Bennie's has become our regular Friday night pizza place. Best place in town. Never disappoints. Perfect pace. Cheerful staff and owners. So Ive been watching some Dave Portnoy pizza reviews lately and he mentioned something called Detroit pizza. Never heard of it. Well, were here at Bennie's last night and there it was on the menu. So we had to try it. But first, for an appetizer with some wonderful viognier from the Rhone, we enjoy some lightly fried burrata in a light vodka sauce. Was cooked perfectly. Hot outside, still cool inside. Tasty sauce with just the slightest zip. We ordered a Detroit with pepperoni, hot honey and a dash of chili. Comes in an eight slice rectangle. Wow. Super flavorful. Cross between a Sicilian and a Chicago. Lighter and more "doughy" than a Sicilian but firm under carriage and generous cheese. Very filling we could only eat one slice each. Took the rest home for lunch. Yum. Love left over pizza cold or sometimes heated up in a skillet. We finished with their homemade cannoli. Perfecto. BYOB. Come early on weekends as the back room gets busy and sometimes loud. read more

See all

I have a gluten allergy, and they are very accommodating and knowledgeable. We love it here!

Fantastic experience. I dined in. These guys made a Detroit style pie - I ordered ahead of time - they had it ready pipping hot. It was terrific - a rectangle with a nice crunchy outer crust with a hint of cheese, softer inner base, a healthy layer of cheese, and topped with chunks of tomato and sauce that blended sweet and salty. Really impressed they did this right here in central Jersey. I mean folks order their cheese slices left and right - but try their Detroit - really great. Next time I'll try their other subspecialty slices - the Brooklyn, grandma, Trenton tomato etc Wait but it doesnt end there - fantastic Greek salad and eggplant rollitini I think I gained weight - but it was worth it read more

Came By today it was my First time. I figured since my pizza place is closed on Sunday why not try out the Food at Beniaminos Cucina? This isnt just a Pizza Joint, it also has philly subs and Mote Italian Fresh Cuisine. I got a Large Pie. You have two choices of size small and large. Large Plain pie 17 n change. Ya look around town and some places want you left kidney and wallet for their service and pies. 17 bucks gets ya a great "undercarriage" minimal "flop" tastes (you can clearly see i had some - dont judge me) and a 17 or 18 in pie which is unheard of at that price ans Quality of Food. The cheese has that quality taste not that "i melt easy mozzarella" taste at other places. The Ambiance is actually low Key. I was Very Surprised (by the way you order at the far end by the two ladies - Remember That) at how relaxed everyone was. The Manager or Owner Helped the Young Lady at the desk Respectfully and helped her out as i got the vibe she may be new. Nice guy & Young Lady - You order at the far end Remember that . Seems like a Family Shop and I highly suggest Checking them Out Just Look at This Great Food. Chicken Fingers & Fries Appetizer Plain Pie read more

See all

We stopped in to Beniamino's for the first time and after being served raw pizza, we will not be back. The complimentary bread was great and we were off to a good start. We ended up waiting around 40 minutes for the pizza, only for it to be raw in the center. I didn't get a chance to take a photo of it after the slices were pulled apart. We each ate a slice from the outer edges and as we got to the center, the dough was not cooked. My brother informed the waitress and she responded that they were going to put the pizza back in the oven for us. We declined. After waiting an overly long time for a single pizza and then not even being able to eat the whole pie, we needed to leave. It also seems unsanitary to take a pizza that was out on our table that we had taken slices from and put it back in the oven. We paid for the pizza and we left. We're not the kind of people to fight over customer service and demand a refund or refuse to pay. However, it seems like this would've been an appropriate time for the staff to offer to comp the meal. read more

Close by, good pizza! Chicken Piccata is wonderful! I usually just do takeout. The food travels well in the 15 minutes it takes me to bring it home. read more

We received delicious subs and cannolis from this place! On behalf of the emergency room - we thank you? read more

Beniamino's Cucina - a tray of pastries - Italian Near Me - Skillman, New Jersey

Great pizza, friendly, prompt service. They seem to know all their customers , super friendly, but even if you're visiting for the first time they're still super friendly. The pizza is awesome too. And they have this giant giant calzone or whatever it is, some say burrito, that can feed six to seven people. Or one, if they're up for a challenge. Would highly recommend. read more

Awesome local pizza joint + BYO. A group of seven of us walked in here on a Saturday for lunch after a hike and wow, so glad we did! There is a more casual area for a quick bite/ orders by the slice and a more formal table seating area in the back - we sat in the back. Ordered two large pies. Warning: the pies are quite generous in size. The veggie pizza was PHENOMENAL - so fresh and light. If you are a veggie lover, get it. The buffalo chicken and jalapeño pizza was good too. And can we take a moment to talk about the fresh, homemade bread we were welcomed with - so divine. Too bad I don't live in the area - or else I would be a regular here. read more

See all

The gluten free pizza is here is amazing!! The regular large my husband loves and the slices are HUGE. This pizza place has had many names but there has always been a pizza in that location for almost 23 years from when we first moved local. The inside is beautiful and cozy and the newer owners are very efficient and good at their jobs. read more

What a fun and lovely family-run restaurant! The decor is simple but the folks running it are as genuine as they come -- three brothers and their father and their colleagues dish up a huge selection of pizza by the slice, as well as pastas, salads, heroes, calzones, and some amazing cannolis and deserts as well! The service is incredibly friendly and warm -- you'll feel like one of the regulars after just coming in once. The pizzas were very delicious, with a perfect crust and toppings that tasted like my nonna was in the kitchen! Try this place -- Youse gonna love it, capisce? read more

O.M.G. Eggplant anyone??? No one does it like this place. So good. So tender. So sweet. All I can ever order. They've spoiled me! I see them making pasta and ravioli by hand whenever I pick up my order and always promise myself I will order that for my family next time. HOWEVER- the eggplant is so perfect- I just cannot waver...it's a perfect go to every single time. Wait-if you do get the eggplantl- leave some for me!!! read more

The service is good but the waiting for pizza is long (30-40 minutes). We visited twice in 2 weeks and had the same experience. Salads are on the expensive side, pizza price is average. Pizza quality is good but not better than some in the area. The place just opened so may take time to adjust. They have good potential and the location is great. read more

Beniamino's Cucina - Vegetarian Pizza - Italian Near Me - Skillman, New Jersey

Highly recommended I'm not want to leave reviews but this place was very nice atmosphere was great food was great I had a veal cutlet on top of arugula and by far was the best read more

Beniamino's Cucina - Veal cutlet on top of arugula salad with parmesan cheese on top - Italian Near Me - Skillman, New Jersey

The food is delicious at Beniamino's and there are many choices of things to eat from pizza to pasta dishes and calzones. I am particularly pleased that they offer gluten free pizza and pasta. This is a family run business that opened their own restaurant years ago after gaining experience in other restaurants. The staff is friendly and helpful. We enjoy eating casual sit-down dinners there. They offer takeout also. Beniamino's is easy to get to and lots of parking. Check it out! read more

Beniamino's is relatively new to the scene, taking over the location from the previous occupant Vera Pizza. I personally like the change. The staff is very friendly and welcoming and the service is quick. The pizza is pretty good too! The Margherita has a decent sauce with great, fresh basil and gooey delicious mozzarella gobs. The plain is nice and saucy with a crispy base and salty cheese. The crust is fluffy, bready, and full of flavor. This is definitely a good spot. -@BoroPizzaHunter on Instagram. read more

The ambiance is good and the staff and owners are very friendly and welcoming. The food is very good.

I ordered through the slicelife app and I waited at the front door for two hours. Then I contact slice and was reported to me to have been delivered, but they never showed up, didn't even receive an email notification of delivery. read more

Average at best. Bread and crust in pizza the best part of lunch. Server was great. Super nice

Apparently I found a hidden gem in the area,all that looked to be around on my maps was pricey Tigers Tale or the same ol BK....the Friendlys is no longer there but tucked in that same shopping center is this place. Wasn't feeling that great so opted for the healthier salad... otherwise I'd like to dig into the pizza or calzones that I usually like. The bread was good quality too. read more

Ive eaten here twice since opening once as a quick slice at the causal area and once as a family sit down meal in their back. I so wanted to give a five star review and I hope I can on another visit but it just isn't deserved. The Brooklyn pizza I love but notably my other three family members didn't like it. I'd order it often for delivery but alas here's a pizza joint that won't deliver. Dumb. On our most recent visits we decided to try their pasta and salads plus the pizza from their dining area. Let's start with service. Horrible. Grant it it was a fri night but we came early and were seated before the place got crowded. Took 10 minutes of flagging down various staff to get a menu. Then another 10 to get someone back to place the order. Forget about getting water or drinks in the mean time. Food took about 40 min to come out. At one point the waiter asked us why we were still there thinking we had paid. Looked very surprised when I snapped back that we were waiting on the food! We just ordered a salad (tasteless) and a kids pasta (suitable but didn't take "homemade"$ and a Brooklyn pie which despite being very greasy I loved. Took forever to get plates cleared and to get a check . They never asked us about desert or suggested we grab wine from next door for their byo policy. Place was loud and decor is cheap. Wouldn't ever eat in again and only would grab a quick slice when I'm in the area read more

See all

I saw this place as they were getting ready to open. I love Italian food and pizza so I was excited to check them out. My family and parents went out for dinner a bit late. They stayed open past their closing time and did not rush us out. The server was so patient with my mom that can be a bit picky with ordering. They accommodated her with no problem. My husband ordered the fresh homemade fettuccine with bolognese. He loved it. I ordered the Porcini and Sausage Ravioli. It was rich and creamy. The ravioli was stuffed I could not believe they could put so much in a tiny package. My son asked for the homemade spinach ravioli with vodka sauce. I tried it. A unique combination but really enjoyed the ravioli. My daughter had the special, homemade spinach fettuccine in a Heirloom cream sauce. I think that was my favorite. My little one even ordered tortellini Alfredo and loved it. The portions were nice. We had some leftovers for lunch the next day. We tried the cannolis. The shell was nice and crispy, NOT soft or soggy. The filling was great, not overly sweet. I liked it so much that I returned for lunch to try the pizza. The slices were big and filled with cheese and toppings. Best of all they were crispy. No floppy pie here. I had a veggie slice. I loved the red peppers. I don't usually like green peppers cooked. So this was an amazing veggie pizza. And they loaded it with fresh ingredients. If you like veggie pizza you have got to try this one. Finally a great pizza place in town. I will definitely be back for dinner, and found my new pizza place. read more

See all

So this place a little pricey, but it's run by family they're super kind, friendly, and welcoming. The food is really yummy so definitely with the little high price. read more

Just wow . Everything was delicious . Meatballs outstanding . Sausage pizza outstanding . Antipasto delicious . What a gem for the Princeton area ! From the fresh bread served with the salads to that perfect crispy crunch when biting into the pizza slice . Ridiculously great food . Bravo . read more

We've ordered here at least once a week since we discovered this gem. After hearing rave reviews from a few locals, we decided to give this place a try. Hands down, best pizza in the area!! We also tried a few of their other dinner entrees and they were delicious as well. read more

Very good Italian. Many varieties of homemade pasta and better is that they offer many different varieties of sauce - traditional marina, spicy arrabiata, an amazing sherry cream sauce etc. Antipasto plate and meatball with ricotta appetizer both excellent. We've had their pasta (A+), pizza (A) veal and chicken meals (B+), and sandwiches (solid B). Family favorites: - Tortellini with sherry cream and prosciutto - Rigatoni with vodka sauce - Meatball with ricotta (add garlic bread for a great lunch meal) - Brooklyn pizza read more

This place is a DELIGHT. We came here on Friday at 7:30pm, after reading Yelp reviews we understood that they were BYOB so we stopped by the wine shop next door and grabbed a bottle of merlot. The front area is for more casual dining, enjoying slices of pizza quickly. In the back they have a sit-down eatery (still casual, but more equipped for date night). The waitstaff was friendly and attentive the whole night (thank you, Devin!), they kept apologizing for things taking so long but everything was quick and fresh! Every meal starts with fresh rolls, provided with oil, seasonings, and garlic. The rolls were steaming hot from the oven, it tasted like they used their pizza dough--absolutely delicious. We wanted to try as many dishes from the menu as we could, so we ordered the fried calamari, fresh fettuccini with ragu and meatballs, and a small pepperoni pizza. The fried calamari came with huge rings of lightly battered calamari, it came with a bowl of the marinara which was superb. The fettuccini was perfectly cooked with delicious ragu and the meatballs are OUT OF THIS WORLD. The pasta dishes are HUGE and so good. Next time, we might try the meatball and ricotta appetizer. The pizza was also excellent, great crust, great amount of cheese, well seasoned. Overall, the food was five stars. We have so much food now for leftovers and I can't wait to keep enjoying our Beniamino's meal. We'll definitely be back! read more

We met a guy in a supermarket who raved about the pizza and Italian food at this place. So after a weekend , I decided to try. I walked in and ordered a slice of pizza to eat and a sub to go. The young man said the sub would take about 15 minutes. So I got and ate my pizza. Pizza was ordinary at best, kind of bland, nothing like NY pizza as the guy recommending it said. Finished my pizza while waiting for the sub, and waiting, and waiting. 28 minutes after ordering I got my sub. The entire time there was no more than one customer and myself eating in at the place. Walk in folks picking up take out orders repeatedly. I do not know what their backup of call in orders was. The sub sandwich was kind of skimpy on meat and very bland also. I come to notice that the sub had no salt, pepper, oil , vinegar or oregano, but it's called an Italian sub. BTW, they charge you to use your credit card, another surprise. read more

The bread was warm and fresh, and the olive oil is really good. The spinach Ravioli was good. Their pizzas are fresh and crispy. Their pasta sauce is really fresh. The severs are friendly! The service is exceptional!! read more

See all

Love Benny's! Awesome staff and awesome food. My son loved the calamari and the pizza has always been great. Wonderful family owned business. BYOB! read more

Amazing food and service. A really warm, family-run place that I regret discovering so recently!

best pizza in montgomery hands down. the wraps are amazing and that hot honey pizza is worth the extra time in the gym. solid lunch spot if you work in the area. just call ahead if you're in a rush read more

The best Sicilian in the Princeton area (Route 206, Skillman), Beniamino's is a hidden gem of remarkable quality. Delicious cheesesteaks, great entrees ... Had a pizza, half pepperoni, that was superb. Generous portions, clean environment, friendly staff. If you haven't tried them you're truly missing out. read more

This is almost a secret and you might miss it if you weren't looking for it but do look for it! Their pies are amazing and always ready when they say. Love this place! read more

UPDATE: My son had some friends over last night. He asked for pizza from Benny for his party. I ordered four pies for him, his friends, and the rest of my family. When I got there the pizzas weren't ready - there was a problem with the printer. But it was a Saturday night and I was happy to relax and have a few good conversations while I was there. I even bumped into an old colleague who couldn't place my face and is probably still scratching his head trying to figure out who I am. I spoke with Benny for a while about the business and found out that he makes his own sausage for the pizza and he makes his own pasta as well. I also found out that he's selling 18 inch pies and calling them 16 inch. That's old school and gets a thumbs up from me. Just so you know, if you want a "works" without mushrooms and with bacon, it's called a "Roland". We brought the four pizzas home and the kids and family all loved them. Well done, like I asked, but not burned at all. Great pies just like the old neighborhood. We're looking forward to coming by again. Maybe have a little fresh pasta on my wife's birthday and open a bottle of wine. More to come... --------------- New place. We read the reviews and noticed that there were a couple that seemed more about the customer's attitude than the food or service. Decided we would try it for ourselves. The pizza and service were excellent - and just what was expected. Interestingly, the crust and especially the sausage seemed to be low in salt, which we prefer. We'll be back read more

My family and I came to Beniamino's for dinner. The restaurant is very clean. You can either dine in and have a waitress/waiter or grab a slice and a seat. We sat in and ordered from the menu. My kids had pizza slices and personal pizza. My husband and I ordered from the menu and we were not disappointed. I had eggplant rollatini and my husband had fried veal with a salad. If your looking for a new place that has fresh flavor this is the place. I love family owned and operated businesses. Keep up the good work. read more

See all

This is our go to spot for Italian subs. Portions are huge and the quality of the meat is amazing! Their seasonal salad is a must. Love the candied walnuts and fresh mandarins that go on it. read more

Very good pizza and sandwiches. The owner is always working hard to please his customers with great hospitality!!

This is my second review (hopefully it will be posted). This restaurant is needed in Montgomery-- everything homemade and delicious. My daughter loves the penne vodka pizza (her new favorite) and the garlic knots. My pizza favorite is Benny's Sausage (thin crust brooklyn). Our 'go to' restaurant. Disregard the negative reviews. They are unwarranted and incorrect. People need to realize that. The owners are always there and eager to make thing 'right' if for some reason you are not satisfied. read more

We have been here multiple times and get takeout from time to time. They are friendly and the food is OUTSTANDING. Beniamino's has become the go to place for pizza, pasta... YUM read more