal. Unfortunately, the food wasn't what we had hoped for. My husband ordered a pizza and it was kind of middle-of-the-road all right. My son had the ravioli and it wasn't that warm and was pretty bland. I ordered the Pasta Mediterranean and the mushrooms were gummy (canned), and the sauce was weird, kind of like sweet-and-sour sauce from a takeout Chinese restaurant. I couldn't muster up the motivation to eat more than a few bites of it. If we came back, it would be to get a pizza fix and not to experiment with any new concoctions. read more

I spend a good bit of time in Castleton during the summers, and I finally made it to the Blue Cat Bistro over 4th of July weekend. What a pleasant surprise this place was. The service was friendly, if a bit nervous. The menu is pretty straightforward and includes a number of Italian selections and burgers. I enjoyed the Mediterranean pasta entree. This was a perfect portion size of well-cooked linguine topped with mushrooms, onions, spinach, and sun dried tomatoes. Really tasty. I was also happy to see Switchback, a Burlington-brewed beer, on tap. That's always a treat for me. The others in my party ordered burgers and everyone enjoyed them. Finally, the space itself in the Blue Cat is beautiful. The ceiling is made to look like a planetarium or night sky, and is really unusual and interesting. The decor was very tasteful and the small bar area was really cute and inviting. I will definitely visit the Blue Cat again in the future. read more

This restaurant has a very nice dining room with an amazing ceiling. The food is pretty good, but there is nothing organc on the menu. They seem to keep odd hours - I've shown up and found them closed - so it's best to call before you go. Gay friendly. read more

Stopped in for a slice of pizza and salad for lunch. kind of a funky place that was really quite pleasurable. a little bit of a college 52 it with all the kids coming and going the food was reasonably priced I'm pretty good. a slice of pizza with extra large read more

Awesome place. Small little intimate place, which my wife and I enjoy. My wife and I have been in Vermont for a week. In that week, our dinner here was the best meal we had. Steak was perfectly tender. Calamari was nice and crispy. My wife's pasta dish was absolutely delicious. Waitress was extremely friendly. Service was quick. Ive recommended it to some other families. Take the trip! read more

Disappointed. We have been here several times and tonight was not the best we have experienced. The veal Marsala had great flavors, but was the toughest veal I have ever had anywhere. The carrot parsnip concoction was only slightly warm. We were never offered bread of any kind with our meal. We skipped dessert. The house salad with maple vinaigrette is always good. We tipped well, though, hoping it was just an off night. We heard the next table having a terrible time with their order as well. read more

The dining room is so cute and lovely. The ceiling is evening blue and painted with stars. The food is great and so is the beer and wine selection. read more

A nice find in an area not known for its cuisine. Menu includes many local foods and a small, but quality selection of microbrews on tap. Everything was fresh and delicious. Portion size was just right. Service was attentive and friendly. I will definitely be back. read more

Nice atmosphere and waitress was good. The salad and bread were very good. My wife's crab cakes were great but my blue cat burger was very dry and tough (overdone?)with little flavor. Advised the waitress who agreed but chef said it was the type of meat due to beef cattle being grass fed etc. May try again but without the burger! The chef could have offered another burger or substitute meal. read more

My family has eaten here at least 6 times, so it is with a heavy heart that I must admit tonight was our last attempt. The food is reasonably good - if you're not looking for something widely good, you should be happy enough here - but do not order the burger! Always dry. However, something is ALWAYS wrong. Tonight a topping was left off my husband's pizza and the onions were left off my meal. This was after a half an hour wait to get out food - and we were one of 2 tables in there. The waitress was apologetic about the missing ingredients, but not worried enough to replace them or adjust our bill - more like, "I'm so sorry about that." but then nothing. I'm sad to say that this is the norm there. Why would we eat there 6 times if something is usually wrong? Truth is there is just not that many options here and it looks nice, so sort of good to bring company too - you just have make a bunch of disclaimers before you get there and ask to keep a menu so you can compare what you get with what you ordered. read more