Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    BBQ On Broadway

    5.0 (2 reviews)

    BBQ On Broadway Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - BBQ On Broadway

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Brisket sandwich was delicious. Have to get the Midwest potatoes they are to die for.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Barbeque 105 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Hunter's BBQ & Catering - Side view of restaurant.

    Hunter's BBQ & Catering

    3.6(14 reviews)
    7.3 mi

    If you want a fun time, sit out in the patio/back area. Staff is fun and teases with you even if…read moreit's your first time there. Love their bloody Mary there, and the food has always been good. They are a bit pricey, but they don't care how long you stay and chat.

    Drive by here weekly on the way to Warsaw but never during dinner time. We made it a point to stop…read morein tonight. We were pleased to find the Dinning side almost filled on a Wednesday night. It has a kinda lodge type feel. Country music playing in the back ground. A nice gentleman made it a point to show us in and seat us right away. Our waitress showed up at the table right away. She was very pleasant. She smiled and was eager share her recommendations. She recommended the chicken wing special, pulled pork, Mac and cheese and mashed potatoes. She did tell us that the Mac and cheese does have a smoked flavor which we very much appreciated that she told us it would be different then the usual Mac and cheese flavor. We ordered the pulled pork, my husband got the Mac and cheese and I ordered the mashed potatoes. We did watch to see if the staff was friendly. We were seated in a corner so we could see the whole room. There were four wait staff all were buzzing about with smiles. They seemed attentive to their tables. Our server came to check on us to see if we needed more drinks. We had only been at our seats 10 min. That's a good sign for me. I always ask for lots of ice and this gal listens. I got a full glass of ice with my water. 10 points! Our meal was out in 15 minutes. We thoroughly enjoyed our meal. I loved the sweet corn bread. My husband would have like butter with his. The pulled pork was very moist, it even tasted wonderful without adding their barbecue sauce. Oh and hi fives to our waitress Taylor, she even remembered to fill my water with ice on my second drink. This place is reasonably priced, you won't go away hungry, and has a reasonable variety of choices. We will definitely will be back.

    Photos
    Hunter's BBQ & Catering - Pulled pork, garlic mashed potatoes, and sweet corn bread.

    Pulled pork, garlic mashed potatoes, and sweet corn bread.

    Hunter's BBQ & Catering
    Hunter's BBQ & Catering - Waffle ff , pulled pork , cheese , onion and sauce .. with Coors light

    See all

    Waffle ff , pulled pork , cheese , onion and sauce .. with Coors light

    Lucille's BBQ - Chicken wings

    Lucille's BBQ

    3.8(231 reviews)
    45.3 mi
    $$

    Decent BBQ joint on North end of town…read more.. Dropped by Lucille's for the first time on Friday for a work lunch with the crew... Been meaning/wanting to try for a while, but have never got around to it. Ok experience, but there's some areas of attention needed. Pros: Friendly/quick service, outstanding brisket, excellent bbq sauces (I particularly liked the vinegar and spicy sauces), and large portions. Cons: Over-priced, average at best sides, extremely smoky in dining room, and dirty/run down restaurant. Overall our experience was good, but the smoke in the dining room was a real problem that actually had my eyes burning/watering while we were eating (it literally looked like an AARP Club Catholic Church bingo event, it was that smoky inside the restaurant), the food is stupid expensive ($35 lunch, one person), and the sides just weren't good (bland coleslaw and broccoli salad). The restaurant also needs a facelift and desperate deep clean... It had that dirty, grimy, sticky feel on the floors and tables (presumably from all the smoke in the dining room). I still consider Shigs n' Pit to be the far and wide the best BBQ in town, but Lucille's has the potential to be really good if they can make some adjustments, improvements, and clean the place up.

    Sweet Smoked Pork Steak with BBQ sauce (Lucille's BBQ, north Lima Road) - tried something…read moredifferent, good value and very tasty I prefer Lucille's BBQ plate selections as I feel they give me good value. A select smoked meat with two sides for $14-16. This gives you a good all around taste of Lucille's offerings. On this trip I selected the sweet smoked pork steak with Mac & Cheese and Wilson baked beans. The entree was $14. The pork steak was a thinly cut piece of pork - maybe 3/4 inch thick. The steak definitely had hints of smokey and grilled flavors. The meat was tender, no pink color and moist. It was easily cut when warm, not as easy as it cooled. This is a large flat piece of meat so it took time to cut into pieces and savor. The BBQ sauce was sweet with no real spicy after taste kick. Glad I tried this selection. I really like the Mac & Cheese as it is very creamy and has a nice cheese flavor. The sauce has some jalapeño pieces - so expect a little heat and kick. The Wilson baked beans are also a bit spicy. There are small pieces of brisket embedded in the sweet savory BBQ bean sauce. Lucille's has a nice selection of other delicious sides for you to try. Lucille's does a nice job with smoked BBQ meats. Make the trip north to the corner of Lima and Wallen Roads. It's worth a try!

    Photos
    Lucille's BBQ
    Lucille's BBQ - Sweet smoked pork steak

    Sweet smoked pork steak

    Lucille's BBQ - Smoked Chef salad

    See all

    Smoked Chef salad

    The Prized Pig - 1/2 chicken and 1/2 ribs

    The Prized Pig

    4.0(112 reviews)
    34.6 mi
    $$

    If disappointment had a smell, it would be whatever's coming out of The Prized Pig. This place…read moresomehow turns barbecue, a cuisine built on patience, care, and flavor, into an expensive lesson in lowered expectations. The meat arrives dry, tired, and joyless, like it's been reheated emotionally as well as physically. Each bite feels less like a meal and more like an obligation. Smoke without flavor, seasoning without purpose, and textures that make you wonder if the kitchen has ever experienced moisture. The sauces don't enhance anything, they just sit there, confused, desperately trying to distract you from the fact that the food underneath is beyond saving. For the prices they charge, you'd expect something memorable. And it is memorable, just not in the way they're hoping. You'll remember how much you paid, how little you enjoyed it, and how fast you wished you'd gone literally anywhere else. This is the rare restaurant where you regret ordering while you're still chewing. The atmosphere tries to sell "rustic farm charm" but delivers "neglected barbecue joint that mistook vibes for effort." It's not cozy, it's not charming, and it certainly isn't worth planning a meal around. I wish I could give this place ZERO stars. The Prized Pig isn't just bad barbecue, it's aggressively mediocre, which somehow feels worse. If you value flavor, money, or happiness, do yourself a favor and keep driving. This is not a destination. It's a warning.

    My uncle & I visited the prized pig and we were ordering there at the prized pig but eating the…read morefood at home. I like eating at home more than at a restaurant. I got the ribs with fries and macaroni and cheese. The ribs came with a couple containers of bbq sauce and that sauce they make is so good it definitely made my ribs even better than they were. I think the price was about the same as other restaurants near by and the amount of food you get was a good amount I was pleased by it and so was my uncle. It looks very clean there and the wait staff was friendly.

    Photos
    The Prized Pig - Bar

    Bar

    The Prized Pig
    The Prized Pig - Cheers

    See all

    Cheers

    BBQ On Broadway - bbq - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...