Beyar's Market WAS the spot to go to for a good sandwich or cream cheese bagel but not anymore. Those days are LONG GONE. Today my wife went there to buy bagels for us. I asked her to pick me up an onion bagel toasted with cream cheese and this is what I got! The bagel in this picture speaks for itself they're supposed to be cream cheese on here. It's supposed to be toasted and normal size. The bagel is half the size it used to be. There's no cream cheese and it's barely toasted. It actually tastes like it's stale. It's a hard bagel. I'm not going there anymore. I'll spend my money elsewhere. read more

Beyar's Market - This was supposed to be a toasted onion bagel with cream cheese and this is how I got it when I unwrapped it at home. - Delis Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Best, heroes on Staten Island for over 40 years. Great quality. Great taste. Great price

Great store! Very good prices and service. A large selection of ready-made food, vegetables and frozen foods. read more

Beyar's Market - Coffee - Delis Near Me - Staten Island, New York

for the past five years, I've gotten my corn beef sandwich on St. Patrick's Day at Beyers market. It's always been exceptionally delicious. This year unfortunately it was horrible. I don't know what they did or who cooked it was absolutely horrible. Very disappointed. read more

I ordered the kids peanut butter and jelly on whole wheat bread very well packed and good. So far I give them a 5 star

Food, service, atmosphere! Everything about Beyers. Never had a bad sandwich or salad.

Two words... MACARONI SALAD. the best I've ever had. Sometimes I find myself craving it, lol. Even if you're not a macaroni salad person, try this one! It's not like commercial one, with the very chemically mayo and the weird aftertaste. This is fresh with onion and peppers and black pepper. Oh man, so good. Tuna salad is good too! The Italian bread is always perfect. It's a cute little neighborhood market read more

Beyar's has been our go to caterer for many years for a variety of events. Working with Elizabeth or Bob always a pleasure. Food is great, we love the Covid era individuality wrapped sandwiches and individual salads! Delivery always on time. read more

This place makes amazing Italian sandwich's. They have all the best you can imagine. Fried eggplant and Italian roasted peppers are delicious don't forget the fresh mozzarella. Enjoy read more

This is my go to place for chicken cutlet sandwiches and home made salads. Also use for all catering needs. Truly delicious food. read more

Unfortunately as much as the staff is kind and clean great place every single time I've ordered sandwiches no matter a BLT , or BEC it is always wrong and/or undercooked and missing ingredients. And for sandwiches I can get anywhere else for cheaper price and made right but always went back to give them another chance because I want to give them the business. At this point over 20+ attempts I don't think I'll be ordering sandwiches from them again. read more

The worst food ever‼chicken cutlets no taste, rice ball's no taste, fresh must, no taste‼ Everything I bought went right in the garbage ‼ I will never buy anything the have in their deli case. Whoever is preparing the food in the case needs to learn how to cook, the "fresh" nuts tasted like chalk I'll stick with La Bella, Top Tomato, Pastosa . read more

Has anyone noticed the high prices on items at this local market? I went there today and seen a small pack of cream cheese for $4.99 Ricotta cheese $9.65 No sales what so ever, I will not go here ever again unless it's an extreme emergency regardless it's 2 min drive for me. Price gauging it it's finest read more

Catered from Beyar's Market for a big party. Everyone loved all the food, it was fresh and delicious! Eggplant rollatini, mini rice balls, sausage and peppers, all was a hit! They provided everything I needed. The sandwiches in a shape of a 30 was a great touch, chicken cutlet and Italian sandwiches with fresh bread was so good. I also go there for there for just about anything, breakfast sandwiches are great, and their boneless buffalo bites are my favorite! read more

See all

I had a wonderful experience catering breakfast for a group of 55. Food was plentiful and very well prepared. Bob was a pleasure to work with. read more

This is a superior store. It's always well stocked & fresh. Terrific service at check out & the deli, as well as anywhere else in the store that you may need assistance. Everyone is so welcoming & congenial. They really care about customer service & treat you as a person not just a number. The staff is superlative : Tom, the owner, the managers; Bob the top manager & managers; Liz & Kaitlin & the staff; Ryan, Joe, Jenna, Brooke. The Deli Dept is absolutely wonderful. They go out of their way for you & their chicken salad is unbeatable. Jack is outstanding. Lastly, the prices are fabulous. Beyars carries things that other stores do not have such as fresh mint, carrots jubilee & exquisite custom cakes & pies plus the best dark chocolate. Lastly they are always patient & kind on the phone esp w my Saturday inquiry calls. Thank you !! read more

Food always fresh and service always friendly. Parking lot makes shopping here very convenient as well.

Beyars has a nice deli selection. A great local place to grab anything you need. A professional friendly staff is also a plus.

Ordered the chicken florentine lunch special on sourdough bread the worst excuse for a panini I've ever had. Sandwich had a few slice of deli chicken and a ton of unmelted cheese. The bread wasn't toasted and the florentine was a few leaves of raw baby spinach. I work on the island and will make sure I don't go back to this place. read more

Don't quote me on this but I think they're open until 11pm. I always forget that when I'm jonesing for some grub on SI... I mostly order sandwiches from the deli counter. It's almost as if you get 8 bucks' worth of chicken breast on your $5.50 deli sandwich! Now granted I'm usually hungry when I'm ordering so maybe it's the fog of noshing. They don't have a seating area so be prepared to drag your goodies down to the Starbucks or home. They also have a large selection of house-prepared foods in their cooler, conveniently packaged in plastic containers and ready to toss in the microwave. (Don't you hate when they put your food in metal containers?) Some examples include turkey, mash potatoes, pasta, meatballs, bulk sauces etc. They'll heat these up for you if you ask at the deli counter. This tiny shop is just like the mom and pop hardware stores in the area, they're small but they seem to have exactly what you need if you ask. They even make their own mozzarella cheese. If you get there at the right time you can watch the magic. read more

See all

I love this place and have been going there for years, since it was Miggy's. They have the basics and then some, a wonderful deli department and lots of fresh breads, rolls and bagels. Parking is sometimes a bit of a challenge, but nothing that would stop me from going there. Even if you pick up a basket full of items, you're still in and out in no time, which I really appreciate. The people who work there, especially management, are very nice. Highly recommend this establishment. read more

I have been coming to this market since I was a kid. The staff is so friendly and helpful. They have a great assortment of groceries and everything is always so clean and fresh. My husband and I like to get salads and sandwiches made before going to the beach to bring for dinner and they're very generous with filling them and making them how we like, and delicious! read more

Absolutely love Beyar's Market. Food is always fresh, hot & on time. They have something for everyone! Catered from them recently and my guests were all so happy. No leftovers=successful party. Love love love supporting this local business and will be ordering again soon. read more

Love this store! I have catered with them a few times and the food is always very fresh. Love the variety of heroes and anything with their marinara sauce is outstanding. read more

I just purchased a home 2 blocks away from this market an I always pass it on my way to the house. I decided to try it out. Plenty of parking in the lot, walking in was very appealing an clean. You can tell it's a well organized clean market. Great meat department looks an smells fresh not like a yucky old meat market. Very nice people working here it's small and cute very family Orientated. Deli selections was ok all the condiments looks very fresh as well. Not dry an old Price is a dollar or two over but not So bad of a difference than a huge market. Overall I'm pleased with my first time coming in I'm hoping it's like that again on my next visit. :) read more

Cashier Kerri had the personality of a rock. She didn't utter a word during the entire transaction....no 'hello'... no 'yo can swipe your card'...no 'thank you' or good night. This employee needs a lesson in common human decency. She is bad for business. read more

Just a heads up called during covid 19 minimum $30 order plus $10 delivery fee...... Uber and grub hub aren't even charging delivery fees. called bagels and buns after my entire order was $30. Good to know who to support after a crisis is over! Never will shop Beyar's again plenty of better places! read more

Absolutely the worst store in the area. Owners and manager are rude and disrespectful to not only their staff but the customers in the store. Head manager is one of the most rude and immature people I've ever met. Owner is disrespectful and careless especially when confronted by customers. Produce and deli foods are not usually fresh, milk is sour more often than not. Deli workers and cashiers are genuine and nice for the most part, but ownership and management are awful human beings. Avoid this store as much as possible! read more

Got our Christmas antipast and apps from Beyars this year and it was fabulous. Made my holiday much easier and everything was delicious.Will definitely use them again. read more

First time we used them for catering and they did a fantastic job! Food was great and service was above and beyond what was expected! Cannot wait to have another party so we can order from them again! read more

I love Beyers market....they have the most delicious potato and macaroni salads and Cole slaw I've ever had.....their sandwiches are unbelievable......I've never had any problems with any products I've ever bought from Beyers read more

Good local neighborhood Deli and grocery store. Good customer service and food. I like their loyalty program. Foods always fresh and they have everything I need. Charlie read more

The location is convenient, by the produce is neither that fresh nor particularly cheap. The cashier seemed nice.

Beyar's is like a Quick Chek.Bigger than a deli,but smaller than a market.I used to go here a lot when I lived on the Island.My bro & I would come here before all NY Giant games to pick up food & drink .They make a nice size sandwich for your "tailgating."Prices are very reasonable. read more

I will say this some of the people here are awesome and are hard workers. Mike in the deli is such a nice guy and knows his customers. Roe is also amazing greets you with a smile and always willing to help you. These are my favorite ones in the deli. Some of the cashiers are very nice to. Also I love that they have pork roll reminds me of my child hood. Keep up the good work Mike and Roe. read more

I purchased 2 large bags of chips amongst other items. I asked for a pound of potato salad and received macaroni. In addition, the deli clerk incorrectly gave me the wrong weight on 2 cold cuts. Instead of 1 lb of each... I got 3/4 lb of each. Since it was raining I was not going back to the store. When I got home and unpacked my bags a mouse/rat had chewed threw one bag of chips. I was so grossed out I tossed it. I should have included a pic. Cashier service was slow even with 2 cashiers and no one in line. read more

3/30/2020 - I had a great experience ordering and receiving my order from Beyar's. Yes, there is a $30 minimum order requirement but it is not fair to ask a business to deliver an order for just a few dollars of merchandise (especially at this time!). As a senior citizen I received free delivery...best of all the prices were not inflated but remained at what they were pre COVID-19. Liz, the staff member who took my order, was wonderful. She called back to let me know what was available and what wasn't, and inquired if I had any specific delivery instructions I wanted followed. From start to finish I had my order delivered within 5 hours...COSTCO took 5 days with inflated prices. Beyar's will be my go to place! read more

Love this market. They have great choice. Make any sandwich u would like. They have the best fruit section I know of. It's just the perfect combo of a deli/supermarket. I go here often read more

I am basing my rating on product. Deli meats. Deli salads and breads awesome. The house has a delicious rice pudding the pickiest person loves. There meat is always fresh. Need to order a platter for an event call them it will get done. Customer service I have nothing to say its business business business!!! They take debit and credit cards and don forget to play lotto I moved to st.george from westerleigh and I go back at least once a week. They sell ready to cook meals can't too that for a working mom!!! read more

Food fresh, huge selection for a small place, abit pricey but quality good and convenient, a pleasure to shop in but be careful if you do too much looking you'll walk out with your wallet lighter and you will end up heavier.... read more