I was too hungry to get a pic. Sorry. We're transplants so I've never had anything from Mary's until I finally had cash and was leaving an appointment in dunkirk. Get cash. The fredonia Mary's isn't the same people and clearly I think some of these comments are about the fredonia one. Anyway, I walked in and asked for a menu, which nailed me as new. The regulars and the owner, Kevin, were wonderful to me. It reminded me of Philly and I felt at ease amongst loud, generous, happy-no-nonsens, folks. Got a turkey and provolone sub. Good almost sweet oil/vingar mix. Delicious wheat bread. Think cut turkey slices. Good amount of cheese and thick cut toppings. I prefer my onions sliced super thin but hey, I can't complain about the peppers and other veggies. After a not so fun appointment and the terrible state of our democracy, I left here feeling like there was good in humanity and neighbors and neighborhoods. read more

Pizza on time and delish. Traveled from out of town Will be back when in Dunkirk. Sauce is very unique. Sweet and delicious read more

Ricky telling people he's an idiot because he doesn't know how to cook food properly isn't a good business look. Crazy how the food only comes under cooked when he's the one who makes it. Terrible service , won't be ordering from here again. read more

Mary's Deli - Raw bread sticks - A sandwich with breadsticks and melted cheese is shown, held by a person's hand, with a cardboard box and foil-lined tray in the background. - Pizza Near Me - Dunkirk, New York

I work in the food industry and it's wild the prices! I only order here every now and then because they have homemade blue cheese and most places around here just use Ken's... from here on out I'll be making my own blue cheese! And not ordering from here! read more

Every time I visit Dunkirk I get an Italian Stallion sub. It is THE BEST sun ever!! Everything is delicious but the sun is my favorite. read more

In an area with a TON of competition the Dunkirk Mary's never let me down. The wings are always crispy and pizza on point. Love their BBQ wings and Chicken Finger Pizza (add bacon). An added bonus is their delivery drivers have always been professional. You aren't dealing with a 20 year old who will quit/get fired next week. I always tipped well for a delivery to Fredonia and they were more than happy to make the trip for me read more

Food is great but this isn't the stone age. Upgrade your payment options. I'd order from there more if it wasn't a cash only business.

After living out West in WY & CO & TX for 1 1/2 years I was craving a good NY Pizza. This place hit the SPOT! My large pep @ gr beef thick pizza was phenomenal! Their dough, not pasty heavy was light and flavorful to say the least ! I also loved the pizza sauce - slightly sweet and reminded me of an Italian family (grandma's) recipe. Keep up the GREAT WORK ! read more

Here's the thing, the food is delicious, subs are obviously made with high quality meat and bread. However, my girlfriend has dietary restrictions due to problems with her gallbladder, and we asked for the condiments on her sub to be on the side instead of on the sandwich. When we got the food, her sandwich was slathered in mayonnaise, completely soaked into the bread and dripping out of the sides. Delivery took and hour and a half, and on top of it they only sent two out of the four drinks we ordered. The food is good, but I wouldn't bother with delivery, and if you have dietary restrictions I'd avoid it completely. read more

I love this place, eat here almost every time I come home. The Sicilian-style (sweet) sauce is my favorite, plus the cheese, never greasy. I usually ask for less cheese and for my pizza to be extra browned. Never had their subs, wings, salads or pasta -only pizza- in 30 years. They're always, always super nice, not sure what the complaint is about..No cards accepted. read more

Mary's Deli - Mary's Deli means eating pizza pulled over in the car, while it's hot. (But it's also good cold!) - Pizza Near Me - Dunkirk, New York

Their service is terrible and the food is very poor I can't believe Little Caesars pizza has a hole pizza for just $5 bucks and great service with nice and pleasant workers that want to serve the customer. U can fool a person once but u sure can't do it a second time. Anyone thinking of this place should consider other pizza places. The only reason I gave a one star it's because they would not let me post it with out a star but this place does not deserve a star what so ever. I give it a big 0. read more

Mary's Deli - My cold soggy pizza from Mary Deli 0 - A slice of pepperoni pizza with melted cheese and pepperoni slices is being lifted from a foil-lined pizza box. - Pizza Near Me - Dunkirk, New York

See all

The man who served my order was so friendly and kind. I had left wallet at home and he waited for me to return with the cash The food was excellent. My sister's tuna sandwich was the best she has had in a long time and she is a lucky eater. The wings were so tasty that i ate all ten without looking back. Small deli that deserves more space and some tables to eat there! Next time I am in Dunkirk. Mary's is in my list of must go to places. read more

I have been coming here since I was a kid. I have moved away now but make it a point to always come and get their amazing subs! The service is amazing, attention to detail like none other, and quality of pizza and subs is fantastic! It seems like a little old city Italian deli ambiance. You will not go wrong if you are in the mood for amazing subs or pizza! read more

This is a Dunkirk classic! The sweet sauce is the best sauce I've ever had & I always ask for an extra cup for dipping my crust. My favorite pizza hands down read more

Been there twice. I'm from out of town, but visit Dunkirk every couple of months. Mary's is now my "go to" place for a slice and a sandwich. Love it! read more

Why I'm giving it 3 stars..... Being gone for 5+ years I couldn't wait to get the famous Mary's deli pizza when I arrived home. I being a mother was a little scattered on the phone while I was talking.... so I understand the irritation from the other end of the phone. People are probably professionals ordering from this place so maybe it's annoying to get questions during busy hours but a typical restaurant is happy to answer any questions that are being asked - guess not this one. Totally understand busy/tired/or anything else ....but still customer service is always an *extra star*. I called at 7:32 and got my food at 8:4and I could of picked it up since I'm not that far away. so now - guess whose irritated? During the phone call, I simply asked what sizes and prices for the pizzas were because I did not have a menu on hand and on a little budget. I then got a rude and aggravated response. I felt like I called a stranger and woke him up from a much needed nap. I then stated I wanted"Buffalo wings" being in the south that has phrase has grown on me - I know it's simply just "hot wings/wings" so the response being "I don't know what that is." "Umm, hot sauce?" "We only have hot, medium, and mild." (In an aggravated tone) Ummmmm.....did I call the dunkirk Mary's delis? Sarcasm is funny when you laugh or have a cheerful voice. Lastly, I said let me get my card or do you take cash and got hung up on. The best part of all this the driver arrived stating they didn't take cards. - Ha! Wish I knew that before; so in that 1 hour and 40 minutes I could of grabbed cash. That should be stated as you hang up since this is the last restaurant on the planet that doesn't take cards and typically most people don't carry cash... We all have bad/busy days but there's no excuse for a restaurant to be so rude and condescending- the reason they have 3 stars is because the food is good (even though it was luke- warm by the time it arrived) but I guess I'll just get my wing and pizza fix elsewhere. read more

I've been coming here for years! Love their wings & my favorite thing to get from here would definitely be the Italian stallion sub! That is a must try! read more

Have to say one of the best pizza joints in the USA. I have ever yet to find a pizza that is better. Best breadsticks as well.

Hands down the best pizza in Dunkirk! I've been to all the local pizza shops in the area and if your looking for quality pizza then I would definitely try this place out. If you like a sweeter pizza sauce this is the place for you. The crust is really good as well. The nice thing about the pizza is they don't load it with cheese, so it's more on the lighter side. I hear the subs are good to, but have yet to try them. read more

Trash. Bitch on the phone was rude af. Id put her name here if i knew. We ordered and joked about how much blue cheese we wanted and then threathened to hang up if we keep playing. Lmao. You're taking orders for a living youre already a joke. So we get our food and its dry wings, pizza tastes like there was dish detergent on it and literally got a small styrofoam cup of blue cheese. You think that thats enough for 50 wings and a party pizza? People here are ridiculous. read more

I got a American sub here and it was one of the best subs I've had in a while loaded with meat fresh and tastey

My place for pizza when I come home. The best pepperoni pizza and breadsticks around. Something about the sweet sauce and that handmade crust. Ask for a side of pizza sauce to dunk your breadsticks. They haven't updated the place for my entire life so it still has its original hole in the wall charm. So delicious... read more

Best sauce in America with the best hospitality making it m, one slice or an apple pie or maybe an amazing hot or cold sub

This cute little pizza joint has become the old stand-by for delivery in our household. Their pizza sauce is on point, and they have some of the best wings in the area (I personally enjoy the butter garlic and honey mustard.) While I've sometimes waited up to an hour for delivery, the food is always warm when it arrives and always worth the wait. read more

This is take out only. They sell pizza, subs, wings, etc. Also have some desert options. A great place to pop in, get a slice of pizza and a drink, and go. Slices always ready. Home made pizza is very good, NOT gas station pizza. The wings are fantastic! Our favorite is garlic parmesan! A great place to get a party pizza with wings. The BEST SUBS IN THE AREA PERIOD! Hot or cold! My favorites are the Italian Roast Beef Sub and the Italian Stallion Sub! The subs have so much meat on them I usually get 1/2 of a sub. The ITALIAN STALLION has so much meat on it 1/2 of a sub must weigh a pound! Two people can easily have it cut in half and both have plenty! We go there often. Things that take time like wings or a party pizza we call the order in and then pick it up. We usually get subs a go to the Point where there are plenty of picnic tables overlooking Lake Erie. WARNING-CASH OR CHECKS ONLY. NO CHARGE CARDS. There are plenty of ATM's in the area. read more

Always stop at least once whenever I visit my parents. Try as I might, I just can't find any mom and pop pizza joints like this since I left Dunkirk, at least not w/ the same quality food. Obviously can't beat western NY wings, and Mary's Deli's are top notch. Subs and calzones are great too, but the Pizza is where it's at! Last I knew they still didn't take Credit Cards. read more

Possibly the worst meal eve.r Very over priced. I have given them several opportunity's and they failed each time. Ordered a white pizza one time and could not even finish the slice. They have been in business way too long and have become very lazy in every aspect read more