Pizza sauce tasted like Chef Boyardee, and there was too much on my sub. Asked for hot peppers, got jalapenos, 2 different things. Fries were cold. Steak hoagie was over seasoned. Generally like their pizza, but won't order subs again. read more

HOLY MOLY THEY DO NOT MESS AROUND. These pizzas are HUGE, we needed up with a couple sheet pizzas and OMG. I couldn't believe it, they weighed like 10 pounds each! For the price, these are a steal. They are huge and totally loaded down with toppings. They are not stingy. We got the Buffalo chicken with bleu cheese sauce and it was a HIT. The chicken finger pizza was also the bomb, I couldn't stop eating it. It wasn't too greasy and the crust was cooked perfectly. I'm super impressed and will definitely be ordering again! read more

I've traveled all around the country and have had pizza from all over...Without a doubt the steak pizza at Blasdell has to be in the running for best pizza in the country....**note there are also 2 other locations in the immediate Buffalo area** PRO TIP: get it with sweet peppers...they go better with the rest of the ingredients....This is advice coming from a hot pepper head. read more

Blasdell Pizza - Steak pizza (with sweet peppers) - Pizza Near Me - Dunkirk, New York

Pleasantly suprised... the other reviews had me skeptical about ordering from Blasdell Pizza but I was sold when I seen Pickle Pizza on menu. I've been wanting to try Pickle pizza for a few weeks, it seems to be the new craze. The 9" Pickle Pizza I received provided all the taste I had hoped for in a pickle pizza. I recommend ordering from this place, they seemed pretty busy with carry out and deliveries. The kitchen is big and can be seen well from counter. It appears to be a very clean and organized. That is important during this covid19 time frame read more

Blasdell Pizza - 9" Pickle Pizza. Very tasty, was everything I had hoped for. - Pizza Near Me - Dunkirk, New York

Good food service is fine but lacking on coverage of beards when preparing food. Complete Turn Off!!

The best pizza in the Dunkirk-Fredonia area! It's not cheap, but it's definitely worth it! I got a pizza with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms and onions today, but I usually add green peppers too. You're talking $25 for this large pizza, but You can't eat more than two slices! And it has the perfect amount of sauce, crusty dough, and quality ingredients. Thanks for touchless delivery, too! read more

Orderered a large pepperoni pizza and it didn't disappoint! My friend loves the little cups the pepperonis make. Took about 5-10 minutes longer to make than their estimate of 20-25 minutes but no big deal. read more

Just ordered a chef salad, a personal chicken finger pizza and a personal cheese pizza with olives and banana peppers. I got a garden salad. And a burned chicken finger pizza that was completely inedible and a burned cheese pizza. The person at the counter acted like it was so awful to take my order. This is the worst pizzeria in a 30 mile radius. read more

Absolutely terrible experience here. Not only is their food subpar and overpriced but they have terrible customer service. Sometimes you can ignore rude people if the food is good but nope. Don't waste your time or money here. read more

Well lets start off with this. You wont get what pay for. Simple order, double order of wings. Over a dollar a wing..not cheap to start. Got home to 15 wings which seems trivial but in reality is 25% short on the order. I have been a regular customer for years, and now I am done. I am overlooking the hour wait times in an area that openly deals crack a block away. Good riddance thieves. read more

I ordered a small pizza. It's about 8 slices. I had pepperoni on the whole pizza, with Italian sausage and green olives on half. The cheese was nice. Crust was thick and chewy. I liked the pepperoni, but didn't care for the flavor of the Italian sausage. The sausage was kinda dried out too. Sauce was ok. read more

Blasdell Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Dunkirk, New York

Ordered a small pizza and a chicken finger sub for pick up. Showed up a half an hour later like requested. Waited an hour once I was there for a cold pizza and a mediocre sub. I normally refrain from reviewing any restaurant on a one off basis but based on multiple orders I've had over this past year, this seems to be pretty much the norm. Always Late, poorly put together, DIRTY atmosphere. read more

The pizza isn't bad, and they deliver which is nice, though expect to wait 45min + for your order to arrive. Don't order a Chefs salad expecting ham, turkey, cheese, eggs and everything else that goes in a chefs salad...instead you'll get lettuce two cherry tomatoes and a can of chickpeas. read more

Their food is never consistent. I work nearby so my co workers and myself eat here often. One time you might have, say, the best taco salad you've ever eaten. Next time you order it the taco meat is cold, like legit came out of the fridge and they didn't bother heating it up, cold. And this is just one example. I boycotted the place a year ago, and recently I decided to give it a try, as my coworkers were ordering. I ordered a chicken caeser salad, I figured that was pretty basic, can't mess it up too bad. Began to eat it and the only topping on it, croutons, were mushy and stale. Oh and beard sticks that come with your salad are 9 times out of 10 so hard you could lose a tooth on them. I've permanently boycotted them now! read more

No customer service. Order was cold. 2 hours late and had no empathy. Done business and given aweso.e reviews before but never again! Worst service and food ever. read more

Basically we just ordered a pizza for a pick up, but I can at least tell you that it was better than many places - not the best, but by far not the worst either and they were both fast and priced right. Inside the place was also clean! read more

I would give it no stars if I could. Screwed up a simple salad and REFUSED to correct their mistake. Plenty of other great local pizza places, I would recommend going to one if them instead. read more

I ordered a chef salad with my friend and what we received was not a chef salad. What we got was lettuce with a few cucumbers. When my friend called and asked about this all they said was we should have ordered their antipasto salad. When asked to look up what a chef salad was the management looked it up and found it was suppose to include multi meats, eggs along with other things. He then said, "Oh that is our antipasto salad", but refused to correct the current order. read more

I wish I could rate 0/5; however, I don't have that option. The menu clearly states chef salad as a menu option. What I received....clearly not a chef salad. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chef_salad in case you were wondering the real definition of chef salad. read more

Consistently good pizza and chicken fingers. Me and my boyfriend usually end up ordering here when we aren't sure what we're in the mood for. I usually get the chicken finger or chicken souvlaki salad and it is very good and fresh. My boyfriend usually gets the chicken fingers and French fries. The chicken fingers are huge as a heads up. They also make a good pizza and have never messed up our order like many of the other local pizza places. Over all the food is good and consistent. read more

We got take out from them once, delivered right onto campus. It came promptly and was great for cheap food to break up the monotony of the 3 Fredonia dinning halls. I would recommend it to anyone wanting something a little more than the usual dinning halls. The pizza is not amazing but better than some local competition and possibly better than William Center's pizza. read more

They have really good pizza & wings, usually when I come here it's for their chicken finger pizza it's the best!

Overpriced for what's received; food does not taste good And is bland and the customer service is atrocious! I would not recommend this place to anyone read more

Terribly mislead From their menu....received chef salad without any of the ingredients that typically make up a chef salad. Management wanted nothing to do with making this right. read more

I agree with the other review 100%. The first problem they have is taking phone orders. A noisy background will guarantee a screwed up order at this place. They have no separation from the kitchen. You will have to repeat the order at least 3 times it will still be wrong when it arrives. Credit card orders are impossible, they will come back not approved because they can not hear the number correctly. They have a bubble gum chewing high school girl that can't remember her name without taking out her ID taking orders. The food is not Blasdell pizza quality. By calling this place Blasdell pizza they are hurting their reputation for the best of the best in NY. Change the name and call it Joe's slop house and fly by night pizza. It is the worst in Dunkirk! Rick Rummings read more

I've been frequenting this establishment for years now, and the selection has been improved a bit. Besides more flavors of wings to try, some of their specialty items have been refined. Yes, their pizzas are well received at my gatherings. I especially enjoy the white pizza with a garlic oil base instead of the traditional red sauce. For something different, the grilled chicken suvlaki on an herb wrap is so good I know I shouldn't eat the hole big thing ... but I do. Actually, several of the specialty sandwiches have become favorites. The veriety of foods offered seems to satisfy the whole gang of friends, so the larger group I find myself amung the more likely we are to be ordering from this spot. Delivery has always been prompt, but when it comes to wings, the more particular of my friends insists on going in for the pick-up. The grilled wings are so good, he's not taking any unnecessary chances on freshness. I say, either way, the extensive menu is always a crowd-pleaser. Why am I not giving this place a full 5/5 score? Its because the food preparation is not always up to their usual high standard. Being a college town, and the numbers of student workers that usually flutter in and out of the local kitchens, its no wonder quality sometimes suffers. Short of threatening to deep fry their mobile phones, there is really little to be done about the quality of workers in this town. Except for the odd shortfall, its normally quite good. read more

I have a different perspective than the other reviewers, I have never had the original Blasdell Pizza. I like the pizza from the Dunkirk store, but its not the best in the area. There i go there more for the salads, subs and bread sticks. I will say the best thing they make are there wings. I don't think the service is as bad as described in the other reviews but I have come to pick up orders and not all the order is ready because some one dropped the ball. Its not my first choice for pizza but when i am tired of the others in town its not that bad. read more

Good food, pizza is great and sub of the month is a good deal . Despite this ,the service is slow and almost every time I have been there they forget part of the order and I have wait while they start again and cook it. read more

Grabbed everyday special small pizza c p, single wings medium, after being disap by pv. Pizza has too much sauce, wings a little over deep fried. Tasty anyway, not the worst. read more

In my experience with Blasdell Pizza I haven't had to deal with the level poor service that others described, but I can attest to the fact that frequently when I have arrived to pick up an order (even sometimes 15-20 minutes later than the estimated time) it is still not ready. Generally I stick to subs and breadsticks when ordering from here, neither of which should be taking that long. Aside from that I have had positive experiences here with the food, but since I haven't had the food from the original Blasdell Pizza, I can't compare the two. read more

This place used to have some decent sub and pizza but recently it seems the owner is more worried about what the young ladies he hires look like instead of worrying about quality and customer service. In the last four or five times we have ordered it seems like something is wrong with each order. I don't recomend this branch of Blasdell Pizza and I will not waste another dime there. read more

This by far the best pizza in all of dunkirk and fredonia. The pepperoni pizza and honey mustard wings are delicious

This place only gets one star because I actually liked the pizza. Customer service is terrible. I ordered two wraps and other items around closing and they were inedible. There was no tuna on the wrap and they stuffed it with wet lettuce to make up for the lack of tuna. My chicken souvlaki wrap was so oily and wet from the lettuce that it slipped out of my hands when I tried to just hold it. I had to throw it away after two bites. I brought back a reciept after taking my disable mother home to buffalo, which consumed my day when I'm helping her pack up all of her things into my car and then unload. Not a single apologize from the employees.They were mad at me for every complaining and offered me only a small credit. This is unacceptable. They were so rude and unapologetic. The absolute worse customer service I've ever received. Im not sure why a business wouldn't keep receipts. I had the only itemized receipt I received but it was not suffienct enough proof. It wasn't even asking for a full refund. The girl that was working there when my Fiance picked it up was there, and it was absolutely dead when we picked it up, so I'm not sure how she couldn't remember making it. But she wasn't a manager so her word doesn't mean anything. read more

Bad to the bone! My family used to frequent Blasdell Pizza. The location was convenient, but the food was always average, at best. My most recent experience, though, has left me fuming. I ordered two large pizzas, one sausage and cheese, the other, veggie with sauce, no cheese. When I got them home, I discovered that they had not put any sauce on the veggie pizza.,,,just veggies and oil. When I took it back, they told me that it was my fault for not asking for "red" sauce. They would not take any responsibility. I left it on their counter and walked out. Upon returning home, I found that my father had tried to eat the sausage pizza. The crust was so tough that he actually broke a tooth on it. Now I need to take him to the dentist! My experience went from bad to worse...never again! read more

I ordered a triple order of wings half teriyaki half italian, I have had them before and they were awesome... This time I ordered them and the wings were very undercooked the skin stretched on the wings instead of being crispy and snapping... the inside was still pink and there were a few that looked they had been shredded with the tongs... what a waste of money... called and complained the didn't even offer to credit me or anything... smh guess i will stick to there subs.. The place has gone downhill in the last 5 years read more

Foods great but the receptionist needs an attitude change. She is clearly miserable and makes your exchange relatively miserable as well.

I like going here because you always know that its going to be good. Only reason I don't give it 5 stars is because 1 employee (a man-unknown name) should not be on the counter. He kind of lacks any people skills and doesn't crack a smile or any sort of expression at all, in fact he's kind of rude... I attributed it to a bad day but Its been more than once. It wont stop me from going there though! read more

let me start buy saying i have eaten at all 4 Blasdell stores and not my first at this location but this was one of the poorest takeouts i have ever. on 07/22/12 walked in and ordered the lg c.p. pizza and 24med wings wated for it so i should of gotten it fresh from the oven the wings were way over cooked and dry and i like crispy the pizza the crust was out in the air and then dropt and re risen agen you could see all the hard spots on the crust payed for first quilty got last place read more

My work orders pizza 2X a week. We kept trying new places each time and this place became our go to pizza place. Consistently good. Only complaint is the wings are kinda dry and bland. read more

I simply cannot agree with adam, I know for a fact that blasdell in dunkirk uses the same ingredients as every other blasdell pizza and in fact sells more pizza than any other pizza place in the dunkirk fredonia area. People don't order food they don't like, so the "other people" that you probably asked are most likely bull shitters! There is on the book proof that blasdell out ranks all other sellers of pizza. read more