I've been in the Santa Rosa area for about five years, but only last week got out to play Bennett Valley. I had heard the horror-stories about six hour rounds and merely average course conditions, but had a whole day to myself and decided to go for it.
Course: overall, the course was in really good shape for early August. Fairways were green and lush, with little signs of drying out. The greens were in good condition too, though a little slower than I would have preferred. One other nice thing: the tee boxes were flat and well-maintained.
Staff: The thing that impressed me the most was the friendliness of the staff, from the guys in the pro-shop, to the woman in the beer cart, to the men and women in the restaurant/bar. To a person, everyone had a smile on their face and accommodating. It was really nice to be treated well, even though the course traffic was high and everyone was busy.
Difficulty: I'd rate the course difficulty as above average, which is good to see from a Muni with high volume. The pin placements on the day I played were challenging (did someone upset the greens keeper?), and there were plenty of trees to navigate if you couldn't land it in the fairway. Overall the course is pretty flat, with only a couple of holes showing significant elevation changes. Of the Par 5s, i think only a couple would be reachable in two for the average/good golfer. The Par 3s were fairly easy, and the Par 4s offered challenges equal to the overall difficulty of the course.
I only have three small complaints, and that's why this review is 4/5 stars:
1. A couple of the holes (#1 and #3 IIRC) had huge oak trees planted right in front of the green, making approach shots unfairly hard. Having played it once now, I'd know where to "miss" and avoid them, but as a first-time player of Bennett Valley it was disheartening to see a good shot be punished by an obstacle.
2. As the course is mostly flat, walking is pretty common. I took a cart out for my round, and it didn't have any GPS (which makes sense for a Muni I guess). Further, not all sprinkler heads had yardages on them, and finding the 200/150/100 markers was super-easy. If you have a range-finder I'd bring it along, otherwise gauging distance can be a bit of a chore.
3. Finally, the round did take 5.5 hours, and for the back nine it was just me and a playing partner. We waited on every, single, shot, for the entire round. To be fair, the starter did tell us it was crowded before we started, so it was not unexpected. That said, the two groups in front of us played every shot like it was Sunday at the British Open. They took their own sweet time, and for that I wish there had been a marshal handy to tell them to pick up the pace.
Bottom line: I'd play here again. read more