The woman helping us was knowledgeable and patient with us since it was our first time. My husband…read morewanted a super thick shake that's almost like blizzard, and she was able to make it for him. Everything was delicious! We will definitely be back some time

Brought my nephews as we're doing a tour of ice cream places in Columbus. Small interior but…read morefriendly staff who let us have samples. One got a strawberry shake, another got the cotton candy and some other kid flavor ice cream and I got a flurry (like a blizzard- vanilla ice cream with Reese peanut butter cup pieces). I wish there was more than one size because it was huge but it was really tasty. We all enjoyed what we had, they didn't haven't bottles of water when we visited but they did give us cups.

While visiting Columbus, OH, I asked a few locals for their favorite ice cream spots, and they all…read morepointed me to Graeter's Ice Cream. I am so glad they did. It was so good that I found myself thinking about it all week. The shop has a charming old school vibe that makes the whole experience feel nostalgic and special. The customer service was fantastic and the staff happily let us sample different flavors before we made our final choice, which made it even more fun. Every flavor we tried was rich, creamy, and full of flavor. You can really taste the quality. I will definitely be going back again and again. Highly recommend if you are in the Columbus area and craving amazing ice cream.

Oprah made a big deal about it, so I had to check it out. And when I saw Mayor Coleman there, that…read morewas all the endorsement I needed. From the Banana Chocolate chip to the Madagascar Vanilla bean. Everything I've had is sharp to the taste and addictive! I'm a straight vanilla guy by nature, but it would be an insult to this place NOT to take advantage of its many blessings. So yeah, I'm working my way around that menu. You should too! I would say, "There's nothing Graeter," but that's been worn out, I'm sure. Check it out and see, or rather, taste what I'm talking about!

Amazing service, delicious treats, and very beautiful well designed location!…read more We had the pleasure of being served by the owner who was so delightful! The chocolate treats are absolutely delicious, and the milkshake and sundae we ordered were delicious. Next time you want icecream, definitely give it a try!

Pretty good milkshakes here, and you'll enjoy these if you like lots of the foods in th. They were…read morea good size and the texture was thick. We ordered the mint cookies & cream and the chocolatier. There were chunks of brownies and chips in every sip in the chocolatier. A little bit overwhelming in that sense. Personally like it with just a little less chunks. For us, this was a solid 3 for the shakes. They also have non dairy ice creams for those who need it. That's a plus for family members. Service was great. 5 star for the constant smiles and greetings from the staff.

It was -5° outside in January, and for some reason we had a hankering for ice cream. You would…read moreimagine that any ice cream shop would be a ghost town on a weekday evening during the most bitter cold weather we've had in over a decade in Central Ohio. Maybe, but Shake No.8 was not a ghost town. When we pushed open the doors there were at least a dozen other people bundled up in their winter parkas, enjoying shakes and sundaes. Proof that the ice cream is so good, you'll even walk through a blizzard for it. It was our first visit and the guy working the counter walked us through the menu and showed us photos of the menu items. We decided to keep it simple with a strawberry milkshake and a limited edition Dubai chocolate shake. His hospitality and service is top-notch. You can tell he loves what he does and takes pride in it. The pictures don't even do these shakes justice, they tasted even better than they looked! The pistachio ice cream in the Dubai shake was world-class; creamy, rich with chunks of toasted pistachios mixed in. And a strawberry milkshake with A SIDE OF CHEESECAKE?! I mean, come on. There is nothing more you could ask for. All to say this place is 10/10, no notes. I'll be back for the Biscoff shake. Not even a polar vortex will stop me!

Shake No Eight has some great shakes. We enjoyed their smores shake and Nutella shake which were…read morereally great. The place gets very busy on the weekend and orders take time. The place is causal and have cafe like seating

Such a great selection of flavors and so many toppings to choose from. The employee even offer…read moresamples. Cute & clean little frozen yogurt shoppe.

It's been soooo long since I've had froyo! As I was scouring the internet for national frozen…read moreyogurt day deals I came across orange leaf and it seemed promising. Walking in was pure nostalgia, taking me back to my middle school days in the 20teens when froyo was all the rave. Personally I think the vanilla based flavors are the best so I went with birthday cake and cheesecake. They have a wide variety of toppings to throw on top of your yogurt like cheesecake bites, brownies, sprinkles, m&ms, fruits, and so much more. The whole concept of fro-yo is self serve so you can choose as many or as little toppings and yogurt you would like. The only thing that was a little annoying was there were no sample cups to try the flavors. It was a little annoying having to go ask for it especially when they only give you one cup to try different flavors. I definitely preferred my experience at orange leaf compared to menchies. I can see myself coming back for my annual fro-yo fix lol! P.S. they have no weigh Wednesdays now during the winter!

Honestly was kind of throne off with how empty this location was, no tables or chairs but a lot of…read moreopen space. I got the matcha ice cream in a waffle cone and it was a really subtle matcha taste, but perfectly balanced. I'd definitely try more flavors!

Ugh I really wanted to try this place while I was in Columbus but the hours online definitely do…read morenot match their actual hours. I tried to go twice and both times they were closed when it said they would be open. Maybe just a staffing issue. However I was really looking forward to trying this place, sad I didn't get to because it looks awesome.

The Yard takes milkshakes to the next level! Their specialty milkshakes in pint jars have crazy…read morecombos like The Buckeye with buckeyes & The Cereal Killer loaded with fruity pebbles! All of their toppings are delicious and their vegan ice cream is great! On top of the milkshakes they have a ton of different edible cookie doughs, floats and ice cream bars! Check it out!

Granddaughter loved the face painting at the anniversary party as well as her mermaid ice cream.read more

If you have never been to a Jeni's ice cream, what are you doing with your life? You can taste…read moreevery flavor they have and everything I've ever ordered is unbelievable.

I have been coming to Jeni's since she first opened and High St was her only location. I love that…read moreshe started in Columbus, so even when I lived out in TX- I supported her. I do think her flavors are getting a bit much. Her originals like the goat cheese and red berries & chocolate cayenne were just so different. She has very different flavors now, but the vast majority have been bad recently. The s'more advertised marshmallow, gave ashtray. All the traditional/ not seasonal flavors taste the same.

Treated myself after an amazing lunch down the block. It's a very tiny location and smells a bit…read morelike an old building (because it is lol) but the gentleman working was friendly and there wasn't any wait. Tried a small cup of their featured vegan flavor: vegan vanilla with raspberry and almond. It's the first time I've had their vegan custard and it's spectacular! I *love* ice creams and custards of all kinds, but my body doesn't do well with lactose. This is a perfect solution. The vanilla was flavorful and creamy, not boring at all. The chopped almonds added a little crunch and the raspberry was a nice addition - not too much nor too sweet. Great deal for $4.25! Can't wait to try more of their vegan flavors!

Cute location right along High Street in Clintonville. It's mainly carryout, though they do have a…read morebench near the window inside the shop and a couple of patio tables on the sidewalk out front. We grabbed some Whitties, their take on an ice cream (well custard here, of course) cookie sandwich - the current special flavor is mint chocolate chip, and they also offer the classic vanilla custard on chocolate chip cookies - to go. We also picked up some fun Dirty Worm sundaes - vanilla custard topped with crushed Oreo and gummy worms - cute and delicious. It was also neat to see they offer vegan selections too. Service was fast and friendly. Nearby street parking is available.

This is my first time at this location. It was clean and the service was OK. I ordered a coffee…read moreshake and received it dripping from the lid. The person took it back and wiped it clean, but as I was walking out the door and got to my car, it was dripping all over again and the lid popped off making a big mess. Maybe it was the paper cup with the domed plastic lid? I ended up just dumping out some of it and leaving it lid less. The taste was OK, although it definitely could have been mixed more to make it a smoother consistency. A small was $7.

Several Johnson's shops are popping up in the Columbus area, and you can never have too many ice…read morecream options. Aside from the courteous staff who welcomed us and offered copious samples, I didn't have a standout experience. But the ice cream was good, and sometimes it's just as simple as that. One suggestion that I will offer is to make the ice cream visible to the customers. The various flavors are hidden under lids, so it's hard to get a visual to go with the flavor name without asking to see it. Perhaps this is done to keep the product colder and fresher, but it's an uncommon experience compared to every other parlor I've visited.