Bethany Sports Cards Plus is a fantastic place. The owners are incredibly friendly and always so kind to my son (12) and daughter (8). My son loves collecting football cards and my daughter is big into Pokémon cards, and this shop has become one of our favorite stops. Their prices are very reasonable, which makes it easy to stop in and let the kids enjoy the hobby. I recently brought my son in after he got an excellent report card, and not only did they celebrate his accomplishment, they even gave him a small reward and encouraged him to keep up the good grades. That meant a lot to him. It's rare to find people who genuinely care about their customers the way they do. They've absolutely earned us as lifetime customers. If you're into memorabilia, sports cards or Pokémon cards, this place is a must-visit. read more

Max & his team are great. Lots of singles, slabs & sealed at competitive prices. They are a must visit in Bethany. read more

Bethany Sports Cards Plus - God pack we ripped in the store - Toy Stores Near Me - Bethany Beach, Delaware

Great atmosphere and good selection of cards and products. Would recommend. Thanks for the service

Went to look for Pokemon cards with a group of friends and had a ton of fun looking through the cards and talking to the guys behind the counter. One of our friends was even given a card of his favorite niche Pokemon for free after we were talking about it in the shop so much read more

I wanted to share an experience my kids and I had recently at Bethany Cards. During our visit, my 8-year-old (along with a few other kids) was looking through some boxes of cards, as he's done before (we have spent hundreds of dollars here this summer). At one point, he stepped away to check something else out. That's when the owner (the son?) addressed me rather abruptly, asking, "Are you going to buy anything, or is your kid just going to take every card out?" I understand completely that it's important for kids to be respectful of store displays, and I immediately went over to help put the cards back and talk to my son about it. However, I was taken aback by the tone and decided to quietly say to just the owner, "I'm sorry, but I really didn't appreciate the way that was said." Unfortunately, the situation escalated from there. The owner became visibly upset, raised his voice, and said some hurtful things to both me and my son. It was a jarring and upsetting moment, especially in front of my children. I completely understand the need for rules in a store like this and my son should have immediately put them away (which we talked about after). But, I believe there are kinder, more constructive ways to handle these situations. Everyone has tough days, and maybe that was the case here. But it left a lasting impression, and sadly, I don't think we'll be returning. I'm sharing this not to shame anyone, but just to give a heads-up to other parents and maybe offer some perspective to the business as well. read more

This was a win for me. Glad I stopped in. The new owners are great. Father and son team. I was looking for vintage cards and found exactly that. Got a great deal on several premium cards for any collector to cherish. I will definitely be stopping back now that I know they're under new ownership. read more

The selection is amazing! The new owners are kind and patient. Great value of trade in. Very fair. Awesome

Under new ownership, so ignore older reviews!!!! my (adult) kids went there recently, and are very excited about this place--owner is very nice, engaged in worthwhile conversation. Good selection, and some pretty good prices! read more

The new owners are awesome! Excellent prices and very personable that made me feel at home. Anyone that's questioning visiting this place due to bad reviews with the old owner should give them a shot! A+ service & will be back again to search through the card bins read more

Was excited to try, but prices were much higher than other stores and customer service was disappointing. I'll stick with the Millville card store read more

The new owners are absolutely wonderful. You won't find two more knowledgeable and kind store owners. Great selection, great prices, and a great experience! read more

My son and I stopped in to see if they had pokemon and the owner greeted us very nicely. They had a wide range of inventory and we even purchased some graded slabs from the 1st edition series. Nice place. read more

New owners are very kind and helpful. Recently reorganized the store and repriced many cards. Had a good time looking through card bins and had a nice conversation with one of the new owners and staff members. Have some fun memorabilia to look at as well and had a great sale running on jerseys. While unopened packs/boxes are marked up from retail you're supporting a local business with great owners and can find good value in the card bins and on some memorabilia read more

Great sports card store and Tommy is really knowledgeable regarding the products that he's selling. All sports teams fans are welcome, even Yankee fans! Let's go O's!!! read more

New owners are nice and will sit and talk to you about sports but the football card boxes marked up over 55% is kinda outrageous. I get that you have to make money as a small business but that's robbery. No proof of authenticity for the signed jerseys hanging up. Single cards worth cents marked up to 5-15$. Everything is extremely marked up and over priced even for a small business but did say they will work with you if you buy multiple items of certain things. Better off ordering online read more

Overpriced and the owner treated me with disdain and my kids as of they weren't even there. Refused to help me with cards (that are all locked up) read more

Visited in sept to browse after about 10-15 minutes was asked if I was not buying to move out man behind counter just sat in his chair and eyed the other persons in shop as if they were criminals not good experience won't be going back or suggesting anyone else to read more

My husband and I were here in May. We enjoyed looking around the store. The owner was great to chat with. He had great deals on Pokémon cards, baseball cards and more. Definitely check it out we got quite a few things for great prices. read more

Went into this shop looking for some cool cards to bring home to me and my friends. As I was looking around I saw a nice card in the case. I asked to look at it he said yes. As I was looking at the card I saw it had lots of damage. So I nicely said I think I am going to pass and handed him the card nicely. So after the owner had the card he throw it all the way across his store. And after that I am never coming back and wouldn't recommend anyone to visit the store. read more

I was intimidated by the negative reviews but after my visit I see nothing wrong. The owner was helpful and kind. The prices were slightly more expensive than others but it is a resort town. I would recommend this store to anyone interested in sports. read more

Would give this store 0 stars if I could. Went in with my daughters and nephew and my dad. Owner was extremely rude, yelled at my nephew for not putting cards back in place (even though my dad was ensuring he was) and made my nephew cry. Will never go back and would strongly recommend against people going especially with kids!!! read more

Nice people there. I decided to check the place it after eating a yummy sandwich from the place near it. Got two packs of cards. Total was 75 dollars. The worker there even showed me his 1995 Charizard. Epic card shop. read more

I would give this place zero stars if I could. The owner seemed nice when I first went in, but apparently looking around the shop for 20 mins was too much for his blood pressure even after I bought $100 worth of product from his over priced store (I always like to support local card shops when possible). Before I left, he expressed his great displeasure and dismay that I didn't buy more and tried to guilt me into buying more. The cards are way over priced and the owner will get very nasty and defensive if you try to nicely negotiate. The 1 star reviews are warranted for this place. It's a tourist trap. read more

See all

DO NOT PURCHASE ANY AUTOGRAPHED ITEMS. After many trips to the store and having mostly good experiences we purchased a Derek Jeter autographed bat which was deemed not authentic by a grading service. I should have known when he told employee that there was an old Jeter authentication certificate laying around somewhere. We have literally spent thousands of dollars at this store. read more

Person working the store was nice but the price we high and he had a great selection of memorabilia

The owner told me to go fuck myself but besides that they had better prices than last year and a little room but wax is still overpriced

wanted to buy a box of Pokemon cards for my nephew and since I was about 8 miles from the store, I called them up to check on availability. Yes they said they had the newest set box, but refused to tell me the price over the phone. If you want to know our prices you must be in person I was told. Strange. But they had the product, so I decided to make the drive. To my disgust they were asking $200 for the box, which has an MSRP of $90! No wonder they don't give prices over the phone, it seems they intend to cheat hapless grandparents and parents who want to buy a nice Pokemon gift for their grandchildren/children who don't know any better, or come in hoping to support a local business. But a local business should also support locals and not try to rip off families off at more than twice the price. This shop is shady and unethical. read more

BEWARE!! FAKE JERSEYS BEING PASSED OFF AS AUTHENTIC!! Purchased several Michell and Ness Jerseys that the owner swore up and down were real. After taking them to the Philadelphia Mitchell and Ness store they confirmed that they were not. read more

Decided to check out the place for the first time and bought a box of 1990-91 Skybox NBA cards that was supposed to have a Shawn Kemp rookie. After going through the box, the entire box was missing every single rookie card that was supposed to still be in the box. They also have a Luka Doncic "autographed" frame for $250 but the signature has the number 37 in it while Luka's number is 77... not a place to go to if you want anything legitimate read more

Didn't have a lot of product, the only product they did have was overpriced and retail. Owner was very rude and acted like he knew it all and tried to start fights. Wouldn't recommend!!!!!!!!!! read more

The owner was extremely rude to me and my son. We have shopped there many times before and every time the owner has seemed hostile and unfriendly. My son was cussed out and yelled at because he was comparing the in-store prices to eBay ones. All of the products in the store are extremely overpriced and you are better off buying what you are looking for off of eBay. The store is a complete mess and highly unorganized, making it nearly impossible to find what you are looking for without sheer luck. Most of the autographs are obvious fakes and none provide any proof that they are real. Overall I would avoid this establishment at all costs and would not recommend it to anyone I know. If you are looking for an establishment to find sports cards, pokemon cards, or any other memorabilia this is not the place. read more

No one is the area like them! Great store. Prices are in the same boat as eBay. I prefer the hand to hand transaction. They always have new product in stock. Cool guys once you get the talking to them. read more

This owner is a crook. I got burned on a Tom Brady photo that was over $200. Couldn't tell it was fake until I got home and looked at it closer. The signature was traced in silver over a lithograph. DO NOT TRUST THIS MAN! The only autographs to trust are certified by JSA or PSA/DNA where you can look up the code online to see if legit. I have spoken to many different people who got burned at this store. STAY AWAY! read more

Fake autographs!!! The autographs I saw in this store would never pass any authentication service!