I have never been to Siesta Key and I was simply passing through on a weeks trip headed south home…read moreand Thought Siesta Key would be a great spot to lay low for the night. Wow was I Lucky! Siesta Key and Siesta Sands On The Beach Hit all the marks for me. Great Beach, excellent clean Motel, & great Food & cocktails nearby. A Very short walk away from the Motel. The Motel is Literally On the beach & a short walk to the village where all the action is. I enjoyed a Clean spotless room with excellent hospitality. Easy check in & check out. It was a beautiful stay. The softest Beach sand I ever walked on. White powder! For that you have to come visit. For all future Siesta Key visits , Siesta Sands on the Beach will be my home base. It's was that great! Check them out!

I just might be opening a can of worms by making this post. You will get everything and more by…read morestaying here. Leslie and Bobby manage the property and are experts. Max and I were warmly welcomed. Usually, I am all words when it comes to reviews, but this one has me star struck. I'll leave it at that.

We rented unit 5 for our spring break stay March 26-April 2 2022. It looks like they have updated…read morethe units and that part is nice and the price was too good to be true for being close to the village and beach. Couches/ chairs were old and gross and needed sheets on them. Location is a 5 star but accommodations w roaches isn't even a 1 star. I let the owner Paul know as soon as we saw the roaches we had a problem. We counted over 20 and they were out day or night so it was not just a little problem. I own several rentals myself so I'm pretty understanding but it was an infestation. After complaining a couple days he finally came in to see and we showed him where they were coming in the bathroom and kitchen. They were caught all over our tooth brushes and even after he filled the open holes in the wall they still got in. He basically said it was in our unit the the one above... I have never ever left a bad review but to this day we have not received our deposit back and I just want people who are looking for a nice place close to the village to be aware.

My boyfriend and I enjoyed a lovely weekend get-away at The Siesta Sunset Royale. Our room was…read moresuper clean with a fun beachy vibe. Down stairs was a pool, hot tub, and grill. So next time, we will definitely bring some food to grill ( also we had a kitchen in our room, so we could have cooked or prepped some food) The beach is just across the street. We woke up early to watch the sun rise. When walked around the village which is fun of fun bars and restaurants. We really enjoyed the fun and relaxing atmosphere. We are looking forward to the next time. :)

Our stay started off great. Amazing location just feet away from the beach and a short walk to the…read morevillage we could not have asked for a better location. Then on the 4th night of our stay we got in late and encountered cockroach in the toilet. When we looked around the bathroom we saw several more. They were small but there we several visible. We didn't sleep well at all but had to stay in the room. When we got u a couple hours later we saw a large cockroach just above the toilet paper holder on the side of the sink vanity. We called Vacasa right then and explained the situation and sent the representative pictures to substantiate our issues. He was helpful and told us the local property manager would be contacting us. We packed our belongings as quickly as possible and reserved a hotel room in Sarasota. Our last full day of vacation was a bust. The local agent could not be reached for several hours. When she did call around 11:30 am she told us she saw no evidence of cockroaches she told us that the picture of the large cockroach in the bathroom didn't look like anywhere in the unit. We told her the location of the other cockroaches and she continued to tell us she could find none at all. She told us the room is rented continuously and they never experienced cockroaches prior to this. She continued to state that she could find none. We felt as if she implied we were lying. She didn't use the word lie or liar but it felt implied. We felt very insulted. We have been visiting Siesta Key the same week for several years and we always stayed at the same place. This time we tried a new place and now we regret that we didn't stay where we had in the past. we had an a legitimate issue and it was handled poorly by the local Vacasa property agent. She is crediting us for the last day but she still insulted us by the implication that we were lying. We won't use Vacasa again. We feel bad for the next guests to experience the cockroaches because it is only a matter of time before someone else sees the cockroaches as well. We stayed in cottage 4.

MY husband and I found this lil slice of heaven on a spur the moment drive to Siesta Key years ago…read more We've been going back ever since. Most recently we stayed in August for our family vacation and rented all 4 units. What a wonderful time! Located a stones throw away from the semi private beach & within walking distance to anything and everything you need in the village. You absolutely cannot beat the location! Especially with children. Its so easy taking them to and from the beach especially when a bathroom break is needed or something forgotten. The units are all decorated with a beachy vibe, well maintained and clean. The pool, grilling area, outdoor shower and laundry is great,and management is very attentive and accomodating.

We stayed at Siesta Dreams 1 in Siesta Village. The location…read morewas perfect steps to the soft sand and beautiful warm water. The condo was clean and stocked with beach accessories. The host Dan was available for questions at any time of the day. We will be back.

DO NOT STAY HERE!!!!!! Please do your research and read the reviews on Yelp. This owner was…read moreabusive, degrading, and unprofessional. He then tried to threaten me and said if I posted my poor experience, (that was witnessed by 17 individuals), he would sue me. My lawyers had to be copied on the emails and once I put them on the emails, Dan told me I was, "blocked." Up until I copied my attorneys on the emails, Dan continued to send threatening emails. Despite me putting it in writing to please leave me alone. I have attached pictures here of our conversation. The conversation was initially dismissive, then he began to threaten me stating that if I went public he would have me charged with a crime. https://m.yelp.com/biz/gertrudes-village-house-siesta-key While the rental company is not responsible for the inside features, nothing worked. The fridge was broken, the air conditioner would work on some nights, others it did not. The sink would clog and the drainer was broken. This hasn't been addressed because it says they are not responsible for this in the contract. But for your knowledge, the pictures are deceiving. We originally booked this place as a 4/3. Please do your research. Dan, the owner, charged us for a 4/3. We placed a call to Dan to let him know we didn't have the 4/3 and in front of 17 individuals on speakerphone, Dan corroborated this by stating, "yes absolutely. That unit is included with the rental." Dan then gave us the address to the second unit and we walked over there, only to find a family inside. It wasn't until he gave us the address and we attempted to get inside, that Dan called us back and took back everything he said. Unfortunately, the website says it's a 4/3. The owner will likely respond by telling you our email correspondence says I agreed to a 3/2. I have attached those screenshots here. He continues to send me a link that I did not click on. I did it through their website. It is advertised as a 4/3. When Dan realized he double booked, he called us back and said we were mistaken. Despite telling us, "absolutely. The 4th unit is included with your rental." The contract also states we are responsible for looking at the website, which advertises this as a 4/3. Upon my attempt to speak with Dan, he yelled at the top of his lungs, "STOP!!!!" It was the most bazaar reaction. I then said, "excuse me? I am trying to explain my frustration with you." Dan then responded by stating, "ugh I don't feel like dealing with this. I'm on vacation. You booked what you booked. This isn't my problem." I asked him who I could speak to when he is on vacation and he responded with, "no one. This isn't my problem. I don't know what you want me to do. I don't feel like dealing with this." Our email exchange sums up the majority of the issues we faced with Dan. I didn't raise my voice once. I tried to calmly express my frustration and the owner responded by yelling at me, telling me it wasn't his problem, and talking down to me. Please read the reviews on the company. NOT THE LOCATION. The location is why this place continues to get bookings. The owner attempted to sell me a rental that opened up the next morning. He ignored the fact that I paid him for the 4th bedroom and then he charged another family to stay there. Therefore, he charged both me (who did not stay in the 4th unit) and the other family, (who actually stayed in the unit). He essentially rented the fourth bedroom twice, profited from us both, and the other family stayed in it. When he texted me the next morning asking if I wanted the extra unit for a "discounted price." I said "no thank you." I didn't send another text or send any emails. I was going to let my lawyer handle it when I got home. The owner then started an email chain stating I booked the 3/2. When I attempted to defend myself, he threatened me, coerced me, and tried to scare me into posting this review. It wasn't until I copied my lawyer onto the email thread that he stopped sending messages. Even the last email was an attempt to threaten me if I went public with this.

I haven't even checked in and they are messing with my vacation. I WAS so excited to bring my kids…read moreto my favorite beach. I haven't stayed at this location in the past a few times and was happy. It must be under new management. I rented a 2 bedroom unit. I have 2 service dogs. They are not at all helpful. Saying only one per unit. The second bedroom doesn't matter. So basically my elderly mother has to be in her own unit. I've brought 3 dogs in the past each time in a one bedroom unit. No issues. If I had not booked nonrefundable I would have canceled. I will never stay here again.

We will never stay here again. Dirty, musty, noisy at all hours of the night and unhealthy. There…read moreis no customer service. The one star is for the location. Great location. Lousy and unhealthy cottages.

I only gave them them 1 star because I had to for the post. I just got off the phone with a lady…read morethat was so rude with trying to change my reservation. She argued with me about how many days I "HAD" to book, she argued with me about whether November was a low season or high season, she informed me that she doesn't even work for the condos...i guess she volunteers. And this was after leaving several voice mails and an email. I could tell by her voice when she did call me back that she was frustrated. Informed me in a hasty manner that the offices were closed until May '25 and that the property is in the process of being sold. Which to my offense...I had no idea! I just wanted to change my reservation. Then she hung up on me. When I responded via text message she told me she will not deal with rude people and that she would cancel my reservation. I guess I'm rude because I called out her nasty attitude. She refused to give me the owners name. I guess this place does not need our business which is sad. I love SK but will take my business somewhere else. I would NOT recommend Sandbox on the Beach for any future stays.

Sandbox is my favorite place to stay in the world. Everyone is gracious, accommdati and helpful…read more The units are impeccably done. You could not find a more convenient place to stay on the beach. I've been many times and never disappointed!

Our annual stay with Horizons West was wonderful. Unit 605 was great with the owners offering use…read moreof their beach "stuff" and the thoughtful snack basket waiting for us was enjoyed by all. We LOVE Siesta Key and always enjoy our time. Brandon in the office is very attentive and acts immediately when there is a need or question. Thank you for another memorable vacation at the beach!

This was our first experience at Horizons West. We have been goingto Siesta Key for over 20 years…read more We only wish we had kept checking at Horizons West. Our 3 week stay was awesome. Colby and Brandon were so accommodating. It was an absolute pleasure dealing with them. the view from our condo (702) was awesome !! We have now booked 2 visits for 2026 and 2027. M and J

This is not the old friendly Siesta Key Inn. as a long time guest I can honestly say I am extremely…read moredisappointed in the direction they have chosen. A once friendly resort has turned downwards. First the ownership will no longer communicate directly with future guests and has retained a new management company, without notifying long term guests. And of course new policies are in place. Once your security deposit is given you are out of luck if you need to make a change. In other words your $$$ are gone. Last year they owned two properties and they sold the one closer to the beach. It's also worth noting the area has changed dramatically. Beach access yes, but good luck trying to find a spot to sit. The hotels have claimed the beach front and you will need to walk quite a distance to find a spot. Also the width of the beach has deteriorated due to the reduction of the sandbar. With all these changes it's time to find a friendlier location. And the response from the Owners during these changes will be crickets. Shame on you Koch family!

My wife and I were celebrating our anniversary and picked Siesta Key Inn to enjoy ourselves and the…read morefamily run inn was very nice and the people are very friendly and had everything we needed,we loved it and will be coming back again.

The best thing about this place is that it's a 2 minute walk to the beach. The beach is beautiful…read morebut the actual villas I would not recommend. The stove had 2 burners that didn't work and the oven over heated within a couple of minutes. The couch was not cleaned after the previous guests, we found dog treats in between the cushions.

It's our best vacation!!! I love it all!!! Amazing Villa!…read moreThere are only 2 blocks to the beach and 2 blocks to the center of Siesta Key!! Great location! Clean rooms! Hammocks, palms and outdoor swim pool! What can you dream more about? It's out 3rd day here. 5 more days are ahead! And I am just enjoying every minute of being here! Thank you, Siesta Key Beachside Villas!

Cottages are clean, location is great! Steps away to the beach. It's a nice 15 minute or so walk…read moreto local places or a quick drive to local restaurants & shops.

If I can give this sh*thole negative stars I would. We stayed in the Buttonwood Cottage for a…read morebachelorette party and our experience was literally awful. On our second night there, a roach the size of a bunny rabbit was found crawling on the wall in the brides bedroom. We were immediately disgusted. Later that night, an additional four roaches were found. One in the kitchen, which was killed. One in the living room, which was also killed under magazines. And two under the bed in the brides bedroom, one alive and one dead. We immediately got in touch with the property manager Misty, but due to the late hours, we did not hear back until the next morning. Misty was informed of the disgusting situation and advised us that this same cottage has had a roach problem in the past. She told us she would contact the owner who was currently traveling, and in order for an exterminator to come spray, the cottage had to be emptied. We informed Misty we will be out all day on a boat and provided her with numerous phone numbers for her to contact with an update. She never called or followed up with anyone. We also told her that we would like to be moved, or quite honestly just leave and stay at a hotel. That night, a sixth roach was found. That was honestly the breaking point. Hotels were booked and ubers were called and we left there by 11:30 PM. We told Misty what was going on and wanted to come to an agreement of some sort of refund. Instead of responding to our calls and emails, they decided to charge us a $75 fee for "trashing" the cottage. We left in a hurry, and unopened food items were left behind. However, anything that was opened was disposed of and all the decorations were taken down. We were refunded the $75 and one nights stay, which quite honestly is not acceptable. The cottage was not livable. Not only were there 6 roaches, there were flies EVERYWHERE. Being married to an exterminator, I can honestly say that this cottage has a huge issue that is not being properly taken care of. We found multiple holes under the bed that lead to outside which is clearly where some of the roaches are coming from. Not only did we barely get responses from Misty, the owner, or booking.com, Misty also accused us of lying, putting rubber roaches all over the house, and disconnecting the WiFi. We had no idea the cottage even had WiFi and Misty admitted to not checking the cottage after the cleaning service left. Do not stay here. This place is disgusting and has a serious moisture problem.