Horrible food. I love Billy Sims but this Elgin location is horrible. The restaurant staff were nice. However, I complained to corporate after receiving a skinny spud with none of the toppings it comes with (I added cheese and that's all it was, a potato with cheese) and a "chopped brisket slider" that was like dry powdery ground beef? The General Manager of the location publicly lied saying that she tried to right their wrong, but she not once attempted to contact me. I have given them over a month just to respond to me, they never did. I outed them on Facebook and the GM came in lying about trying to fix their issue. To add, I have had billy sims in Lawton a few times. The skinny spud always had all the provided toppings, and the "chopped brisket" has NEVER looked like this. I simply wanted it remade but the GM was very disrespectful about such a small mistake. read more

Billy Sims BBQ - Skinny Spud - Barbeque Near Me - Elgin, Oklahoma

See all

We went into the restaurant around 5 pm on Sunday evening. The restaurant appeared clean and orderly. We got to place our order right away to the friendly staff of two because there were only two other customers in the restaurant. My friend and I each ordered baked potatoes with butter, onions, sour cream and cheese. We usually get it with chicken but we just wanted a big, potato. Took it home and opened the box to see a dry, hard, small and shriveled up potato that had obviously been in a warmer for a long time, long time. it had truly seen better days. I tasted mine after deciding it was probably safe although I couldn't even pierce the skin with my fork and that's my favorite part. It tasted as bad as it looked but because we were hungry we decided to doctor up our pitiful potatoes with all the extras to cover up the taste. it worked fairly well and we tasted more sour cream and onion than potatoes. These two potatoes and one small iced tea cost over $21. What a shame. I gave this store 2 stars because neither of us got sick. read more

Billy Sims BBQ - Potato - Barbeque Near Me - Elgin, Oklahoma

The service was fine but the bbq could use some help. It's nothing like down south mouth watering BBQ.

Dry. Driest BBQ I have ever had, ever. I have been trying to like them cuz the locals rave, but they some how managed to remove all juices from the meat before serving and I can't fathom it. Also? The staff is super inexperienced... And it's a rotating door, so it's been that way for a while. Lastly, check your order, cuz they tend to forget things. read more

I've always loved Billy Sims BBQ but when I went in last week it was very uncomfortable. I felt like I had walked in on a fight or something. The employees all had scowls on their faces. They weren't speaking to each other barely spoke to me. But, the food was still good read more

Husband went there when they had there reopening with new management and billy sims there signing autographs. Scammed us out of $88 on my bank account and they won't fix it. Bought a $5.99 sandwich. Cost me $88. Worst food and service and management. read more

Amazing BBQ ribs. So tender and lick your fingers yummy! Loved the baked potato salad side as well. Manager was very friendly and made sure we were well taken care of. read more

Wow. What a find. Lucky for us the pizza place was closed. The half rack (6) rib dinner was falling off the bone tender. The flavor was great. I had the Baked Potato Salad as a side. Good prices and truly good food. The manager is very nice and is a budding owner which says a lot as far as commitment. It's a home run. We dined in and everything was clean and welcoming. read more

Hey Billy you need to look into this place. The food is terrible day old dried out small portions crap. People hang out in there like its their front room its either friends or family, very inappropriate. I will not be back again. read more

Horrible, even with new owner/management, all the young girls and boys can't get anything rite, they don't listen, one girl kept rolling her eyes, even after telling them 3 times a very simple thing they still messed up, baked potatoes were not done as well, the one in Lawton on Gore is much better if you really wanna have Billy sims read more

Picked up 3 HARD as a brick, undercooked baked potatoes for dinner. They weren't even cut open, the toppings were placed on the top of the potatoes and melted off into the to go box. I keep making the mistake of giving this place chance after chance becuase supposedly its under new management. Never get my ranch, pickles or onions either. read more

We had just relocated from Houston and we could not believe that this place served the best pork ribs I had ever tasted! It's self service and the place is small for dining in; some customers prefer to take out! read more

Great bbq ribs! Really like the bake potato salad! Will be trying the pull pork next time

DON'T ORDER FROM HERE!!! Horrible takeout experience. We ordered online which clearly provides the order to the cooks. Two salads with no onion and regular ranch and a side of turkey. Picked up the order and had to ask for the barbecue sauce for the turkey. Going out the door I only saw two boxes. Did you folks include the side of turkey? Yes we did sir. Got home, no side of turkey, onions in the salad, bque ranch, and the wrong salad with extra cheese. I called the manager to complain. Oh, turkey wasn't listed on the order but I was changed on the receipt and it's on the online order. Refund? Sure...I think I can do it or you can come down and pickup the turkey. If not, I'll have to go through a third party. Then as she's trying to process the missing turkey refund, I check the sliced brisket. It looks chopped. She says the brisket is overcooked and falls apart. Then why serve it? Chicken and brisket were bone dry. I told her to disregard the refund as they lost a customer. Omg...can they even read a clear online order? Just annoying. Again, don't go here folks!!! read more

It is good bbq, for the price you get a decent portion of food. I eat there several times a month. I like the Heisman sandwich. So I recommend stopping by there next time your in Elgin Oklahoma. read more

Got their loaded spud and it was amazing. You could almost feed two people with one. Got the cherry cheese cake desert and it was fantastic. Great portions for the price. read more

Everything is pre made and kept on a warmer. It's a little on the expensive side but since they don't have much competition as far as BBQ goes, if you are craving some smoked meats, this would be your go to. Brisket is pretty tender fall a part but I got a lot of overly dry pieces. I don't like to drench in sauce so it was a disappointment. Smoked turkey is pretty good, i would highly recommend it. If you go the sandwich route, it's pretty sad buns. I would almost get the combo and bring it home to make my own sandwich. Pretty standard sides. Can't go wrong with Mac n cheese and BBQ baked beans. Which in my opinion are vegetables. I actually liked their coleslaw, it wasn't overly dressed and had a good crunch that made it seem fresh. Nothing fancy though. It's a chain fast food place. It's a bit pricey: if you are going for the combo dinner plate, it will probably run you $20 if you want a drink with it. But you can almost fool yourself to thinking it's a step up from regular fast food to justify the cost. Nothing stellar but if you are in Elgin and craving BBQ, it's decent. read more

I ordered 2 legendary spud $7.99 each with extra meat each $1.99x2 and 1 drink $2.25. Got home realized that they didn't give me the extra meat, okay accidents happen, I called them and told Anthony (believe that was his name) that I didn't get my extra meat...he said do you have your receipt I said no but I paid 22.21 and he said that is right I said I don't think it is he said no it was right and I didn't charge you for 2 extra sides of meat hmmmmm $7.99x2 + 1.99x2 + 2.25 for a drink = $22.21....tax exempt yap thats what I paid $22.21 soooooo how did they not charge me???? read more

Billy Sims BBQ - the menu of the restaurant - Barbeque Near Me - Elgin, Oklahoma

From Eldgin to Oklahoma City, Billy Sims provides down home BBQ that lives up to the name. Regardless of the location, the variety and quality of the brisket, ribs, and pulled pork is top notch. Most impressive is that every location I have frequented is always clean and kept clean even when orders start to roll on. A very nice BBQ joint! read more

I had the chopped brisket on a baked potato which was very good and I would have it again. But my husband had the barbecue chicken and it was dry and lacking in taste. We usually do like Billy Sims BBQ. read more

I suppose the food is good. Not one single healthy choice on the menu. My stomache cannot handle the fat. My kids really liked it. It was clean. The staff was very nice. read more

Best BBQ in the area, especially in a small town. A little overpriced. Overall, good food and good customer service.

This place is amazing, this was my first visit here back in March and I loved every bit. Just so sad that the owner doesn't run their franchises the same in Lawton because the food does not taste the same. I would go back to Elgin location again On my way! Out of town but I will never eat at the ones in Lawton again! read more

I have been going there since they first opened. I get takeout most of the time. In particular I get the loaded baked potatoes with everything & chopped brisket. The last 3 times, I was missing the Ranch dressing & bacon bits. I called this last time to let them know I was missing items. The manager informed me I had to ask for those items, they didn't come with the loaded potato. I told him I never did in the past & neither did my husband or daughter when they picked up our food. He got very defensive & rude & told me in the future if I wanted the 'extras' that I had to ask for them. I told him with his attitude, I'll just spend my money elsewhere. I noticed their business has slackened & I feel it's probably because of the new manager's attitude. I'm never going back, Native Sun BBQ is much more friendly & values my patronage and they are even better in taste, amounts & most importantly Service. read more

Pretty good BBQ. From Texas and expected a little more flavor....but overall was good. Baked potato salad was delicious!

This place has some great BBQ. Chicken was a little dry. But everything taste great. Coleslaw. And Mac and cheese are the best sides.